登陆注册
5237100000224

第224章 VOLUME IV(11)

Now, I want to come back to my original question. Trumbull says that Judge Douglas had a bill with a provision in it for submitting a constitution to be made to a vote of the people of Kansas. Does Judge Douglas deny that fact? Does be deny that the provision which Trumbull reads was put in that bill? Then Trumbull says he struck it out. Does he dare to deny that? He does not, and I have the right to repeat the question ,--Why Judge Douglas took it out? Bigler has said there was a combination of certain senators, among whom he did not include Judge Douglas, by which it was agreed that the Kansas Bill should have a clause in it not to have the constitution formed under it submitted to a vote of the people. He did not say that Douglas was among them, but we prove by another source that about the same time Douglas comes into the Senate with that provision stricken out of the bill. Although Bigler cannot say they were all working in concert, yet it looks very much as if the thing was agreed upon and done with a mutual understanding after the conference; and while we do not know that it was absolutely so, yet it looks so probable that we have a right to call upon the man who knows the true reason why it was done to tell what the true reason was. When he will not tell what the true reason was, he stands in the attitude of an accused thief who has stolen goods in his possession, and when called to account refuses to tell where he got them. Not only is this the evidence, but when he comes in with the bill having the provision stricken out, he tells us in a speech, not then but since, that these alterations and modifications in the bill had been made by HIM, in consultation with Toombs, the originator of the bill. He tells us the same to-day. He says there were certain modifications made in the bill in committee that he did not vote for. I ask you to remember, while certain amendments were made which he disapproved of, but which a majority of the committee voted in, he has himself told us that in this particular the alterations and modifications were made by him, upon consultation with Toombs. We have his own word that these alterations were made by him, and not by the committee.

Now, I ask, what is the reason Judge Douglas is so chary about coming to the exact question? What is the reason he will not tell you anything about How it was made, BY WHOM it was made, or that he remembers it being made at all? Why does he stand playing upon the meaning of words and quibbling around the edges of the evidence? If he can explain all this, but leaves it unexplained, I have the right to infer that Judge Douglas understood it was the purpose of his party, in engineering that bill through, to make a constitution, and have Kansas come into the Union with that constitution, without its being submitted to a vote of the people. If he will explain his action on this question, by giving a better reason for the facts that happened than he has done, it will be satisfactory. But until he does that--until he gives a better or more plausible reason than he has offered against the evidence in the case--I suggest to him it will not avail him at all that he swells himself up, takes on dignity, and calls people liars. Why, sir, there is not a word in Trumbull's speech that depends on Trumbull's veracity at all. He has only arrayed the evidence and told you what follows as a matter of reasoning. There is not a statement in the whole speech that depends on Trumbull's word. If you have ever studied geometry, you remember that by a course of reasoning Euclid proves that all the angles in a triangle are equal to two right angles. Euclid has shown you how to work it out. Now, if you undertake to disprove that proposition, and to show that it is erroneous, would you prove it to be false by calling Euclid a liar? They tell me that my time is out, and therefore I close.

FIFTH JOINT DEBATE, AT GALESBURGH, OCTOBER 7, 1858

Mr. LINCOLN'S REPLY.

MY FELLOW-CITIZENS: A very large portion of the speech which Judge Douglas has addressed to you has previously been delivered and put in print. I do not mean that for a hit upon the Judge at all.--- If I had not been interrupted, I was going to say that such an answer as I was able to make to a very large portion of it had already been more than once made and published. There has been an opportunity afforded to the public to see our respective views upon the topics discussed in a large portion of the speech which he has just delivered. I make these remarks for the purpose of excusing myself for not passing over the entire ground that the Judge has traversed. I however desire to take up some of the points that he has attended to, and ask your attention to them, and I shall follow him backwards upon some notes which I have taken, reversing the order, by beginning where he concluded.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 梦不曾消失

    梦不曾消失

    他们是相爱的啊!到底是什么把他们给分开的呢?他们还会在一起吗?他们的爱情还会持续下去吗?也许会,但是阻碍着他们爱情的东西太多了,想要在一起太难了,那么,怎么办呢?牛郎和织女每年见一次面感情还那么好,他们天天见面感情却无人知晓。不过,女主角是不会放弃的!
  • 美丽时光走丢了

    美丽时光走丢了

    新概念作文人气新星+90后主力青春作家,集体书写生命之初那些最美最真令人动容的友谊与爱情。
  • 封神演义故事

    封神演义故事

    《封神演义》以周武王伐纣为历史背景,讲述了仙人妖三界大战、姜子牙伐纣封神等一系列故事,气势恢宏。故事曲折生动,想象丰富奇幻,塑造了一批栩栩如生的人物,描写了一出又一出惊心动魄的神魔大战。儿童文学作家管家琪潜心研习,巧妙地将古典名著与孩子们的需要相结合,为小读者们引入浩瀚奇妙的经典文学旅程,让孩子们接触经典名著,亲近经典文学,不知不觉中感受经典的魅力。
  • 沦落风尘的公主:倾国倾城

    沦落风尘的公主:倾国倾城

    一千年前的雪和一千年后的雪没有两样。一千年前的人却和一千年后的人大不相同。一千年前的她是皇宫内那个温婉如玉的女子,一千年前的他是笔端生花的画师。只是因了一次偶然的邂逅,这个女子便凝住在那画师的深情笔端……而这个女子也就此发誓——若有来世,请给我以轨迹,叫我寻到那位画师,给他以我的感激和回报……穿越千年之后,她能否找到那位她心目中念念不忘的人?……
  • 悍妃戏邪王

    悍妃戏邪王

    【彪悍女匪VS腹黑王爷】说我嚣张?说我跋扈?说我眼高于顶,看不上东楚最高贵的王爷?尼玛!非要逼着我倒追男,你们才甘心?某日,大街上!缺心眼的女人拦住错身而过的男人,豪情万丈的放话,“本小姐给你三个选择,第一;你娶我!”“第二呢?”“我嫁你!”某人腹黑一笑,淡然询问:“第三,别说你要跟我回府?”当嚣张女悍匪与邪恶王爷激情碰撞,究竟会擦出怎样的火花?【完结】
  • 唯一

    唯一

    突如其来的邂逅,她与他初识在海边,他竟然趁她不注意偷拍,她必须要惩罚他,楚月霸道的将安烨手机里的照片删掉以示警戒……万万没有想到,世上竟有如此巧合,他竟然是她与闺蜜要去实习的集团总裁,什么破总裁嘛,不过是一个没有礼貌的花心大萝卜罢了……接下来更可气的是,她和闺蜜同时爱上了这个花心大萝卜,既便明白他们是两个世界的人,她会因他小小感冒心疼担忧、因他与前女友过度亲昵醋意大发、因他忽然的冷落肝肠寸断、直到她有性命危险,他竟奋不顾身的上前来保护她而受伤,她就彻底的陷进去了……没有想到,他们之间的感情并不是想象中的那么顺利,长辈的感情恩怨纠缠、以及他前女友的妒忌,楚月与安烨的感情之路又将何去何从?
  • 世界文化博览1

    世界文化博览1

    带你领略世界文化的博大精深,感受文化的力量和魅力,享受精神的盛宴,浓缩世界文化知识精粹。旨在为读者提高文化修养、丰富人生内涵、添加知识储备、准备写作素材、增加聚会谈资……
  • 胶东白人集中营

    胶东白人集中营

    1941年12月7日,夏威夷群岛上事尽周末劝夜酌岛民正浸在晨梦中,忽被一阵阵惊心动魄的巨响和刺耳的飞机呼啸声震醒。正在度假的、有经验的驻地军人纷纷跑出营房,朝太子洋舰队基地珍珠港奔去……然而,迎接他们的却是一个疯狂而又惨烈的场面:在灰蒙蒙的空中是兽性发作的不明国籍的飞机,战舰在阴沉沉的海面上爆炸,值班士兵在滩头狼狈逃窜……
  • 尽三生之缘起

    尽三生之缘起

    上古时期,天地存亡的危难之际,众神以身为界,投身于天地之间,化为六界。剩余不多的神便留在神界,守护这一方天地的安宁与长存。不知过了多久,神界出了个不世天才,其天赋比之远古神界最优秀的神也不差。然而,此小神并不是个安分的,调皮捣蛋,打架闹事更是家常便饭。偏偏身份不凡,年幼不知深浅,又法力强悍,少有人敢惹。至此,神界再无安宁。直到有一天,一枚上古令牌的出现,改变了一切……
  • 雪域樱花

    雪域樱花

    白雪覆盖的雪域,毅然挺立着一棵枯死的樱花树。传说,曾经的曾经,雪域并非这个样子,那是这里盛开着绵延千里的樱花……她,雪樱,是雪樱的守护神,超然的存在他,冽,是一国的君王,强大的霸主,雪域在他的手中犹如精致的水晶,一点点的破裂为护雪域和她的子民,她做了他的王后。为得到她,他对她呵护备至,却不知,她,无心,她的存在只是为了守护……