登陆注册
5237300000155

第155章 Lectures XIV and XV(3)

Skepticism cannot, therefore, be ruled out by any set of thinkers as a possibility against which their conclusions are secure; and no empiricist ought to claim exemption from this universal liability. But to admit one's liability to correction is one thing, and to embark upon a sea of wanton doubt is another. Of willfully playing into the hands of skepticism we cannot be accused. He who acknowledges the imperfectness of his instrument, and makes allowance for it in discussing his observations, is in a much better position for gaining truth than if he claimed his instrument to be infallible. Or is dogmatic or scholastic theology less doubted in point of fact for claiming, as it does, to be in point of right undoubtable? And if not, what command over truth would this kind of theology really lose if, instead of absolute certainty, she only claimed reasonable probability for her conclusions? If WE claim only reasonable probability, it will be as much as men who love the truth can ever at any given moment hope to have within their grasp. Pretty surely it will be more than we could have had, if we were unconscious of our liability to err.

Nevertheless, dogmatism will doubtless continue to condemn us for this confession. The mere outward form of inalterable certainty is so precious to some minds that to renounce it explicitly is for them out of the question. They will claim it even where the facts most patently pronounce its folly. But the safe thing is surely to recognize that all the insights of creatures of a day like ourselves must be provisional. The wisest of critics is an altering being, subject to the better insight of the morrow, and right at any moment, only "up to date" and "on the whole."

When larger ranges of truth open, it is surely best to be able to open ourselves to their reception, unfettered by our previous pretensions. "Heartily know, when half-gods go, the gods arrive."

The fact of diverse judgments about religious phenomena is therefore entirely unescapable, whatever may be one's own desire to attain the irreversible. But apart from that fact, a more fundamental question awaits us, the question whether men's opinions ought to be expected to be absolutely uniform in this field. Ought all men to have the same religion? Ought they to approve the same fruits and follow the same leadings? Are they so like in their inner needs that, for hard and soft, for proud and humble, for strenuous and lazy, for healthy-minded and despairing, exactly the same religious incentives are required?

Or are different functions in the organism of humanity allotted to different types of man, so that some may really be the better for a religion of consolation and reassurance, whilst others are better for one of terror and reproof? It might conceivably be so; and we shall, I think, more and more suspect it to be so as we go on. And if it be so, how can any possible judge or critic help being biased in favor of the religion by which his own needs are best met? He aspires to impartiality; but he is too close to the struggle not to be to some degree a participant, and he is sure to approve most warmly those fruits of piety in others which taste most good and prove most nourishing to HIM.

I am well aware of how anarchic much of what I say may sound.

Expressing myself thus abstractly and briefly, I may seem to despair of the very notion of truth. But I beseech you to reserve your judgment until we see it applied to the details which lie before us. I do indeed disbelieve that we or any other mortal men can attain on a given day to absolutely incorrigible and unimprovable truth about such matters of fact as those with which religions deal. But I reject this dogmatic ideal not out of a perverse delight in intellectual instability. I am no lover of disorder and doubt as such. Rather do I fear to lose truth by this pretension to possess it already wholly. That we can gain more and more of it by moving always in the right direction, I believe as much as any one, and I hope to bring you all to my way of thinking before the termination of these lectures. Till then, do not, I pray you, harden your minds irrevocably against the empiricism which I profess.

I will waste no more words, then, in abstract justification of my method, but seek immediately to use it upon the facts.

In critically judging of the value of religious phenomena, it is very important to insist on the distinction between religion as an individual personal function, and religion as an institutional, corporate, or tribal product. I drew this distinction, you may remember, in my second lecture. The word "religion," as ordinarily used, is equivocal. A survey of history shows us that, as a rule, religious geniuses attract disciples, and produce groups of sympathizers. When these groups get strong enough to "organize" themselves, they become ecclesiastical institutions with corporate ambitions of their own. The spirit of politics and the lust of dogmatic rule are then apt to enter and to contaminate the originally innocent thing; so that when we hear the word "religion" nowadays, we think inevitably of some "church" or other; and to some persons the word "church" suggests so much hypocrisy and tyranny and meanness and tenacity of superstition that in a wholesale undiscerning way they glory in saying that they are "down" on religion altogether. Even we who belong to churches do not exempt other churches than our own from the general condemnation.

同类推荐
  • 香奁润色

    香奁润色

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 楚辞

    楚辞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 老子道德经校释

    老子道德经校释

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上说青玄雷令法行因地妙经

    太上说青玄雷令法行因地妙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 诸经要抄

    诸经要抄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 冒险追踪记

    冒险追踪记

    夏洛克·福尔摩斯是英国小说家亚瑟·柯南·道尔所创造出的侦探,现在已成为世界通用的名侦探最佳代名词。福尔摩斯作为一个文学形象已经深入人心。本书中的作品谴责了各种犯罪和不道德行为,宣扬善恶有报和法网难逃的思想,在普通公众中引起心理共鸣。
  • 科学育儿0~6岁(健康女人时尚阅读书系)

    科学育儿0~6岁(健康女人时尚阅读书系)

    我们依据大量的国内外科学育儿资料,结合成功妈妈育儿的实践经验,通过对各种教育理论的深入研究,精心编写了这本《科学育儿0~6岁》,全书包括“如何培养一个聪明的宝宝”“科学育儿0~6岁最关键”“科学育儿技巧‘0’岁宝宝篇”“科学育儿技巧‘1~2’岁宝宝篇”“科学育儿技巧‘2~3’岁宝宝篇”“科学育儿技巧‘4~6’岁宝宝篇”等章节。
  • 岫岩志略

    岫岩志略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 倾城女帝

    倾城女帝

    秦王府满门抄斩,被火烧成灰烬。秦心颜至死方知,一切尽是自己心心念念感恩之夫君所为,背叛之痛,剜心渗骨,死不瞑目。涅槃莫过重生,她摒弃昔日桀骜坚持,改心换性,步步为营,只为命运不为他人所控,手刃仇人,报血海深仇。宫墙深渊,铁血沙场,她都勇往直前,复仇路再难,她不悔前行。他本为对权势不屑一顾的侯爷,只因全她心愿,便毫不犹豫舍安逸,踏上夺位征途。“你不后悔吗,我的邪王殿下?”她挑眉轻问。他宠溺笑道:“你毁我前半生桃花,后半辈子,罚你给我生一窝猴子!”情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 一夕繁华梦

    一夕繁华梦

    一场爱恨情仇,一夕繁华似梦也许在相遇的那一刻就已经注定,今生再也无法逃脱。夏瑶,一个普通上班族,平凡地生活,平凡地工作,却遭遇了两场不同的爱情。钱浩宇给她的爱和痛一样深刻,他霸道却又温柔,因为自己的仇恨,将她带入他的游戏之中,当他开始害怕她受到伤害,他已经无法回头。
  • 太子追妃记

    太子追妃记

    她,一朝穿越,成了丞相府最受宠的小姐,哥哥疼爱,父亲慈祥,居然还是未来的太子妃,可是她对太子不来电怎么办,退婚。开酒楼,夺花魁,混的风生水起,逼得太子无奈追妻。一朝暴露,她掐住太子的脖子“好啊,你敢骗老娘,居然还骗了我三次,看我不掐死你。”太子邪魅一笑“掐死我,谁照顾你下半辈子。”--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 傲娇魔帝呆萌妃

    傲娇魔帝呆萌妃

    她是特种兵中的诡医天才,纨绔狠辣,人称罗刹,一朝穿越,却成了被剜心取骨的废柴!灵脉断绝,人人可欺?别闹,她可是诡医罗刹!一锅在手,天下我有!吃遍美食,是她的追求;坐拥金山,是她的梦想;看遍美男,是她的夙愿,可是……可是美男当前,却发现,要不起,这可咋办?
  • 天地刀传

    天地刀传

    人类进化到一个崭新的时代神武时代。为了更好的开发太阳系,众多宇宙战舰从地球出发按不同角度如蝗虫般飞向太阳系的各个角落,绘制太阳系的星系地图。情节虚构,切勿模仿。
  • 越玩越成功

    越玩越成功

    人类的生命成长是一个认识自我、改变自我、超越自我的过程。只有真正地、全面地认识了自己,才会改变自我、超越自我,所以认识自我是实现自我发展的前提和基础。然而,认识自我是十分艰难的。如何才能破解心灵的密码,使自己能够清晰地认识自己呢?心理测试其实就是一把打开心门的金钥匙,它可……
  • 快穿攻略:腹黑BOSS撩不停

    快穿攻略:腹黑BOSS撩不停

    淘宝淘到了一个系统,从此陈白酥过上非正常生活。小白上路,经验为零,一手烂牌,演技不行,前有猛虎后有饿狼,如此人生唯有作死。“我诅咒,诅咒酥酥会再次遇见我。”他哭泣着说。被抹掉记忆的竹马:“看过你喜欢的云霞后,我发现我也偏爱上了它,还有院后的那一片向日葵。”心怀苍生的师兄:“我记得,最后,有一朵云消失在了我手中。”人民币玩家:“实在是忘不了,竞技场中她揍人的样子。”病态的实验狂人:“感受过将要喷发的火山吗?换一下心,你就能体会到了。”【乖。】当初说好做彼此的天使呢?男人的影子把她整个人都遮住,任务完成的陈白酥背着一身的死亡flag蹲在墙角,不敢动。