登陆注册
5237300000154

第154章 Lectures XIV and XV(2)

So soon as the fruits began to seem quite worthless; so soon as they conflicted with indispensable human ideals, or thwarted too extensively other values; so soon as they appeared childish, contemptible, or immoral when reflected on, the deity grew discredited, and was erelong neglected and forgotten. It was in this way that the Greek and Roman gods ceased to be believed in by educated pagans; it is thus that we ourselves judge of the Hindu, Buddhist, and Mohammedan theologies; Protestants have so dealt with the Catholic notions of deity, and liberal Protestants with older Protestant notions; it is thus that Chinamen judge of us, and that all of us now living will be judged by our descendants. When we cease to admire or approve what the definition of a deity implies, we end by deeming that deity incredible.

Few historic changes are more curious than these mutations of theological opinion. The monarchical type of sovereignty was, for example, so ineradicably planted in the mind of our own forefathers that a dose of cruelty and arbitrariness in their deity seems positively to have been required by their imagination. They called the cruelty "retributive justice," and a God without it would certainly have struck them as not "sovereign" enough. But today we abhor the very notion of eternal suffering inflicted; and that arbitrary dealing-out of salvation and damnation to selected individuals, of which Jonathan Edwards could persuade himself that he had not only a conviction, but a "delightful conviction," as of a doctrine "exceeding pleasant, bright, and sweet," appears to us, if sovereignly anything, sovereignly irrational and mean. Not only the cruelty, but the paltriness of character of the gods believed in by earlier centuries also strikes later centuries with surprise. We shall see examples of it from the annals of Catholic saintship which makes us rub our Protestant eyes.

Ritual worship in general appears to the modern transcendentalist, as well as to the ultra-puritanic type of mind, as if addressed to a deity of an almost absurdly childish character, taking delight in toy-shop furniture, tapers and tinsel, costume and mumbling and mummery, and finding his "glory" incomprehensibly enhanced thereby:--just as on the other hand the formless spaciousness of pantheism appears quite empty to ritualistic natures, and the gaunt theism of evangelical sects seems intolerably bald and chalky and bleak.

Luther, says Emerson, would have cut off his right hand rather than nail his theses to the door at Wittenberg, if he had supposed that they were destined to lead to the pale negations of Boston Unitarianism.

So far, then, although we are compelled, whatever may be our pretensions to empiricism, to employ some sort of a standard of theological probability of our own whenever we assume to estimate the fruits of other men's religion, yet this very standard has been begotten out of the drift of common life. It is the voice of human experience within us, judging and condemning all gods that stand athwart the pathway along which it feels itself to be advancing. Experience, if we take it in the largest sense, is thus the parent of those disbeliefs which, it was charged, were inconsistent with the experiential method. The inconsistency, you see, is immaterial, and the charge may be neglected.

If we pass from disbeliefs to positive beliefs, it seems to me that there is not even a formal inconsistency to be laid against our method. The gods we stand by are the gods we need and can use, the gods whose demands on us are reinforcements of our demands on ourselves and on one another. What I then propose to do is, briefly stated, to test saintliness by common sense, to use human standards to help us decide how far the religious life commends itself as an ideal kind of human activity. If it commends itself, then any theological beliefs that may inspire it, in so far forth will stand accredited. If not, then they will be discredited, and all without reference to anything but human working principles. It is but the elimination of the humanly unfit, and the survival of the humanly fittest, applied to religious beliefs; and if we look at history candidly and without prejudice, we have to admit that no religion has ever in the long run established or proved itself in any other way.

Religions have APPROVED themselves; they have ministered to sundry vital needs which they found reigning. When they violated other needs too strongly, or when other faiths came which served the same needs better, the first religions were supplanted.

The needs were always many, and the tests were never sharp. So the reproach of vagueness and subjectivity and "on the whole"-ness, which can with perfect legitimacy be addressed to the empirical method as we are forced to use it, is after all a reproach to which the entire life of man in dealing with these matters is obnoxious. No religion has ever yet owed its prevalence to "apodictic certainty." In a later lecture I will ask whether objective certainty can ever be added by theological reasoning to a religion that already empirically prevails.

One word, also, about the reproach that in following this sort of an empirical method we are handing ourselves over to systematic skepticism.

Since it is impossible to deny secular alterations in our sentiments and needs, it would be absurd to affirm that one's own age of the world can be beyond correction by the next age.

同类推荐
  • 惜春

    惜春

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Cruise of the Cachalot

    The Cruise of the Cachalot

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 人间乐诱部

    人间乐诱部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 美人谱

    美人谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 养吉斋丛录

    养吉斋丛录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 你最喜欢的300篇哲理故事(青少年阅读故事书系)

    你最喜欢的300篇哲理故事(青少年阅读故事书系)

    在人生中,有些事必须得到别人的信赖才能实现;生命的源头就是知识和智慧,只有努力学习,才能和源头相连;当上苍要把更大的好运赐给我们的时候,我们却又茫然失措,徒然让机会溜掉;每个奇迹总是始于一种伟大的想法。或许没有人知道今天的一个想法将会走多远。只要沉下心来,你就会听见目标就在不远处。让我们从故事中去汲取这些人生的智慧,本书推荐了300篇哲理的小故事,希望读者们从中启发智慧以及受到激励。
  • 绝境长城上的王者

    绝境长城上的王者

    穿越到《权力的游戏》或者说《冰与火之歌》的世界里,干点啥合适呢。后宫?争霸?种田?倒霉的艾格没得选择,因为他在一开始就被守夜人抓了壮丁。
  • 异界之文明建设

    异界之文明建设

    陈乐在异界创造国强民富的华夏帝国!引领艾泽星球的潮流!让华夏文明传播到世界每个角落!陈乐想要的很简单——让老人老有所依,可以安享晚年;让父母不再担心孩子被人贩子拐卖;让孩子们喝上放心牛奶;走在路上不用担心被碰瓷;让好人得到好报;文明社会的建设需要所有人共同努力!加油!
  • 牧民政要

    牧民政要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 桃花醉渔痕

    桃花醉渔痕

    你吃过外星人的食品吗?它不仅仅有味道、还有声音。很搞笑吧!惨淡的月光,古老的城堡,吸血鬼的预言在铁与火的洗礼下,终于要……本书语言风趣而老辣,有诗情、画意、曲音、情节跌岩起伏,脑洞纵横大开,幻想如滔滔江水不绝。
  • 至尊仙途

    至尊仙途

    一把剑,划开万丈天幕!一腔血,掀起九霄风雷!一个被寄予厚望的废体少年,决心以最卑微的姿态挤进修真界,本以为从此超脱世外,岂料修真界更是无情。从此,少年拼命喋血,努力抓住命运契机,取阴阳乾坤戒,吞魔神灵脉,一寸修为一寸血,杀出一条白骨路,逍遥天地间。
  • 贪财王爷抱错妃

    贪财王爷抱错妃

    老天不带这么开玩笑的,穿越不是她的错,上错花轿不是她的错,遇人不淑也不是她的错,为什么每当她食欲大开的时候,就有个穷鬼在叨念:表妹,我想拉屎。不能好好地吃就算了,每当她跟帅哥艳遇的时候,总有一个吝啬财主追在后面喊:还我两个包子!他,年仅七岁踩到婚礼现场当着众位叔伯兄弟面前宣布,将来要迎娶一个求而不得的女子为妻,打滚十多年,好不容易觅得佳人,关键时刻,点错了新娘子。
  • 居委“小妈”

    居委“小妈”

    居委会大妈?已经过时了,现在是“小妈”当道!上得了厅堂、下得了厨房;写的了报告、查得出流氓;招待起领导、调解完夫妻;照顾了小家、顾得起街道;斗得起小鬼、收服得了“洋瘪三”!
  • 和谐处世(中华民族传统美德教育读本)

    和谐处世(中华民族传统美德教育读本)

    本丛书筛选内容主要遵循以下原则要求:(1)坚持批判继承思想,取其精华、去其糟粕。既不全盘肯定,也不全盘否定。坚持抽象继承、演绎发展、立足当代、为我所用。(2)坚持系统整体的原则。注意各历史时期分布;注意各民族的进步人物;注意各层面人物;注意人物各侧面。做到:竖看历史五千年,纵向成条线;横看美德重实践,横向不漏面。(3)坚持古为今用,为我所用原则。在发掘美德资源时,特别挖掘古代人物故事、言论,注重寻找挖掘各阶层、各民族的传统公德、通德、同德;注重人民性、民主性、进步性、发展性、普遍性、抽象性,不求全古代,不求全个体。
  • 写给孩子的世界地理

    写给孩子的世界地理

    西尔耶《写给孩子的世界地理》像是一本“历险”之作。在本书中,作者就像是一位经验颇丰、风趣幽默的环球导游,边走边以优美、富有童趣的语言给孩子们讲解各地的风土人情、山川河流。在作者笔下原本枯燥乏味的地理常识变得鲜活生动、兴味盎然。读完这本书,如同跟作者进行了一次轻松愉悦的环球之旅。