登陆注册
5246300000663

第663章 CHAPTER XIV(5)

A question was now raised which might justly excite the anxiety of every man in the kingdom. That question was whether the highest tribunal, the tribunal on which, in the last resort, depended the most precious interests of every English subject, was at liberty to decide judicial questions on other than judicial grounds, and to withhold from a suitor what was admitted to be his legal right, on account of the depravity of his moral character. That the supreme Court of Appeal ought not to be suffered to exercise arbitrary power, under the forms of ordinary justice, was strongly felt by the ablest men in the House of Commons, and by none more strongly than by Somers. With him, and with those who reasoned like him, were, on this occasion, allied many weak and hot-headed zealots who still regarded Oates as a public benefactor, and who imagined that to question the existence of the Popish plot was to question the truth of the Protestant religion. On the very morning after the decision of the Peers had been pronounced, keen reflections were thrown, in the House of Commons, on the justice of their lordships. Three days later, the subject was brought forward by a Whig Privy Councillor, Sir Robert Howard, member for Castle Rising. He was one of the Berkshire branch of his noble family, a branch which enjoyed, in that age, the unenviable distinction of being wonderfully fertile of bad rhymers. The poetry of the Berkshire Howards was the jest of three generations of satirists. The mirth began with the first representation of the Rehearsal, and continued down to the last edition of the Dunciad.397 But Sir Robert, in spite of his bad verses, and of some foibles and vanities which had caused him to be brought on the stage under the name of Sir Positive Atall, had in parliament the weight which a stanch party man, of ample fortune, of illustrious name, of ready utterance, and of resolute spirit, can scarcely fail to possess.398 When he rose to call the attention of the Commons to the case of Oates, some Tories, animated by the same passions which had prevailed in the other House, received him with loud hisses. In spite of this most unparliamentary insult, he persevered; and it soon appeared that the majority was with him.

Some orators extolled the patriotism and courage of Oates: others dwelt much on a prevailing rumour, that the solicitors who were employed against him on behalf of the Crown had distributed large sums of money among the jurymen. These were topics on which there was much difference of opinion. But that the sentence was illegal was a proposition which admitted of no dispute. The most eminent lawyers in the House of Commons declared that, on this point, they entirely concurred in the opinion given by the judges in the House of Lords. Those who had hissed when the subject was introduced, were so effectually cowed that they did not venture to demand a division; and a bill annulling the sentence was brought in, without any opposition.399The Lords were in an embarrassing situation. To retract was not pleasant. To engage in a contest with the Lower House, on a question on which that House was clearly in the right, and was backed at once by the opinions of the sages of the law, and by the passions of the populace, might be dangerous. It was thought expedient to take a middle course. An address was presented to the King, requesting him to pardon Oates.400 But this concession only made bad worse. Titus had, like every other human being, a right to justice: but he was not a proper object of mercy. If the judgment against him was illegal, it ought to have been reversed.

If it was legal, there was no ground for remitting any part of it. The Commons, very properly, persisted, passed their bill, and sent it up to the Peers. Of this bill the only objectionable part was the preamble, which asserted, not only that the judgment was illegal, a proposition which appeared on the face of the record to be true, but also that the verdict was corrupt, a proposition which, whether true or false, was not proved by any evidence at all.

The Lords were in a great strait. They knew that they were in the wrong. Yet they were determined not to proclaim, in their legislative capacity, that they had, in their judicial capacity, been guilty of injustice. They again tried a middle course. The preamble was softened down: a clause was added which provided that Oates should still remain incapable of being a witness; and the bill thus altered was returned to the Commons.

The Commons were not satisfied. They rejected the amendments, and demanded a free conference. Two eminent Tories, Rochester and Nottingham, took their seats in the Painted Chamber as managers for the Lords. With them was joined Burnet, whose well known hatred of Popery was likely to give weight to what he might say on such an occasion. Somers was the chief orator on the other side; and to his pen we owe a singularly lucid and interesting abstract of the debate.

The Lords frankly owned that the judgment of the Court of King's Bench could not be defended. They knew it to be illegal, and had known it to be so even when they affirmed it. But they had acted for the best. They accused Oates of bringing an impudently false accusation against Queen Catherine: they mentioned other instances of his villany; and they asked whether such a man ought still to be capable of giving testimony in a court of justice.

The only excuse which, in their opinion, could be made for him was, that he was insane; and in truth, the incredible insolence and absurdity of his behaviour when he was last before them seemed to warrant the belief that his brain had been turned, and that he was not to be trusted with the lives of other men. The Lords could not therefore degrade themselves by expressly rescinding what they had done; nor could they consent to pronounce the verdict corrupt on no better evidence than common report.

同类推荐
  • 古画品录

    古画品录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 先识览

    先识览

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说一向出生菩萨经

    佛说一向出生菩萨经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 雷峰塔

    雷峰塔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说频婆娑罗王经

    佛说频婆娑罗王经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 告诉你一个富兰克林的故事

    告诉你一个富兰克林的故事

    精选了富兰克林人生中富有代表性的事件和故事,以点带面,从而折射出他充满传奇的人生经历和各具特点的鲜明个性。通过阅读《告诉你一个富兰克林的故事》。我们不仅要了解他的生活经历,更要了解他的奋斗历程,以及学习他在面对困难、失败和挫折时所表现出来的杰出品质。
  • 瀛涯勝覽

    瀛涯勝覽

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 凤凰蛋:腹黑上神VS大白鸟

    凤凰蛋:腹黑上神VS大白鸟

    传闻白衣凤凰英勇善战,唯独掉下忘川后记性不好,见一个忘一个。传闻白衣上神只记得长的好看的美男,见一个喜欢一个。传闻……凤栖喝着酒卧在竹塌上:“咦,说的是我?我明明一千年不曾迈出栖凤山。”华莲:“上神可记得在下?”凤栖:“哦,老身记得你,你长得很好看。”华莲:“是的,你记得我,所以你爱我。”凤栖:“咦,说的是我?我明明自断情根,断情绝爱。”佛曰:花开并蒂,步步莲华。不可说啊,不可说。凤凰蛋书友群欢迎大家:398599680叩门砖:书中任意人名新书(懒仙下凡:一睹定三生)已发,木木哒
  • 坑爹金手指发家史

    坑爹金手指发家史

    别人家的金手指是灵泉肥田,别人家的金手指是要风得风要雨得雨,别人家的……对,那是别人家的!女猪脚表示,自己家的金手指就是坑姐的!摸啥啥就坏,碰啥啥就散,尼玛每天还提心吊胆的怕把别人给摸“散”了!唉,这日子可神马时候到头啊……【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 萌妻100分之老公宠我

    萌妻100分之老公宠我

    一朝穿越,竟成了开国元老家的小宝贝,上有爷爷宠,下有爸妈宠,身边还有几个哥哥宠,苏颜的小日子过得好不滋润。直到遇见了他……【全文甜宠无虐,前期家长宠,后期老公宠】
  • 玄变

    玄变

    玄天大陆,无数生灵,人类是这片大陆的主宰。而我们的主角绝对是这大陆的异类。小小外玄便叫嚣与天罚抗争、远古神兽任其随意驾行、成就一代强者、他的一生注定不会平凡、他注定是这片大路上主宰的主宰!玄变!记录他成为主宰的一生!
  • 我的穿越有点问题

    我的穿越有点问题

    胡岳在找工作的途中处处碰壁,却因为一则神秘的工作通知突然心肌梗塞了。等他醒来,已经一千多年以后了,自己也变成一个行尸了。就在他在为未来发愁的时候,才突然发现这个世界已经变得不同了,这里有妖怪,有会用法术的修仙者,甚至还有机器人和外星人!但作为一个穿越者,他却有着一个无敌的技能给予系统!不管什么技能只有有好东西带在身上,就能够学到!什么高级法术?不好意思我把玉佩揣在怀里,几天后就会了,要辛辛苦苦的学吗?!无敌战技?武器借我玩几天,我就能使出比你更加无敌的战技来!有着这个系统在,胡岳不管是什么技能,只要你东西给我,我什么都能够学会,你哪怕给的是一块石头,我也能打出一连串的飞蝗石来!
  • 连襟小说

    连襟小说

    五点多,天刚一亮计策就起床了。这些日子他情绪特别亢奋,总感到有许多的事要做,有许多的事做不完,有许多的事怕做不好。他做完早饭,边吃边看着每天清晨电视台的“健康早班车”节目。饭吃完了电视也看完了,他就起身出屋。他没有直接去上班,而是朝海滨路走去。为了锻炼身体,他把开了好几年的车停了,每天步行上下班。到了撇了四十奔五十的岁数,病就开始找人了,他开始注意起自己的身体,把抽了二十年的烟也戒了。特别是去年,处理完机关一位同事的丧事以后,他尤其感到人生之短暂,生命之无常。那个同事比他还小七八岁,前一天下午俩人还在一块商量着起草文件,第二天人就没了。
  • 捧月奇遇记

    捧月奇遇记

    失落少女李紫沁穿越时空之门,逃亡修仙的过程带着个宝贝却又当成石头,所谓情路坎坷,修仙坎坷…………
  • 妖精领主

    妖精领主

    腹黑宅男穿越魔法世界的妖精生涯冒险收集魔法装备变强建立妖精塔