登陆注册
5247200000041

第41章 THE GREAT POLITICAL SUPERSTITION(2)

Therefore before the names of just and unjust can have place, there must be some coercive power, to compel men equally to the performance of their covenants, by the terror of some punishment, greater than the benefit they expect by the breach of their covenant."(3*)Were people's characters in Hobbes's day really so bad as to war rant his assumption that none would perform their covenants in the absence of a coercive power and threatened penalties? In our day "the names of just and unjust can have place" quite apart from recognition of any coercive power. Among my friends I could name half a dozen whom I would implicitly trust to perform their covenants without any "terror of some punishment" and over whom the requirements of justice would be as imperative in the absence of a coercive power as in its presence. Merely noting, however, that this unwarranted assumption vitiates Hobbes's argument for State-authority, and accepting both his premises and conclusion, we have to observe two significant implications. One is that State-authority as thus derived, is a means to an end, and has no validity save as subserving that end: if the end is not subserved, the authority, by the hypothesis, does not exist. The other is that the end for which the authority exists, as thus specified, is the enforcement of justice -- the maintenance of equitable relations. The reasoning yields no warrant for other coercion over citizens than that which is required for preventing direct aggressions, and those indirect aggressions constituted by breaches of contract; to which, if we add protection against eternal enemies, the entire function implied by Hobbes's derivation of sovereign authority is comprehended.

Hobbes argued in the interests of absolute monarchy. His modern admirer, Austin, had for his aim to derive the authority of law from the unlimited sovereignty of one man, or of a number of men, small or large compared with the whole community. Austin was originally in the army; and it has been truly remarked that "the permanent traces left" may be seen in his Province of Jurisprudence. When, undeterred by the exasperating pedantries --the endless distinctions and definitions and repetitions -- which serve but to hide his essential doctrines, we ascertain what these are, it becomes manifest that he assimilates civil authority to military authority: taking for granted that the one, as the other, is above question in respect of both origin and range. To get justification for positive law, he takes us back to the absolute sovereignty of the power imposing it -- a monarch, an aristocracy, or that larger body of men who have votes in a democracy; for such a body also, he styles the sovereign, in contrast with the remaining portion of the community which, from incapacity or other cause, remains subject. And having affirmed, or, rather, taken for granted, the unlimited authority of the body, simple or compound, small or large, which he styles sovereign, he, of course, has no difficulty in deducing the legal validity of its edicts, which he calls positive law. But the problem is simply moved a step further back and there left unsolved. The true question is -- Whence the sovereignty? What is the assignable warrant for this unqualified supremacy assumed by one, or by a small number, or by a large number, over the rest? Acritic might fitly say -- "We will dispense with your process of deriving positive law from unlimited sovereignty: the sequence is obvious enough. But first prove your unlimited sovereignty."To this demand there is no response. Analyse his assumption, and the doctrine of Austin proves to have no better basis than that of Hobbes. In the absence of admitted divine descent or appointment, neither single-headed ruler nor many-headed ruler can produce such credentials as the claim to unlimited sovereignty implies.

"But surely," will come in deafening chorus the reply, "there is the unquestionable right of the majority, which gives unquestionable rights to the parliament it elects."Yes, now we are coming down to the root of the matter. The divine right of parliaments means the divine right of majorities.

The fundamental assumption made by legislators and people alike, is that a majority has powers to which no limits can be put. This is the current theory which all accept without proof as a self-evident truth. Nevertheless, criticism will, I think, show that this current theory requires a radical modification.

同类推荐
  • 佛说处处经

    佛说处处经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞房内经注

    太上洞房内经注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Bureaucracy

    Bureaucracy

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东维子集

    东维子集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中本起经

    中本起经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 捕风

    捕风

    胡太接到仓库遭袭的消息是在晚上十二点。“什么,草桥仓库遭到一伙不明身份的人袭击,伤亡惨重?”电话是警察署特别大队大队长宋明远打来的。胡太一听就火了,能不火吗,草桥仓库是警察署重要仓库,里面不但放了警察署很多物资,还有哈尔滨警察部部长浅野正二大佐放在那里的东西,包括武器弹药及其他军用物资。胡太这个警察署副署长,正想混成正的,他实在不想在这个时候给浅野留下什么不好的印象。他不敢耽搁,命令宋明远保护好现场,加强戒备,说自己马上就到。他连夫人梅香的话都没有听清楚,穿好衣服,匆匆下楼,开着车走了。仓库里面一片混乱。
  • 阴阳师之式神别哭

    阴阳师之式神别哭

    离岛不知火,大江山酒吞,神秘大妖玉藻前,暴力草爹,沉睡竹节中的少女辉夜姬,执着于偷孩子的姑获鸟,稻荷神御馔津,罗生门之鬼茨木,受尽苦痛却心怀光明的座敷童子……还有很多很多,我们所牵挂着的,费尽心血养大的它们……喜欢阴阳师的小伙伴们,让我们一起重拾关于它们的故事吧^_^书友群:642616920
  • 浮影

    浮影

    下午三点钟的时候,办公室的陆美云从澡堂洗了澡出来,老远就听见有人在喊。回头看时,就见工会的黄胖子黄爱玲从食堂那头颠颠地跑来。黄胖子气还没喘匀,就开始冲着陆美云哇啦哇啦地喊,我看你奖金是不想拿了,上班的时候去洗澡。我就知道你肯定是在洗澡。黄胖子身子很粗,嗓子却是很细,说话的声音又高又尖,听起来就很刺耳。不过,陆美云同黄胖子很要好,所以,陆美云听黄胖子说话并不刺耳。陆美云笑一笑,沥了沥头发上的水,说,你什么时候要给厂里发奖金了?我现在早都忘了奖金长什么样了。
  • 江湖败类

    江湖败类

    杏花疏影里,落日明珠袍;弓摧南山虎,杀人如剪草。魏无忌穿越到大魏帝国,却被卷入一场波谲云诡的惊天阴谋中,阴差阳错成为小皇帝的心腹,创办锦衣卫,征方腊,灭梁山,诛东厂,定天下,借朝廷之力一统江湖,成为江湖中人人得而诛之的败类。
  • 陈汉雄谜案追踪之复活者系列(中国好小说)

    陈汉雄谜案追踪之复活者系列(中国好小说)

    小说以复活者的案件为故事主线,在侦破该案的过程中,发生了一连串的各类案件,围绕这些案件,侦探人员找到了其中的关联和蛛丝马迹,通过层层追凶,最终并追查到幕后指使,并将其绳之依法。
  • 中华成语故事(利)

    中华成语故事(利)

    成语源远流长,是汉语重要的组成部分。它多源于历史典故诗词歌赋和寓言故事中。成语把丰富的历史知识和浓郁的文学色彩融为一体,堪称中华民族文化的瑰宝,是中国历史文化的精华。每个成语都是个故事,它的形式虽然简单,但却形象生动,十分富有表现力,往往几个字就能说出一个非常深刻的道理,发人深省,读了让人受益匪浅。
  • 明伦汇编官常典大理寺部

    明伦汇编官常典大理寺部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 漫步榕城

    漫步榕城

    九零后男生周锦康因高考失利,致使填报志愿的范围受限,再加上过敏体质,尤其是在每年的白露期间对家乡北方的蒿草过敏,不得不填报考了南方城市福州的大学。六零后妈妈金雪莉不放心儿子独自南下,于是陪儿子周锦康来福州读大学。对于母亲的陪伴,儿子锦康从始至终都是反对的,在此期间母子俩冲突不断,令母亲金雪莉心力交瘁疲惫不堪。虽然身旁有妹妹金雪莹温情陪伴,可是没想到妹妹雪莹的个人感情因来福州后有了更大的变故……
  • 夫君不乖

    夫君不乖

    可怜女主无辜穿越到女尊世界,不料被迫装成男人,练就绝世武功,还收了一大堆绝世美男。本文不小白,搞笑加点玄幻色彩,喜欢的女尊文的亲们,可千万不要错过啊!前世的情,后世的债,原来人死之后真的有天使。死在男人手里,也算是一大笑话,死了却也不安分,揍了天使,砸了轮盘,于是不小心穿越了。死了,又活了,遇见了‘天人’。天人说,你个登徒子。我说,我哪敢!天人说,我是男的。我知道。天人说,我的清白。拜托,我不就偷看了几眼嘛?天人说,你不许走。好,那咱就不走。天人最后说了,你要对我负责。啊,原来,这看男人也是罪过…女尊文,NP……好这口的定要来支持啊。感谢亲爱的宝宝,为我做的封面,实在是太赞了。推荐新文:痞女修仙传,,水宣给花生建的群:104863278,大家有兴趣的来啊,另外非常感谢水宣!
  • 第一专宠,匪姐不好惹

    第一专宠,匪姐不好惹

    孽债啊!不能啊!他是个非男勿扰的怪王爷,女人,从来不碰!关起门来,翻翻账本,不是东风压倒西风,就是西风压倒东风。