登陆注册
5247200000043

第43章 THE GREAT POLITICAL SUPERSTITION(4)

"Yes, but," comes the obvious rejoinder, "as there is no deed by which the members of a nation are incorporated -- as there neither is, nor ever was, a specification of purposes for which the union was formed, there exist no limits; and, consequently, the power of the majority is unlimited."Evidently it must be admitted that the hypothesis of a social contract, either under the shape assumed by Hobbes or under the shape assumed by Rousseau, is baseless. Nay more, it must be admitted that even had such a contract once been formed, it could not be binding on the posterity of those who formed it. Moreover, if any say that in the absence of those Stations to its powers which a deed of incorporation might imply, there is nothing to prevent a majority from imposing its will on a minority by force, assent must be given an assent, however, joined with the comment that if the superior force of the majority is its justification, then the superior force of a despot backed by an adequate army, is also justified: the problem lapses. What we here seek is some higher warrant for the subordination of minority to majority than that arising from inability to resist physical coercion. Even Austin, anxious as he is to establish the unquestionable authority of positive law, and assuming, as he does, an absolute sovereignty of some kind, monarchic, aristocratic, constitutional, or popular, as the source of its unquestionable authority, is obliged, in the last resort, to admit a moral limit to its action over the community. While insisting, in pursuance of his rigid theory of sovereignty, that a sovereign body originating from the people "is legally free to abridge their political liberty, at its own pleasure or discretion," he allows that "a government may be hindered by positive morality from abridging the political liberty which it leaves or grants to its subjects."(4*) Hence, we have to find, not a physical justification, but a moral justification, for the supposed absolute power of the majority.

This will at once draw forth the rejoinder -- "Of course, in the absence of any agreement, with its implied limitations, the rule of the majority is unlimited; because it is more just that the majority should have its way than that the minority should have its way." A very reasonable rejoinder this seems until there comes the re-rejoinder. We may oppose to it the equally tenable proposition that, in the absence of an agreement, the supremacy of a majority over a minority does not exist at all. It is co-operation of some kind, from which there arise these powers and obligations of majority and minority; and in the absence of any agreement to co-operate, such powers and obligations are also absent.

Here the argument apparently ends in a dead lock. Under the existing condition of things, no moral origin seems assignable either for the sovereignty of the majority or for the limitation of its sovereignty. But further consideration reveals a solution of the difficulty. For if, dismissing all thought of any hypothetical agreement to cooperate heretofore made, we ask what would be the agreement into which citizens would now enter with practical unanimity, we get a sufficiently clear answer; and with it a sufficiently clear justification for the rule of the majority inside a certain sphere, but not outside that sphere.

Let us first observe a few of the limitations which at once become apparent.

Were all Englishmen now asked if they would agree to co-operate for the teaching of religion, and would give the majority power to fix the creed and the forms of worship, there would come a very emphatic "No" from a large part of them. If, in pursuance of a proposal to revive sumptuary laws, the inquiry were made whether they would bind themselves to abide by the will of the majority in respect of the fashions and qualities of their clothes, nearly all of them would refuse. In like manner if (to take an actual question of the day) people were polled to ascertain whether, in respect of the beverages they drank, they would accept the decision of the greater number, certainly half, and probably more than half, would be unwilling. Similarly with respect to many other actions which most men now-a-days regard as of purely private concern. Whatever desire there might be to co-operate for carrying on, or regulating, such actions, would be far from a unanimous desire. Manifestly, then, had social co-operation to be commenced by ourselves, and had its purposes to be specified before consent to co-operate could be obtained, there would be large parts of human conduct in respect of which co-operation would be declined; and in respect of which, consequently, no authority by the majority over the minority could be rightfully exercised.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 禅林宝训顺朱

    禅林宝训顺朱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 绯色婚宠,宁少的1号夫人

    绯色婚宠,宁少的1号夫人

    每天打四份工艰苦度日却不小心打到总裁头上,柳明媚表示很无辜。面前摆着三条路:监狱、婚姻、娱乐圈,柳明媚觉得第三条路勉强可以接受。本以为他帮她,宠她,是她坚实的依靠,却不想,宁奕辰不过是她的监牢,他跟她永远隔着一堵高墙。当她站在最闪亮的聚光灯下,功成名就之时,宁奕辰才发觉自己做错了一件事。宁奕辰:“你不适合娱乐圈!”柳明媚:“你说一个天后不适合娱乐圈?”宁奕辰:“你最适合嫁给我!”
  • 丝绸之路的故事

    丝绸之路的故事

    作为龙的传人,你想知道中国为什么被称为世界文明古国吗?拿起这本书,走进时空隧道,读读丝绸之路上那些壮丽的故事,你就有答案了……
  • 钓鱼的男孩

    钓鱼的男孩

    当我想起我们的故事,想到从那天早晨开始,我们这从未分离过的一家人分开了,我真希望——即便过了二十年也是如此——希望他不曾离开,不曾收到那封调动通知。在那个通知到来之前,一切井然有序:父亲每天早晨出门上班,在露天市场摆摊卖生鲜食品的母亲照料我和我的五个兄弟姐妹。我们跟阿库雷大多数人家的孩子一样,得去上学。万事都顺其自然。我们很少回想过去……我将成为飞行员,或者是尼日利亚总统,或者是大富翁,买得起直升飞机——因为未来在我们手中。未来是一块空白的画布,什么都有可能。然而,父亲调去约拉这件事改变了这一切:时间、季节和过去变得重要了,我们对过去的渴望甚至超过了当下和未来。
  • 饮水词

    饮水词

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 两界诡师

    两界诡师

    命运总是喜欢和他开玩笑。他以为他只是个普通平凡的大学生,命运却把他拉入到曲折离奇的人生道路中,等他慢慢地适应了自己的不平凡,命运却又让他变回了普通人。他珍视的人不珍视他,珍视他的人他却刻意回避,等他终于接受他忽视的那个人,那人却离他而去。然而命运的考验并不能让他屈服,他终将会被众人仰视……
  • 重生国民校草:柒男神,狠撩人

    重生国民校草:柒男神,狠撩人

    一日惨遭人陷害,她成了陆家唯一的小姐,父母双亡,由叔叔带大的她,嚣张,跋扈,目中无人。做的一些事也非常寒心,但,当宁柒变成陆宁柒,由一部电视剧爆红的国民校草,让大家重新认识她。“他”是小妹妹心中的温柔哥哥,是迷妹心中的白马王子,也是一个在某人眼中,闪闪发亮的星星。“如果我说,我要你做我男朋友,怎么样?”某女挑眉,嘴角微微上扬,明知故问,“可我是女的,做不了你男朋友。”“正好,我缺个女朋友。”在最美的青春,遇见最美的你,此生足矣。(本文女扮男,宠文,男女身心干净,1v1)
  • The Vicomte de Bragelonne

    The Vicomte de Bragelonne

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 青云剑尊

    青云剑尊

    废柴叶峰只因无法修炼,遭到亲人驱逐,枉死在守陵房中。异界剑神附体重生之后,却发现这幅身躯,竟是亿万万人中,都难得一见的绝世体质,混元无极之体!
  • 沙弥学戒仪轨颂注

    沙弥学戒仪轨颂注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。