登陆注册
5247200000044

第44章 THE GREAT POLITICAL SUPERSTITION(5)

Turn now to the converse question -- For what ends would all men agree to co-operate? None will deny that for resisting invasion the agreement would be practically unanimous. Excepting only the Quakers, who, having done highly useful work in their time, are now dying out, all would unite for defensive war (not, however, for offensive war); and they would, by so doing, tacitly bind themselves to conform to the will of the majority in respect of measures directed to that end. There would be practical unanimity, also, in the agreement to co-operate for defence against internal enemies as against eternal enemies. Omitting criminals, all must wish to have person and property adequately protected. In short, each citizen desires to preserve his life, to preserve those things which conduce to maintenance of his life and enjoyment of it, and to preserve intact his liberties both of using these things and getting further such. It is obvious to him that he cannot do all this if he acts alone. Against foreign invaders he is powerless unless he combines with his fellows; and the business of protecting himself against domestic invaders, if he did not similarly combine, would be alike onerous, dangerous, and inefficient. In one other co-operation all are interested --use of the territory they inhabit. Did the primitive communal ownership survive, there would survive the primitive communal control of the uses to be made of land by individuals or by groups of them; and decisions of the majority would rightly prevail respecting the terms on which portions of it might be employed for raising food, for making means of communication, and for other purposes. Even at present, though the matter has been complicated by the growth of private landownership, yet, since the State is still supreme owner (every landowner being in law a tenant of the Crown) able to resume possession, or authorize compulsory purchase, at a fair price; the implication is that the will of the majority is valid respecting the modes in which, and conditions under which, parts of the surface or sub-surface, may be utilized: involving certain agreements made on behalf of the public with private persons and companies.

Details are not needful here; nor is it needful to discuss that border region lying between these classes of cases, and to say how much is included in the last and how much is excluded with the first. For present purposes, it is sufficient to recognize the undeniable truth that there are numerous kinds of actions in respect of which men would not, if they were asked, agree with anything like unanimity to be bound by the will of the majority; while there are some kinds of actions in respect of which they would almost unanimously agree to be thus bound. Here, then, we find a definite warrant for enforcing the will of the majority within certain limits, and a definite warrant for denying the authority of its will beyond those limits.

But evidently, when analysed, the question resolves itself into the further question -- What are the relative claims of the aggregate and of its units? Are the rights of the community universally valid against the individual? or has the individual some rights which are valid against the community? The judgment given on this point underlies the entire fabric of political convictions formed, and more especially those convictions which concern the proper sphere of government. Here, then, I propose to revive a dormant controversy, with the expectation of reaching a different conclusion from that which is fashionable.

Says Professor Jevons, in his work, The State in Relation to Labour "The first step must be to rid our minds of the idea that there are any such things in social matters as abstract rights."Of like character is the belief expressed by Mr Matthew Arnold, in his article on copyright: -- "An author has no natural right to a property in his production. But then neither has he a natural right to anything whatever which he may produce or acquire."(5*) So, too, I recently read in a weekly journal of high repute, that "to explain once more that there is no such thing as 'natural right' would be a waste of philosophy." And the view expressed in these extracts is commonly uttered by statesmen and lawyers in a way implying that only the unthinking masses hold any other.

One might have expected that utterances to this effect would have been rendered less dogmatic by the knowledge that a whole school of legalists on the Continent, maintains a belief diametrically opposed to that maintained by the English school.

The idea of Natur-recht is the root-idea of German jurisprudence.

Now whatever may be the opinion held respecting German philosophy at large, it cannot be characterized as shallow. A doctrine current among a people distinguished above all others as laborious inquirers, and certainly not to be classed with superficial thinkers, should not be dismissed as though it were nothing more than a popular delusion. This, however, by the way.

Along with the proposition denied in the above quotations, there goes a counter-proposition affirmed. Let us see what it is; and what results when we go behind it and seek its warrant.

同类推荐
  • 观自在菩萨说普贤陀罗尼经

    观自在菩萨说普贤陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 诗镜总论

    诗镜总论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • INTENTIONS

    INTENTIONS

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中复堂选集

    中复堂选集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 诗经稗疏

    诗经稗疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 甘心为帝

    甘心为帝

    一开始,他只是闲来无事消磨时光,否则该如何度过那漫长的千年时光;可后来,却心甘情愿一步一步赔尽所有;到了最后,终是什么都没剩下。而她,从未想过会走到如此境地,那个仇视嫉恨昔日恩人的陌生帝王,真的是自己吗?直到最后一刻,她才明白自己这一生有多不幸,又有多么幸运。
  • 穿越V5,王妃有个APP

    穿越V5,王妃有个APP

    只不过在手机上装了个APP,居然穿越了!还穿成了个傻子。慕筱舒大呼坑爹,但是更坑爹的还在后头某人曰:“本王知恩图报,愿将全部身家交付。”“可是你只有一个铜板……”某人威武霸气:“本王给你!”慕筱舒掀桌:“这还不如一个铜板呢!”“本王的房子给你住,本王的手下给你用,你还不满意?别急,本王的人也给你睡!”【情节虚构,请勿模仿】
  • 棺爷

    棺爷

    干爹离奇死亡,尸体被切割成两千多块。下葬之后,八爷收我为徒!棺爷由我传承!
  • 嘉陵江记

    嘉陵江记

    嘉陵江几乎是至今可以认定有两个源头、而以草书方式一泻千里的唯一江河。站在重庆朝天门的码头看去,一脉浩荡从左向右,把最后、最为抒情的一笔作为她最优美的收势,插入长江的腹中。这是一幅人文的漫长书卷,一次精神的长途跋涉,经陕、甘、川、渝三省一市,一路惊涛拍岸,一路风花雪月,而这最后的落笔,却是我生命的记忆,是我的永远。我的第一声啼哭就是嘉陵江的涛声。在嘉陵江汇入长江之前一公里处,江水平静、舒缓,偶尔几处急流险滩,也不曾改变她终年修成的婉约和神秘。岸边有一个厂的名字很响亮,它叫长安,一个厂居然可以与唐朝的皇都同名。
  • 天外飞仙恩怨录

    天外飞仙恩怨录

    《天外飞仙》是一款武侠网游《天外飞仙》是游戏中一本举世无双的武功秘籍无数江湖好汉为了寻找争夺这本《天外飞仙》而掀起江湖腥风血雨叶圣,也不例外,一剑西来天外飞仙
  • 波兰童话·译言古登堡计划

    波兰童话·译言古登堡计划

    《波兰童话》精选了最精彩的7篇波兰童话,删去了其中重复的部分,留下了最引人入胜的讲述。这些故事大多流传已久,有些甚至可以追溯到原始雅利安人时期。波兰地处东欧,历史上曾经是欧洲最强盛的国家。独特的地理位置虽然给它招来了连年的战火,也造就了它独特的文化。作者戈林斯基出身自农民之家,他曾走遍波兰,收集并出版了大量的波兰民间故事,并多次再版。
  • 海阔云高波澜生

    海阔云高波澜生

    损友三人档,大学毕业的一次聚会后闹市穿越遭遇仙侠世界,各有奇遇,看天高海阔,述儿女情长,在各种奇葩经历中,女主们各自成长
  • 侵犯公民人身、民主权利罪与侵犯财产罪

    侵犯公民人身、民主权利罪与侵犯财产罪

    本书是中华人民共和国重要基本法律知识宣讲系列丛书之一,具体内容是对我国刑法分则第四章所规定的侵犯公民人身权利、民主权利罪,第五章所规定的侵犯财产罪,以及与其相关的司法解释等内容进行宣讲和普及。
  • 海外明夷录

    海外明夷录

    明初大航海时代,伟大的航海先驱郑和率空前绝世的水师舰队,云帆高举,七下西洋,臣服数十国,辉煌记忆让人热血沸腾;其同袍、朋友分踪五大陆、七大洲,历险奇趣寻宝探秘……
  • 僵尸暴君太疯狂

    僵尸暴君太疯狂

    他是一座与世隔绝的孤岛上的僵尸之王,历经沧桑等待死去千年的爱人女巫转世!她一个富贵人家的小姐天煞孤星,不受家人宠爱镇上的煞星,以为嫁给心爱之人便能拜托命运的捉弄,岂不知出嫁的路上被劫亲,她来到一个陌生的孤岛上救她的人非但绝美得不像人还要让她以身相许,当她坠入他无边无际的爱河时却发现她不过是一个替身,而他的身份竟然是令人闻风丧胆的僵尸,天帝的阻挠、亲人的相继离去、可怕的真相一步步揭开后她该情归何处?