登陆注册
5247200000045

第45章 THE GREAT POLITICAL SUPERSTITION(6)

On reverting to Bentham, we find this counter-proposition overtly expressed. He tells us that government fulfils its office "by creating rights which it confers upon individuals: rights of personal security; rights of protection for honour; rights of property;" etc.(6*) Were this doctrine asserted as following from the divine right of kings, there would be nothing in it manifestly incongruous. Did it come to us from ancient Peru, where the Ynca "was the source from which evening flowed";(7*) or from Shoa (Abyssinia), where "of their persons and worldly substance he [the king] is absolute master";(8*) or from Dahome, where "all men are slaves to the king";(9*) it would be consistent enough. But Bentham, far from being an absolutist like Hobbes, wrote in the interests of popular rule. In his Constitutional Code(10*) he fixes the sovereignty in the whole people; arguing that it is best "to give the sovereign power to the largest possible portion of those whose greatest happiness is the proper and chosen object," because "this proportion is more apt than any other that can be proposed" for achievement of that object.

Mark, now, what happens when we put these two doctrines together. The sovereign people jointly appoint representatives, and so create a government; the government thus created, creates rights; and then, having created rights, it confers them on the separate members of the sovereign people by which it was itself created. Here is a marvellous piece of political legerdemain! Mr Matthew Arnold, contending, in the article above quoted, that "property is the creation of law," tells us to beware of the "metaphysical phantom of property in itself." Surely, among metaphysical phantoms the most shadowy is this which supposes a thing to be obtained by creating an agent, which creates the thing, and then confers the thing on its own creator.!

From whatever point of view we consider it, Bentham's proposition proves to be unthinkable. Government, he says, fulfils its office "by creating rights." Two meanings may be given to the word "creating." It may be supposed to mean the production of something out of nothing; or it may be supposed to mean the giving form and structure to something which already exists. There are many who think that the production of something out of nothing cannot be conceived as effected even by omnipotence; and probably none will assert that the production of something out of nothing is within the competence of a human government. The alternative conception is that a human government creates only in the sense that it shapes something pre-existing.

In that case, the question arises -- "What is the something pre-existing which it shapes?" Clearly the word "creating" begs the whole question -- passes off an illusion on the unwary reader. Bentham was a stickler for definiteness of expression, and in his Book of Fallacies has a chapter on "Impostor-terms."It is curious that he should have furnished so striking an illustration of the perverted belief which an impostor-term may generate.

But now let us overlook these various impossibilities of thought, and seek the most defensible interpretation of Bentham's view.

It may be said that the totality of all powers and rights, originally existed as an undivided whole in the sovereign people;and that this undivided whole is given in trust (as Austin would say) to a ruling power, appointed by the sovereign people, for the purpose of distribution. If, as we have seen, the proposition that rights are created is simply a figure of speech; then the only intelligible construction of Bentham's view is that a multitude of individuals, who severally wish to satisfy their desires, and have, as an aggregate, possession of all the sources of satisfaction, as well as power over all individual actions, appoint a government, which declares the ways in which, and the conditions under which, individual actions may be carried on and the satisfactions obtained. Let us observe the implications. Each man exists in two capacities. In his private capacity he is subject to the government. In his public capacity he is one of the sovereign people who appoint the government. That is to say, in his private capacity he is one of those to whom rights are given; and in his public capacity he is one of those who, through the government they appoint, give the rights. Turn this abstract statement into a concrete statement, and see what it means. Let the community consist of a million men, who, by the hypothesis, are not only joint possessors of the inhabited region, but joint possessors of all liberties of action and appropriation: the only right recognized being that of the aggregate to everything. What follows? Each person, while not owning any product of his own labour, has, as a unit in the sovereign body, a millionth part of the ownership of the products of all others' labour. This is an unavoidable implication. As the government, in Bentham's view, is but an agent; the rights it confers are rights given to it in trust by the sovereign people. If so, such rights must be possessed en bloc by the sovereign people before the government, in fulfilment of its trust, confers them on individuals; and, if so, each individual has a millionth portion of these rights in his public capacity, while he has no rights in his private capacity. These he gets only when all the rest of the million join to endow him with them; while he joins to endow with them every other member of the million!

Thus, in whatever way we interpret it, Bentham's proposition leaves us in a plexus of absurdities.

同类推荐
  • 青颈观自在菩萨心陀罗尼经

    青颈观自在菩萨心陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 勅修百丈清规

    勅修百丈清规

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 贞白遗稿

    贞白遗稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 荈茗录

    荈茗录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中宗祀昊天乐章·豫

    中宗祀昊天乐章·豫

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 腹黑老公追逃妻

    腹黑老公追逃妻

    为了报答蓝家的养育之恩,她顶替姐姐嫁给了那个恶名在外的齐家大少。一直到结婚后两个人才“第一次”见面,她发现,嫁的人竟然是那个“他”。他厌恶她,她也不喜欢他,两个人做了一对人前恩爱人后冷淡的名义夫妻。阴差阳错之下,他们做了名符其实的夫妻,他是一个负责任的好男人,开始认真的履行丈夫的职责。幸福来得太快,她有点不知所措,当她终于怀上了他的孩子满心欢喜的准备告诉他的时候,看到的却是他和姐姐在一起的情景……儿子不是他的?想他堂堂齐家大少,竟然被女人如此的耍弄?男人火冒三丈,所有的柔情蜜意都变成了熊熊燃烧的烈焰!怜她、爱她、宠她,原来只是一场笑话,她居然这样对他,他——【一对一,本文男女主皆身心干净,甜宠文,就算偶尔小虐也是虐男。开篇可能有些小误会,会让女主吃些苦头,此乃成长必经之路途,觉悟之后的男主绝对是新时代的好男人!温馨治愈系好文章,有钱的出钱有力的出力,欢迎大家一起和作者来打造一个新好男人出来,给力跳坑啊……】
  • 极品蛊师混都市

    极品蛊师混都市

    蛊!能救人于垂死,亦能杀人于无形!稚气未脱的少年唐风,为了活命从大山深处来到都市之中,寻找那一丝活下去的希望。可是,唐风现在却非常烦恼,林云妃要与他共度余生,韩笑笑要与他长相厮守,魏思卿要与他不离不弃,花凌烟要与他双宿双飞……
  • 第一神算

    第一神算

    卜算的虽多,神算极少。哪怕神算也多,第一只有一个。别人卜算用外物,而我卜算用“炁”。2007年的一个女孩失踪,让我卷入了一场诡异的通灵风波,接二连三的怪事层出不穷,落在身上的“死劫”也逐步应验,开始我以为自己是个倒霉蛋,后来才知道,原来怪异的是我自己……
  • 长风当歌

    长风当歌

    武林第一美女是大多数武林女子梦寐以求的头衔吧。可是在这个武林中,这个头衔像个诅咒一样,所有当上武林第一美女的女子都会悄无声息地从武林中消失这一年,宁歌出乎人们意料地成为了武林第一美女,那她的命运将会如何呢?而那些失踪的武林第一美女又是怎么回事呢?
  • 最强三界聊天群

    最强三界聊天群

    手机掉进水里,重新打开后发现自己竟然加入了三界聊天群。齐天大圣的猴毛,太上老君的仙丹,南极仙翁的寿桃,月老的红线~~~~一群在手,天下我有!
  • 校园全能高手

    校园全能高手

    身价高、相貌好的千金大小姐兼校花,竟然是自己保护对象!身怀绝技的张凤梧虐小人、救美女,获其芳心,踏上炫酷人生之路。
  • 情商高,就是说话让人舒服

    情商高,就是说话让人舒服

    《情商高,就是说话让人舒服》为什么同样的产品,同事提成百万,你却总是卖不出去?——搞不定客户为什么同事聚餐时唯独不叫你?——职场遭排挤为什么你斥责下属时,对方总是选择离职?——带不好团队为什么你的约会邀请女神不接受?——撩妹失败为什么你一开口朋友就“开躲”,不愿意跟你说话的人越来越多?——出口就伤人……归根结底是因为你不懂得好好说话!要怎么说话呢?说到底就是,照顾别人的感受,不让人难堪。
  • 全阶战术

    全阶战术

    最强战神名扬天下,曾经杀遍一国,无人能挡。后却遭到江湖神秘组织魔师团的黑手。千年之后他重生于世间,再次踏上了巅峰之路。寻找并铲除魔师团这一邪教,为世人除害……
  • 殊途

    殊途

    “暖情天后”叶紫温暖巨献。相爱相思,相恨相怜,情至深处,殊途同归……越逃,命运越要把我们捆在一起。既然这样,不如相依过完此生!安宁因遭到相恋多年男友关信的抛弃,自杀未遂后背井离乡来到一个陌生的城市。在这个人生地不熟的地方,因为机缘巧合,她同苏旷开始了异性同居的生活。安宁和他之间有过误会,有过挣扎,有过甜蜜,有过心酸,从一开始的猜忌、怀疑到后来的相知相爱,两人走过许多弯路。安宁终于守到云开见月明时,却意外地发现关信当年离开她并非出自本意,误会解除后,她陷入两难的局面。面对两位同样优秀、痴情的男子,她该如何抉择?
  • 网游之魔创世

    网游之魔创世

    徘徊在光明与黑暗之中手中的十字啊祷告冷酷的恶魔变的善良在漆黑的云中我展开恶魔翅膀当无情的眼眸融化成绿色后光的降临,在洁白的云中聆听来自你心中的誓言眼里以没有了坚强眼里以没有了冷漠风,飘动心也跟着跳动云,飘动带走不去永久载着黑夜与灵魂来临就算死亡也无法隔离距离