登陆注册
5273300000043

第43章 THE UNION A FEDERATIVE AND NOT A NATIONAL GOVERNME

Congress might,by resolution,determine that the constitution was not republican,and direct the State to form a new one.And suppose that the State should refuse to do so,on the ground that it had already complied with the requisitions of the Federal Constitution in that respect?Could Congress direct an issue to try the question at the bar of the Supreme Court?This would,indeed,be an odd way of settling the rights of nations,and determining the extent of their powers!Besides,who would be parties to the issue?at whose suit should the State be summoned to appear and answer?Not at that of the United States,because a State cannot be sued by the United States,in a federal court;not at that of any other State,nor of any individual citizen,because they are not concerned in the question.

It is obvious that the case does not present proper subject matter for judicial investigation;and even if it did,that no parties could be found authorized to present the issue.

Again,Congress has authority "to provide for organizing,arming and disciplining the militia,and for governing such part of them as may be employed in the service of the United States;reserving to the States,respectively,the appointment of the officers and the authority of training the militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress."Suppose that Congress should usurp the right to appoint the militia officers,or the State should insist on training the militia in their own way,and not "according to the discipline prescribed by Congress."How could this matter be brought before the Supreme Court?And even if properly brought there,how could its sentence be executed?

Again,suppose that Congress should enact that all the slaves of the country should immediately be free.This is certainly not impossible,and I fear not even improbable,although it would be the grossest and most palpable violation of the rights of the slaveholder.This would certainly produce the most direct conflict between the State and Federal Governments.

It would involve a mere question of political power ?the question whether the act of Congress forbidding slavery,or the laws and Constitution of the State allowing it,should prevail.And yet it is manifest that it presents no subject matter proper for judicial decision,and that the parties to it could not be convened before the Supreme Court.

These examples are sufficient to show that there is a large class of "constitutional controversies,"which could not possibly be brought under the cognizance of any judicial tribunal,and still less under that of the federal courts.As to these cases,therefore,each State must,of necessity,for the reasons already stated,be its own "final judge or interpreter."

They involve the mere question of political power,as between the State and Federal Governments;and the fact that they are clearly withheld from the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court,goes far to prove that the States in framing the Constitution did not design to submit to that court any question of the like kind,in whatever form or between whatever parties it might arise,except so far only as the parties themselves were concerned.

Judge Story himself does not contend that the Supreme Court is the "final judge or interpreter"in all cases whatsoever;he,of course,admits that no court can decide any question which is not susceptible of a proper form for judicial enquiry.But he contends that,in all cases of which the Supreme Court can take cognizance,its decisions are final,and absolutely binding and conclusive in all respects,to all purposes,and against the States and their people.It is this sweeping conclusion which it has been my object to disprove.I can see in the federal courts nothing more than the ordinary functions of the judiciary in every country.It is their proper province to interpret the laws;but their decisions are not binding,except between the parties litigant and their privies.So far as they may claim the force of authority,they are not conclusive,even upon those who pronounce them,and certainly are not so beyond the sphere of their own government.Although the Judiciary may,and frequently do,enlarge or contract the powers of their own governments,as generally understood,yet they can never enlarge or contract those of other governments,for the simple reason that other governments are not bound by their decisions.And so in our own systems.

There is no case in which a judicial question can arise,before a federal court,between a State and the Federal Government.Upon what principle,then,are the States bound by the decisions of the federal judiciary?Upon no principle,certainly,except that,as to certain subjects,they have agreed to be so bound.But this agreement they made in their character of Sovereign States,not with the Federal Government,but with one another.

As sovereign States,they alone are to determine the nature and extent of that agreement,and,of course,they are to determine whether or not they have given the federal courts authority to bind them in any given case.This principle has frequently been asserted by the States,and always successfully.24

同类推荐
  • 太上正一法文经

    太上正一法文经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南翁梦录

    南翁梦录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 玉壶野史

    玉壶野史

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 神农本草经读

    神农本草经读

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Mountain Woman

    A Mountain Woman

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 满洲秘档选辑

    满洲秘档选辑

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 兼职医师

    兼职医师

    程强本是龙华国一个小小的普通人,但最后不知道怎么滴,就变成了整个九霄的王,程强其实并不想当什么王,他也想低调,可实力ta不允许啊!(轻松搞笑文,喜欢请收藏投票支持,谢谢!)
  • 狼谷口

    狼谷口

    我舅舅马二和尚死于一九八九年冬天。我舅舅死的前两天,狼谷口下了一场罕见的大雪,雪花铺天盖地,整整一天一夜,像满世界被白色的轻盈的羽毛填充了,飘飘扬扬,把个偌大的狼谷口下成了一只白色的巨鸟。冷气瞬间包围了村子,舅舅家后院茅坑里结了厚厚的一层冰凌,就连堂屋木架子上的酸菜缸,也冻裂了。我舅舅马二和尚蜷在炕上,透过糊满眼屎的眼睛和窗户纸破开的小洞,看着院子里半尺余深的积雪,他蜡黄色的脸上浮出一丝奇怪的笑。火盆里的火烧得很旺,外婆坐在炕上缝补旧衣裳,边缝边抹眼泪,说:“儿,你每回一钻山,我这心……就跟着抖哩。
  • 罪恶之城

    罪恶之城

    背负着沉重的期望,那身具恶魔和精灵血脉的少年毅然走向毁灭与重生的位面战场。放不下的执念支撑着他踏过熔岩,冲破深冰,更在绝域战场中纵横杀戮,只为打倒遥遥前方那个巍巍身影。终有一日,他驻足插刀,放眼四顾,却已茫茫不见敌手。原来曾经的巍峨绝峰,已在脚下。这个家族血管中流的每一滴血,都充满了罪恶和肮脏的东西。他们是所有矛盾的集合:他们热情,他们冷酷;他们善于记忆,他们经常遗忘;他们忠于梦想,他们随时妥协;他们愿与圣徒为伴,他们总和魔鬼合作;他们冷静,他们疯狂。他们是天使,他们也是魔鬼。所以我爱他们,我恨他们。
  • 创世农场

    创世农场

    赵强一个普通的大学学生。自从得到了创世农场,人生的轨迹发生了极大的改变。你觉得你很有钱,你的钱可以买下一个县城。赵强说“不好意思,我可以创造一个世界”。你觉得你的小弟很多,可以号召上万小弟,赵强说“不好意思,我可以创造一个种族。”
  • 东西均

    东西均

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 思益堂词钞

    思益堂词钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 科举论

    科举论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 风是沙的路

    风是沙的路

    父亲的三周年到了,按老家的习俗要“过一下”。在老家,一个人去世后,一周年、三周年、五周年、十周年都要“过一下”。“过一下”就是请阴阳做法事念经超度。父亲7岁上就给人拉长工,受了一辈子苦,去世那天,还犁了一上午的地。一辈子哺育我们兄弟姐妹八个,个个成家立业,后继有人。一辈子连只鸟都没宰过,见鸡啄架狗争势还要劝开,他有什么需要超度的呢?但是,经不得不念,“过一下”是一种规矩,是一种礼节,更是一种仪式,人是需要仪式感的。细想想,“过一下”是有意义的,不可或缺,逝者的生前好友和四方乡亲都会来烧纸焚香,吃吃喝喝,念叨念叨亡人,这是一种无可替代的怀念,更是儿孙感恩敬意的一种延伸。
  • 星际重生:拒当太子妃

    星际重生:拒当太子妃

    她易容成满脸斑的丑女设计指腹为婚的太子殿下退婚,一心只想找回万年前宠她如命的师父。可是,谁能告诉她,她师父怎么突然从温润如玉的仙人变身吃人不吐骨的狼人了?“师父,你…在做什么?”“傻落儿,师父突然想起来,有件事忘了教你……”“什么事啊?”“傻落儿,别捂着嘴,会呼吸不过来的…为师设了结界,不会有人听到的……”第二天晚上,她悲愤地跑去质问他:“师父你骗人!不是说没人会听到么?!”他微微一笑,“是没人听到…不过,你在我床上睡了一天一夜,他们可都看到了。”“落儿,你该好好补补了……身体这么弱怎么行?”“…………”