登陆注册
5273300000042

第42章 THE UNION A FEDERATIVE AND NOT A NATIONAL GOVERNME

but this clause is clearly not susceptible of any such construction.Every right may be said to be a constitutional right,because no right exists which the Constitution disallows;and,consequently,every remedy to enforce those rights presents "a case arising under the Constitution."But a construction so latitudinous will scarcely be contended for by any one.The clause under consideration gives jurisdiction only as to those matters,and between those parties,enumerated in the Constitution itself.Whenever such a case arises,the Federal courts have cognizance of it;but the right to decide a case arising under the Constitution,does not necessarily imply the right to determine in the last resort what that Constitution is.If the Federal courts should,in the very teeth of the eleventh amendment,take jurisdiction of cases "commenced or prosecuted against one of the States by citizens of another State,"the decisions of those courts,that they had jurisdiction,would certainly not settle the Constitution in that particular.The State would be under no obligation to submit to such a decision,and it would resist it by virtue of its sovereign right to decide for itself,whether it had agreed to the exercise of such a jurisdiction or not.

Considering the nature of our system of government,the States ought to be,and I presume always will be,extremely careful not to interpose their sovereign power against the decisions of the Supreme Court in any case where that court clearly has jurisdiction.Of this character are the cases already cited at the commencement of this inquiry;such,for example,as those between two States,those affecting foreign ministers,those of admiralty and maritime jurisdiction,&c.As to all these subjects the jurisdiction is clear,and no State can have any interest to dispute it.

The decisions of the Supreme Court,therefore,ought to be considered as final and conclusive,and it would be a breach of the contract on the part of any State to refuse submission to them.There are,however,many cases involving questions of the powers of government,State and federal,which cannot assume a proper form for judicial investigation.Most questions of mere political power are of this sort;and such are all questions between a State and the United States.As to these,the Constitution confers no jurisdiction on the federal courts,and,of course,it provides no common umpire to whose decision they can be referred.In such cases,therefore,the State must of necessity decide for itself.But there are also cases between citizen and citizen,arising under the laws of the United States,and between the United States and the citizen,arising in the same way.

So far as the federal tribunals have cognizance of such cases,their decisions are final.If the constitutionality of the law under which the case arises,should come into question,the court has authority to decide it,and there is no relief for the parties,in any other judicial proceeding.If the decision,in a controversy between the United States and a citizen,should be against the United States,it is,of course,final and conclusive.If the decision should be against the citizen,his only relief is by an appeal to his own State.He is under no obligation to submit to federal decisions at all,except so far only as his own State has commanded him to do so;

and he has,therefore,a perfect right to ask his State whether her commands extend to the particular case or not.He does not ask whether the federal court has interpreted the law correctly or not,but whether or not she ever consented that Congress should pass the law.If Congress had such power,he has no relief,for the decision of the highest federal court is final;if Congress had not such power,then he is oppressed by the action of a usurped authority,and has a right to look to his own State for redress.

His State may interpose in his favor or not,as she may think proper.If she does not,then there is an end of the matter;if she does,than it is no longer a judicial question.The question is then between new parties,who are not bound by the former decision;between a State and the United States.As between these parties the federal tribunals have no jurisdiction,there is no longer a common umpire to whom the controversy can be referred.

The State must of necessity judge for itself,by virtue of that inherent,sovereign power and authority,which,as to this matter,it has never surrendered to any other tribunal.Its decision,whatever it may be,is binding upon itself and upon its own people,and no farther.

A great variety of cases are possible,some of which are not unlikely to arise,involving the true construction of the Federal Constitution,but which could not possibly be presented to the courts,in a form proper for their decision.The following are examples:

By the 4th section of the 4th article it is provided that "Congress shall guaranty to every State in the Union a republican form of government."What is a republican form of government,and how shall the question be decided?In its very nature,it is a political,and not a judicial question,and it is not easy to imagine by what contrivance it could be brought before a court.Suppose a State should adopt a constitution not republican,in the opinion of Congress,what course would be pursued?

同类推荐
  • 平书

    平书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Jean of the Lazy A

    Jean of the Lazy A

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金刚瑜伽降三世成就极深密门

    金刚瑜伽降三世成就极深密门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 阿毗昙毗婆沙论

    阿毗昙毗婆沙论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Twelve Stories and a Dream

    Twelve Stories and a Dream

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 凌世神帝

    凌世神帝

    【火爆新书】【热血玄幻】最强神帝,重生归来。即便跌落凡尘,亦能逆天改命,再临万界主宰!
  • 送令狐尚书赴东都留

    送令狐尚书赴东都留

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 揭秘西方魔术(走进魔术世界)

    揭秘西方魔术(走进魔术世界)

    《走进魔术世界:揭秘西方魔术》分为几个部分,起篇介绍魔术史上的一些趣闻轶事,并在其中穿插进一些古老的魔术表演,后面是全书重点,披露了很多节目的表演过程、道具制作及一些常用手法。
  • 西南夷风土记

    西南夷风土记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 我真的这么厉害

    我真的这么厉害

    新书《无敌从高考开始》,请各位读者继续支持!林修从仙岛归来,以高傲姿态,吊打各路高手。不服?你是圣尊强者?不好意思,我踩的就是圣尊!书友群:564842229
  • 黄泉眼之印1:海怪事件调查手记

    黄泉眼之印1:海怪事件调查手记

    因为工作的关系,邹凯男经常要出海。一次,公司领导孟洋重金邀请他出海一起从事一项生物技术的研发,自从踏上黄泉眼岛之后,接连发生的一连串怪事使邹凯男疑窦丛生。鬼发水母、异岛巨蟒、潜艇坟场、死亡日记……这些尘封已久的历史密件一一浮出水面,原来一路上遇到到的那些鬼魅、令人惊悚的海怪都是常见的动物基因嫁接的产物,用来作为二战时期的生化武器;原来孟洋出海并不是做药品开发,而是寻找当年生产生化武器遗留的隐性资料;原来王晨飞是当年一起上岛的科学家王际遇的儿子,原来赵边城和韩西城是亲兄弟,原来所有的一切都不是最初所理解的那样,原来每个人都有一个别人不知道的身份,原来邹凯男也有另一个身份,只是他自己还不知道……
  • 古仙庭

    古仙庭

    数万年前掌控三界秩序的仙庭神秘消失,留下了无尽的传说,引后世遐想!仙庭消失数万年后,三界建立了全新的秩序,无数天之骄子涌现,盛世已经来临。是泯然众人,还是浴血而起!
  • 和你在一起的每一个雨天

    和你在一起的每一个雨天

    “每一个雨天,都有你陪伴的辰光”——丸语儿《呆萌妹妹》–夜幕降临,外面夜雨寄北,……
  • 辛巴达航海历险记

    辛巴达航海历险记

    《辛巴达航海历险记》,出自《天方夜谭》,是中古阿拉伯文学中一部规模宏大、内容丰富的民间故事集,是世界文学中一颗璀璨的明珠。是亚洲中近东各国、阿拉伯地区广大市井艺人和文人学者经才几百年的共同加工、提炼、编纂而成的。它包罗了各种各样的精彩故事,集中了阿拉伯世界民间故事精华,是规模宏大的阿拉伯民间故事集。包括寓言、童话、冒险、爱情、名人轶事等各类故事。因其想象丰富、描写生动、故事曲折而风靡全世界。
  • 檐醉杂记

    檐醉杂记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。