登陆注册
5273900000051

第51章 RIGHTS OF CAPTURE BY LAND.(2)

Seventy years ago the question of the right of a successful enemy to carryaway with him works of art was a matter of violent controversy in this countryand in the whole of Europeand the subject was several times debated inthe British ParliamentIt is a fact very generally known that after theearly and astonishing successes of Napoleon Bonaparte in 1796and afterwardsin 1797there was only one of the small Italian States which was not compelledto give up to the conquering French Government the works of art that werethe glory of its chief citiesThe Apollo Belvederethe Dying Gladiator,the Medicean Venusthe Laocoonthe Bronze Horseswere conveyed to Parisand deposited in the Louvrein which they remained until the overthrow ofthe first French EmpireOn the overthrow of that Empirewhen the allies,entering Paris for the second timegained possession of the whole city,they restored most of these famous masterpieces to their original owners.

The French expressedand no doubt genuinely feltthe greatest indignation,which washowevermanifestly treated with much scorn by the English writersof that daywho seemed to look upon the anger of the French or Parisianpopulation as amounting to an absurd refusal to have a rule applied to themselveswhich they had freely applied to othersbut if we are to suppose that strictlaw applied to the case there was something to say against the internationalvalidity of the restorations in the way in which they were actually accomplished.

Argumentsfounded on thiswere submitted to the British House of Commons,especially by the great lawyer RomillyIt was a fact that some of theseworks of art had formed part of forced military contributionswhich a conquerormay always levyand some were given up under express conventions to whichthe surrendering state had no power of resistanceIn some other cases thestate to which the return was made had been absorbed in another state duringthe long war with FranceFor exampleVenicewhich had surrendered someof the most beautiful works of art in the Louvrehad now become absorbedin the Austrian EmpireIt was further argued that it was for the advantageof civilization that these works of art should not be dispersed over a numberof small cities in Italy which were not thenall of themeasily accessible,but that they should remain in a place which on the whole was so easily reachedas ParisThe fact seems to be that the carrying off of these works of artfrom their old Italian homes had been a new rule of warFor exampleFrederickthe Greatwho more than once occupied Dresdenalways spared the famousgallery and its contentsThe new rule was introduced by Napoleon Bonaparteas conqueror of Italyand what the allies in occupation of Paris appliedseems to have been the rule of reprisalThere wasno doubtif we throwthe technical rule asidea great deal to be urged on behalf of giving backthese sculptures and paintings to the Italian citiesThey were valued bythem more than any mere propertySome of these cities before the war werehardly ever visited except by persons desirous of seeing some famous work.

As I saythe one tenable argument against their restoration was the greaterconvenience to the civilised world of their being left in Parisbut in anage of railways their distance in Italy is no appreciable inconvenience,and the Manuals published recently by civilised states generally condemnthe capture of works of artOur own Manual says that the seizure of scientificobjects and works of art can only be justified as a measure of retaliation.

Here I may observe that an act attributable to a British commander of Britishtroopswhich is almost universally condemned in the numerous American workson International Lawcan always be justified in the same wayUndoubtedly,at first sightthe destruction of the Capitol at Washington in 181is notan act of which an Englishman can be proudbut on examining the historyof that warit will appear that the British troops in Washington had beenfired at from the arsenaland that alsoa short time beforethe chiefcity of Lower Canadathen called Yorkhad been burnt with all its publicbuildings by the American troops who occupied itHence this actwhich atfirst sight deserves unqualified condemnationmay be to a certain extentjustified as a measure of reprisal.

In all modern books on this subject there is more or less distinct condemnationof unauthorized pillage by the soldiers of an invading armyyet there is,unfortunatelyno doubt that in all wars pillage does continueand especiallyin every land warThere is a very old association between war and pillage,and pillage is generally very easyA great deal of itthough not of theworst kindunquestionably took place when the Germans occupied large portionsof FranceThe English in Spain abstained from it so far as the orders ofWellington compelled them to do soHe in fact sometimes employed the severestpunishments for the purpose of deterring his troops from plunderhowever,he was operating in a friendly countryand would have suffered serious damageby its being converted to unfriendlinessA commander mayhoweverauthorisepillagebut as to authorised pillage there is one considerable mitigation.

同类推荐
  • THE END OF

    THE END OF

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Clouds

    The Clouds

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Of the Jealousy of Trade

    Of the Jealousy of Trade

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说炽盛光大威德消灾吉祥陀罗尼经

    佛说炽盛光大威德消灾吉祥陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 说疑

    说疑

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 重生之明月何皎皎

    重生之明月何皎皎

    生不逢时,爱而不得,皆是命数。她死在他怀里时,他信命了,这辈子他未曾珍惜过她,也没有好好对过她,而这次呢,他活该,他彻底丢了她。后来人人都说他疯了,抱着一个尸体满世界跑,散尽家财去找让人复活的方法
  • 仙尘遗事

    仙尘遗事

    天地者,日月之逆旅!百代者,光阴之过客!有人说,苍生万物,不过岁月长河的一滴水珠,不过是亘古匆匆的一粒芥子,再璀璨的光芒,也敌不过时间的洗礼。终将冥灭而亡。只是,万物苍生,幸好有那么一些不甘沉寂的生命,逆流而上,逆势而为,寻求长生之术,不死之方,欲求打个破命运的牢笼,证道长生,逍遥不死。
  • 千里走貂蝉

    千里走貂蝉

    赵焰,中国作协会会员、安徽作家协副主席。创作形式多样,出版有长篇小说《无常》,徽州文化系列散文八种,历史传记《晚清三部曲》等书籍二十多种。多种作品在全国有较大影响。题记真相就像一个迷宫般的城镇,里面有很多街道。现在,就让我们在这些街道上穿梭行走。在这些街道上行走的时候,就是我们认识街道的过程。——卡尔维诺我是关羽很多年后,当我已拎不太动那把沉重的青龙偃月刀的时候,我总是让周仓把它扛在肩上,和他一起漫步聊天。我喜欢漫步在襄阳的城墙上,眺望不远处的汉水迤逦流淌。
  • 反派他偏执狠厉城府深

    反派他偏执狠厉城府深

    (1V1,暗黑苏爽甜宠文)一不小心得罪了病娇美人大反派,反派他偏执狠戾城府深,心黑腹窄气量小,上天入地痴缠不休,专咬她这张祸从口出的嘴。小黑屋中,言萝捂着腊肠嘴强烈抗议:“报仇归报仇,咱好好动手,别动口!”人偶师气定神闲,展臂捞她入怀,对她动手又动脚,“恭敬不如从命。”朝堂上,言萝伏地疾呼:“皇上恕罪,臣不举!”少年天子温声道:“无妨,朕可举。”侯府内,言萝不吝夸赞:“侯府的舞姬,眼眸尤为勾人。”矜贵世子脉脉含笑:“你若喜欢,摘下赠你便是。”逃脱无望,言萝痛定思痛,决定以身相许来谢罪。#前方病娇横行,埋雷慎入#【旧文《快穿女配:你的男主又黑化了》已完结,1V1相爱相杀暗黑重口味,欢迎订阅。】
  • 10天打造强大内心

    10天打造强大内心

    一个人的内心像一个气球,内心强大的人伸缩的范围就大,内心弱小的人伸缩的范围就小。对于同样的坎坷,内心强大者比内心弱小者更能从容淡定地去面对和处理。《10天打造强大内心》从对人内心的分析、内心强大与弱小的不同表现、内心强大的训练等方面进行了全方位的解读,指导读者塑造强大的内心。具备强大内心的人,脚下即使不是坦途,步子也一样坚定!
  • 格斗少爷

    格斗少爷

    你若敬我,我便敬你三尺。你若爱我,我便一诺千金。你若害我,我便十倍奉还。这就是我,我就是孙洪源,我的命由我不由人。兄弟!这天下,我们共同霸唱!
  • 海的梦

    海的梦

    《海的梦》写于九一八事变后的第二年,日本不断加快侵华的步伐,正值民族危难之际。巴金在小说中构建了一个类似童话般的奇异的故事,似真似假,如梦似幻,却真实的映射着现实。小说的结构方式别出心裁,上半部分通过女主人公里娜的口述,再现了“杨”和那个孩子率领岛国奴隶英勇抵抗侵略者的壮举;下半部分通过里娜的日记,展现了她丰富的内心世界。
  • 炽焰豪门:boss老公诱妻成瘾

    炽焰豪门:boss老公诱妻成瘾

    “女人,你只需要对我绝对服从,你要的东西我自然会给你。”他勾起她的下颚,冷傲不可一世的警告道。“包括你的命吗?”一纸交易为目的婚约。一个由柔弱性格逐渐露出利爪的女人,每每挑战他极限的瞬间,都让他露出猎捕的冲动。殊不知,她只是一个长着和他妻子相同面孔的女人,伊雪同父异母的妹妹伊薇,她最大的愿望就是看着姐姐找到幸福,让她措手比较的是,伊雪却在两个月之后流产离世,种种事件都透着诡异的阴谋,为了查清凶手,她顶替伊雪呆在安墨寒的身边,和他斗智斗勇。是谁对姐姐下的堕胎药?安墨寒?还是另有他人?姐姐肚子里的孩子不是安墨寒的?那……是谁的崽?在家防暗箭,在外防情敌,睡觉防‘老公’。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 法医狂宠:枭爷,追妻!

    法医狂宠:枭爷,追妻!

    名满国外的法医王,突然回国,外媒多方打探,竟然知道了一个惊天秘密!法医王北辰枭竟然是X.R集团的总裁!“枭,你回国,不会是为了涣然吧?”“嗯。”“……”【坑品保证,快来围观!???!(??????)??】
  • Beethoven