登陆注册
5273900000051

第51章 RIGHTS OF CAPTURE BY LAND.(2)

Seventy years ago the question of the right of a successful enemy to carryaway with him works of art was a matter of violent controversy in this countryand in the whole of Europeand the subject was several times debated inthe British ParliamentIt is a fact very generally known that after theearly and astonishing successes of Napoleon Bonaparte in 1796and afterwardsin 1797there was only one of the small Italian States which was not compelledto give up to the conquering French Government the works of art that werethe glory of its chief citiesThe Apollo Belvederethe Dying Gladiator,the Medicean Venusthe Laocoonthe Bronze Horseswere conveyed to Parisand deposited in the Louvrein which they remained until the overthrow ofthe first French EmpireOn the overthrow of that Empirewhen the allies,entering Paris for the second timegained possession of the whole city,they restored most of these famous masterpieces to their original owners.

The French expressedand no doubt genuinely feltthe greatest indignation,which washowevermanifestly treated with much scorn by the English writersof that daywho seemed to look upon the anger of the French or Parisianpopulation as amounting to an absurd refusal to have a rule applied to themselveswhich they had freely applied to othersbut if we are to suppose that strictlaw applied to the case there was something to say against the internationalvalidity of the restorations in the way in which they were actually accomplished.

Argumentsfounded on thiswere submitted to the British House of Commons,especially by the great lawyer RomillyIt was a fact that some of theseworks of art had formed part of forced military contributionswhich a conquerormay always levyand some were given up under express conventions to whichthe surrendering state had no power of resistanceIn some other cases thestate to which the return was made had been absorbed in another state duringthe long war with FranceFor exampleVenicewhich had surrendered someof the most beautiful works of art in the Louvrehad now become absorbedin the Austrian EmpireIt was further argued that it was for the advantageof civilization that these works of art should not be dispersed over a numberof small cities in Italy which were not thenall of themeasily accessible,but that they should remain in a place which on the whole was so easily reachedas ParisThe fact seems to be that the carrying off of these works of artfrom their old Italian homes had been a new rule of warFor exampleFrederickthe Greatwho more than once occupied Dresdenalways spared the famousgallery and its contentsThe new rule was introduced by Napoleon Bonaparteas conqueror of Italyand what the allies in occupation of Paris appliedseems to have been the rule of reprisalThere wasno doubtif we throwthe technical rule asidea great deal to be urged on behalf of giving backthese sculptures and paintings to the Italian citiesThey were valued bythem more than any mere propertySome of these cities before the war werehardly ever visited except by persons desirous of seeing some famous work.

As I saythe one tenable argument against their restoration was the greaterconvenience to the civilised world of their being left in Parisbut in anage of railways their distance in Italy is no appreciable inconvenience,and the Manuals published recently by civilised states generally condemnthe capture of works of artOur own Manual says that the seizure of scientificobjects and works of art can only be justified as a measure of retaliation.

Here I may observe that an act attributable to a British commander of Britishtroopswhich is almost universally condemned in the numerous American workson International Lawcan always be justified in the same wayUndoubtedly,at first sightthe destruction of the Capitol at Washington in 181is notan act of which an Englishman can be proudbut on examining the historyof that warit will appear that the British troops in Washington had beenfired at from the arsenaland that alsoa short time beforethe chiefcity of Lower Canadathen called Yorkhad been burnt with all its publicbuildings by the American troops who occupied itHence this actwhich atfirst sight deserves unqualified condemnationmay be to a certain extentjustified as a measure of reprisal.

In all modern books on this subject there is more or less distinct condemnationof unauthorized pillage by the soldiers of an invading armyyet there is,unfortunatelyno doubt that in all wars pillage does continueand especiallyin every land warThere is a very old association between war and pillage,and pillage is generally very easyA great deal of itthough not of theworst kindunquestionably took place when the Germans occupied large portionsof FranceThe English in Spain abstained from it so far as the orders ofWellington compelled them to do soHe in fact sometimes employed the severestpunishments for the purpose of deterring his troops from plunderhowever,he was operating in a friendly countryand would have suffered serious damageby its being converted to unfriendlinessA commander mayhoweverauthorisepillagebut as to authorised pillage there is one considerable mitigation.

同类推荐
  • 洞玄靈寶真人修行延年益算法

    洞玄靈寶真人修行延年益算法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 裨海记游

    裨海记游

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞玄灵宝投简符文要诀

    太上洞玄灵宝投简符文要诀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Messer Marco Polo

    Messer Marco Polo

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 疠疡机要

    疠疡机要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 上清道类事相

    上清道类事相

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 王爷家的悍妃

    王爷家的悍妃

    国陌离本是Z的一名特警,身赋异能的她屡破奇案,然而一次任务中,出现了意外。本以为死定了的她,竟魂穿到了一个名叫东轩的国家。灵魂也穿到了一个同名同姓的女孩身上。并且传承了女孩所以的记忆,医术以及绝世的武功。一封家书,陌离被自己的丞相爹爹设计嫁入了安王府,沦为了王府弃妃,受尽众人的嘲笑,却不知她们口中的弃妃,竟是医死人肉白骨,医手遮天的医仙大人,是那个曾经救了太后一命的下凡天仙。当安王爷君墨染得知府中弃妃实为自己日思夜想的医仙后,展开了漫长的追妻之路。陌离不知道的是,这只是另一个阴谋的开始。自己的身世,身赋的异能,皆是所有人想要争夺的。安王府大火过后,大家都说安王爷疯了。西凉被灭后的一年中,帝都都在传安王爷从两年前的那次大火中,除了大战西凉,从此就没有出过门,天天把自己灌醉,日日夜夜都在念着一个人儿的名字。两年后,东轩举国欢庆,各国使者出使东轩。“姑娘有些眼熟,不知我们是否在哪里见过。”“不曾见过。”“那我们现在算不算是见过了呢!”君墨染挑眉。奈何两年不曾笑一次的安王爷,居然对着人家姑娘傻笑。
  • 争取做优秀的自己

    争取做优秀的自己

    耐心是等待时机成熟的一种成事之道,反之,人在不耐烦时,往往易变得固执己见,粗鲁无礼,而使别人感觉难以相处,更难成大事。当一个人失去耐心的时候,也失去了明智的头脑去分析事物。所以,做任何事,都要抱有一份耐心,先打好基础,筹划好资本,然后再着手行动。
  • 魅力女人精彩一生

    魅力女人精彩一生

    全书从形象、气质、品位、风情、心态、智慧、情商、情感、健康、职场、交际、礼仪等生活中的方方面面来揭示现代女性的魅力要点,全面而细致地讲述了现代女性获取魅力与成功的必备要素,帮助女性朋友们迅速提升个人魅力,打造成功资本,赢得更为幸福的生活。
  • 颐庵文选

    颐庵文选

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 坏家伙

    坏家伙

    从办公楼出来,我趿拉着一双鞋。第一次走进这幢楼,也趿拉着鞋。我是实在等得不耐烦了,才跑去找他们的。妈妈办了提前退休的手续,回到家里已经两个多月,我顶职的事,一问就是叫我们等着。那天红毛告诉我,市长到了劳动局,在开会。我对红毛和光头说:去弄只鸡来,我把它送到会场去。两个家伙一听就哈哈笑,一齐说好。只要是捣蛋的事,他们就开心。那时候,劳动局在我眼里,就是一个嘀嘀咕咕的老头,加上一幢楼房。一年十二个月,楼房也是十二层。一层一层往垒,楼上的地板,就是楼下的天堂。一些房间其实空在那里,给我一间,我们一家就可以住得足够宽敞。
  • 娘子不太乖

    娘子不太乖

    某王爷不是对天下的女人都反感吗?但是为毛却把她这个穿越来的可怜人圈在身边呢?还不许她反抗,当她是死的吗?不仅如此,他竟然还威胁她:“你若是再敢逃跑的话,就把你的腿打断,让你哪里也去不了……”
  • 世界军事百科之现代陆战

    世界军事百科之现代陆战

    军事是一个国家和民族强大和稳定的象征,在国家生活中具有举足轻重的作用。国家兴亡,匹夫有责,全面而系统地掌握军事知识,是我们每一个人光荣的责任和义务,也是我们进行国防教育的主要内容。
  • 说话让人舒服的程度,决定你的高度

    说话让人舒服的程度,决定你的高度

    口才的好坏,会影响人的一生,因此每个人都希望自己能有一副好口才,纵横社交场合,给他人留下美好印象。那么,到底怎样才算真正的好口才?好口才,不一定口齿伶俐,不一定口若悬河,不一定巧言善辩,不一定妙语连珠,但一定令人舒服,这才是好口才的实质。说话令人舒服的程度,能反映一个人的品质、修养、胸怀、格局……一句话,它体现着你的高度。纵观历史、横看全球,那些在各个时代各行各业叱咤风云的“高人”,大多都懂得高超的说话之道,能与人和谐交往,说出来的话无一不令人舒服。
  • 全中国最穷的小伙子发财日记

    全中国最穷的小伙子发财日记

    老康三十而立,带着老婆,拖着儿子;没有存款,没有房子;读的是烂学校、破专业,一无所长;毕业后混了多年,稀里糊涂,不幸下岗;因为混得差,朋友都断了联系;举目望去,走投无路;看见老婆就内疚,丈母娘面前更是抬不起头;一家三口,低声下气,长期在丈母娘家“蜗居”……有一天……