登陆注册
5362500000218

第218章

I am not sure, but that it will be found highly expedient and useful, to divide the United States into four or five or half a dozen districts; and to institute a federal court in each district, in lieu of one in every State. The judges of these courts, with the aid of the State judges, may hold circuits for the trial of causes in the several parts of the respective districts. Justice through them may be administered with ease and despatch; and appeals may be safely circumscribed within a narrow compass. This plan appears to me at present the most eligible of any that could be adopted; and in order to it, it is necessary that the power of constituting inferior courts should exist in the full extent in which it is to be found in the proposed Constitution.

These reasons seem sufficient to satisfy a candid mind, that the want of such a power would have been a great defect in the plan. Let us now examine in what manner the judicial authority is to be distributed between the supreme and the inferior courts of the Union.

The Supreme Court is to be invested with original jurisdiction, only "in cases affecting ambassadors, other public ministers, and consuls, and those in which A STATE shall be a party." Public ministers of every class are the immediate representatives of their sovereigns. All questions in which they are concerned are so directly connected with the public peace, that, as well for the preservation of this, as out of respect to the sovereignties they represent, it is both expedient and proper that such questions should be submitted in the first instance to the highest judicatory of the nation. Though consuls have not in strictness a diplomatic character, yet as they are the public agents of the nations to which they belong, the same observation is in a great measure applicable to them. In cases in which a State might happen to be a party, it would ill suit its dignity to be turned over to an inferior tribunal.

Though it may rather be a digression from the immediate subject of this paper, I shall take occasion to mention here a supposition which has excited some alarm upon very mistaken grounds. It has been suggested that an assignment of the public securities of one State to the citizens of another, would enable them to prosecute that State in the federal courts for the amount of those securities; a suggestion which the following considerations prove to be without foundation.

It is inherent in the nature of sovereignty not to be amenable to the suit of an individual without its consent. This is the general sense, and the general practice of mankind; and the exemption, as one of the attributes of sovereignty, is now enjoyed by the government of every State in the Union. Unless, therefore, there is a surrender of this immunity in the plan of the convention, it will remain with the States, and the danger intimated must be merely ideal. The circumstances which are necessary to produce an alienation of State sovereignty were discussed in considering the article of taxation, and need not be repeated here. A recurrence to the principles there established will satisfy us, that there is no color to pretend that the State governments would, by the adoption of that plan, be divested of the privilege of paying their own debts in their own way, free from every constraint but that which flows from the obligations of good faith. The contracts between a nation and individuals are only binding on the conscience of the sovereign, and have no pretensions to a compulsive force. They confer no right of action, independent of the sovereign will. To what purpose would it be to authorize suits against States for the debts they owe? How could recoveries be enforced? It is evident, it could not be done without waging war against the contracting State; and to ascribe to the federal courts, by mere implication, and in destruction of a pre-existing right of the State governments, a power which would involve such a consequence, would be altogether forced and unwarrantable.

Let us resume the train of our observations. We have seen that the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court would be confined to two classes of causes, and those of a nature rarely to occur. In all other cases of federal cognizance, the original jurisdiction would appertain to the inferior tribunals; and the Supreme Court would have nothing more than an appellate jurisdiction, "with such exceptions and under such regulations as the Congress shall make."

The propriety of this appellate jurisdiction has been scarcely called in question in regard to matters of law; but the clamors have been loud against it as applied to matters of fact. Some well-intentioned men in this State, deriving their notions from the language and forms which obtain in our courts, have been induced to consider it as an implied supersedure of the trial by jury, in favor of the civil-law mode of trial, which prevails in our courts of admiralty, probate, and chancery.

A technical sense has been affixed to the term "appellate," which, in our law parlance, is commonly used in reference to appeals in the course of the civil law. But if I am not misinformed, the same meaning would not be given to it in any part of New England. There an appeal from one jury to another, is familiar both in language and practice, and is even a matter of course, until there have been two verdicts on one side. The word "appellate," therefore, will not be understood in the same sense in New England as in New York, which shows the impropriety of a technical interpretation derived from the jurisprudence of any particular State.

同类推荐
  • 革除遺事

    革除遺事

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 清江贝先生诗集

    清江贝先生诗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • King Edward the Third

    King Edward the Third

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 苦吟

    苦吟

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 上清诸真人授经时颂金真章

    上清诸真人授经时颂金真章

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 姒女仙途

    姒女仙途

    现代少女死后魂魄到异世界的酆都,从一个魂体到鬼修鲜葩,从冥界到道修之地与各路天骄争锋斗奇的成长故事。无CP。
  • 二十世纪英美短篇小说选读

    二十世纪英美短篇小说选读

    沈炎选编的《二十世纪英美短篇小说选读》以( 短篇)小说基本要素,如描述(deion),叙述 (narration),情节(plot),人物与人物塑造 (character&characterization),背景(setting) ,叙事角度(point of view),主题(theme),和象 (symbolism)等为轴线,选取经典英美短篇小说介绍小说阅读技巧,以提高学生文学阅读和欣赏的能力。本教材由两部分组成:①理论讲解;②23篇短篇小说。本教材为全英语教材。
  • 好方法教出好孩子

    好方法教出好孩子

    父母、孩子、教育,这几个词频频出现在大家的视线之中,不断的提醒着为人父母者要负起教育孩子的责任,履行教育孩子的义务。
  • 文化视野下的近代中国

    文化视野下的近代中国

    《文化视野下的近代中国》展示了2007年7月1—2日由北京师范大学中国近代文化研究中心主办、北京文化发展研究基地协办的“近代文化与近代中国”学术研讨会所取得的丰硕成果。书中选录了参会论文中的五十二篇。这些论文大致分为文化与社会、文化思潮及知识分子类;学术、史学类;教育、艺术类;社会文化及文化事业类;中外文化类等六部分,作为《文化视野下的近代中国》的主体内容。
  • 氾胜之书

    氾胜之书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 良缘配之捡来的徒弟

    良缘配之捡来的徒弟

    “师父!有了我,你的生活从此充满阳光!我上得厅堂,入得厨房,暖的了床。笑比花艳,怒比人俏,貌比妖美,人也聪敏,又有钱。简直是天降钻石雨!师父你心里一定笑的牙都合不拢吧。”董青青扳着手指看着对面自己的师父沐阳笑道。沐阳:“......”汗!天降石头雨吧!“八怪师妹,你乖乖洗衣服去吧。”清风忍着强翻白眼的冲动,笑看着董青青说道。青出于蓝而胜于蓝,八怪师妹就是传说中的天下无敌!
  • 穿越之独爱极品妃

    穿越之独爱极品妃

    莫名其妙穿越了,而且还是穿越到了偏僻的小山村,我的网络、我的汉堡、我的披萨、还有我的国学圣手,美好的现代生活、永别了。还遇上了传说中心如冰块、心狠手辣、杀人不眨眼,不近女色的男人,可是怎么跟传说的不一样,是遇上一个假传吗?不过这个桃花运也太多了吧?
  • 凤倾天下之独霸后宫

    凤倾天下之独霸后宫

    夕阳火热,洒下热烈的光芒,划过天空倾于大地,这是一个炎夏,划过的微风柔和的吹着人的脸颊,吹得人一阵舒爽,好似吹走热气的同时也吹走了所有的烦恼,连心情都跟着轻松了是的。“唔……秦楚,这里的风景好漂亮,以后我们常常来玩好不好。”山顶上,女孩扎着马尾,穿着合身的运动服,整个人都显得阳光、富有活力。她站在郁郁葱葱的大树前,浓郁的绿色衬得她更加青春。任谁也想不到这样一个女孩会是特工界……
  • 这里曾经是汉朝(全集)

    这里曾经是汉朝(全集)

    《这里曾经是汉朝》是最最通俗两汉史!《这里曾经是汉朝》是一套全面解读两汉史的通俗历史读物。它完整呈现了汉朝四百年的兴旺与衰落,是目前为止最完整、最强悍、最通透的白话汉朝历史读物。昊天牧云、罗杰等诚意推荐,千万网友疯狂追捧。宫斗、离间、喋血、嗜杀、阴谋、诡辩,一起围观这部风起云涌的历史大剧!
  • 文明解密

    文明解密

    《我的第一本探索书