登陆注册
5362500000222

第222章

Wednesday, May 28, 1788

HAMILTON

To the People of the State of New York:

THE objection to the plan of the convention, which has met with most success in this State, and perhaps in several of the other States, is that relative to the want of a constitutional provision for the trial by jury in civil cases. The disingenuous form in which this objection is usually stated has been repeatedly adverted to and exposed, but continues to be pursued in all the conversations and writings of the opponents of the plan. The mere silence of the Constitution in regard to civil causes, is represented as an abolition of the trial by jury, and the declamations to which it has afforded a pretext are artfully calculated to induce a persuasion that this pretended abolition is complete and universal, extending not only to every species of civil, but even to criminal causes. To argue with respect to the latter would, however, be as vain and fruitless as to attempt the serious proof of the existence of matter, or to demonstrate any of those propositions which, by their own internal evidence, force conviction, when expressed in language adapted to convey their meaning.

With regard to civil causes, subtleties almost too contemptible for refutation have been employed to countenance the surmise that a thing which is only not provided for, is entirely abolished. Every man of discernment must at once perceive the wide difference between silence and abolition. But as the inventors of this fallacy have attempted to support it by certain legal maxims of interpretation, which they have perverted from their true meaning, it may not be wholly useless to explore the ground they have taken.

The maxims on which they rely are of this nature: "A specification of particulars is an exclusion of generals"; or, "The expression of one thing is the exclusion of another." Hence, say they, as the Constitution has established the trial by jury in criminal cases, and is silent in respect to civil, this silence is an implied prohibition of trial by jury in regard to the latter.

The rules of legal interpretation are rules of common sense, adopted by the courts in the construction of the laws. The true test, therefore, of a just application of them is its conformity to the source from which they are derived. This being the case, let me ask if it is consistent with common-sense to suppose that a provision obliging the legislative power to commit the trial of criminal causes to juries, is a privation of its right to authorize or permit that mode of trial in other cases?

Is it natural to suppose, that a command to do one thing is a prohibition to the doing of another, which there was a previous power to do, and which is not incompatible with the thing commanded to be done?

If such a supposition would be unnatural and unreasonable, it cannot be rational to maintain that an injunction of the trial by jury in certain cases is an interdiction of it in others.

A power to constitute courts is a power to prescribe the mode of trial; and consequently, if nothing was said in the Constitution on the subject of juries, the legislature would be at liberty either to adopt that institution or to let it alone. This discretion, in regard to criminal causes, is abridged by the express injunction of trial by jury in all such cases; but it is, of course, left at large in relation to civil causes, there being a total silence on this head. The specification of an obligation to try all criminal causes in a particular mode, excludes indeed the obligation or necessity of employing the same mode in civil causes, but does not abridge the power of the legislature to exercise that mode if it should be thought proper. The pretense, therefore, that the national legislature would not be at full liberty to submit all the civil causes of federal cognizance to the determination of juries, is a pretense destitute of all just foundation.

From these observations this conclusion results: that the trial by jury in civil cases would not be abolished; and that the use attempted to be made of the maxims which have been quoted, is contrary to reason and common-sense, and therefore not admissible. Even if these maxims had a precise technical sense, corresponding with the idea of those who employ them upon the present occasion, which, however, is not the case, they would still be inapplicable to a constitution of government. In relation to such a subject, the natural and obvious sense of its provisions, apart from any technical rules, is the true criterion of construction.

Having now seen that the maxims relied upon will not bear the use made of them, let us endeavor to ascertain their proper use and true meaning.

This will be best done by examples. The plan of the convention declares that the power of Congress, or, in other words, of the national legislature, shall extend to certain enumerated cases. This specification of particulars evidently excludes all pretension to a general legislative authority, because an affirmative grant of special powers would be absurd, as well as useless, if a general authority was intended.

In like manner the judicial authority of the federal judicatures is declared by the Constitution to comprehend certain cases particularly specified. The expression of those cases marks the precise limits, beyond which the federal courts cannot extend their jurisdiction, because the objects of their cognizance being enumerated, the specification would be nugatory if it did not exclude all ideas of more extensive authority.

These examples are sufficient to elucidate the maxims which have been mentioned, and to designate the manner in which they should be used. But that there may be no misapprehensions upon this subject, I shall add one case more, to demonstrate the proper use of these maxims, and the abuse which has been made of them.

同类推荐
  • 产鉴

    产鉴

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金箓祈祷晚朝仪

    金箓祈祷晚朝仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 岫岩志略

    岫岩志略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Wolfville

    Wolfville

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • An Outcast of the Islands

    An Outcast of the Islands

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 古穿今:一直喜欢你

    古穿今:一直喜欢你

    女主:从一国公主到沈家养女,沈歆都在做好自己的本分,唯一不够本分的就是当公主的时候喜欢上了一个不符合自己身份的琴师。国忧家患,沈歆无奈将情弃。临死的时候还在想,幸好没表明过心意。可没想到,重活一世,没有最无奈,只有更无奈。大司乐,你听我解释啊……男主:今世你将我“弃如敝履”,来世我让你追赶不及。别以为我喜欢你,你就可以……好吧,我还是喜欢你,一直喜欢你,喜欢的只有你。
  • 小说月报·原创版(2016年02期)

    小说月报·原创版(2016年02期)

    《小说月报·原创版》创刊于2003年初,凭借强大的发行网络和发行数量,多年来一直居全国原创类文学期刊之首,并曾多次荣获省市级、国家级优秀期刊奖项。其影响已不仅仅在文学界,更延伸到更广阔的领域之中。许多作品一经发表,即被各大报刊转载,更有近半数作品被改编为影视剧,并产生巨大影响。本刊以贴近现实、关注人生的中长篇小说为主要内容,并力求在秉持沉稳、厚重的风格的同时,依然留有一片充满激情、活力的年轻声音。
  • 情人的奢华

    情人的奢华

    本书为都市情感中篇小说。当一场婚姻步入平淡生活,正好碰上意外初恋的滋味,如何面对第三者关系,如何选择梦想追寻的爱情?小说通过邝蓓、穆燃、安振皓三人的感情纠葛,精彩而流畅的叙述了一个挣扎在婚姻与爱情中的现实生活故事。精细的心理描写与鲜明的人物性格,丰满而鲜活的人物形象跃然纸上。这是一个走过半世还在追梦的女人生活感悟的表达,引导读者思考面临情感问题时的选择,是一部慢火熬煮下的精彩好文。本书为第一届海峡两岸网络原创文学大赛入围作品。
  • 豪门婚劫之复仇新娘

    豪门婚劫之复仇新娘

    我爱的人为了我举行瞩目的婚礼,新娘不是我。那时的我正躺在陌生人的床上与之纠缠,眼看着自己堕落。幕少城说因为太爱我,所以不能接受我,我一巴掌甩在他脸上。男人:虚伪。我的父亲不要我,我的男朋友抛弃我,我的买主践踏我。我依旧乐观的活着,因为我相信人在做,天在看。秦子昊说他不爱我,但是迷恋我的身体,我一脚踹在他身下。男人:肮脏。当支撑我的信念倒塌时,当真相血淋淋的摆在我面前时,我所有的坚强瞬间崩溃。我要把那些将我拒之门外的所谓豪门搅得天翻地覆。“幕少城,我明天举行婚礼,希望你能参加。”我平淡无奇的说完,递上了鲜艳的请帖。他跪在我面前求我不要结婚,我踢开他,笑着转身离开。躺在血泊里,我紧紧捂着小腹,“秦子昊,我肚子里的孩子其实是你的,你亲手杀了我们的孩子。”说完我张狂的笑,我看到秦子昊的脸由青变白。爱的起点,恨是终点;性的起点,是否会有终点?【卷一:今日种种,似水无痕】【卷二:明夕何夕,君已陌路】五年后:秦子昊领着一个粉妆玉琢的小男孩站在我面前,“陈筱雅,这是我儿子,三岁了。”男孩笑着叫我‘阿姨’。街头偶遇幕少城,他正在为他身边的女孩拉上外衣的拉链,笑着向我介绍说:“我老婆,我们结婚两年了。”蓦然回首,物是人非,还有谁在原地等我?【本文基调悲伤,但不是悲剧。】纯属虚构、禁止模仿◆◆◆◆推荐新文《失婚》“宏正集团总裁深夜幽会嫩模”“宏正集团总裁车中拥吻女星”“宏正集团总裁与某高校校花酒店开房”层出不穷的花边新闻让他们的婚姻亮起了红灯。她一直想无视,身边的人却逼着她去直视。结婚三年,他是个称职的丈夫,每晚按时回家,对她有求必应,珠宝首饰从未间断。她总想,倘若生活就这样持续下去,或许也是一种平静的幸福。只是最近发生的事仿佛已经脱离了原先的轨道。他开始周游在风流的国度,艳事不断,频频上报。这一切来得太过突然,她完全招架不住。嫁给雷煜城三年,三年的风平浪静之后终究还是迎来了暴风骤雨。离开,让事情变得更简单。遗忘,是无法改变的一种宿命。苏静柔:如果时间可以倒转,我好想回到儿时,那时你还是我的煜城哥哥。雷煜城:我以为埋藏在心底的是最爱,原来时间早已冲淡了一切。是她教会我这个道理,然而明白时,她已永远离开,只是那清脆的‘煜城哥哥’总不经意间回荡在耳际。
  • 感悟父爱:感天动地的116个时刻

    感悟父爱:感天动地的116个时刻

    这位老人是一位父亲,他带来的不仅是三袋大米,还有因为儿子而自豪的荣耀,和一颗颗饱满的思念。
  • 乐育堂语录

    乐育堂语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 鲁春秋

    鲁春秋

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金牌小助理:影帝男神求放过

    金牌小助理:影帝男神求放过

    【犯二鬼精灵小助理VS高冷腹黑傲娇俊美影帝】她本是孤儿,因意外而重生,成了他的助理。他是国际上鼎鼎大名的影帝,是她的老板,是她的男人,是她孩子的爸爸,更是她想要征服的对象。他心思如云,让人猜不透看不清,但是她依旧飞蛾扑火。即使伤了身,冷了心,她也不放弃。浴火重生归来,她已不是曾经懦弱的她。身份不配?影后配影帝,配不配?两不相识?有过孩子,算不算相识?没有感情?半夜爬她的床,算不算有感情?有女朋友?小三儿而已,正主在这里还不让道?荣耀回归,迎新会上她优雅大方的朝男人伸出手,魅惑一笑,“前辈你好,我是新人郁琪,以后还请多多指教。”
  • 封少独宠九姑娘

    封少独宠九姑娘

    族人尊称她九姑娘,她生于大山,长于大山。当她出山时,你以为她是山里什么都不懂的丫头……他出生顶级世家,做为商场幕后boss赚起钱来也是毫不手软。那是因为他12岁时遇见了5岁的九姑娘,那时的他就决定可以开始存老婆本了……
  • 罗尔斯·罗伊斯的传奇(发动机家族)

    罗尔斯·罗伊斯的传奇(发动机家族)

    丛书全面讲述了罗尔斯·罗伊斯公司的传奇故事,其时间跨度从罗尔斯·罗伊斯公司创业伊始,直至当今。罗尔斯·罗伊斯公司这个品牌是极富魅力的,而这份魅力得益于它的员工和产品。