登陆注册
5381100000111

第111章

But this disproportion will seem still more shocking when it is remembered that the calculation which we have just made concerning the electoral class is altogether wrong, altogether in favor of the voters.

In fact, the only taxes which are levied for the enjoyment of the right of suffrage are: (1) the land tax; (2) the tax on polls and personal property;

(3) the tax on doors and windows; (4) license-fees.Now, with the exception of the tax on polls and personal property, which varies little, the three other taxes are thrown back on the consumers; and it is the same with all the indirect taxes, for which the holders of capital are reimbursed by the consumers, with the exception, however, of the taxes on property transfers, which fall directly on the proprietor and amount in all to 150,000,000.

Now, if we estimate that in this last amount the property of voters figures as one-sixth, which is placing it high, the portion of direct taxes (409,000,000)

being 12 francs for each person, and that of indirect taxes (547,000,000)

16 francs, the average tax paid by each voter having a household of five will reach a total of 265 francs, while that paid by the laborer, who has only his arms to support himself, his wife, and two children, will be 112

francs.In more general terms, the average tax upon each person belonging to the upper classes will be 53 francs; upon each belonging to the lower, 28.Whereupon I renew my question: Is the welfare of those below the voting standard half as great as that of those above it?

It is with the tax as with periodical publications, which really cost more the less frequently they appear.A daily journal costs forty francs, a weekly ten francs, a monthly four.Supposing other things to be equal, the subscription prices of these journals are to each other as the numbers forty, seventy, and one hundred and twenty, the price rising with the infrequency of publication.Now, this exactly represents the increase of the tax: it is a subscription paid by each citizen in exchange for the right to labor and to live.He who uses this right in the smallest proportion pays much;

he who uses it a little more pays less; he who uses it a great deal pays little.

The economists are generally in agreement about all this.They have attacked the proportional tax, not only in its principle, but in its application;

they have pointed out its anomalies, almost all of which arise from the fact that the relation of capital to income, or of cultivated surface to rent, is never fixed.

Given a levy of one-tenth on the income from lands, and lands of different qualities producing, the first eight francs' worth of grain, the second six francs' worth, the third five francs' worth, the tax will call for one-eighth of the income from the most fertile land, one-sixth from that a little less fertile, and, finally, one-fifth from that less fertile still.(4*)

Will not the tax thus established be just the reverse of what it should be? Instead of land, we may suppose other instruments of production, and compare capitals of the same value, or amounts of labor of the same order, applied to branches of industry differing in productivity: the conclusion will be the same.There is injustice in requiring the same poll- tax of ten francs from the laborer who earns one thousand francs and from the artist or physician who has an income of sixty thousand.-- J.Garnier:

Principles of Political Economy.

These reflections are very sound, although they apply only to collection or assessment, and do not touch the principle of the tax itself.For, in supposing the assessment to be made upon income instead of upon capital, the fact always remains that the tax, which should be proportional to fortunes, is borne by the consumer.

The economists have taken a resolve; they have squarely recognized the iniquity of the proportional tax.

"The tax," says Say, "can never be levied upon the necessary." This author, it is true, does not tell us what we are to understand by the necessary, but we can supply the omission.The necessary is what each individual gets out of the total product of the country, after deducting what must be taken for taxes.Thus, making the estimate in round numbers, the production of France being eight thousand millions and the tax one thousand millions, the necessary in the case of each individual amounts to fifty-six and a half centimes a day.Whatever is in excess of this income is alone susceptible of being taxed, according to J.B.Say; whatever falls short of it must be regarded by the treasury as inviolable.

The same author expresses this idea in other words when he says: "The proportional tax is not equitable." Adam Smith had already said before him: "It is not unreasonable that the rich man should contribute to the public expenses, not only in proportion to his income, but something more."

"I will go further," adds Say; "I will not fear to say that the progressive tax is the only equitable tax." And M.J.Garnier, the latest abridger of the economists, says: "Reforms should tend to establish a progressional equality, if I may use the phrase, much more just, much more equitable, than the pretended equality of taxation, which is only a monstrous inequality."

So, according to general opinion and the testimony of the economists, two things are acknowledged: one, that in its principle the tax is a reaction against monopoly and directed against the rich; the other, that in practice this same tax is false to its object; that, in striking the poor by preference, it commits an injustice; and that the constant effort of the legislator must be to distribute its burden in a more equitable fashion.

I needed to establish this double fact solidly before passing to other considerations: now commences my criticism.

同类推荐
  • 有德女所问大乘经

    有德女所问大乘经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 北郭集

    北郭集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The City of Dreadful Night

    The City of Dreadful Night

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 赞阿弥陀佛偈

    赞阿弥陀佛偈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 唐玄宗御制道德真经疏外传

    唐玄宗御制道德真经疏外传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 阅读的刀锋

    阅读的刀锋

    《阅读的刀锋》为庞溟先生近年文化随笔文字的结集,系“独立阅读书系”第三辑之一。《阅读的刀锋》作者庞溟是一位独立书评人,先后获中国人民大学金融学学士、香港科技大学经济学硕士、美国芝加哥大学社会学硕士、香港大学经济学博士学位。
  • 我家柠檬精又又又酸了

    我家柠檬精又又又酸了

    四岁的他抱着皱皱巴巴的小女孩,在纸上歪歪扭扭的写下三个字。小、火、勺。某天,她扬言要以身相许。“夏小灼,你知不知道,长得好看的叫以身相许,长得丑的叫恩将仇报。”“嘤嘤嘤,那我这样的呢。”“你这叫命中注定是我的人。”他比她大了四岁,一字读半边,他总是叫她夏小火,她总爱叫他臭哥哥。某日,她张开双臂,“哥哥要抱抱!”“抱。”隔日,她撅起嘴,“哥哥要亲亲!”“亲。”再隔日,“哥哥,…”“举高高?”【青梅竹马】
  • 人参谱

    人参谱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 比丘尼受戒录

    比丘尼受戒录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 海贼王之海航记

    海贼王之海航记

    加莱捂着头,茫然的看着四周,视线落在不远处的桅杆上:这里是……海贼船?明明记得被什么人从后面打了一下就失去了知觉。啊,不管怎么样,居然意外见到了他,最爱的船长大人。哟西,从今天开始,我会一直跟随您的,船长大人!哪怕前路坎坷(还没允许你上船吧喂!)本文海贼穿越同人,其中人物性格也许稍有改变,欢迎大家按抓收藏(握拳:为了最爱的船长大人:罗!)
  • 文人的风骨

    文人的风骨

    当代文人在经济、文化、科技、社会生活等方面,都应该具有划时代的先进意义。应该具有一种高度的社会责任感和历史使命感,紧紧把握时代脉搏,关注社会,反映民间疾苦,针砭时弊,鞭挞丑恶,弘扬人间正气。$$当今社会,竞争日趋激烈,经济的飞速发展导致了精神文化领域的相对低落,文人的身价,似乎在一天天贬值。冷静客观地面对现实,甘守清贫,耐得住寂寞,不为世俗浮华所左右,潜心写一些有责任写、喜欢写的文章,保持文人应有的风骨,这是一个真正的文人应该做到的。$$本书就是再现了中国文人的风骨。
  • 排骨归你你归我

    排骨归你你归我

    祁安没想到自己会被陆程戈一碗糖醋排骨给锁死。陆程戈人生信条:死皮赖脸追妻(祁)
  • 思路决定出路:成功策划36法

    思路决定出路:成功策划36法

    《影响时空管理丛书》由影响力训练集团组织十几位专家、几十位学者、上百位培训界精英历经三年时间精心创作,内容注重实战,以解决企业管理实际问题为导向;论述深入浅出,通俗易懂;工具多、方法多、案例多,且经过多轮培训课程使用并经过多次修订,受到各层次管理者的欢迎和好评。本书介绍了策划的6大思路、策划人的6大能力、策划的6大步骤、策划的7大误区等内容,以案例和图表分析为辅,将三十六计的策划思想和方法充分应用到实战策划中。
  • 大唐官

    大唐官

    安史之乱对煌煌大唐而言,并不是耻辱的终点,而是蜕变的起始。中晚唐,既开此后五百年华夏之新格局,也是个被理解得最为僵化的词汇。朝政衰败?藩镇割据?外敌欺辱?党争酷烈?单单是这些?不。肃宗回马杨妃死,云雨虽亡日月新!现代不得志的编剧高子阳,因个微不足道的偏差,穿越到了唐代宗大历十二年,获得了太学生高岳的身份,并准备要通过考试,当大唐的公务员。在他眼前,是个盛世不再但又历久弥新的大唐,至此一副荣华迁转的八隽图卷徐徐展开。我高子阳也不是谦虚,进士是要及第的,五姓女是要娶的,政事堂是要入的,各镇节度使也都是要做一做的,东南西北那票找不快活的也都是要殴打的......
  • 异能鲜妻:凌少,太生猛

    异能鲜妻:凌少,太生猛

    一次意外的重生。她来到这个完全陌生的世界,却苦逼的没有第一时间继承原主的记忆。看着眼前惊为天人的男子,苏灵含惊愣“你是谁?”男子邪魅一笑:“我是你未婚夫”“哈?对不起,我失忆了,你现在只是个陌生人。”“没关系,一回生,二回熟,你若想现在就深入了解一下彼此,我也乐意配合”“流氓”“我只是你一个人的专属流氓。”苏灵含咬牙切齿,却又无可奈何,认命般接受从此后生活中多了人形忠犬。可是,这生活到底跟想的不一样。他的仇人,她的冤家,一个个都忙着出来蹦哒。日子就是虐也虐不完的渣,幸好姐异能在手,人无我有。再加上还有个厚颜无下线,宠妻宠翻天的美男助威。苏灵含表示,这日子再也不怕无聊了。