登陆注册
5381100000111

第111章

But this disproportion will seem still more shocking when it is remembered that the calculation which we have just made concerning the electoral class is altogether wrong, altogether in favor of the voters.

In fact, the only taxes which are levied for the enjoyment of the right of suffrage are: (1) the land tax; (2) the tax on polls and personal property;

(3) the tax on doors and windows; (4) license-fees.Now, with the exception of the tax on polls and personal property, which varies little, the three other taxes are thrown back on the consumers; and it is the same with all the indirect taxes, for which the holders of capital are reimbursed by the consumers, with the exception, however, of the taxes on property transfers, which fall directly on the proprietor and amount in all to 150,000,000.

Now, if we estimate that in this last amount the property of voters figures as one-sixth, which is placing it high, the portion of direct taxes (409,000,000)

being 12 francs for each person, and that of indirect taxes (547,000,000)

16 francs, the average tax paid by each voter having a household of five will reach a total of 265 francs, while that paid by the laborer, who has only his arms to support himself, his wife, and two children, will be 112

francs.In more general terms, the average tax upon each person belonging to the upper classes will be 53 francs; upon each belonging to the lower, 28.Whereupon I renew my question: Is the welfare of those below the voting standard half as great as that of those above it?

It is with the tax as with periodical publications, which really cost more the less frequently they appear.A daily journal costs forty francs, a weekly ten francs, a monthly four.Supposing other things to be equal, the subscription prices of these journals are to each other as the numbers forty, seventy, and one hundred and twenty, the price rising with the infrequency of publication.Now, this exactly represents the increase of the tax: it is a subscription paid by each citizen in exchange for the right to labor and to live.He who uses this right in the smallest proportion pays much;

he who uses it a little more pays less; he who uses it a great deal pays little.

The economists are generally in agreement about all this.They have attacked the proportional tax, not only in its principle, but in its application;

they have pointed out its anomalies, almost all of which arise from the fact that the relation of capital to income, or of cultivated surface to rent, is never fixed.

Given a levy of one-tenth on the income from lands, and lands of different qualities producing, the first eight francs' worth of grain, the second six francs' worth, the third five francs' worth, the tax will call for one-eighth of the income from the most fertile land, one-sixth from that a little less fertile, and, finally, one-fifth from that less fertile still.(4*)

Will not the tax thus established be just the reverse of what it should be? Instead of land, we may suppose other instruments of production, and compare capitals of the same value, or amounts of labor of the same order, applied to branches of industry differing in productivity: the conclusion will be the same.There is injustice in requiring the same poll- tax of ten francs from the laborer who earns one thousand francs and from the artist or physician who has an income of sixty thousand.-- J.Garnier:

Principles of Political Economy.

These reflections are very sound, although they apply only to collection or assessment, and do not touch the principle of the tax itself.For, in supposing the assessment to be made upon income instead of upon capital, the fact always remains that the tax, which should be proportional to fortunes, is borne by the consumer.

The economists have taken a resolve; they have squarely recognized the iniquity of the proportional tax.

"The tax," says Say, "can never be levied upon the necessary." This author, it is true, does not tell us what we are to understand by the necessary, but we can supply the omission.The necessary is what each individual gets out of the total product of the country, after deducting what must be taken for taxes.Thus, making the estimate in round numbers, the production of France being eight thousand millions and the tax one thousand millions, the necessary in the case of each individual amounts to fifty-six and a half centimes a day.Whatever is in excess of this income is alone susceptible of being taxed, according to J.B.Say; whatever falls short of it must be regarded by the treasury as inviolable.

The same author expresses this idea in other words when he says: "The proportional tax is not equitable." Adam Smith had already said before him: "It is not unreasonable that the rich man should contribute to the public expenses, not only in proportion to his income, but something more."

"I will go further," adds Say; "I will not fear to say that the progressive tax is the only equitable tax." And M.J.Garnier, the latest abridger of the economists, says: "Reforms should tend to establish a progressional equality, if I may use the phrase, much more just, much more equitable, than the pretended equality of taxation, which is only a monstrous inequality."

So, according to general opinion and the testimony of the economists, two things are acknowledged: one, that in its principle the tax is a reaction against monopoly and directed against the rich; the other, that in practice this same tax is false to its object; that, in striking the poor by preference, it commits an injustice; and that the constant effort of the legislator must be to distribute its burden in a more equitable fashion.

I needed to establish this double fact solidly before passing to other considerations: now commences my criticism.

同类推荐
  • 十洲记

    十洲记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛为胜光天子说王法经

    佛为胜光天子说王法经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 黄箓斋十天尊仪

    黄箓斋十天尊仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 从公三录

    从公三录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三十年临证经验集

    三十年临证经验集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 纯备德禅师语录

    纯备德禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天价萌宝:腹黑总裁喜当爹

    天价萌宝:腹黑总裁喜当爹

    五年前,一场算计,他将她原本安静的生活撕得粉碎;五年里,她在阴影中挣扎,噩梦不断;五年后,她带娃归来决心复仇;她千方百计得到他的心,引他入局,只为最后让他也尝试粉身碎骨,坠入泥潭的滋味。可谁知狡猾如他,套路与反套路,究竟是谁入了谁的局,谁夺走了谁的心?
  • 亿万爹地强势宠

    亿万爹地强势宠

    六年前,她被妹妹陷害,一无所有,被迫逃到异国避丑。临行之际却不料被自己好心救的男人,意外生情。六年后,她带着天才宝宝归来,这包子做的第一件事,就是帮助妈咪把亲爹坑回来。从此,她夺回一切,过上了开挂般的人生。“女人,你偷了我的种这几年,处处跟别人说我死了?”夜深人静,她被逼到墙角,动弹不得……““你始乱终弃,还不负责,我自然当你不存在了!”男人霸道的进入她的生活:“我负责,把这些年欠你的一次一次补回来,让你知道我的存在!”
  • 重生电竞,女扮男装撩美男

    重生电竞,女扮男装撩美男

    她带着一身的十八班武艺从一个顶尖黑客L重生到一个富二代高中学生的身上,性格懦弱无能?一无是处?这些她都通通破解开来,只是有一点她实在是不明白,为什么要女版男装啊喂!不过幸好有美男相伴~前面她使出洪荒之力来撩他,却没有一点用:某桐死皮赖脸的说:“小哥哥,有没有男朋友啊?有的话介不介意多一个,没有的话看我这个怎么样?”可后面的剧情发展不太对啊!某个衣冠禽兽提着她后领道:“你即喜欢我,就不可以再和别的男人对视超过三秒,不许跟别的男人吃饭,不许跟别的男人接触!”某桐讪讪道:“那男孩呢?”某禽兽冷冷道:“你觉得呢?”
  • 漫威之重力魔

    漫威之重力魔

    窥探宇宙黑暗的意志,得无上引力权能在漫威世界重生醒来,看宇宙恶魔的如何在这个精彩纷呈的世界里面搅弄风云。(漫威电影故事线)
  • 每夜一个鬼故事

    每夜一个鬼故事

    每夜都有一个诡故事!收录了百十个发生在乡村城市的离奇故事。风门灵异事件,根据鬼村风门村事件改编,凶宅事件,根据某地十几年前的三大悬案改编,真实还原当年悬案,灵宠物语,生活中那些动物,发生在我们身边的故事!或离奇古怪,或感人!
  • 无尽世界我为王

    无尽世界我为王

    一个从天而降的手机,一段段瑰丽神奇的历程,从武侠到仙侠,从魔法到科技,从水蓝星到宇宙······无尽世界任我行,宇宙洪荒我为王。穿越不是目的,咱们滴目标,是星辰大海。
  • 我的妹妹是狠人

    我的妹妹是狠人

    “不为成仙,只为在这红尘中等你回来……”九天之上,居然传来这么一句话,震动了万古。……突然有一个逆世称尊、动辄杀尽天下的狠人妹妹,是什么体验?而且,这个妹妹还不是一般的狠……惊才绝艳、天姿惊世、绝代风华傲古今…………和狠人大帝的诸界游。也有大量的国漫元素,如大鱼和风语咒、武庚等,也会有神话仙侠背景的影视世界。
  • 纨绔将军是个假小子

    纨绔将军是个假小子

    "这是谁?我不认识!!!”某女表示不认识这个掉底子的……皇帝。
  • 被诅咒的家族

    被诅咒的家族

    1976年春节刚过,家里便来了三位客人,可以说是稀客。他们是大姑、大姑丈、小姑。虽说是至亲,但父亲过世后,我们再也没有回过老家,非常明确地与老家断绝了关系。所以他们忽然降临,带给我们的更多是惊诧、狐疑,和强烈的陌生、不安。这陌生、不安更多来自这三位客人的严肃、郑重、冷漠。从他们的架势来看,他们显然是有备而来的,是为处理大事而来的。家里顿时弥漫着一种剑拔弩张的气氛。大姑拿出一毛钱,让我带弟弟到小店铺买葱头糖吃,还特意叮咛买回来后就在庭院里吃,别进屋去。我知道她是想把我和弟弟支开。