登陆注册
5381100000126

第126章

Is it fraudulent to mix wines? Chaptal, in his treatise on the art of making wine, advises this as eminently useful; on the other hand, experience proves that certain wines, in some way antagonistic to each other or incompatible, produce by their mixture a disagreeable and unhealthy drink.Then you are obliged to say what wines can be usefully mixed, and what cannot.Is it fraudulent to aromatize, alcoholize, and water wines? Chaptal recommends this also; and everybody knows that this drugging produces sometimes advantageous results, sometimes pernicious and detestable effects.What substances will you proscribe? In what cases? In what proportion? Will you prohibit chicory in coffee, glucose in beer, water, cider, and three-six alcohol in wine?

The Chamber of Deputies, in the rude attempt at a law which it was pleased to make this year regarding the adulteration of wines, stopped in the very middle of its work, overcome by the inextricable difficulties of the question.

It succeeded in declaring that the introduction of water into wine, and of alcohol above the proportion of eighteen per cent., was fraudulent, and in putting this fraud into the category of offences.It was on the ground of ideology; there one never meets an obstacle.But everybody has seen in this redoubling of severity the interest of the treasury much more than that of the consumer; the Chamber did not dare to create a whole army of wine- tasters, inspectors, etc., to watch for fraud and identify it, and thus load the budget with a few extra millions; in prohibiting watering and alcoholization, the only means left to the merchant-manufacturers of putting wine within the reach of all and realizing profits, it did not succeed in increasing the market by a decrease in production.The chamber, in a word, in prosecuting the adulteration of wines, has simply set back the limits of fraud.To make its work accomplish its purpose it would first have to show how the liquor trade is possible without adulteration, and how the people can buy unadulterated wine, -- which is beyond the competency and escapes the capacity of the Chamber.

If you wish the consumer to be guaranteed, both as to value and as to healthfulness, you are forced to know and to determine all that constitutes good and honest production, to be continually at the heels of the manufacturer, and to guide him at every step.He no longer manufactures; you, the State, are the real manufacturer.

Thus you find yourself in a trap.Either you hamper the liberty of commerce by interfering in production in a thousand ways, or you declare yourself sole producer and sole merchant.

In the first case, through annoying everybody, you will finally cause everybody to rebel; and sooner or later, the State getting itself expelled, trade-marks will be abolished.In the second you substitute everywhere the action of power for individual initiative, which is contrary to the principles of political economy and the constitution of society.Do you take a middle course? It is favor, nepotism, hypocrisy, the worst of systems.

Suppose, now, that the marking be left to the manufacturer.I say that then the marks, even if made obligatory, will gradually lose their significance, and at last become only proofs of origin.He knows but little of commerce who imagines that a merchant, a head of a manufacturing enterprise, making use of processes that are not patentable, will betray the secret of his industry, of his profits, of his existence.The significance will then be a delusion; it is not in the power of the police to make it otherwise.

The Roman emperors, to discover the Christians who dissembled their religion, obliged everybody to sacrifice to the idols.They made apostates and martyrs;

and the number of Christians only increased.Likewise significant marks, useful to some houses, will engender innumerable frauds and repressions;

that is all that can be expected of them.To induce the manufacturer to frankly indicate the intrinsic composition -- that is, the industrial and commercial value - of his merchandise, it is necessary to free him from the perils of competition and satisfy his monopolistic instincts: can you do it? It is necessary, further, to interest the consumer in the repression of fraud, which, so long as the producer is not utterly disinterested, is at once impossible and contradictory.Impossible: place on the one hand a depraved consumer, China; on the other a desperate merchant, England;

between them a venomous drug causing excitement and intoxication; and, in spite of all the police in the world, you will have trade in opium.

Contradictory: in society the consumer and the producer are but one, --

that is, both are interested in the production of that which it is injurious to them to consume; and as, in the case of each, consumption follows production and sale, all will combine to guard the first interest, leaving it to each to guard himself against the second.

The thought which prompted trade-marks is of the same character as that which formerly inspired the maximum laws.Here again is one of the innumerable cross-roads of political economy.

It is indisputable that maximum laws, though made and supported by their authors entirely as a relief from famine, have invariably resulted in an aggravation of famine.Accordingly it is not injustice or malice with which the economists charge these abhorred laws, but stupidity, inexpediency.

But what a contradiction in the theory with which they oppose them!

To relieve famine it is necessary to call up provisions, or, to put it better, to bring them to light; so far there is nothing to reproach.

To secure a supply of provisions it is necessary to attract the holders by profits, excite their competition, and assure them complete liberty in the market: does not this process strike you as the absurdest homoeopathy?

How is it that the more easily I can be taxed the sooner I shall be provided?

同类推荐
  • 楚辞补注

    楚辞补注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞玄灵宝大纲钞

    太上洞玄灵宝大纲钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 受菩萨戒仪

    受菩萨戒仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 台湾外记

    台湾外记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 释氏稽古略

    释氏稽古略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 城工部最后一个地下党

    城工部最后一个地下党

    F省省府所在地的省立高中是所历史悠久的学校。整个校园透着古老的文化气息,尤其是那座在城中并不多见的三层高的教学楼,粉墙黛瓦,雄伟壮观,更是远近闻名,人称“魁星楼”。魁星楼可谓实至名归,从这里走出去的学生,成为著名的政治家、军事家及社会名流者,不下千余人。秦涛是在抗战胜利国家需要各方面人才之际,怀着报国之志,在父亲的介绍下,投学来到这里的。秦涛还有一个特殊的身份,他是中共F省委派入学校做秘密工作的地下党,隶属于省委城工部,他是学运工作的负责人。
  • 病毒在召唤

    病毒在召唤

    安迪洛克斯表示他很无辜。一觉醒来,竟到了虐杀原形的纽约,A哥正四处肆虐。被感染了,好不容易把A哥干掉,终于能睡个好觉。一觉醒来,到了生化危机,这下好了,变成跟着A姐满地球跑。千辛万苦终于怼死大丧失保护伞,安迪终于能轻松了,但他想到一个问题:一觉醒来之后呢?出乎意料,他来到了平行地球,可惜,这时却发现因为一个A妹,变成了通缉犯。安迪:“艹!我跟A有仇啊!”
  • 家庭幸福经济学

    家庭幸福经济学

    对于“什么是幸福”,范伟曾在电影中有过这样的解释:“我饿了看见别人手里拿个热肉包子,那他就比我幸福;我冷了,看见别人穿了一件厚棉袄,他就比我幸福;我想上茅房,就一个坑,你蹲那儿,你就比我幸福。”范伟的这段话通俗易懂,却有着丰富的经济学内涵。幸福的感觉能在比较中获得,经济学中便有比较优势的理论。
  • 指要钞

    指要钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 异界之逆天玄尊

    异界之逆天玄尊

    异界重生,一位神秘的老者,一套玄奥的功法,造就他逆天的战力。他,携手今生的恋人,将如何面对前世的爱人,将如何找寻前世的好友。他,面对着奇境的修士、妖兽、精怪,幻境的斗者、魔法师、召唤师,将如何走向巅峰,执掌天地。仗剑飞驰,遨游天宇,寻龙探宝踏歌行,纷纷扰扰天地间。
  • 策划女性:女性未来人生与事业的10大系统策划

    策划女性:女性未来人生与事业的10大系统策划

    成功的女性身上自有许多美好的精神和思想,完全可以借鉴和发扬。本书阐述了对女性关于人生与事业的十项策划,介绍了人生模式的改变、目标的注定、提高自身才能、发挥优势、创业因素等。
  • 二度梅全传

    二度梅全传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 不朽妖塔

    不朽妖塔

    大陆中央屹立着一座妖塔,万年不倒,直冲天宇,造就了诸多传说令人向往。传说,通天九州埋藏着诸神的一切。传说,妖塔的尽头通往长生的世界。少年背神秘石碑,从无极山走出,一路高歌勇猛前行。最终走向那波澜壮阔的……
  • 天地霸体诀

    天地霸体诀

    【火爆爽文】少年莫然,获取记忆传承,修《天地霸体诀》,一路狂霸,无人可挡!顽木书友群:163510956顽木铁杆群:693435571(需截图验证,学徒以上粉丝方可进入)
  • 花开花落只因爱过

    花开花落只因爱过

    男主身负悲命,在绝望时一一与红颜相遇,缓解重重危机……