登陆注册
5381100000072

第72章

BETWEEN the hundred-headed hydra, division of labor, and the unconquered dragon, machinery, what will become of humanity? A prophet has said it more than two thousand years ago: Satan looks on his victim, and the fires of war are kindled, Aspexit gentes, et dissolvit.To save us from two scourges, famine and pestilence, Providence sends us discord.

Competition represents that philosophical era in which, a semi- understanding of the antinomies of reason having given birth to the art of sophistry, the characteristics of the false and the true were confounded, and in which, instead of doctrines, they had nothing but deceptive mental tilts.Thus the industrial movement faithfully reproduces the metaphysical movement;

the history of social economy is to be found entire in the writings of the philosophers.Let us study this interesting phase, whose most striking characteristic is to take away the judgment of those who believe as well as those who protest.

1.-- Necessity of competition.

M.Louis Reybaud, novelist by profession, economist on occasion, breveted by the Academy of Moral and Political Sciences for his anti-reformatory caricatures, and become, with the lapse of time, one of the writers most hostile to social ideas, -- M.Louis Reybaud, whatever he may do, is none the less profoundly imbued with these same ideas: the opposition which he thus exhibits is neither in his heart nor in his mind; it is in the facts.

In the first edition of his "Studies of Contemporary Reformers," M.

Reybaud, moved by the sight of social sufferings as well as the courage of these founders of schools, who believed that they could reform the world by an explosion of sentimentalism, had formally expressed the opinion that the surviving feature of all their systems was ASSOCIATION.M.Dunoyer, one of M.Reybaud's judges, bore this testimony, the more flattering to M.Reybaud from being slightly ironical in form:

M.Reybaud, who has exposed with so much accuracy and talent, in a book which the French Academy has crowned, the vices of the three principal reformatory systems, holds fast to the principle common to them, which serves as their base, -- association.Association in his eyes, he declares, is the greatest problem of modern times.It is called, he says, to solve that of the distribution of the fruits of labor.Though authority can do nothing towards the solution of this problem, association could do everything.

M.Reybaud speaks here like a writer of the phalansterian school....

M.Reybaud had advanced a little, as one may see.Endowed with too much good sense and good faith not to perceive the precipice, he soon felt that he was straying, and began a retrograde movement.I do not call this about-

face a crime on his part: M.Reybaud is one of those men who cannot justly be held responsible for their metaphors.He had spoken before reflecting, he retracted: what more natural! If the socialists must blame any one, let it be M.Dunoyer, who had prompted M.Reybaud's recantation by this singular compliment.

M.Dunoyer was not slow in perceiving that his words had not fallen on closed ears.He relates, for the glory of sound principles, that, "in a second edition of the `Studies of Reformers,' M.Reybaud has himself tempered the absolute tone of his expressions.He has said, instead of could do everything, could do much."

It was an important modification, as M.Dunoyer brought clearly to his notice, but it still permitted M.Reybaud to write at the same time:

These symptoms are grave; they may be considered as prophecies of a confused organization, in which labor would seek an equilibrium and a regularity which it now lacks....At the bottom of all these efforts is hidden a principle, association, which it would be wrong to condemn on the strength of irregular manifestations.

Finally M.Reybaud has loudly declared himself a partisan of competition, which means that he has decidedly abandoned the principle of association.

For if by association we are to understand only the forms of partnership fixed by the commercial code, the philosophy of which has been summarized for us by MM.Troplong and Delangle, it is no longer worth while to distinguish between socialists and economists, between one party which seeks association and another which maintains that association exists.

Let no one imagine, because M.Reybaud has happened to say heedlessly yes and no to a question of which he does not seem to have yet formed a clear idea, that I class him among those speculators of socialism, who, after having launched a hoax into the world, begin immediately to make their retreat, under the pretext that, the idea now belonging to the public domain, there is nothing more for them to do but to leave it to make its way.M.Reybaud, in my opinion, belongs rather to the category of dupes, which includes in its bosom so many honest people and people of so much brains.M.Reybaud will remain, then, in my eyes, the vir probus dicendi peritus, the conscientious and skilful writer, who may easily be caught napping, but who never expresses anything that he does not see or feel.

Moreover, M.Reybaud, once placed on the ground of economic ideas, would find the more difficulty in being consistent with himself because of the clearness of his mind and the accuracy of his reasoning.I am going to make this curious experiment under the reader's eyes.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 飞天龙舞

    飞天龙舞

    人世间,什么是好的,什么是坏的,谁知道?自然界,什么应该存在,什么又不该存在,谁做主?宇宙中,什么是正义,什么是邪恶,谁衡量?对错,好坏,该与不该。一只无形的手,牵动者宇宙的一切规则。
  • 一恋情深

    一恋情深

    她是身名狼藉的女人,有人说她手段狠,有人夸她技术好。她们结婚三年,他不碰她。终于等到这一天,他甩出离婚协议,“你想要的东西已经到手,咱们离婚!”
  • 想和你在一起是真的

    想和你在一起是真的

    网爆:当红小花旦国民初恋女友扯证了。宋清晚520在微博晒出结婚证照,配文:我的男人。某篮球明星也同时晒出结婚证照,配文:我的女人。男粉纷纷哭晕在厕所,女粉秒变颜狗,对宋清晚老公陆善言纷纷路转粉。――(微博瘫痪24小时后恢复正常,程序员表示无语,特喵的老子正在结婚,能不能提前打个招呼?)1Ⅴ1甜文,看当红小花旦如何花样厚脸皮追到男神。
  • 百家姓(国学启蒙书系列)

    百家姓(国学启蒙书系列)

    中华民族文化博大精深,源远流长,是历代仁人志士的智慧源泉和精神支柱,同时也是人类历史上璀璨的瑰宝。可以说,传统文化是一个民族的标志和灵魂。国学门类繁多,内容丰富,思想深刻,体现了中华民族特有的气度和精神。通过阅读国学,能使孩子从中汲取思想的力量,对孩子语言能力的开发和良好品质的形成都具有重要意义。
  • 佛说出生无边门陀罗尼经

    佛说出生无边门陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 雀难归

    雀难归

    “容川,每个人有每个人的使命,我们必须遵守命运。”“阿宸,这就是你说的命运吧,,”说到底,又是谁伤的真心人。
  • 玄宇苍黄

    玄宇苍黄

    大世当空,万族争霸,中华经典闪耀宇内百万载匆匆而过,宇内每逢大衰必先大兴界花不选无用之人,宇内争霸从那一刻开始……
  • 悍妃驾到:王爷请温柔

    悍妃驾到:王爷请温柔

    她厌恶鲜血、痛恨杀戮,无法逃离杀手组织宁愿去死。再世为人,竟又成为杀手。但这次她要活下去,更要与命运抗争。朝廷与组织勾结?既然她不得不去杀了个无辜的将军,那便顺便杀了恶贯满盈的厉王来恕罪。他是晋天国厉王赵子修,气势狠戾、手段毒辣,逆我者死。逍遥阁的杀手竟然来刺杀他?可笑!不过这倔强又刁钻聪颖的女子却引起他兴趣。她就如同一匹烈马,只有强者才能征服。这个强者,便是他!
  • 最美不过诗经Ⅱ

    最美不过诗经Ⅱ

    《最美不过诗经2》:阅读大中国系列最新诗词力作,更严谨的解读,更感人的文笔,更耐读的故事。最唯美的诗经读本,最动人的爱情史诗。以诗词会古人,以古人读心灵,以心灵悟人生。阅读大中国系列一获国学大师汤一介、北大教授李中华、王守常倾情推荐。
  • 我的老婆是灯神

    我的老婆是灯神

    天上不会掉馅饼,但是却掉下来个小姑娘,自称宝莲灯的灯神。被灯神收为仆人的许飞,只能踏上了协助灯神大人寻找失落花瓣的路途。被困在同一天的时空循环中?穿越到恐怖小说里?真人孤儿怨?原来都是花瓣在搞鬼!许飞想说,别闹了,能许个愿望先吗?