登陆注册
5381100000074

第74章

COMPETITION? Is there a theorem in geometry more certain, more peremptory, than that? How then, upon what conditions, in what sense, can a principle which is its own denial enter into science? How can it become an organic law of society? If competition is necessary; if, as the school says, it is a postulate of production, -- how does it become so devastating in its effects? And if its most certain effect is to ruin those whom it incites, how does it become useful? For the inconveniences which follow in its train, like the good which it procures, are not accidents arising from the work of man: both follow logically from the principle, and subsist by the same title and face to face.

And, in the first place, competition is as essential to labor as division, since it is division itself returning in another form, or rather, raised to its second power; division, I say, no longer, as in the first period of economic evolution, adequate to collective force, and consequently absorbing the personality of the laborer in the workshop, but giving birth to liberty by making each subdivision of labor a sort of sovereignty in which man stands in all his power and independence.Competition, in a word, is liberty in division and in all the divided parts: beginning with the most comprehensive functions, it tends toward its realization even in the inferior operations of parcellaire labor.

Here the communists raise an objection.It is necessary, they say, in all things, to distinguish between use and abuse.There is a useful, praiseworthy, moral competition, a competition which enlarges the heart and the mind, a noble and generous competition, -- it is emulation; and why should not this emulation have for its object the advantage of all? There is another competition, pernicious, immoral, unsocial, a jealous competition which hates and which kills, -- it is egoism.

So says communism; so expressed itself, nearly a year ago, in its social profession of faith, the journal, "La Reforme."

Whatever reluctance I may feel to oppose men whose ideas are at bottom my own, I cannot accept such dialectics."La Reforme," in believing that it could reconcile everything by a distinction more grammatical than real, has made use, without suspecting it, of the golden mean, -- that is, of the worst sort of diplomacy.Its argument is exactly the same as that of M.Rossi in regard to the division of labor: it consists in setting competition and morality against each other, in order to limit them by each other, as M.Rossi pretended to arrest and restrict economic inductions by morality, cutting here, lopping there, to suit the need and the occasion.I have refuted M.Rossi by asking him this simple question: How can science be in disagreement with itself, the science of wealth with the science of duty? Likewise I ask the communists: How can a principle whose development is clearly useful be at the same time pernicious?

They say: emulation is not competition.I note, in the first place, that this pretended distinction bears only on the divergent effects of the principle, which leads one to suppose that there were two principles which had been confounded.Emulation is nothing but competition itself;

and, since they have thrown themselves into abstractions, I willingly plunge in also.There is no emulation without an object, just as there is no passional initiative without an object; and as the object of every passion is necessarily analogous to the passion itself, -- woman to the lover, power to the ambitious, gold to the miser, a crown to the poet, -- so the object of industrial emulation is necessarily profit.

No, rejoins the communist, the laborer's object of emulation should be general utility, fraternity, love.

But society itself, since, instead of stopping at the individual man, who is in question at this moment, they wish to attend only to the collective man, -- society, I say, labors only with a view to wealth; comfort, happiness, is its only object.Why, then, should that which is true of society not be true of the individual also, since, after all, society is man and entire humanity lives in each man? Why substitute for the immediate object of emulation, which in industry is personal welfare, that far-away and almost metaphysical motive called general welfare, especially when the latter is nothing without the former and can result only from the former?

Communists, in general, build up a strange illusion: fanatics on the subject of power, they expect to secure through a central force, and in the special case in question, through collective wealth, by a sort of reversion, the welfare of the laborer who has created this wealth: as if the individual came into existence after society, instead of society after the individual.

For that matter, this is not the only case in which we shall see the socialists unconsciously dominated by the traditions of the regime against which they protest.

But what need of insisting? From the moment that the communist changes the name of things, vera rerum vocabala, he tacitly admits his powerlessness, and puts himself out of the question.That is why my sole reply to him shall be: In denying competition, you abandon the thesis; henceforth you have no place in the discussion.Some other time we will inquire how far man should sacrifice himself in the interest of all: for the moment the question is the solution of the problem of competition, -- that is, the reconciliation of the highest satisfaction of egoism with social necessities;

spare us your moralities.

Competition is necessary to the constitution of value, -- that is, to the very principle of distribution, and consequently to the advent of equality.

同类推荐
  • 日知录

    日知录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 黄庭内外景玉经解

    黄庭内外景玉经解

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 唱道真言

    唱道真言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 哭京兆庞尹

    哭京兆庞尹

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 科举论

    科举论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 害羞的小蜜蜂

    害羞的小蜜蜂

    《害羞的小蜜蜂》讲述了: 有一只小蜜蜂,太害羞了。不论见了谁,她的脸都羞得像苹果一般红,而飞起来也是东躲西藏的。小 蜜蜂妈妈很着急,想让她到人多的地方去,多和大家接触接触。但小蜜蜂总是不肯,这可把蜜蜂妈妈愁坏 了。蜜蜂妈妈终于说服小蜜蜂跟着自己一起去采蜜了 。最后,小蜜蜂变得开朗了。
  • 重生之能量为王

    重生之能量为王

    张瀚重生了,这一世,他只想做个安静的护花使者。可当身边出现一个又一个的美女,伴随而来的是来自商界、医学界、音乐界、武术界、美食界……接踵而来的挑战。
  • 舞步毒医腹黑邪王

    舞步毒医腹黑邪王

    灯突然熄了,纪梦岚被人在黑暗中从十米高的舞台上推下去。想她一代杀手女王竟是这样死的,真是丢脸。一夕间,她有了一次重生的机会,怎么能放过。这一世,她要做自己喜欢的事...奈何,遇见了他,打乱了她一生的计划......
  • 情深意暖:深吻99次

    情深意暖:深吻99次

    既然相遇在青春美好之年,娶你便在情深意暖之时。我并不是不喜欢说话,只是想让你多找我几次。意暖,我秦深,此身只为你深情。
  • 百川书志

    百川书志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 浮世尘华一

    浮世尘华一

    生活就像一场戏,每一个细节都要你仔细去把握。一个惊天大案,一个缜密阴谋,塑造了一个这样的天人。郁清与欧阳若琳的相遇注定是个悲剧,六皇子的相邀又是一个难以估计的惨剧。三国相争,阴谋中有多少阴谋,谁也无法预测。等一切初定,郁清才发现,原来自己所执着的一切只不过是一场红尘俗世。十几年的旧案,几个执着的人。皇位相争,痴男怨女,一切只是个缘字。多年以后,当几个不同的人再回首往事时,才发现还好没有错过。
  • 无爱五百

    无爱五百

    一家开在半夜的藏物阁,揽存世间一切光怪陆离的的东西,从古至今神秘而又悠远。
  • 张恨水经典作品系列:魍魉世界(下)

    张恨水经典作品系列:魍魉世界(下)

    抗战时期。陪都重庆。黑暗混乱,鬼蜮横行。区老先生一生读书,也教育四个子女认真读书,用学得的知识谋生。然而,重庆物价飞涨,物资奇缺,民不聊生,靠工资生活实难度日。于是,区老先生的三儿子弃文开车跑运输,发了大财;二儿子弃医经商作买卖,生活小康;长子仍然是机关公务员,穷愁潦倒。其周围的朋友、同事、邻居、亲戚,无不投机钻营,唯利是图,为挣钱发财苦度时光而日夜奔忙,真正是“前方吃紧,后方紧吃”!
  • 我在大唐有座城

    我在大唐有座城

    在大唐,有这么一座城!它没有城墙防御,却是这个世界上最安全的地方!这里的商店拥有无数超脱这个时代的奇珍!这里的医疗,教育,文娱都引领着世界主流!这里的居民必须是各个领域的精英级人才!某国国王为求购一套这里的公寓只能搭上国土!这里是大唐的经济中心。也是整个世界的经济中心!而它的主人,拥有这个世界80%的财富总和...
  • 眸若寒星心若月

    眸若寒星心若月

    景朝文帝十一年。神捕南天远为追查盗窃库银的江南五虎而身负重伤,其女南若月代父下江南追杀五虎。原本以为此行势单力薄,没有想到,竟然在路上巧遇了千里投军却被父亲遣回的林寒星。林寒星隐瞒身份,和南若月机缘巧合而一路前行,途中合力破获了多起离奇案件,两人惺惺相惜……正当南若月芳心暗许,想要将自己南下的实情和盘托出时,却发现,原来林寒星的身世竟然暗藏玄机——--情节虚构,请勿模仿