登陆注册
5381900000002

第2章

That we are right in this criticism is easy to perceive. For 'alteration' is a fact of observation. While the substance of the thing remains unchanged, we see it 'altering' just as we see in it the changes of magnitude called 'growth' and 'diminution'. Nevertheless, the statements of those who posit more 'original reals' than one make 'alteration' impossible. For 'alteration, as we assert, takes place in respect to certain qualities: and these qualities (I mean, e.g. hot-cold, white-black, dry-moist, soft-hard, and so forth) are, all of them, differences characterizing the 'elements'. The actual words of Empedocles may be quoted in illustration-The sun everywhere bright to see, and hot, The rain everywhere dark and cold;and he distinctively characterizes his remaining elements in a similar manner. Since, therefore, it is not possible for Fire to become Water, or Water to become Earth, neither will it be possible for anything white to become black, or anything soft to become hard; and the same argument applies to all the other qualities. Yet this is what 'alteration' essentially is.

It follows, as an obvious corollary, that a single matter must always be assumed as underlying the contrary 'poles' of any change whether change of place, or growth and diminution, or 'alteration';further, that the being of this matter and the being of 'alteration'

stand and fall together. For if the change is 'alteration', then the substratum is a single element; i.e. all things which admit of change into one another have a single matter. And, conversely, if the substratum of the changing things is one, there is 'alteration'.

Empedocles, indeed, seems to contradict his own statements as well as the observed facts. For he denies that any one of his elements comes-to-be out of any other, insisting on the contrary that they are the things out of which everything else comes-to-be; and yet (having brought the entirety of existing things, except Strife, together into one) he maintains, simultaneously with this denial, that each thing once more comes-to-be out of the One. Hence it was clearly out of a One that this came-to-be Water, and that Fire, various portions of it being separated off by certain characteristic differences or qualities-as indeed he calls the sun 'white and hot', and the earth 'heavy and hard'. If, therefore, these characteristic differences be taken away (for they can be taken away, since they came-to-be), it will clearly be inevitable for Earth to come to-be out of Water and Water out of Earth, and for each of the other elements to undergo a similar transformation-not only then, but also now-if, and because, they change their qualities. And, to judge by what he says, the qualities are such that they can be 'attached' to things and can again be 'separated' from them, especially since Strife and Love are still fighting with one another for the mastery. It was owing to this same conflict that the elements were generated from a One at the former period. I say 'generated', for presumably Fire, Earth, and Water had no distinctive existence at all while merged in one.

There is another obscurity in the theory Empedocles. Are we to regard the One as his 'original real'? Or is it the Many-i.e. Fire and Earth, and the bodies co-ordinate with these? For the One is an 'element' in so far as it underlies the process as matter-as that out of which Earth and Fire come-to-be through a change of qualities due to 'the motion'. On the other hand, in so far as the One results from composition (by a consilience of the Many), whereas they result from disintegration the Many are more 'elementary' than the One, and prior to it in their nature.

同类推荐
  • 殿阁词林记

    殿阁词林记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 五事毗婆沙论

    五事毗婆沙论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 阅藏知津

    阅藏知津

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 棟亭書目

    棟亭書目

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太极拳经

    太极拳经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 婚婚欲睡,公子染妻上瘾

    婚婚欲睡,公子染妻上瘾

    (日更6000+)“嫁给我,从此保你荣华富贵!”听到这句话的时候,吕陌涵的心中只有心痛与愤怒。“混账!”她狠狠的甩了他一巴掌,落荒而逃。她知道,荣华富贵,是要用生命换取的。可内心深处,她的答案竟然是,我愿意!她为任务而来,遗落的却是心,既是假妻,为何他表现的那么真?凉萧瀚,像毒药一般的男人,我何时才能读懂你?而他却说,既然是我妻,我便再不允你逃跑。
  • 崩溃

    崩溃

    李莉在某天晚上发现自己的小狗被人割断了喉咙,她开始寻找杀死小狗的凶手,这个家庭里的任何一个人都是疑凶,在黑夜里举着匕首的丈夫,心怀鬼胎的婆婆,变异的儿子,惊恐的小保姆……家庭中的任何一个人都在经历着前所未有的困难,他们各自的表情都和自己受伤的心灵有关,都有无法向别人言说的故事,也最终使这个家庭中的每个人走向绝望的境地……
  • 相教与平行

    相教与平行

    两个平行的生活轨迹绘出了两个不同的人,却偏偏是最适合对方的人。。。
  • 三国奇公子

    三国奇公子

    这是一个波澜壮阔的时代…拨开眼前的云雾,你会发现,你所看到的,是你所想不到的。这是一个三国,一个与众不同的三国……(本文构思比较缓慢,前期发力较晚,望各位拭目以待,读一本你不曾读到的三国。)
  • 太上金华天尊救劫护命妙经

    太上金华天尊救劫护命妙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三个人的末世

    三个人的末世

    大一新生洛小花和她的闺蜜莫小羽在末世初期凭借机智和果断艰难存活了两个月,可就当或许是两个女孩走到极限的时候,遇上了一个奇怪的男生,一个坐在那里等待丧尸来吃的沐九歌。(全书兴趣之作,免费,混个眼熟)(预防针:第一卷男主篇,第二卷以后女主篇)
  • 3分钟读懂一个经济学常识

    3分钟读懂一个经济学常识

    以浅显的语言普及经济学常识,以轻松的笔墨回答经济学问题,是本书的编写宗旨。本书将经济学划分为商品、市场、金融、消费、投资、职场、民生、三农以及世界经济,分门别类总结归纳了生活中各个方面遇到的经济学常识及规律。在本书中每篇内容之后,还附着一个经济学小常识。这些小常识基本囊括了经济学中常见的规律、定理、定律、效应、法则等。每天读一篇内容,每天读一个小常识,能帮助广大读者在潜移默化中学会并应用经济学。其实,经济学并不像远远挂在天边的星辰,可望而不可即;经济学也并不是复杂的理论,高深的原理以及抽象的数学符号。在本书里,经济学仅仅是和我们现实生活密切相关、不可分离的、妙趣横生的事实。
  • 信心比黄金更重要(员工励志版)

    信心比黄金更重要(员工励志版)

    转型时期的智慧全书,危机年代的成功宝典。困难面前,信心就是力量,展望未来,坚定必胜信心。“心暖则经济暖”,企业发展不怕金融危机,就怕信心危机。信心是带我们走出困境,迈向成功的力量。
  • 城岛市杀人秘密

    城岛市杀人秘密

    城岛市的大学城近一年来频频发生自杀事件,本来没有什么可疑的地方,但直到一起谋杀案的出现,城南分局的侦查队长冯子锋发现之前的自杀案件有些蹊跷,冥冥之中有一股力量在操纵着这一切......
  • 春雨杏花会烽烟

    春雨杏花会烽烟

    妙美仙子化为白兔以传不世医书,未曾想邂逅一段佳缘,至此伉俪情深,救助万民,弘扬正气,流芳百世!