登陆注册
5381900000029

第29章

As for those who agree with Empedocles that the 'elements' of body are more than one, so that they are not transformed into one another-one may well wonder in what sense it is open to them to maintain that the 'elements' are comparable. Yet Empedocles says 'For these are all not only equal...'

If it is meant that they are comparable in their amount, all the 'comparables' must possess an identical something whereby they are measured. If, e.g. one pint of Water yields ten of Air, both are measured by the same unit; and therefore both were from the first an identical something. On the other hand, suppose (ii) they are not 'comparable in their amount' in the sense that so-much of the one yields so much of the other, but comparable in 'power of action (a pint of Water, e.g. having a power of cooling equal to that of ten pints of Air); even so, they are 'comparable in their amount', though not qua 'amount' but qua Iso-much power'. There is also (iii) a third possibility. Instead of comparing their powers by the measure of their amount, they might be compared as terms in a 'correspondence':

e.g. 'as x is hot, so correspondingly y is white'. But 'correspondence', though it means equality in the quantum, means similarity in a quale. Thus it is manifestly absurd that the 'simple' bodies, though they are not transformable, are comparable not merely as 'corresponding', but by a measure of their powers; i.e. that so-much Fire is comparable with many times-that-amount of Air, as being 'equally' or 'similarly' hot. For the same thing, if it be greater in amount, will, since it belongs to the same kind, have its ratio correspondingly increased.

A further objection to the theory of Empedocles is that it makes even growth impossible, unless it be increase by addition. For his Fire increases by Fire: 'And Earth increases its own frame and Ether increases Ether." These, however, are cases of addition: but it is not by addition that growing things are believed to increase. And it is far more difficult for him to account for the coming-to-be which occurs in nature. For the things which come-to-be by natural process all exhibit, in their coming-to-be, a uniformity either absolute or highly regular: while any exceptions any results which are in accordance neither with the invariable nor with the general rule are products of chance and luck. Then what is the cause determining that man comes-to-be from man, that wheat (instead of an olive) comes-to-be from wheat, either invariably or generally? Are we to say 'Bone comes-to-be if the "elements" be put together in such-and such a manner'? For, according to his own estatements, nothing comes-to-be from their 'fortuitous consilience', but only from their 'consilience'

in a certain proportion. What, then, is the cause of this proportional consilience? Presumably not Fire or Earth. But neither is it Love and Strife: for the former is a cause of 'association' only, and the latter only of 'dissociation'. No: the cause in question is the essential nature of each thing-not merely to quote his words) 'a mingling and a divorce of what has been mingled'. And chance, not proportion, 'is the name given to these occurrences': for things can be 'mingled' fortuitously.

同类推荐
  • 周易参同契发挥

    周易参同契发挥

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 词综偶评

    词综偶评

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 十六国春秋

    十六国春秋

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 戒单

    戒单

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 舍利弗陀罗尼经

    舍利弗陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 七燕翎

    七燕翎

    小说讲述了现代都市龟大爷蔺子然为代表的一批青年与STW联盟谋略纵横、尔虞我诈的商战。STW联盟崇尚拜金主义,它的成员来自社会各个层面,每个成员都爱财如命,他们为了金钱不择手段,一些精英成员深藏在诸多公司,步步为营,予以击命的一击。
  • The Moravians in Georgia

    The Moravians in Georgia

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大健事

    大健事

    “喂,靓仔,不用看了,说的就是你,戴眼镜的帅哥!”“是不是想找工作啊,过来这里看看,你面相老实,一看就适合干我们这一行。”某某公司出事的时候,工商局到店里检查,说真的,白轩当时就差点跑了。总觉得好像入错了行,被忽悠了,而且那个女孩看着有点眼熟,这就有点巧了。
  • 福妻天降

    福妻天降

    成了恶汉媳妇,林宝珠觉得还不算倒霉,至少能狐假虎威。谁能想到满脸凶相臭名昭著的汉子,其实是个护短宠妻无度的?于是本来想着搭伙过日子的俩人,就这么过起了甜蜜的小日子。
  • 最强红包王

    最强红包王

    红包在手,天下我有。左手拿屠龙宝刀,右手拿40火,一句话谁不服就是干。
  • 火如何灼痛它自己

    火如何灼痛它自己

    塞巴斯蒂安·荣格尔自创了一门专业,他复活了自然的戏剧与人类的本性。很少有作家到过地球上如此迥乎不同且求生艰难的角落。没有人提供过对于极端事件的更触目惊心的思考线索。从美国西部闷烧的雷电山火,加勒比海惊心动魄的鲸鱼捕捞,克什米尔危机四伏的旅行,到科索沃腐烂发臭的集体坟墓、塞拉利昂无情无义的钻石交易,再到阿富汗无止无休的炮火硝烟,《火如何灼痛它自己》一书向人们展示了世界上最危险的一些地方和局势中的细枝末节。
  • 入骨相思知不知

    入骨相思知不知

    再遇见她,贺维庭一把掐住她的脖子,眼中满是狠戾,“我问你回来干什么?!”乔叶轻轻闭上眼,就像熄灭了整个星河里所有的灯。聘用一个曾经狠狠背叛自己的女人作私人医生,他大概是疯了。五年前遇见乔叶,对贺维庭来说,似一场绵延入骨,不死不休的顽疾,可其实我们都明白,生命何其短暂,相逢何其稀罕,过去那段情分明是一段谎话,却谁都不肯先放下。
  • 与伤痕干杯

    与伤痕干杯

    人的一生是一条长长的项链,坠满了各色各式的珍珠。有明这的,有灰暗的,有圆润的,有怪异的,有我们自己抬起的,也人命运赐予的,有乐意接受的,也有无法拒绝的。每一颗都记满了喜怒哀乐,每一颗都有沉重的分量,同样,每一颗都附在生命的路上。
  • 灵缘界

    灵缘界

    任你道法精深,怎比我通汇五行,万法加身!任你秘宝通玄,怎比我地藏仙府,宝若星辰!任你金刚不坏,怎比我四圣五绝,天狐之体!任你机关算尽,怎比我缘法通天,心怀本真!读者交流群:289662745
  • 技艺天王

    技艺天王

    雕刻、竹编、漆艺、书法、茶艺、香艺……中华上下五千年,每一种手工艺,都曾熠熠生辉!五千年来,这些的传统技艺明媚了中华儿女的日常生活。五千年后,传统依旧在!主角秦淮,潜心研究传统技艺,愿在此间久伫,守中华家文脉万世明光。……PS1:好书,就是这么自信(●?●)PS2:技艺天王一群已满,技艺天王二群:725949132。技艺天王VIP群:214200594,须2500粉丝值。