登陆注册
5382300000250

第250章 CHAPTER XXXIII(5)

(Cour de Cassation) does not enter into the material facts of the case, but merely decides the question as to whether the essential formalities have been duly observed, and as to whether the law has been properly interpreted and applied; and if it be found on examination that there is some ground for invalidating the decision, it does not decide the case. According to the new Russian system, the sole Court of Revision is the Senate.

This is the procedure referred to by Karl Karl'itch, vide supra, p 37.

*I am quite aware that the term "Court of Revision" is equivocal, but I have no better term to propose, and I hope the above explanations will prevent confusion.

The Senate thus forms the regulator of the whole judicial system, but its action is merely regulative. It takes cognisance only of what is presented to it, and supplies to the machine no motive power. If any of the lower courts should work slowly or cease to work altogether, the Senate might remain ignorant of the fact, and certainly could take no official notice of it. It was considered necessary, therefore, to supplement the spontaneous vitality of the lower courts, and for this purpose was created a special centralised judicial administration, at the head of which was placed the Minister of Justice. The Minister is "Procureur-

General," and has subordinates in all the courts. The primary function of this administration is to preserve the force of the law, to detect and repair all infractions of judicial order, to defend the interests of the State and of those persons who are officially recognised as incapable of taking charge of their own affairs, and to act in criminal matters as Public Prosecutor.

Viewed as a whole, and from a little distance, this grand judicial edifice seems perfectly symmetrical, but a closer and more minute inspection brings to light unmistakable indications of a change of plan during the process of construction. Though the work lasted only about half-a-dozen years, the style of the upper differs from the style of the lower parts, precisely as in those Gothic cathedrals which grew up slowly during the course of centuries.

And there is nothing here that need surprise us, for a considerable change took place in the opinions of the official world during that short period. The reform was conceived at a time of uncritical enthusiasm for advanced liberal ideas, of boundless faith in the dictates of science, of unquestioning reliance on public spirit, public control, and public honesty--a time in which it was believed that the public would spontaneously do everything necessary for the common weal, if it were only freed from the administrative swaddling-clothes in which it had been hitherto bound. Still smarting from the severe regime of Nicholas, men thought more about protecting the rights of the individual than about preserving public order, and under the influence of the socialistic ideas in vogue malefactors were regarded as the unfortunate, involuntary victims of social inequality and injustice.

Towards the end of the period in question all this had begun to change. Many were beginning to perceive that liberty might easily turn to license, that the spontaneous public energy was largely expended in empty words, and that a certain amount of hierarchical discipline was necessary in order to keep the public administration in motion. It was found, therefore, in 1864, that it was impossible to carry out to their ultimate consequences the general principles laid down and published in 1862. Even in those parts of the legislation which were actually put in force, it was found necessary to make modifications in an indirect, covert way. Of these, one may be cited by way of illustration. In 1860 criminal inquiries were taken out of the hands of the police and transferred to Juges d'instruction (Sudebniye Sledovateli), who were almost entirely independent of the Public Prosecutor, and could not be removed unless condemned for some legal transgression by a Regular Tribunal. This reform created at first much rejoicing and great expectations, because it raised a barrier against the tyranny of the police and against the arbitrary power of the higher officials.

But very soon the defects of the system became apparent. Many Juges d'instruction, feeling themselves independent, and knowing that they would not be prosecuted except for some flagrantly illegal act, gave way to indolence, and spent their time in inactivity. In such cases it was always difficult, and sometimes impossible, to procure a condemnation--for indolence must assume gigantic proportions in order to become a crime--and the minister had to adopt the practice of appointing, without Imperial confirmation, temporary Juges d'instruction whom he could remove at pleasure.

A flagrant case of this kind came under my own observation.

It is unnecessary, however, to enter into these theoretical defects. The important question for the general public is: How do the institutions work in the local conditions in which they are placed?

同类推荐
  • 摄生纂录

    摄生纂录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 强国

    强国

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Letters of Two Brides

    Letters of Two Brides

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Massimilla Doni

    Massimilla Doni

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞真经洞章符

    太上洞真经洞章符

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 锦宫

    锦宫

    重活一世,她要做他心间上拔不下来的刺。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 掌上明珠2:思无邪

    掌上明珠2:思无邪

    亲军都尉府创建以来最大的叛徒王冒,为何会被释放?上官翘究竟是痴心错付,还是另有隐情?是谁揭穿了“白鹤”的真面目?郁李与宝珠这对小冤家将情归何处?防御部新晋的正卫、白沉,对“清理者”小顾妹子一见钟情?继续上一部的爱恨纠葛、潜伏暗战。随着真相一一浮出水面,更多的人物参与进来,局面也变得更加复杂。另一方面,沈家四房突然要到扬州府认人,各路人马竞相而至,原本危机四伏的境遇,愈发莫测……
  • 高原美丽人生

    高原美丽人生

    这是发生在青海省西宁市湟中县一个真实的故事。剧中主要人物,均为真实姓名,事件也都是曾经真实发生过的。讲述的是西宁市湟中县下麻尔村残疾(无手)回族教师马复兴的感人事迹。在读了他的新闻和深入采访他之后,我的灵魂被深深震撼。他用别样的方式诠释着人生的意义,演绎着生命的美丽。在三尺讲台,在生活中,他用超出常人想象的顽强和毅力,体现了人生的价值,认识马复兴老师的人都会说:“马老师有手,他的手在他的心里。”马复兴曾荣获中央电视台“三农人物”、“青海省优秀共产党员”、全国“五一”劳动模范等荣誉,“全国最美乡村教师”荣誉称号。
  • 枫城旧事

    枫城旧事

    人生如梦,岁月悠悠。“金宝儿。”“嗯。在呢。”“金荣,妈累了你了。”“这个老太太,你呀,身体好好的,多活几天比什么都强,别的不用你管。”“不是我的我也不想,是我的想赖了也不行,今天要不我死在这,要不你们就看着办,泥人还有土性。”“你们哪,好好的,好好的就好,不用惦记我和你爸。我还干得动,啊。”韶华渐去,那年那月已成往事。一个家,三代人,看尽世态炎凉。书友群:601928557
  • 剑灵洪门异世录

    剑灵洪门异世录

    冰冷的时代,冰冷的剑,无论光明黑暗,我只想走自己的路!(剑灵世界同人作品,献给曾经热爱过剑灵的童鞋们,回忆那条一起走过的洪门之路!)
  • 十二挑盐客

    十二挑盐客

    一年以后,矮后生石卵成了抗日游击小队长,他领导的游击小队在猴子岩打了一个漂亮的伏击战,俘虏了一队日本兵,还有一个中国挑夫。那挑夫不是别人,正是望柏的侄子羊皮。原来那天羊皮坠到崖下,日本人以为他必死无疑,事实上他没有死;向他开了一枪也没有打在致命的地方。可惜的是他醒来后一瘸一瘸地往回走,在路上又被日本人抓住了,也没有打他,只要他当挑夫,他也尽职尽责地当。游击小队长派人把羊皮送回家,并嘱那人实告了羊皮一年前在猴子岩的表现。羊皮的母亲本在病中,被活活地气死了;羊皮的父亲把他赶出家门,又禀告族里,不认他做儿子,并把他的名字从族谱中划掉。羊皮流浪在外,不知所终。历史的车轮滚到新世纪,猴子岩建了一座自来水厂,矿泉水远销省内外。为了纪念七十多年前发生在猴子岩的那次屠杀,矿泉水厂建了一座纪念碑,碑文由离休老干部石卵撰写,其中有这样一句:“无一人求饶,无一人残杀同胞!”稍稍修正了一下历史。
  • 開原縣志

    開原縣志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Daddy, We Hardly Knew You

    Daddy, We Hardly Knew You

    Influential feminist writer and intellectual Germaine Greer tracks the life of her father, an Australian intelligence officer during World War II, who died in her childhood. A secretive man, Reg Greer took pains to hide his working-class roots. As she painstakingly assembles the jigsaw pieces of his life, Germaine discovers surprising secrets about her father, her family, and herself.Obsessed with family history, Greer is chasing not just her father's life story, but the parental love she always felt deprived of. Brimming with emotion, loss, regret, fury, and the intense depth of love, this book offers a moving climax--as well as sharp observations about Australian culture during the war.
  • 经济学常识全知道

    经济学常识全知道

    冯雷钢编著的《经济学常识全知道:经典珍藏》讲述了:经济学不仅能够帮助我们更好地了解这个世界,还能够帮助我们更好地懂得生活、懂得人生,可以更深刻地用经济学常识去掌控我们的生活。让我们不仅仅知道如何理财、如何投资、如何消费、如何看待生活中的各种现象。《经济学常识全知道:经典珍藏》更能培养我们一种看问题的理念和思维方式,从而深刻地影响和改变我们的生活。所以,的作家萧伯纳说:“经济学是一门使人幸福的艺术。”
  • 请不要对我说sorry

    请不要对我说sorry

    张东和周莲本是互不相干的两条线,过着各自的生活,然而,一次偶然的相遇,让他们相识,相知,相恋,相离……从最初的排斥到最后的互相欣赏,从内心的波澜起伏,到后来的逐渐归于平静。也许相濡以沫,不如相忘于江湖……