登陆注册
5382300000251

第251章 CHAPTER XXXIII(6)

This is a question which has an interest not only for Russians, but for all students of social science, for it tends to throw light on the difficult subject as to how far institutions may be successfully transplanted to a foreign soil. Many thinkers hold, and not without reason, that no institution can work well unless it is the natural product of previous historical development. Now we have here an opportunity of testing this theory by experience; we have even what Bacon terms an experimentum crucis. This new judicial system is an artificial creation constructed in accordance with principles laid down by foreign jurists. All that the elaborators of the project said about developing old institutions was mere talk. In reality they made a tabula rasa of the existing organisation. If the introduction of public oral procedure and trial by jury was a return to ancient customs, it was a return to what had been long since forgotten by all except antiquarian specialists, and no serious attempt was made to develop what actually existed. One form, indeed, of oral procedure had been preserved in the Code, but it had fallen completely into disuse, and seems to have been overlooked by the elaborators of the new system.*

I refer to the so-called Sud po forme established by an ukaz of Peter the Great, in 1723. I was much astonished when I

accidentally stumbled upon it in the Code.

Having in general little confidence in institutions which spring ready-made from the brains of autocratic legislators, I expected to find that this new judicial organisation, which looks so well on paper, was well-nigh worthless in reality. Observation, however, has not confirmed my pessimistic expectations. On the contrary, I

have found that these new institutions, though they have not yet had time to strike deep root, and are very far from being perfect even in the human sense of the term, work on the whole remarkably well, and have already conferred immense benefit on the country.

In the course of a few years the Justice of Peace Courts, which may perhaps be called the newest part of the new institutions, became thoroughly acclimatised, as if they had existed for generations.

As soon as they were opened they became extremely popular. In Moscow the authorities had calculated that under the new system the number of cases would be more than doubled, and that on an average each justice would have nearly a thousand cases brought before him in the course of the year. The reality far exceeded their expectations: each justice had on an average 2,800 cases. In St.

Petersburg and the other large towns the amount of work which the justices had to get through was equally great.

To understand the popularity of the Justice of Peace Courts, we must know something of the old police courts which they supplanted.

The nobles, the military, and the small officials had always looked on the police with contempt, because their position secured them against interference, and the merchants acquired a similar immunity by submitting to blackmail, which often took the form of a fixed subsidy; but the lower classes in town and country stood, in fear of the humblest policeman, and did not dare to complain of him to his superiors. If two workmen brought their differences before a police court, instead of getting their case decided on grounds of equity, they were pretty sure to get scolded in language unfit for ears polite, or to receive still worse treatment. Even among the higher officers of the force many became famous for their brutality. A Gorodnitchi of the town of Tcherkassy, for example, made for himself in this respect a considerable reputation. If any humble individual ventured to offer an objection to him, he had at once recourse to his fists, and any reference to the law put him into a state of frenzy. "The town," he was wont to say on such occasions, "has been entrusted to me by his Majesty, and you dare to talk to me of the law? There is the law for you!"--the remark being accompanied with a blow. Another officer of the same type, long resident in Kief, had a somewhat different method of maintaining order. He habitually drove about the town with a Cossack escort, and when any one of the lower classes had the misfortune to displease him, he ordered one of his Cossacks to apply a little corporal punishment on the spot without any legal formalities.

In the Justice of Peace Courts things were conducted in a very different style. The justice, always scrupulously polite without distinction of persons, listened patiently to the complaint, tried to arrange the affairs amicably, and when his efforts failed, gave his decision at once according to law and common-sense. No attention was paid to rank or social position. A general who would not attend to the police regulations was fined like an ordinary workingman, and in a dispute between a great dignitary and a man of the people the two were treated in precisely the same way. No wonder such courts became popular among the masses; and their popularity was increased when it became known that the affairs were disposed of expeditiously, without unnecessary formalities and without any bribes or blackmail. Many peasants regarded the justice as they had been wont to regard kindly proprietors of the old patriarchal type, and brought their griefs and sorrows to him in the hope that he would somehow alleviate them. Often they submitted most intimate domestic and matrimonial concerns of which no court could possibly take cognisance, and sometimes they demanded the fulfilment of contracts which were in flagrant contradiction not only with the written law, but also with ordinary morality.*

Many curious instances of this have come to my knowledge, but they are of such a kind that they cannot be quoted in a work intended for the general public.

同类推荐
  • 明伦汇编人事典命运部

    明伦汇编人事典命运部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 北齐书

    北齐书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 阿阇世王授决经

    阿阇世王授决经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 浴佛功德经

    浴佛功德经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 辟邪集

    辟邪集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 格里莎三部曲Ⅱ:暗黑再临

    格里莎三部曲Ⅱ:暗黑再临

    暗主不但从黑幕中生还,还获得了更可怕的能力;阿丽娜渴望与玛尔共同开创新生活,但她无法逃离过去,也无法无视自己的命运,更无法否认自己身为太阳召唤者的事实。在神秘的武装民船船长斯特姆霍德协助下,阿丽娜回到拉夫卡,重新集结所有力量,为应对即将全面反扑的暗主势力作准备;但阿丽娜越接近理想,就离最爱的玛尔越远。国家、力量与爱,阿丽娜必须在这三者当中做出选择,或者,当暗黑再临之际,在即将来袭的风暴里,她将失去一切;而所有尔虞我诈的政治算计、狂热信徒的骇人追随,以及格里莎、古老魔法及新时代科学之间的战斗,早已在不知不觉间全面启动?
  • 丑女选夫记

    丑女选夫记

    当她是丑女的时候,他就爱上了她,凤凰涅槃,复仇之后……是昔日情人,还是妖媚的鱼族王子?是生死相依的微服君王,还是双眸剪水的宗主?是绚烂缤纷的护卫,还是纵横天下的魔法师……她的爱何去何从……
  • 桥(中小学生必读丛书)

    桥(中小学生必读丛书)

    《桥》是萧红短篇小说中的代表作,她对此篇十分偏爱,在发表之前就以此名结集成小说、散文集《桥》。作品在意象选择、人物刻画和语言运用等艺术方面,做了很多新的尝试,使她的作品创作始由稚嫩走向成熟,为日后创作更具深度的长篇小说奠定了基础,而它所体现的悲剧性则代表了萧红的创作基调。
  • 意识:从自我到自我感

    意识:从自我到自我感

    意识是一个明确的现象,也是一个复杂的议题,它是最困惑人类智力的现象之一。当代“意识研究”涉及了三个基本层次的问题:即意识的现象学问题、意识的实证科学问题和意识的形而上学问题。
  • 魔咒降临

    魔咒降临

    2xxx年,魔咒突然降临了,没有人知道魔咒从何而来,也没有人知道它为什么会出现,而魔咒的出现带来了一个全新的世界“诅咒者的世界。”
  • 伏山霁妖

    伏山霁妖

    被好姐妹陷害的霓姬背贴着火架,任凭火烧火燎,发誓:来生不再是一个软弱的女子!
  • 中学生最喜欢的99个情商故事

    中学生最喜欢的99个情商故事

    用最美的故事培养中学生的健全人格。全书通过丰富多彩的惰商故事,让学生体会团队合作力量的伟大,品味探索发现的快乐趣味,珍惜朋友时的友谊真情,培养日常生活中的公平正义感,奠定孩子一生成长的基础。性格决定命运,也影响未来。
  • 翼之影Ⅱ:四分之一休止符

    翼之影Ⅱ:四分之一休止符

    佛明伦州的军演如期而至,年仅17岁的天才飞官波尔德一边烦恼着自己未来的去向,一边追随着王牌飞行员鲁迪斯继续飞行。然而就在军演进行到第三阶段,波尔德一行人前往尚恩基地的时候,有人意外地挟持了他们的战友……那片天空依旧自由而宁静,但自由之下孕育着无法挣脱的枷锁,宁静的背后则是漫长的永眠——四分休止符,当这个符号出现在乐谱中意味着停顿一拍。之后,还要继续行进……如果在你心底存在一份对草莽精神的渴盼,一份对自由无畏的狂热,一份对爱与时光的执念,那么欢迎进入White Phantom的世界,成为我们的同伴。
  • 佛说护诸童子陀罗尼经

    佛说护诸童子陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 婚姻的梦幻

    婚姻的梦幻

    在四姑十九岁那年的春天里,媒人走上门来,要给介绍一个女婿,四姑躲出门去。回来以后,三奶和四姑说:媒人给介绍的那个人,姓杨,在双木台火车站当值班员,听说这个小伙子不错,安排个日子你俩见见面吧。四姑说:不见。三奶说:你想当一辈子老姑娘?四姑和五姑晚上睡在里屋,五姑说:姐姐,现在讲婚姻自由,你要自己做主,不要妈和媒人来定,你人太老实,找一个不上线的,你可就毁了一辈子了。四姑叹了一口气,没吱声。五姑又说:我有个主意,你听我的,就这样办。五姑比四姑小三岁,在村里妇女会当主任,人小志气大,能说会唱,能杀伐决断。