登陆注册
5382300000251

第251章 CHAPTER XXXIII(6)

This is a question which has an interest not only for Russians, but for all students of social science, for it tends to throw light on the difficult subject as to how far institutions may be successfully transplanted to a foreign soil. Many thinkers hold, and not without reason, that no institution can work well unless it is the natural product of previous historical development. Now we have here an opportunity of testing this theory by experience; we have even what Bacon terms an experimentum crucis. This new judicial system is an artificial creation constructed in accordance with principles laid down by foreign jurists. All that the elaborators of the project said about developing old institutions was mere talk. In reality they made a tabula rasa of the existing organisation. If the introduction of public oral procedure and trial by jury was a return to ancient customs, it was a return to what had been long since forgotten by all except antiquarian specialists, and no serious attempt was made to develop what actually existed. One form, indeed, of oral procedure had been preserved in the Code, but it had fallen completely into disuse, and seems to have been overlooked by the elaborators of the new system.*

I refer to the so-called Sud po forme established by an ukaz of Peter the Great, in 1723. I was much astonished when I

accidentally stumbled upon it in the Code.

Having in general little confidence in institutions which spring ready-made from the brains of autocratic legislators, I expected to find that this new judicial organisation, which looks so well on paper, was well-nigh worthless in reality. Observation, however, has not confirmed my pessimistic expectations. On the contrary, I

have found that these new institutions, though they have not yet had time to strike deep root, and are very far from being perfect even in the human sense of the term, work on the whole remarkably well, and have already conferred immense benefit on the country.

In the course of a few years the Justice of Peace Courts, which may perhaps be called the newest part of the new institutions, became thoroughly acclimatised, as if they had existed for generations.

As soon as they were opened they became extremely popular. In Moscow the authorities had calculated that under the new system the number of cases would be more than doubled, and that on an average each justice would have nearly a thousand cases brought before him in the course of the year. The reality far exceeded their expectations: each justice had on an average 2,800 cases. In St.

Petersburg and the other large towns the amount of work which the justices had to get through was equally great.

To understand the popularity of the Justice of Peace Courts, we must know something of the old police courts which they supplanted.

The nobles, the military, and the small officials had always looked on the police with contempt, because their position secured them against interference, and the merchants acquired a similar immunity by submitting to blackmail, which often took the form of a fixed subsidy; but the lower classes in town and country stood, in fear of the humblest policeman, and did not dare to complain of him to his superiors. If two workmen brought their differences before a police court, instead of getting their case decided on grounds of equity, they were pretty sure to get scolded in language unfit for ears polite, or to receive still worse treatment. Even among the higher officers of the force many became famous for their brutality. A Gorodnitchi of the town of Tcherkassy, for example, made for himself in this respect a considerable reputation. If any humble individual ventured to offer an objection to him, he had at once recourse to his fists, and any reference to the law put him into a state of frenzy. "The town," he was wont to say on such occasions, "has been entrusted to me by his Majesty, and you dare to talk to me of the law? There is the law for you!"--the remark being accompanied with a blow. Another officer of the same type, long resident in Kief, had a somewhat different method of maintaining order. He habitually drove about the town with a Cossack escort, and when any one of the lower classes had the misfortune to displease him, he ordered one of his Cossacks to apply a little corporal punishment on the spot without any legal formalities.

In the Justice of Peace Courts things were conducted in a very different style. The justice, always scrupulously polite without distinction of persons, listened patiently to the complaint, tried to arrange the affairs amicably, and when his efforts failed, gave his decision at once according to law and common-sense. No attention was paid to rank or social position. A general who would not attend to the police regulations was fined like an ordinary workingman, and in a dispute between a great dignitary and a man of the people the two were treated in precisely the same way. No wonder such courts became popular among the masses; and their popularity was increased when it became known that the affairs were disposed of expeditiously, without unnecessary formalities and without any bribes or blackmail. Many peasants regarded the justice as they had been wont to regard kindly proprietors of the old patriarchal type, and brought their griefs and sorrows to him in the hope that he would somehow alleviate them. Often they submitted most intimate domestic and matrimonial concerns of which no court could possibly take cognisance, and sometimes they demanded the fulfilment of contracts which were in flagrant contradiction not only with the written law, but also with ordinary morality.*

Many curious instances of this have come to my knowledge, but they are of such a kind that they cannot be quoted in a work intended for the general public.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 神鹰之城(兽王系列)

    神鹰之城(兽王系列)

    宠兽学校的暑假到了,三年级以上的学生全部离开了学校,在邱雷的帮助下,留在学校的兰虎有幸来到了传说中的新人类聚集之地 ——神鹰城,为了凑齐邱雷下学期的学费,两人在神鹰城开始辛苦奔波,兰虎在一个意外的情况下通过考核参加了神鹰城举办的宠兽电子大赛,然而面对来自四面八方,身怀绝技,武功强悍的宠兽战士们,兰虎也只能咬牙坚持,就在宠兽电子大赛开展得如火如荼的时候,因为兰虎暴露了兽王身份,却意外地引发了另一场危机,潜伏在暗中的敌人虎视眈眈地窥视着。
  • 凰权:腹黑王爷替嫁妃

    凰权:腹黑王爷替嫁妃

    “在本王的王府里,你只有听从的份儿!”某爷站在她三步开外负手讲着他的规矩。她不觉心里有些嘀咕,这人知不知道自己是王妃而不是丫鬟呢?“你最好安分一点儿,如果敢做出对本王不利的事情来…”“那不如这样吧王爷,”她盈盈一笑,眼波流转,“你休了我咱们两不相干,我自然不会…”“想走?”某爷扳指微转,“除非你是具死尸,或者,直接化做一堆灰…”晚上,她身穿薄衾爬到了他的榻上,“王爷,臣妾来侍寝了呢!”王爷黑眸一闪压她于身下,他的王妃怕是又别有用心了吧!--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 人无完美

    人无完美

    苏若失恋后急欲寻觅一位男士伴侣陪同回家过中秋,相亲未果后果断决定找一位临时演员扮演自己的未婚夫,这个时候被家里赶出来一贫如洗的蒋彦南出现在了她的视线里。
  • 犯罪侧写师2

    犯罪侧写师2

    郑岩在失去挚爱后,远走美国避世,慕雪不离不弃,一直追随,努力指引他走出抑郁症,但与此同时,Z小组也失去主心骨,濒临解散。然而半年后,一系列匪夷所思罪案再度爆发,提线木偶杀人、烂尾楼藏尸、名为狩猎之鹰的凶手设下迷局挑战警方底线……危急时刻,郑岩毅然回国,重组Z小组,他凭借强大的推理天赋和犯罪侧写的专业知识,再度踏入黑暗,于凶险叵测中触摸罪犯的心理和真凶的踪迹,捍卫法律尊严。而这一次,郑岩又将面对怎样的对手和挑战?
  • 快穿之人生总要逆袭

    快穿之人生总要逆袭

    女主一步步成长,体会人生百态!人的一生,总有许多不甘,总想要重新来过的机会,他们为此付出所有!而我便是快穿任务者,为这些心中有悔,有恨,心中有牵挂的他/她/它们努力。
  • 奶爸的黑科技商店

    奶爸的黑科技商店

    穿越异界当奶爸,开个商店来哄娃。“粑粑,兮兮累了。”“叮!获得新商品‘红牛能量饮料’,瞬间恢复百分百灵力!”“粑粑,兮兮想看你练拳。”“叮!获得商品‘武道版拳皇游戏机’,虚拟现实游戏体验!”“粑粑,小奶龙好可爱,兮兮也想养。”“叮!获得商品‘数码暴龙机’,究极进化战斗暴龙兽!”“粑粑,隔壁小强说他喜欢我。”“叮!获得四十米大刀一把,呵呵,小强什么的,砍死就好!”......异界开店流,实体店+网店,佛系带娃,黑科技商品。
  • 战至绝巅

    战至绝巅

    天地万物,始有轮回,前世因果,今生情缘!一代兵王,穿越异世,战天战地,无所不战,战至绝巅!成为逆命者,能否改变命运!面对爱人离去,却无能为力,必将踏入九幽黄泉将她找回!
  • 得配本草

    得配本草

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 捕捉

    捕捉

    靠近三点,老游午睡起来,小便,洗脸,叼一支烟,蹬着自行车往文联骑。这是一辆永久牌自行车,至今老游已骑了十年,早已油漆斑驳,灰不溜秋,骑一路响一路,咯吱咯吱。老游骑着它慢悠悠来到单位,下车把车锁上。文联是一幢灰不溜秋的小楼,在整个机关大院,就数这幢楼最矮最小,最破最旧,整个看上去像个破衣烂裳的小脚老太婆。老游笃笃笃上楼,双脚在挂着白底红字“创作研究室”小招牌的门口立住,手伸向裤子口袋摸钥匙。
  • 青春修炼手册

    青春修炼手册

    家境贫寒的少女洛梓星某一天得到了一份为偶像组合做助理的工作。从此生活开始波澜壮阔,绚烂无比。她更是被一个精致漂亮的少年吸引,那个少年有着最完美的容颜,坏脾气却心地善良。然而生活却总不是一帆风顺,家庭,生病……一系列的事情让他们越来越远。等到一切尘埃落定,她还会回到他身边吗?