登陆注册
5384300000141

第141章

In short, any classification of the emotions is seen to be as true and as 'natural ' as any other , if it only serves some purpose; and such a question as "What is the 'real' or 'typical' expression of anger, or fear?" is seen to have no objective meaning at all.Instead of it we now have the question as to how any given 'expression' of anger or fear may have come to exist; and that is a real question of physiological mechanics on the one hand, and of history on the other, which (like all real questions)

is in essence answerable, although the answer may be hard to find.On a later page I shall mention the attempts to answer it which have been made.DIFFICULTY OF TESTING THE THEORY EXPERIMENTALLY.

I have thus fairly propounded what seems to me the most fruitful way of conceiving of the emotions.It must be admitted that it is so far only a hypothesis, only possibly a true conception, and that much is lacking to its definitive proof.The only way coercively to dis prove it, however, would be to take some emotion, and then exhibit qualities of feeling in it which should be demonstrably additional to all those which could possibly be derived from the organs affected at the time.

But to detect with certainty such purely spiritual qualities of feeling would obviously be a task beyond human power.We have, as Professor Lange says, absolutely no immediate criterion by which to distinguish between spiritual and corporeal feelings; and, I may add, the more we sharpen our introspection, the more localized all our qualities of feeling become (see above, Vol.I.p.300) and the more difficult the discrimination consequently grows.

A positive proof of the theory would, on the other hand, be given if we could find a subject absolutely anæsthetic inside and out, but not paralytic, so that emotion-inspiring objects might evoke the usual bodily expressions from him, but who, on being consulted, should say that no subjective emotional affection was felt.Such a man would be like one who, because he eats, appears to bystanders to be hungry, but who afterwards confesses that he had no appetite at all.Cases like this are extremely hard to find.Medical literature contains reports, so far as I know, of but three.In the famous one of Remigius Leins no mention is made by the reporters of his emotional condition.In Dr.G.Winter's case the patient is said to be inert and phlegmatic, but no particular attention, as I learn from Dr.W., was paid to his psychic condition.In the extraordinary case reported by Professor Strumpell (to which I must refer later in another connection) we read that the patient, a shoemaker's apprentice of fifteen, entirely anæsthetic, inside and out, with the exception of one eye and one ear, had shown shame on the occasion of soiling his bed, and grief , when a formerly favorite dish was set before him, at the thought that he could no longer taste its flavor.Dr.Strumpell is also kind enough to inform me that he manifested surprise , fear , and anger on certain occasions.In observing him, however, no such theory as the present one seems to have been thought of; and it always remains possible that, just as he satisfied his natural appetites and necessities in cold blood, with no inward feeling, so his emotional expressions may have been accompanied by a quite cold heart. Any new case which turns up of generalized anæsthesia ought to be carefully examined as to the inward emotional sensibility as distinct from the 'expressions'

of emotion which circumstances may bring forth.Objections Considered.

Let me now notice a few objections.The replies will make the theory still more plausible.

First Objection.There is no real evidence, it may be said, for the assumption that particular perceptions do produce wide-spread bodily effects by a sort of immediate physical influence, antecedent to the arousal of an emotion or emotional idea?

Reply.There is most assuredly such evidence.In listening to poetry, drama, or heroic narrative we are often surprised at the cutaneous shiver which like a sudden wave flows over us, and at the heart-swelling and the lachrymal effusion that unexpectedly catch us at intervals.In listening to music the same is even more strikingly true.If we abruptly see a dark moving form in the woods, our heart stops beating, and we catch our breath instantly and before any articulate idea of danger can arise.

If our friend goes near to the edge of a precipice, we get the well-known feeling of 'all-overishness,' and we shrink back, although we positively know him to be safe, and have no distinct imagination of his fall.

The writer well remembers his astonishment, when a boy of seven or eight, at fainting when he saw a horse bled.The blood was in a bucket, with a stick in it, and, if memory does not deceive him, he stirred it round and saw it drip from the stick with no feeling save that of childish curiosity.

Suddenly the world grew black before his eyes, his ears began to buzz, and he knew no more.He had never heard of the sight of blood producing faintness or sickness, and he had so little repugnance to it, and so little apprehension of any other sort of danger from it, that even at that tender age, as he well remembers, he could not help wondering how the mere physical presence of a pailful of crimson fluid could occasion in him such formidable bodily effects.

Professor Lange writes:

"No one has ever thought of separating the emotion produced by an unusually loud sound from the true inward affections.No one hesitates to call it a sort of fright, and it shows the ordinary signs of fright.And yet it is by no means combined with the idea of danger, or in any way occasioned by associations, memories, or other mental processes.The phenomena of fright follow the noise immediately without a trace of 'spiritual' fear.

同类推荐
  • 臣轨

    臣轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Gaming Table

    The Gaming Table

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天童弘觉忞禅师北游集

    天童弘觉忞禅师北游集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 答长安崔少府叔封游

    答长安崔少府叔封游

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Oakdale Affair

    The Oakdale Affair

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 拉闸

    拉闸

    郑振树踩着一地松软木屑,从锯木场出来,走到半圆形的蓄料场上。背景是带式钢锯经过木头身体所发出来的剧烈声。蓄料场上,一辆大卡车正在阳光下卸木头。四五个工人车上车下蚂蚁搬家一样地忙碌着。至于身后的情景,他知道,看大门的老头形同虚设。大门之外,不容置疑的春天既改变了旷野的颜色,又步步紧逼,令人不敢在春光里有丝毫的懈怠。在蓄料场边缘一棵樟树的阴影里,郑振树收住了脚步。他歪着脑袋的情形,似乎还没有从钢锯快速切割木头的惬意中解脱出来,又掉进了新的喜悦之中。由于树阴外面阳光的强烈作用,他的眼睛眯成了一条缝。
  • The Paris Sketch Book

    The Paris Sketch Book

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 遗忘降临

    遗忘降临

    多变/不稳定的世界,前一秒是冷兵器时代,下一秒却可能变成星际争霸;前一秒是飞机、大炮、火箭筒,下一秒却可能变成火球、闪电、圣光术。伴随着这种无法解释的现象,人们会自然而然带入进全新的人生角色,忘记上一秒的一切。遗忘,便是不再记得。你是谁?我是谁?这个世界怎么了?如何破解世界的真相?是否能重塑稳定?是否能不再遗忘?!
  • 沉没的羔羊

    沉没的羔羊

    学校车棚凶杀案背后的凶案;《纸面具》:流水村庄里畸形恐怖的洞穴展厅,在绝望和深情的诡异纠结中,看警察李俊怎样一步步解开谜团。最后时刻,到底是正义战胜邪恶还是绝杀复仇,让我们拭目以待。
  • 初恋之只有你

    初恋之只有你

    第一次跌倒是不小心,她可以这样安慰自己,这不是自己的错,是这地面不平的缘故。可是第二次在同一个地方跌倒,这就说不过去了,她想了想,实在不是自己的错,敌军太狡猾,而且身边的人竟然叛变了。子在手,万事都有,不是应该说的是她吗?到最后怎么是他?
  • 盗墓手记之神将诛邪

    盗墓手记之神将诛邪

    主人公黄童在幼年时曾盗过一个不知名的将军墓,得到一本古代的武功秘笈,由此练成一套飞刀绝技,但成年之后,诡异的事情接连找上门来……。千年不死的妖狐长眠于黑暗的深处,只为了凄美绝伦的爱情。拥有至强能力的雨火,有一段痛苦绵长的回忆。
  • 七十年代大佬生涯

    七十年代大佬生涯

    新文上传,快穿:专业打脸指南,大家可以先养肥。秦桑直至去世才知道,原来她和她的六个妹妹都是别人故事里的炮灰,还是有心人为了夺取她的传家宝乾坤镜特意安排的炮灰。为了报仇,秦桑在器灵的帮助下穿越了无数次,用所有的修为换取时光倒流,回到了一切悲剧未发生之前。这一次,秦桑要好好的保护自己的家人,不管是谁,敢伤害她和她的家人,秦桑不介意告诉他花儿为什么这样红。
  • 领导的方与圆:洞察人性管理的奥秘

    领导的方与圆:洞察人性管理的奥秘

    我们常常听见有些领导抱怨:中国人真难管!我们的回应则是:谁让您管中国人?“管理”一共两个字,一个是“管”,一个是“理”。 “管事理人”,是领导者做好工作的根本。曾仕强教授在书中用风趣幽默的语言,向世人阐述了管理者“外圆内方”的领导艺术,令你在读后充分领悟领导者从成功到卓越的真谛。
  • 烈日乌云刀

    烈日乌云刀

    一个在武侠世界里经商创业的故事。来自于世界各国的门派,就如同现代化的公司,它们有着各自赚钱的手段。这些公司中,都有一个部门——杀手组织。这些门派的掌门,就叫作董事长、总裁。?
  • 绝世杀手妻:魔后当道

    绝世杀手妻:魔后当道

    他腹黑,她奸诈,他狂妄她强势,他嗜血,她残忍,他冷情她无情,他凌厉霸气,她生杀予夺。当现代锋利的剑遇上异世寒芒毕露的刀,是谁迷了谁的眼?谁乱了谁的心?“吾主天下”她,现代顶级杀手,穿越异世,狂妄之音,依旧不改。“舍我其谁”他,异世未来之王,只有他想要的,没有他得不到的。两王相斗,是他征服了她?还是她驯服了他?(本故事纯属虚构)