登陆注册
5406800000185

第185章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(11)

This is indeed a legitimate consequence of his principles.But why stop here? Why not roast Dissenters at slow fires? All the general reasonings on which this theory rests evidently lead to sanguinary persecution.If the propagation of religious truth be a principal end of government, as government; if it be the duty of a government to employ for that end its constitutional Power;if the constitutional power of governments extends, as it most unquestionably does, to the making of laws for the burning of heretics; if burning be, as it most assuredly is, in many cases, a most effectual mode of suppressing opinions; why should we not burn? If the relation in which government ought to stand to the people be, as Mr.Gladstone tells us, a paternal relation, we are irresistibly led to the conclusion that persecution is justifiable.For the right of propagating opinions by punishment is one which belongs to parents as clearly as the right to give instruction.A boy is compelled to attend family worship: he is forbidden to read irreligious books: if he will not learn his catechism, he is sent to bed without his supper: if he plays truant at church-time a task is set him.If he should display the precocity of his talents by expressing impious opinions before his brothers and sisters, we should not much blame his father for cutting short the controversy with a horse-whip.All the reasons which lead us to think that parents are peculiarly fitted to conduct the education of their children, and that education is the principal end of a parental relation, lead us also to think that parents ought to be allowed to use punishment, if necessary, for the purpose of forcing children, who are incapable of judging for themselves, to receive religious instruction and to attend religious worship.Why, then, is this prerogative of punishment, so eminently paternal, to be withheld from a paternal government? It seems to us, also, to be the height of absurdity to employ civil disabilities for the propagation of an opinion, and then to shrink from employing other punishments for the same purpose.For nothing can be clearer than that, if you punish at all, you ought to punish enough.The pain caused by punishment is pure unmixed evil, and never ought to be inflicted, except for the sake of some good.It is mere foolish cruelty to provide penalties which torment the criminal without preventing the crime.Now it is possible, by sanguinary persecution unrelentingly inflicted, to suppress opinions.In this way the Albigenses were put down.In this way the Lollards were put down.In this way the fair promise of the Reformation was blighted in Italy and Spain.But we may safely defy Mr.Gladstone to point out a single instance in which the system which he recommends has succeeded.

And why should he be so tender-hearted? What reason can he give for hanging a murderer, and suffering a heresiarch to escape without even a pecuniary mulct? Is the heresiarch a less pernicious member of society than the murderer? Is not the loss of one soul a greater evil than the extinction of many lives? And the number of murders committed by the most profligate bravo that ever let out his poniard to hire in Italy, or by the most savage buccaneer that ever prowled on the Windward Station, is small indeed, when compared with the number of souls which have been caught in the snares of one dexterous heresiarch.If, then, the heresiarch causes infinitely greater evils than the murderer, why is he not as proper an object of penal legislation as the murderer? We can give a reason, a reason, short, simple, decisive, and consistent.We do not extenuate the evil which the heresiarch produces; but we say that it is not evil of that sort the sort against which it is the end of government to guard.But how Mr.Gladstone, who considers the evil which the heresiarch produces as evil of the sort against which it is the end of government to guard, can escape from the obvious consequence of his doctrine, we do not understand.The world is full of parallel cases.An orange-woman stops up the pavement with her wheelbarrow; and a policeman takes her into custody.A miser who has amassed a million suffers an old friend and benefactor to die in a workhouse, and cannot be questioned before any tribunal for his baseness and ingratitude.Is this because legislators think the orange-woman's conduct worse than the miser's? Not at all.It is because the stopping up of the pathway is one of the evils against which it is the business of the public authorities to protect society, and heartlessness is not one of those evils.It would be the height of folly to say that the miser ought, indeed, to be punished, but that he ought to be punished less severely than the orange-woman.

The heretical Constantius persecutes Athanasius; and why not?

Shall Caesar punish the robber who has taken one purse, and spare the wretch who has taught millions to rob the Creator of His honour, and to bestow it on the creature? The orthodox Theodosius persecutes the Arians, and with equal reason.Shall an insult offered to the Caesarean majesty be expiated by death; and shall there be no penalty for him who degrades to the rank of a creature the almighty, the infinite Creator? We have a short answer for both: "To Caesar the things which are Caesar's.Caesar is appointed for the punishment of robbers and rebels.He is not appointed for the purpose of either propagating or exterminating the doctrine of the consubstantiality of the Father and the Son.""Not so," says Mr.Gladstone, "Caesar is bound in conscience to propagate whatever he thinks to be the truth as to this question.

同类推荐
  • 晚次巴陵

    晚次巴陵

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上通玄灵印经

    太上通玄灵印经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A DREAM OF JOHN BALL

    A DREAM OF JOHN BALL

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 寄上舍人叔

    寄上舍人叔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 唐玄宗御制道德真经疏外传

    唐玄宗御制道德真经疏外传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 三万佛同根本神秘之印并法龙种上尊王佛法

    三万佛同根本神秘之印并法龙种上尊王佛法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 社交礼仪全书

    社交礼仪全书

    成功学历来被人们视为抽象、玄奥的学问,本套丛书从社会礼仪、为人处世、心志心理、感悟与人生等诸多方面的阐述中归纳出最有实用性、最有指导价值,且带有规律性的方法、定律和成功范例。
  • 六十种曲千金记

    六十种曲千金记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 最后的奇门遁甲

    最后的奇门遁甲

    本人周易,本市最著名的江湖骗……呸!是奇门遁甲传人!诸位有什么捉妖驱邪,怀孕求子,取名改运等等的迷信活……呸!是业务活动,欢迎加微信咨询。同时,本人不定期在频道999现场直播捉妖除煞,欢迎客户观摩和同行指教。
  • 人生忠告

    人生忠告

    本套《现代名言妙语全集》分四大部分,分别是:第一部分“名言集”,第二部分“格言集”,第三部分“警言集”,第四部分“赠言集”, 这些名言警句句句经典,字字珠玑,精辟睿智,闪耀着智慧的光芒和精神的力量,具有很强的鼓舞性、哲理性和启迪性。具有成功心理暗示和潜在力量开发的功能,不仅可以成为我们的座右铭,还能增进自律的能力。
  • 婚途漫漫:傲娇新娘快入怀

    婚途漫漫:傲娇新娘快入怀

    他一直都知道,她的孤傲都是装的,却偏偏不戳穿。她一直都知道,找不到解药,她就失去了爱人的权利。两个人都心知肚明,却都小心翼翼,不捅破那张纸。她以为她是孤身一人潜入敌部寻找解药,却不知他为了她,以另一层身份陪在她身边。一年前:“有什么问题就问吧!我看心情要不要实话告诉你。”“林柯冉啊林柯冉,你还真是多变。"一年后:“有什么问题就问吧!我看……”“我看你是三天不打上房揭瓦!”“等等!我一定实话实说!喂!你别动手动脚的!”【看冰(chi)山(qing)军花怎么变成软(dou)萌(bi)女友】
  • 江湖老友:蔡澜散文集(修订版)

    江湖老友:蔡澜散文集(修订版)

    本书精选了蔡澜写文化名人的文章,所写者是耳熟能详的名家,如金庸、黄霑、黄永玉、丁雄泉、张彻、胡金铨、古龙、成龙、吴宇森等。作者妙笔生花,对这些人物的描写,妙趣横生,具有很高的文学价值。蔡澜已在国内出版了近百本简体字版的著作,本书选取的角度比较独特,从蔡澜的文章中精选了写人物的文章,其中不少文章是首次结集出版。
  • 最坑召唤系统

    最坑召唤系统

    【本书单人无限流,最终将召唤各世界强者降临,对抗黑暗种族】目前有6个世界,预计还有6个世界要写。以下简介无力:自从有了系统,陈百经感觉自己在变强的道路上一去不返。被动变强。系统:“我都是为你好。”狗系统占我便宜?陈百经:“那我还谢谢了?”系统羞涩一笑,递上来一堆死亡任务:“不客气,应该的。”
  • 第一个主角

    第一个主角

    我叫苏昊。博览群书,这似乎是苏家人必备的特性......精通所有武器,听起来可厉害,但实际上貌似也没什么用啊喂!我五感远超旁人,这算是个有用的东西吧......闲话不多说,那么.....“师兄,可愿切磋?”
  • 文化民生论

    文化民生论

    本书围绕文化民生主题,梳理现代汉语文化精神内涵,辨识纷乱的文化现象中对于文化的种种错觉和误解,探索公共文化服务的实践经验与理论支撑提出当前中国城市化进程中的文化认同难题及其解决路径。全书分为“文化精神论”、“决策咨询篇”、“生活体验说”和“人文随笔录”四个部分,辑录作者近年来参与上海市及部分区县一些重大文化咨询调研的方案策划和经验体会,尤其是通过具体的案例分析,剖解社区文化民生建设中的是非与得失努力寻求现代化从作为奋斗目标,到只能作为一种方式手段的转换轨迹,积极思考如何实现国家有主张、人民有尊严的文化民生理想。本书融理论辨析于案例分析,接地气,讲人话,文字鲜活生动,理论性、可读性、操作性兼备。