登陆注册
5406800000187

第187章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(13)

According to him, Government ought to exclude Dissenters from office, but not to fine them, because Christ's kingdom is not of this world.We do not see why the line may not be drawn at a hundred other places as well as that which he has chosen.We do not see why Lord Clarendon, in recommending the act of 1664against conventicles, might not have said, "It hath been thought by some that this classis of men might with advantage be not only imprisoned but pilloried.But methinks, my Lords, we are inhibited from the punishment of the pillory by that Scripture, 'My kingdom is not of this world."' Archbishop Laud, when he sate on Burton in the Star-Chamber, might have said, "I pronounce for the pillory; and, indeed, I could wish that all such wretches were delivered to the fire, but that our Lord hath said that His kingdom is not of this world." And Gardiner might have written to the Sheriff of Oxfordshire "See that execution be done without fall on Master Ridley and Master Latimer, as you will answer the same to the Queen's grace at your peril.But if they shall desire to have some gunpowder for the shortening of their torment, I see not but you may grant it, as it is written, Regnum meum non est de hoc mundo; that is to say, My kingdom is not of this world."But Mr.Gladstone has other arguments against persecution, arguments which are of so much weight, that they are decisive not only against persecution but against his whole theory."The Government," he says, "is incompetent to exercise minute and constant supervision over religious opinion." And hence he infers, that "a Government exceeds its province when it comes to adapt a scale of punishments to variations in religious opinion, according to their respective degrees of variation from the established creed.To decline affording countenance to sects is a single and simple rule.To punish their professors, according to their several errors, even were there no other objection, is one for which the State must assume functions wholly ecclesiastical, and for which it is not intrinsically fitted."This is, in our opinion, quite true.But how does it agree with Mr.Gladstone's theory? What! the Government incompetent to exercise even such a degree of supervision over religious opinion as is implied by the punishment of the most deadly heresy! The Government incompetent to measure even the grossest deviations from the standard of truth! The Government not intrinsically qualified to judge of the comparative enormity of any theological errors! The Government so ignorant on these subjects that it is compelled to leave, not merely subtle heresies, discernible only by the eye of a Cyril or a Bucer, but Socinianism, Deism, Mahometanism, Idolatry, Atheism, unpunished! To whom does Mr.

Gladstone assign the office of selecting a religion for the State, from among hundreds of religions, every one of which lays claim to truth? Even to this same Government, which is now pronounced to be so unfit for theological investigations that it cannot venture to punish a man for worshipping a lump of stone with a score of heads and hands.We do not remember ever to have fallen in with a more extraordinary instance of inconsistency.

When Mr.Gladstone wishes to prove that the Government ought to establish and endow a religion, and to fence it with a Test Act, Government is _to pan_ in the moral world.Those who would confine it to secular ends take a low view of its nature.A religion must be attached to its agency; and this religion must be that of the conscience of the governor, or none.It is for the Governor to decide between Papists and Protestants, Jansenists and Molinists, Arminians and Calvinists, Episcopalians and Presbyterians, Sabellians and Tritheists, Homoousians and Homoiousians, Nestorians and Eutychians, Monothelites and Monophysites, Paedobaptists and Anabaptists.It is for him to rejudge the Acts of Nice and Rimini, of Ephesus and Chalcedon, of Constantinople and St.John Lateran, of Trent and Dort.It is for him to arbitrate between the Greek and the Latin procession, and to determine whether that mysterious filioque shall or shall not have a place in the national creed.When he has made up his mind, he is to tax the whole community in order to pay people to teach his opinion, what ever it may be.He is to rely on his own judgment, though it may be opposed to that of nine-tenths of the society.He is to act on his own judgment, at the risk of exciting the most formidable discontents.He is to inflict, perhaps on a great majority of the population, what, whether we choose to call it persecution or not, will always be felt as persecution by those who suffer it.He is, on account of differences often too slight for vulgar comprehension, to deprive the State of the services of the ablest men.He is to debase and enfeeble the community which he governs, from a nation into a sect.In our own country, for example, millions of Catholics, millions of Protestant Dissenters, are to be excluded from all power and honours.A great hostile fleet is on the sea; but Nelson is not to command in the Channel if in the mystery of the Trinity he confounds the persons.An invading army has landed in Kent; but the Duke of Wellington is not to be at the head of our forces if he divides the substance.And after all this, Mr.

Gladstone tells us, that it would be wrong to imprison a Jew, a Mussulman, or a Buddhist, for a day; because really a Government cannot understand these matters, and ought not to meddle with questions which belong to the Church.A singular theologian, indeed, this Government! So learned, that it is competent to exclude Grotius from office for being a Semi-Pelagian, so unlearned that it is incompetent to fine a Hindoo peasant a rupee for going on a pilgrimage to Juggernaut.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 只得徐妃半面妆

    只得徐妃半面妆

    莫夸此地分天下,只得徐妃半面妆。他和她,幼年成婚,少年情深,却又怎么一步步走到相看断肠,爱恨两难的地步?她说,阿符,这一次,你不用来救我了,他说,想出妻,我成全你。纵然曾相扶相携情似海,终究是海棠零落随风雨。
  • 太上老君戒经

    太上老君戒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 我只是你一夜的情郎

    我只是你一夜的情郎

    不爱,就走开;爱,就留下;可你总在我面前走来走去是爱还是不爱?难道向一夜情的伴侣要一个结果是奢侈吗?如果不是,那为什么每一次都选择彼此老死不相往来。
  • 混在三国做张宝

    混在三国做张宝

    史上最惨穿越,一穷二白的游戏策划穿越成了张宝,还降临到了张宝死去的曲阳城,手下是无装备,无技术,无军事素养的三无部队黄巾军,城外是虎视眈眈的刘关张和右中郎将。看主角如何在洛阳建立地下组织,如何秘密拉拢各式人才,翻身农奴把歌唱,创立真正的太平天国。
  • 魔笑娇娆

    魔笑娇娆

    千古一笑,笑煞千古,绝然傲情,狂歌傲舞!忍辱负重,破茧重生,十年鬼窟,修魔成神!“如果有一天,我真的成了魔,你们还会爱我吗?”独孤绝笑,白发红眸,绝世容颜,似魔非魔,笑魅众生。曾经,她也单纯的笑过,单纯的爱过,用尽了一生痴傻。现在,也许恨都成了奢侈,万众瞩目时,白色的发丝张扬的飞舞,绝色的女子用着血色双眸看着这世间百态,轻浅的笑容,悠远而飘渺,妩媚且娇娆,好似不属于这尘世间的美丽…“今天,只要我想,在场的所有人都不可能活着离开…”
  • 佛祖都说了些什么?

    佛祖都说了些什么?

    《佛祖都说了些什么》用轻松易懂的写法,介绍了汉传佛教的历史。六道轮回是否存在?罗汉和菩萨谁的级别更高?坏人到庙里捐钱能否获得福报?为什么有的佛经像绕口令?……所有和佛学相关的疑问,这里都有解答。所有对佛教模糊的概念,这里都会进行清晰地分辨。对佛学一窍不通的人,也能轻松地看懂。
  • 女英记(中国好小说)

    女英记(中国好小说)

    本文解构了读者耳熟能详的舜与娥皇女英的故事。女英被神秘人引导,发现了舜日后的秘密。为了不使家人丧命于此,她与神秘人一路寻找破解龙脉的方法,试图阻挡舜登基称帝。将要成功时,舜和娥皇赶来,他们是否能阻止女英?神秘人究竟是什么身份和目的?
  • 名著故事

    名著故事

    无数事实、经验和理性已经证明:好故事可以影响人的一生。而以我们之见,所谓好故事,在内容上讲述的应是做人与处世的道理,在形式上也应听得进、记得住、讲得出、传得开,而且不会因时代的变迁而失去她的本质特征和艺术光彩。为了让更多的读者走进好故事,阅读好故事,欣赏好故事,珍藏好故事,传播好故事,我们特编选了一套“故事会5元精品系列”以飨之。其选择标准主要有以下三点:一、在《故事会》杂志上发表的作品。二、有过目不忘的艺术感染力。三、有恒久的趣味,对今天的读者仍有启迪作用。愿好故事伴随你的一生!
  • 中华家训4

    中华家训4

    “家训”是中国古文化的重要组成部分,它以其深厚的内涵、独特的艺术形式真实地反映了各个时代的风貌和社会生活。它怡悦着人们的情志、陶冶着人们的情操、感化着人们的心灵。正是这些优秀的文化因子,潜移默化地影响着现代人的人格理想、心理结构、风尚习俗与精神素质。这都将是陪伴我们一生的精神财富。所谓“家训”就是中国古人进行家教的各种文字记录,包括诗歌、散文、格言、书信等。家训是古人留给我们的一大笔宝贵的文化遗产。学习研究并利用这些知识,对提高我们每个人的文化素质,品德修养,一定会起到不可磨灭的作用。
  • 诊余举隅录

    诊余举隅录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。