登陆注册
5406800000190

第190章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(16)

The plain state of the case is this.No man in his senses would dream of applying Mr.Gladstone's theory to India; because, if so applied, it would inevitably destroy our empire, and, with our empire, the best chance of spreading Christianity among the natives.This Mr.Gladstone felt.In some way or other his theory was to be saved, and the monstrous consequences avoided.Of intentional misrepresentation we are quite sure that he is incapable.But we cannot acquit him of that unconscious disingenuousness from which the most upright man, when strongly attached to an opinion, is seldom wholly free.We believe that he recoiled from the ruinous consequences which his system would produce, if tried in India; but that he did not like to say so, lest he should lay himself open to the charge of sacrificing principle to expediency, a word which is held in the utmost abhorrence by all his school.Accordingly, he caught at the notion of a treaty, a notion which must, we think, have originated in some rhetorical expression which he has imperfectly understood.There is one excellent way of avoiding the drawing of a false conclusion from a false major; and that is by having a false minor.Inaccurate history is an admirable corrective of unreasonable theory.And thus it is in the present case.A bad general rule is laid down, and obstinately maintained, wherever the consequences are not too monstrous for human bigotry.But when they become so horrible that even Christ Church shrinks, that even Oriel stands aghast, the rule is evaded by means of a fictitious contract.One imaginary obligation is set up against another.Mr.Gladstone first preaches to Governments the duty of undertaking an enterprise just as rational as the Crusades, and then dispenses them from it on the ground of a treaty which is just as authentic as the donation of Constantine to Pope Sylvester.His system resembles nothing so much as a forged bond with a forged release indorsed on the back of it.

With more show of reason he rests the claims of the Scotch Church on a contract.He considers that contract, however, as most unjustifiable, and speaks of the setting up of the Kirk as a disgraceful blot on the reign of William the Third.Surely it would be amusing, if it were not melancholy, to see a man of virtue and abilities unsatisfied with the calamities which one Church, constituted on false principles, has brought upon the empire, and repining that Scotland is not in the same state with Ireland, that no Scottish agitator is raising rent and putting county members in and out, that no Presbyterian association is dividing supreme power with the Government, that no meetings of procursors and repealers are covering the side of the Calton Hill, that twenty-five thousand troops are not required to maintain order on the north of the Tweed, that the anniversary of the Battle of Bothwell Bridge is not regularly celebrated by insult, riot, and murder.We could hardly find a stronger argument against Mr.Gladstone's system than that which Scotland furnishes.The policy which has been followed in that country has been directly opposed to the policy which he recommends.And the consequence is that Scotland, having been one of the rudest, one of the poorest, one of the most turbulent countries in Europe, has become one of the most highly civilised, one of the most flourishing, one of the most tranquil.The atrocities which were of common occurrence: while an unpopular Church was dominant are unknown, In spite of a mutual aversion as bitter as ever separated one people from another, the two kingdoms which compose our island have been indissolubly joined together.Of the ancient national feeling there remains just enough to be ornamental and useful; just enough to inspire the poet, and to kindle a generous and friendly emulation in the bosom of the soldier.But for all the ends of government the nations are one.And why are they so?

The answer is simple.The nations are one for all the ends of government, because in their union the true ends of government alone were kept in sight.The nations are one because the Churches are two.

Such is the union of England with Scotland, an union which resembles the union of the limbs of one healthful and vigorous body, all moved by one will, all co-operating for common ends.

The system of Mr.Gladstone would have produced an union which can be compared only to that which is the subject of a wild Persian fable.King Zohak--we tell the story as Mr.Southey tells it to us--gave the devil leave to kiss his shoulders.Instantly two serpents sprang out, who, in the fury of hunger, attacked his head, and attempted to get at his brain.Zohak pulled them away, and tore them with his nails.But he found that they were inseparable parts of himself, and that what he was lacerating was his own flesh.Perhaps we might be able to find, if we looked round the world, some political union like this, some hideous monster of a state, cursed with one principle of sensation and two principles of volition, self-loathing and self-torturing, made up of parts which are driven by a frantic impulse to inflict mutual pain, yet are doomed to feel whatever they inflict, which are divided by an irreconcileable hatred, Yet are blended in an indissoluble identity.Mr.Gladstone, from his tender concern for Zohak, is unsatisfied because the devil has as yet kissed only one shoulder, because there is not a snake mangling and mangled on the left to keep in countenance his brother on the right.

同类推荐
  • 九转灵砂大丹

    九转灵砂大丹

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 光赞经

    光赞经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 晏林子

    晏林子

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘起信论裂网疏

    大乘起信论裂网疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 医学传灯

    医学传灯

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 妻威

    妻威

    她提心吊胆做了一辈子的假公主。帮他锄奸佞,守乾坤,排除异己,篡位成功。可直到最后一刻,才知道他的狼子野心!好在上天给了她重来的机会,既如此,她倒想看看那些曾匍匐在她脚下的人,怎么翻身。新书《最娇》已发布,小迷弟追女神的小甜饼,等你来磕!
  • 呼兰河传(中小学生必读丛书)

    呼兰河传(中小学生必读丛书)

    《中小学必读丛书》系列图书是为了配合语文新课标的需要,根据中小学生不同阶段语文教学要求,邀请国内著名作家、学者、专家参与选目、编辑出版的一套目前国内规模较大、内容比较完备的课外阅读丛书。在阅读中提升学生词汇和语感,在实践中培养学生的思考与写作能力。拓展学生的视野,实现自我超越。
  • 冷面杀手特工倾城妃

    冷面杀手特工倾城妃

    她是前世猖狂无边的杀手她是今生逐鹿天下的狂妃人不犯我我不犯人人若犯我百倍还之以牙还牙以眼还眼?不够伤她一分她就要千刀万剐她冷血无情一生只为还命最后却死在她人手里今朝她一眼万年情义天地我命由我不由天且看如今天下巾帼胜须眉
  • 葱·姜·蒜·酒·茶·醋治百病(中华传统医学养生精华)

    葱·姜·蒜·酒·茶·醋治百病(中华传统医学养生精华)

    古语云:“医食同源,药食同用”。的确,有些食物就是天然的药物,药物就是可以充饥的食物。在现实生活中,往往越是身边的,不起眼儿的东西就越可能是治疗某些疾病的良药。葱、姜、蒜、酒、茶、醋与人们的日常生活密切相关,也是千家万户常用的必备之物。它们的作用不仅广泛应用于人类的饮食烹调,还可应用在人类的防病治病及强身健体上,是名幅其实的“小食物大功效”。本书从浩如烟海的中医典籍中精心遴选了近万例葱、姜、蒜、酒、茶、醋治病验方,分门别类、归纳整理成书奉献给读者。
  • 独宠坏心小妻子

    独宠坏心小妻子

    狡猾的神偷居然重生到了一个豪门少奶奶身上,而且,还是一个十六岁的未成年……她,凌氏集团总裁的独宠小妻子老婆,纵然拥有着凌氏总裁的万千宠爱,心中一直爱的却并非她的丈夫。意外的死亡,心脏暂停之后的复苏,再一次睁开眼时,她,已并非她。白小果,一个享誉黑道的神偷,一个诡计多端的小女人,然而,却在一次偷得绝世至宝之后,被自己的同门师兄冷枪杀死。死之前,她曾发誓,若有来生,此辱命之仇,定以碎心报之。是否上天开玩笑,在她睁开眼时,眼前的却并非天堂。这是上天的注定还是机缘的巧合?狡猾的神偷重生到了豪门少奶奶身上。而她,最终会选择重操旧业,续享神偷美誉。还是选择金盆洗手,以报辱命之仇?浴火涅槃,且看重获新生的凤凰怎样翱翔九天。
  • Man of the Outback

    Man of the Outback

    When beautiful Sally Baxter moves to Australia, she is eager for adventure, freedom, and to make a life of her own--far from the demands of her meddling family. Her friend, Julia, owns a ranch--and when she offers to take Sally in, it seems too good to be true. But Julia's ranch is in danger. Arrogant, domineering landowner Grant Forsythe wants to buy the land--and he'll stop at nothing to get Julia to sell. At first intimidated and enraged, Sally can't help but be drawn to the handsome, determined Grant--and he makes no secret of his attraction to her.But then Grant proposes to Sally. And she can't help but wonder--is he doing it for love, or for the ranch?
  • 红楼草根攻略

    红楼草根攻略

    草根小包子傍上荣国府,逆袭红楼,成就“木石前盟”,种田经商,励志做个小地主,养得起家人,追得上帅哥,不做妾室做金主——某男捏着小包子脸坏笑:“你确定要做金主包-养-本-王-吗?”红楼有我,黛玉不哭——醉渔暮雪讲述最爽红楼故事,快乐升级中,亲,不见不散哦!
  • 冷情盟主霸道妻

    冷情盟主霸道妻

    “好!不就成亲嘛,有什么了不起的。你倒是给我变个女人出来,我便立刻成亲!”“变?怎么变?难不成给你从天上掉下一个!”结果,实践证明,上天不仅会掉馅儿饼,还会掉……话音刚落,只听到“啊”的一声长音,一个巨大的不明飞行物朝两人砸了过来。情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 小叔,别乱撩

    小叔,别乱撩

    姬家孪生姐妹爱上同一个男人,订婚宴上,姐姐姬心茹看着心爱的男人挽着亲爱的妹妹从红毯上走来,一脸的不可思议。心灰意冷之下,喝酒买醉,却误惹了梅家小叔梅诗帆。
  • 99亿宠婚

    99亿宠婚

    众人皆知,沈城亿万少女的梦中情人盛煜,家养一位财迷小娇妻,卖公司卖房卖地,以及,卖老公夜晚,盛煜看着小娇妻,一脸坏笑:“老婆,我有个项目要找你合作一下……”为了报复出轨的前男友,顾晚舟转身去泡了个金光闪闪的大人物。没想到,大人物秒变牛皮糖,沾上了就甩不脱。【1v1高甜宠文,欢迎宝宝们入坑】