登陆注册
5406800000190

第190章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(16)

The plain state of the case is this.No man in his senses would dream of applying Mr.Gladstone's theory to India; because, if so applied, it would inevitably destroy our empire, and, with our empire, the best chance of spreading Christianity among the natives.This Mr.Gladstone felt.In some way or other his theory was to be saved, and the monstrous consequences avoided.Of intentional misrepresentation we are quite sure that he is incapable.But we cannot acquit him of that unconscious disingenuousness from which the most upright man, when strongly attached to an opinion, is seldom wholly free.We believe that he recoiled from the ruinous consequences which his system would produce, if tried in India; but that he did not like to say so, lest he should lay himself open to the charge of sacrificing principle to expediency, a word which is held in the utmost abhorrence by all his school.Accordingly, he caught at the notion of a treaty, a notion which must, we think, have originated in some rhetorical expression which he has imperfectly understood.There is one excellent way of avoiding the drawing of a false conclusion from a false major; and that is by having a false minor.Inaccurate history is an admirable corrective of unreasonable theory.And thus it is in the present case.A bad general rule is laid down, and obstinately maintained, wherever the consequences are not too monstrous for human bigotry.But when they become so horrible that even Christ Church shrinks, that even Oriel stands aghast, the rule is evaded by means of a fictitious contract.One imaginary obligation is set up against another.Mr.Gladstone first preaches to Governments the duty of undertaking an enterprise just as rational as the Crusades, and then dispenses them from it on the ground of a treaty which is just as authentic as the donation of Constantine to Pope Sylvester.His system resembles nothing so much as a forged bond with a forged release indorsed on the back of it.

With more show of reason he rests the claims of the Scotch Church on a contract.He considers that contract, however, as most unjustifiable, and speaks of the setting up of the Kirk as a disgraceful blot on the reign of William the Third.Surely it would be amusing, if it were not melancholy, to see a man of virtue and abilities unsatisfied with the calamities which one Church, constituted on false principles, has brought upon the empire, and repining that Scotland is not in the same state with Ireland, that no Scottish agitator is raising rent and putting county members in and out, that no Presbyterian association is dividing supreme power with the Government, that no meetings of procursors and repealers are covering the side of the Calton Hill, that twenty-five thousand troops are not required to maintain order on the north of the Tweed, that the anniversary of the Battle of Bothwell Bridge is not regularly celebrated by insult, riot, and murder.We could hardly find a stronger argument against Mr.Gladstone's system than that which Scotland furnishes.The policy which has been followed in that country has been directly opposed to the policy which he recommends.And the consequence is that Scotland, having been one of the rudest, one of the poorest, one of the most turbulent countries in Europe, has become one of the most highly civilised, one of the most flourishing, one of the most tranquil.The atrocities which were of common occurrence: while an unpopular Church was dominant are unknown, In spite of a mutual aversion as bitter as ever separated one people from another, the two kingdoms which compose our island have been indissolubly joined together.Of the ancient national feeling there remains just enough to be ornamental and useful; just enough to inspire the poet, and to kindle a generous and friendly emulation in the bosom of the soldier.But for all the ends of government the nations are one.And why are they so?

The answer is simple.The nations are one for all the ends of government, because in their union the true ends of government alone were kept in sight.The nations are one because the Churches are two.

Such is the union of England with Scotland, an union which resembles the union of the limbs of one healthful and vigorous body, all moved by one will, all co-operating for common ends.

The system of Mr.Gladstone would have produced an union which can be compared only to that which is the subject of a wild Persian fable.King Zohak--we tell the story as Mr.Southey tells it to us--gave the devil leave to kiss his shoulders.Instantly two serpents sprang out, who, in the fury of hunger, attacked his head, and attempted to get at his brain.Zohak pulled them away, and tore them with his nails.But he found that they were inseparable parts of himself, and that what he was lacerating was his own flesh.Perhaps we might be able to find, if we looked round the world, some political union like this, some hideous monster of a state, cursed with one principle of sensation and two principles of volition, self-loathing and self-torturing, made up of parts which are driven by a frantic impulse to inflict mutual pain, yet are doomed to feel whatever they inflict, which are divided by an irreconcileable hatred, Yet are blended in an indissoluble identity.Mr.Gladstone, from his tender concern for Zohak, is unsatisfied because the devil has as yet kissed only one shoulder, because there is not a snake mangling and mangled on the left to keep in countenance his brother on the right.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 星际争霸II:恶魔契约

    星际争霸II:恶魔契约

    《恶魔契约》讲述了吉姆·雷诺生命中一段极为跌宕起伏的时光。他在这一时期堕落为科普卢星区的一名罪犯,和深谙各种黑社会门路的泰凯斯·芬利一同闯荡江湖,距离养育他长大的边疆世界夏伊洛越来越遥远。也正是在这个时候,雷诺遭遇了人生中最具考验性的一些挑战。他做出的决定将彻底改变他的命运,并最终验证他的父亲经常对他说的那句话:“一个人会变成什么样子,全是他自己的选择。”
  • 培养男子汉

    培养男子汉

    《培养男子汉》主要内容:男孩天生具有竞争和冒险精神,父母对孩子的态度会直接影响孩子未来的行为。然而在当前的教育体制之下,全世界的男孩正表现得日渐柔弱。《培养男子汉》的目的是培养男孩子明显的阳刚气质、强烈的好奇心、勇敢、礼貌、坚忍克己、尝试各种挑战、永不服输等完美男性品质。
  • 无上仙侣,神君哪里跑!

    无上仙侣,神君哪里跑!

    落魄的妖族女皇遇上遭人追杀的冰冷神帝!同是天涯沦落人又同体共存,冰冷神帝次次解围,妖族女皇的倾心以待,能换回属于他们的幸福吗?
  • 九州·丧乱之瞳

    九州·丧乱之瞳

    在九州各地突然发生许多杀人挖眼的恐怖事件,游侠云湛回到家中,发现已经死去的独眼人,云湛变成重大嫌疑犯,独眼人的追杀循着神秘歌声而来……一封求救书函揭开神秘组织的一角,一枚诡异神秘的金属圆章,三起跨越六十年的悬案,黑袍独眼的神从不露面,他在幕后操纵着所有人的欲望和未来……地底钻出的杀人婴、轰动全国的灭门案,复活两次的死者,诡奇的秘术争斗,神秘的辰月法器库,孪生姐妹为爱拔剑相向,皇宫里的争权夺利,公主遭遇刺杀……所有这些令人不寒而栗的事件,似乎蕴藏着某种无法言喻的魔力,陷入重重谜团的云湛面临最严峻考验!
  • UFO大揭秘

    UFO大揭秘

    UFO是不能在实验室进行研究,也没有任何公式可用,连确切的证据都没有。这正是它不为正统科学界承认的一个重要原因。人们已经习惯于借助电子和光学等仪器验测数据,用公式演算分析去证实一个发现。但研究UFO,却没有任何仪器可使用,也无法重演,因而难以让人信服。本书向读者介绍了UFO目击案。这是一本探索飞碟问题的内容丰富的著作。书中收有大量目击报告和调查报告,书中也谈到宇宙生命——外星人的情况。该书材料翔实,情节引人入胜,科学知识十分丰富,值得一读。
  • 抬起头,世界很美

    抬起头,世界很美

    《抬起头世界很美》故事精悍简练,包含深刻哲理:《出卖》讲述青年为了买房而出卖理想的故事;《歪打正着的E-mail》则讲述一个调皮捣蛋的中学生 如何被老师的真情感化的故事……《抬起头世界很美》由阿辞所著。
  • 牧民赘语

    牧民赘语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 滚动在刀尖上的爱情

    滚动在刀尖上的爱情

    张建快要疯掉了。和刘晓琪的恋爱谈了足足半年,两个人之间的爱情也已经浓烈到了彩霞满天的地步,张建却连正经八般的吻都没能捞上一个,更不要说进一步的亲密接触了。在女人面前他还从来没有如此这般失败过呢。当然,问题的症结不在于张建而在于刘晓琪。在为时半年的恋爱期间,张建曾经绞尽脑汁,精心策划地蓄意制造过一千次上床的机遇,但都被刘晓琪毅然决然而又不容置疑地拒绝了。放着一个温婉可心、柔情蜜意的恋人在身旁,却又不能有丝毫的造次,就仿佛是饥肠辘辘的人面对香喷喷的面包无处下口一样。说实在话,刘晓琪并不算是特别漂亮的女孩。
  • 晚清之后是民国

    晚清之后是民国

    本书系在全国颇有影响的“晚清三部曲”(《晚清有个李鸿章》、《晚清有个曾国藩》、《晚清有个袁世凯》)续篇,由晚清而入民国,由个案扩及群像,从大历史角度描述自袁世凯去世后,中国社会各方面的嬗变。古老的东方帝国,在一跃成为亚洲最早的共和国之后,不但没有新生,反而陷入内斗的泥淖,一切都在崩溃:政治和军事,经济和文化,信心和信仰……最后不得不以再度集权的方式,画了一个简单的句号。真实的北洋民国是怎样一种状态?内外各种势力如何博弈?世道人心如何演化?历史走向是否可以掌控?这一切与国民性有何关联?作者从容织出一张历史的网,其间,偶然与必然交错,变幻与恒定交织,振奋与悲怆交替。
  • 花开浪漫的华年·春

    花开浪漫的华年·春

    作品以诗一样的笔触,记录、描写了中国目前最大的、自农村涌向城市的漂泊人群中,一个大学毕业的知识人员的生活中的所遇、所感,抒写着其身上所承载的中华民族的美丽诗性与浪漫情怀。