登陆注册
5406800000191

第191章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(17)

But we must proceed in our examination of his theory.Having, as he conceives, proved that is the duty of every Government to profess some religion or other, right or wrong, and to establish that religion, he then comes to the question what religion a Government ought to prefer; and he decides this question in favour of the form of Christianity established in England.The Church of England is, according to him, the pure Catholic Church of Christ, which possesses the apostolical succession of ministers, and within whose pale is to be found that unity which is essential to truth.For her decisions he claims a degree of reverence far beyond what she has ever, in any of her formularies, claimed for herself; far beyond what the moderate school of Bossuet demands for the Pope; and scarcely short of what that school would ascribe to Pope and General Council together.To separate from her communion is schism.To reject her traditions or interpretations of Scripture is sinful presumption.

Mr.Gladstone pronounces the right of private judgment, as it is generally understood throughout Protestant Europe, to be a monstrous abuse.He declares himself favourable, indeed, to the exercise of private judgment, after a fashion of his own.We have, according to him, a right to judge all the doctrines of the Church of England to be sound, but not to judge any of them to be unsound.He has no objection, he assures us, to active inquiry into religious questions.On the contrary, he thinks such inquiry highly desirable, as long as it does not lead to diversity of opinion; which is much the same thing as if he were to recommend the use of fire that will not burn down houses, or of brandy that will not make men drunk.He conceives it to be perfectly possible for mankind to exercise their intellects vigorously and freely on theological subjects, and yet to come to exactly the same conclusions with each other and with the Church of England.And for this opinion he gives, as far as we have been able to discover, no reason whatever, except that everybody who vigorously and freely exercises his understanding on Euclid's Theorems assents to them."The activity of private judgment," he truly observes, "and the unity and strength of conviction in mathematics vary directly as each other." On this unquestionable fact he constructs a somewhat questionable argument.Everybody who freely inquires agrees, he says, with Euclid.But the Church is as much in the right as Euclid.Why, then, should not every free inquirer agree with the Church? We could put many similar questions.Either the affirmative or the negative of the proposition that King Charles wrote the Icon Basilike is as true as that two sides of a triangle are greater than the third side.

Why, then, do Dr.Wordsworth and Mr.Hallam agree in thinking two sides of a triangle greater than the third side, and yet differ about the genuineness of the Icon Basilike? The state of the exact sciences proves, says Mr.Gladstone, that, as respects religion, "the association of these two ideas, activity of inquiry, and variety of conclusion, is a fallacious one." We might just as well turn the argument the other way, and infer from the variety of religious opinions that there must necessarily be hostile mathematical sects, some affirming, and some denying, that the square of the hypothenuse is equal to the squares of the sides.But we do not think either the one analogy or the other of the smallest value.Our way of ascertaining the tendency of free inquiry is simply to open our eyes and look at the world in which we live; and there we see that free inquiry on mathematical subjects produces unity, and that free inquiry on moral subjects produces discrepancy.There would undoubtedly be less discrepancy if inquiries were more diligent and candid.But discrepancy there will be among the most diligent and candid, as long as the constitution of the human mind, and the nature of moral evidence, continue unchanged.That we have not freedom and unity together is a very sad thing; and so it is that we have not wings.But we are just as likely to see the one defect removed as the other.It is not only in religion that this discrepancy is found.It is the same with all matters which depend on moral evidence, with judicial questions, for example, and with political questions.All the judges will work a sum in the rule of three on the same principle, and bring out the same conclusion.But it does not follow that, however honest and laborious they may be, they will all be of one mind on the Douglas case.So it is vain to hope that there may be a free constitution under which every representative will be unanimously elected, and every law unanimously passed; and it would be ridiculous for a statesman to stand wondering and bemoaning himself because people who agree in thinking that two and two make four cannot agree about the new poor law, or the administration of Canada.

There are two intelligible and consistent courses which may be followed with respect to the exercise of private judgment; the course of the Romanist, who interdicts private judgment because of its inevitable inconveniences; and the course of the Protestant, who permits private judgment in spite of its inevitable inconveniences.Both are more reasonable than Mr.

Gladstone, who would have private judgment without its inevitable inconveniences.The Romanist produces repose by means of stupefaction.The Protestant encourages activity, though he knows that where there is much activity there will be some aberration.

Mr.Gladstone wishes for the unity of the fifteenth century with the active and searching spirit of the sixteenth.He might as well wish to be in two places at once.

同类推荐
  • 嘉泰吴兴志

    嘉泰吴兴志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 续小儿语

    续小儿语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 投辖录

    投辖录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上元始天尊说北帝伏魔神咒妙经

    太上元始天尊说北帝伏魔神咒妙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 杨文敏集

    杨文敏集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 特工重生之将门小竹马

    特工重生之将门小竹马

    前世的她为了报仇,和仇人同归于尽,可意外重生,从此过上小公主的生活,衣来伸手,饭来张口,还能随时逗逗她可爱的家人们,意外得到芥子空间,修炼秘法,从此无人能敌,可终究还是败给了他,他把她宠上天,就是要天上的星星也要给她摘下来,只为博美人一笑。本文男强女强,宠上天际,请放心食用。
  • 沧海之约

    沧海之约

    在A国重返亚太、推进再平衡战略为背景,中国与周边国家在政治、军事、外交等多方面进行角逐,以陈江丰、林珊为代表的中国情报人员以亚盟博览会为契机,与B国特工人员程超、阮月娥展开了隐秘展现的情报较量,运用智慧,创造性地提出解决争端的新机制,阻止了战争的爆发,达成了不带武器的合约,破解了A国的围堵战略,不战而屈人之兵,为解决岛争提供了新思路。
  • 闻鱼

    闻鱼

    「新书《赊香美人》已于3.20发布」她为水,他为鱼,纵然忘却,亦是清欢。相遇,就是宿命。弱水三千,谁又是那一瓢……《闻鱼》将以“龙鱼”和“弱水”为基,描绘“天地人”三界,讲五行起源,说六道轮回。从“鱼符”到“鱼魂”,再由“水灵”到“水色”,妖有护花“青丘狐”,神有姻缘月神族,仙有阴阳双鱼洛,魔有“青魔缘月夜”……“水有三生,鱼有三世。”不管遭遇有多离奇,鱼总是离不开水的。结识“桃夭妖”,掌心“彼岸花”,当“闻鱼”梦醒之际,可歌可泣的“清欢之爱”才刚刚开始。她愿为鱼弃善从恶,她肯为鱼改头换面。那他呢?仅仅是为水摘下“鱼面”,还是不惜抹去“记忆”……常言道:鱼的记忆只有七秒!可谁又知道,“弱水三千”,鱼取一瓢,才有了如今的故事。
  • 六十种曲玉合记

    六十种曲玉合记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 甜妻嫁到:总裁大人碰个瓷

    甜妻嫁到:总裁大人碰个瓷

    一夜缠绵,她成了帝都第一少的小情人。说好的只谈钱不谈感情,她负责暖床,他负责给钱,怎么这第一大少处处违背约定?什么?还不准她跟其他男人聊天约会?这少爷未免太霸道,不行,她要逃跑。某少冷哼,想跑?能从他的床上走下去再说!
  • 黄金山林

    黄金山林

    【新书《力气太大只能种田》】 蓝天白云相映,绿树青山成群。程大牛获得连接山林意识的力量,变身黄金山林守护者。斗村霸,斗奸商,斗一切恶势力。救治野生植物,保护野生动物,捍卫黄金山林。黄金山林读书群:459844030
  • 牧心人

    牧心人

    牧心者牧天下,做风一样的自己。本书没有跌宕起伏的情节,行文不甚严谨,史料不够真实,所谓看点应该有两个,一是语言,一是语言所涵盖的内容。本书结尾喜剧,通篇也是喜剧的调侃和暗讽风格,气氛轻松,语言幽默,但表达的内容却值得现代社会和现代人的深醒。如果你是一个牧心人,你也应该具备这样的品味。欢迎加入网文读者交流会:182220421
  • 星星在长眠

    星星在长眠

    青涩时我曾许下愿望让星星告诉你,我喜欢你。可那个星星睡着了。如果星星在长眠,等不到它告诉你我喜欢你……那我就……
  • 神医高手在都市

    神医高手在都市

    【十万追读】他是杀手界令人闻风丧胆的死神,他是中医界让人起死回生的神医,一场变故,让他重回都市,续写巅峰传奇。群:418852337
  • 订正仲景全书伤寒论注

    订正仲景全书伤寒论注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。