登陆注册
5406800000195

第195章 GLADSTONE ON CHURCH AND STATE(21)

No stream can rise higher than its fountain.The succession of ministers in the Church of England, derived as it is through the Church of Rome, can never prove more for the Church of England than it proves for the Church of Rome.But this is not all.The Arian Churches which once predominated in the kingdoms of the Ostrogoths, the Visigoths, the Burgundians, the Vandals, and the Lombards, were all episcopal Churches, and all had a fairer claim than that of England to the apostolical succession, as being much nearer to the apostolical times.In the East, the Greek Church, which is at variance on points of faith with all the Western Churches, has an equal claim to this succession.The Nestorian, the Eutychian, the Jacobite Churches, all heretical, all condemned by councils, of which even Protestant divines have generally spoken with respect, had an equal claim to the apostolical succession.Now if, of teachers having apostolical orders, a vast majority have taught much error, if a large proportion have taught deadly heresy, if on the other hand, as Mr.Gladstone himself admits, Churches not having apostolical orders, that of Scotland for example, have been nearer to the standard of orthodoxy than the majority of teachers who have had apostolical orders, how can he possibly call upon us to submit our private judgment to the authority of a Church on the ground that she has these orders?

Mr.Gladstone dwells much on the importance of unity in doctrine.

Unity he tells us, is essential to truth.And this is most unquestionable.But when he goes on to tell us that this unity is the characteristic of the Church of England, that she is one in body and in spirit, we are compelled to differ from him widely.

The apostolical succession she may or may not have.But unity she most certainly has not, and never has had.It is a matter of perfect notoriety, that her formularies are framed in such a manner as to admit to her highest offices men who differ from each other more widely than a very high Churchman differs from a Catholic, or a very low Churchman from a Presbyterian; and that the general leaning of the Church, with respect to some important questions, has been sometimes one way and sometimes another.

Take, for example, the questions agitated between the Calvinists and the Arminians.Do we find in the Church of England, with respect to those questions, that unity which is essential to truth? Was it ever found in the Church? Is it not certain that, at the end of the sixteenth century, the rulers of the Church held doctrines as Calvinistic as ever were held by any Cameronian, and not only held them, but persecuted every body who did not hold them? And is it not equally certain, that the rulers of the Church have, in very recent times, considered Calvinism as a disqualification for high preferment, if not for holy orders?

Look at the questions which Archbishop Whitgift propounded to Barret, questions framed in the very spirit of William Huntington, S.S.[One question was, whether God had from eternity reprobated certain persons; and why? The answer which contented the Archbishop was "Affirmative, et quia voluit."] And then look at the eighty-seven questions which Bishop Marsh, within our own memory, propounded to candidates for ordination.

We should be loth to say that either of these celebrated prelates had intruded himself into a Church whose doctrines he abhorred, and that he deserved to be stripped of his gown.Yet it is quite certain that one or other of them must have been very greatly in error.John Wesley again, and Cowper's friend, John Newton, were both Presbyters of this Church.Both were men of ability.Both we believe to have been men of rigid integrity, men who would not have subscribed a Confession of Faith which they disbelieved for the richest bishopric in the empire.Yet, on the subject of predestination, Newton was strongly attached to doctrines which Wesley designated as "blasphemy, which might make the ears of a Christian to tingle." Indeed it will not be disputed that the clergy of the Established Church are divided as to these questions, and that her formularies are not found practically to exclude even scrupulously honest men of both sides from her altars.It is notorious that some of her most distinguished rulers think this latitude a good thing, and would be sorry to see it restricted in favour of either opinion.And herein we most cordially agree with them.But what becomes of the unity of the Church, and of that truth to which unity is essential? Mr.

Gladstone tells us that the Regium Donum was given originally to orthodox Presbyterian ministers, but that part of it is now received by their heterodox successors."This," he says, "serves to illustrate the difficulty in which governments entangle themselves, when they covenant with arbitrary systems of opinions, and not with the Church alone.The opinion passes away, but the gift remains." But is it not clear, that if a strong Supralapsarian had, under Whitgift's primacy, left a large estate at the disposal of the bishops for ecclesiastical purposes, in the hope that the rulers of the Church would abide by Whitgift's theology, he would really have been giving his substance for the support of doctrines which he detested? The opinion would have passed away, and the gift would have remained.

This is only a single instance.What wide differences of opinion respecting the operation of the sacraments are held by bishops, doctors, presbyters of the Church of England, all men who have conscientiously declared their assent to her articles, all men who are, according to Mr.Gladstone, ordained hereditary witnesses of the truth, all men whose voices make up what, he tells us, is the voice of true and reasonable authority! Here, again, the Church has not unity; and as unity is the essential condition of truth, the Church has not the truth.

Nay, take the very question which we are discussing with Mr.

同类推荐
  • 杂纂之广杂纂

    杂纂之广杂纂

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 西塘集耆旧续闻

    西塘集耆旧续闻

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 圆明园总管世家

    圆明园总管世家

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 警世通言

    警世通言

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 古刻丛钞

    古刻丛钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • A Personal Record

    A Personal Record

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 舌尖上的健康之道

    舌尖上的健康之道

    《舌尖上的健康之道》是作者依据自己多年的工作经验总结出来的一部通过饮食来改善健康的养生宝典。本书共11章,分别从饮食细节、饮食安全、饮食搭配以及男女老幼不同人群的饮食讲究等方面进行了论述,引用一系列真实案例,详尽地分析讲解了吃什么、如何吃这一经典课题,并提倡通过饮食疗法来到达祛病保健的目的。文中所述的饮食养生细节内容丰富,贴近生活,简单易操作,我们只需顺应天时,合理安排饮食,便可发现身体向健康和长寿迈进了一大步。
  • 法宝:宁夏“继续解放思想推进跨越式发展”研讨文集

    法宝:宁夏“继续解放思想推进跨越式发展”研讨文集

    明确提出,要“继续解放思想,坚持改革开放,推动科学发展,促进社会和谐”,要“勇于变革、勇于创新,永不僵化、永不停滞,不为任何风险所惧,不被任何干扰所惑。”思想上的不断解放,观念上的不断创新,实践上的不断开拓,使中国特色社会主义事业进入了欣欣向荣的新阶段。
  • 问汝平生爱情

    问汝平生爱情

    这是一部70后的成长史,一个师专生的爱情史,一介乡土知识青年的心灵史。作品描写透过一群70年代出生的师专生的成长经历,呈现了一个时代人们的感情、生活的缩影。作品时间跨度大,人物众多,故事纵横交错异彩纷呈。
  • 中学生必读的精彩作文(下)

    中学生必读的精彩作文(下)

    作文是经过人的思想考虑和语言组织,通过文字来表达一个主题意义的记叙方法。对于培养写作能力与思维能力有非常好的效果。本书精选了部分中学生的作文,以阅读来提高中学生的作文水平,加强文字表达能力,对于提高中学作文写作有很好的帮助。
  • 李彦宏传

    李彦宏传

    他,坐拥六百多亿资产,执掌世界上最大的中文搜索引擎——百度,引领全国互联网发展潮流。李彦宏,已成传奇。一个“海归”,是如何走到这一步的?张丽编著的《李彦宏传》详尽剖析了李彦宏的创业历程和他的管理智慧,让每一个想从他身上汲取经验和力量的读者,都能有所收获。一起来翻阅《李彦宏传》吧!
  • 求知力学的故事(中华成语故事全集)

    求知力学的故事(中华成语故事全集)

    成语是汉语词汇宝库里的璀璨明珠。它是长期以来人们在相沿习用的过程中,形成的形式简洁面意义精辟的固定短语。它结可严谨,表现性强,具有庄重典雅的书面语色彩,历来为人们喜闻乐用。不论讲话或作文,准确恰当地镶嵌或点缀一些成语。本书注重知识性、可读性和完整性,每个成语都辟有释义、出处、故事三大部分。编排顺序按笔画多少排列,既方便读者阅读,又方便读者查阅。本书既可作为中小学生学习成语的工具书,又适合不同层次读者作为故事阅读,具有广泛的适用性。
  • 恭喜您的手机已成精

    恭喜您的手机已成精

    【2018王者荣耀文学大赛·征文参赛作品】给我一根撬棍,我能撬动整个星际。这是一个阿宅美少女穿越到星际,不断被坑,不断成长的故事。“叮!恭喜绑定王者系统!”靳乔乔:哇哦,好棒!“叮!恭喜你的手机掉了马甲!”靳乔乔:啊咧?“叮!恭喜你已成功被献祭!”靳乔乔:妈卖批“叮!恭喜,你已正确走向死亡!”靳乔乔:我已生无可恋。请选择:死亡or绝地求生都走开,她要掀桌子啦!于是靳乔乔就干上了暗搓搓挖星际墙角的伟大事业
  • 摩根传

    摩根传

    一提起摩根这个姓氏,全世界都会为之震荡。1837年的时候,一位从美国来的商人乔治·皮博迪来到英国敦伦,开办了一家商号。16年后,另一个名叫朱尼厄斯的美国小伙子成为了皮博迪的合伙人。10年之后,年轻人将这个商号更名为自己的姓氏——摩根,从此这个姓氏为世人所熟知。
  • 满级龙神万界游

    满级龙神万界游

    萧娜:爸爸!那只巨龙好威武!我要它当坐骑!萧辰:是你自己过来!还是我打到你过来?巨龙:TAT萧娜:爸爸,那个怪兽好可怕……萧辰,掏出四千米长刀……萧娜:爸爸,那套机甲好酷!我也想要一套。萧辰,直接从虚空中拿出一套机甲……萧娜:哇,那个小哥哥好帅啊!?(??3`?)?萧辰:……萧娜:他说要我和他结婚……萧辰带上无限手套:少年,我打个响指,你可能会死。一个无敌奶爸带着系统,老婆和女儿闯万界的故事!无后宫,不装逼打脸!