登陆注册
5406800000245

第245章 FRANCIS BACON(45)

"I ate very sparingly of them on Sunday, and was very slightly indisposed in the evening.But on Christmas-day I almost dined on them, and was so ill that I was in great danger." This is the comparentia instantiarum secundum magis et minus."It cannot have been the brandy which I took with them.For I have drunk brandy daily for years without being the worse for it." This is the rejectio naturarum.Our invalid then proceeds to what is termed by Bacon the Vindemiatio, and pronounces that minced pies do not agree with him.

We repeat that we dispute neither the ingenuity nor the accuracy of the theory contained in the second book of the Novum Organum;but we think that Bacon greatly overrated its utility.We conceive that the inductive process, like many other processes, is not likely to be better performed merely because men know how they perform it.William Tell would not have been one whit more likely to cleave the apple if he had known that his arrow would describe a parabola under the influence of the attraction of the earth.Captain Barclay would not have been more likely to walk a thousand miles in a thousand hours, if he had known the place and name of every muscle in his legs.Monsieur Jourdain probably did not pronounce D and F more correctly after he had been apprised that D is pronounced by touching the teeth with the end of the tongue, and F by putting the upper teeth on the lower lip.We cannot perceive that the study of grammar makes the smallest difference in the speech of people who have always lived in good society.Not one Londoner in ten thousand can lay down the rules for the proper use of will and shall.Yet not one Londoner in a million ever misplaces his will and shall.Dr.Robertson could, undoubtedly, have written a luminous dissertation on the use of those words.Yet, even in his latest work, he sometimes misplaced them ludicrously.No man uses figures of speech with more propriety because he knows that one figure is called a metonymy and another a synecdoche.A drayman in a passion calls out, "You are a pretty fellow.", without suspecting that he is uttering irony, and that irony is one of the four primary tropes.The old systems of rhetoric were never regarded by the most experienced and discerning judges as of any use for the purpose of forming an orator."Ego hanc vim intelligo," said Cicero, "esse in praeceptis omnibus, non ut ea secuti oratores eloquentiae laudem sint adepti, sed quae sua sponte homines eloquentes facerent, ea quosdam observasse, atque id egisse; sic esse non eloquentiam ex artificio, sed artificium ex eloquentia natum." We must own that we entertain the same opinion concerning the study of Logic which Cicero entertained concerning the study of Rhetoric.A man of sense syllogises in celarent and cesare all day long without suspecting it; and, though he may not know what an ignoratio elenchi is, has no difficulty in exposing it whenever he falls in with it; which is likely to be as often as he falls in with a Reverend Master of Arts nourished on mode and figure in the cloisters of Oxford.Considered merely as an intellectual feat, the Organum of Aristotle can scarcely be admired too highly.But the more we compare individual with individual, school with school, nation with nation, generation with generation, the more do we lean to the opinion that the knowledge of the theory of logic has no tendency whatever to make men good reasoners.

What Aristotle did for the syllogistic process Bacon has, in the second book of the Novum Organum, done for the inductive process;that is to say, he has analysed it well.His rules are quite proper, but we do not need them, because they are drawn from our own constant practice.

But, though everybody is constantly performing the process described in the second book of the Novum Organum, some men perform it well and some perform it ill.Some are led by it to truth, and some to error.It led Franklin to discover the nature of lightning.It led thousands, who had less brains than Franklin, to believe in animal magnetism.But this was not because Franklin went through the process described by Bacon, and the dupes of Mesmer through a different process.The comparentiae and rejectiones of which we have given examples will be found in the most unsound inductions.We have heard that an eminent judge of the last generation was in the habit of jocosely propounding after dinner a theory, that the cause of the prevalence of Jacobinism was the practice of bearing three names.He quoted on the one side Charles James Fox, Richard Brinsley Sheridan, John Horne Tooke, John Philpot Curran, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Theobald Wolfe Tone.These were instantiae convenientes.He then proceeded to cite instances absentiae in proximo, William Pitt, John Scott, William Windham, Samuel Horsley, Henry Dundas, Edmund Burke.He might have gone on to instances secundum magis et minus.The practice of giving children three names has been for some time a growing practice, and Jacobinism has also been growing.The practice of giving children three names is more common in America than in England.In England we still have a King and a House of Lords; but the Americans are Republicans.The rejectiones are obvious.Burke and Theobald Wolfe Tone are both Irishmen: therefore the being an Irishman is not the cause of Jacobinism.Horsley and Horne Tooke are both clergymen; therefore the being a clergyman is not the cause of Jacobinism.Fox and Windham were both educated at Oxford; therefore the being educated at Oxford is not the cause of Jacobinism.Pitt and Horne Tooke were both educated at Cambridge; therefore the being educated at Cambridge is not the cause of Jacobinism.In this way, our inductive philosopher arrives at what Bacon calls the Vintage, and pronounces that the having three names is the cause of Jacobinism.

同类推荐
  • 优语录

    优语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宗伯集

    宗伯集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Changed Man and Other Tales

    A Changed Man and Other Tales

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 否泰錄

    否泰錄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 速疾立验魔醯首罗天说阿尾奢法

    速疾立验魔醯首罗天说阿尾奢法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 往北的地方海未眠

    往北的地方海未眠

    本书为长篇小说,一个靠坑蒙拐骗的小神棍,阴差阳错以英雄救姿救走了被后母凌虐的混血小王子,一时的善意,却卷进成人的陷阱。生活是最大的阴谋家,用最温柔的网织出一段最残酷的青春成长迷局,后来,谢欢喜会想,如果没有相遇,一切是不是会不会不一样?
  • 万花笑颜皆似你

    万花笑颜皆似你

    生在帝王家,却对皇位不感兴趣,本想着皇帝老儿罩着他,可以正常娶妻生子,游历山水,潇洒度过一生。但没想到,等着他的,竟然是——
  • 索多玛的苹果

    索多玛的苹果

    在一次航海旅行中,少年御景风对一种名为“索多玛的苹果”的毒品紧迫不舍,与他一起参与整个事件的少女橘真绫也对他的真实身份产生了好奇与疑惑,与此同时,一连串神秘的死亡事件频频发生……随后,令御景风更为惊讶的是,一个名为“STH”的神秘程序总是被人反复提起,而因追逐STH秘密而亡故的人越来越多。这个程序到底隐藏着怎样的秘密?它和御景风从不愿意多提的身世有着怎样的联系?接下来的变故与转折,御景风和超级骇客杰比又该怎样面对?亦正亦邪的神秘少年御景风到底会路向何方?于索多玛城内幻化的苹果到底象征的是希望还是失望?一在劫数与结束来临之前一切已然开始……“苹果”在《圣经》中是智慧之果,但产于死海之滨索多玛城的一种苹果,却有着另外一种含义,即“空欢喜”与“失望的源泉”。面对离奇的身世、飘忽的爱情、忠实的友情以及人与人之问的狡诈争斗,少年御景风该何去何从?作者以独特的笔触细致抒发了一种独立、叛逆、迷茫而又坚定的少年情怀。
  • 重生千金是学霸

    重生千金是学霸

    【新文《农门小恶女》火热连载中】养姐杀害她、冒名顶替她成为T大学生、联合养兄夺她家产、逼死她父母,还让他们死后无人收尸。她带着滔天恨意重生回十五岁,誓要让白眼狼付出代价。斗渣姐、虐渣兄、护至亲、保家产、当学霸……她要活出不一样的精彩人生!只是一不留神,她就被一个扮猪吃老虎的财团继承人,一步步收归羽翼之下。从此她的复仇路上,多了一个宠她入骨的霸道总裁护航!
  • 江湖街

    江湖街

    段姑娘小我一岁,但我从来没叫过她段姑娘,因为她是我的亲小姨。十二岁那年,外婆去世后母亲便把段姑娘从乡下接到我们家,从此我和段姑娘便一起在江湖街小学上学,风里雨里来去像是一对兄妹,虽然我年纪稍长,但母亲从来不准我叫段姑娘的名字,只准我喊她小姨,梳子去掉齿,背(辈)儿在。反正我也顺口了,只把“小姨”两个字当作她的名字叫。段姑娘白白净净的瘦细身子,性格却像个男孩子,比我顽皮的多,没少让母亲烦心。记得小学五年级那年暑假,有一天段姑娘跑到江湖街尽头的老庙里抓壁虎,也不知是怎么一回事儿,她竟爬到了庙顶上。
  • 花都战神

    花都战神

    一个如同神一样的超级兵王,厌倦了杀戮的生涯,甘愿隐藏在花都。且看陆浩,如何穿梭凡尘,游戏人间……
  • 傲笑天地间

    傲笑天地间

    四地域,六遗族。八天宗,九神谷。战天抗魔,枭雄争。琥珀长剑,血染如何?琥珀色眼眸,热血之心,大道向前,血染又如何。争夺,杀戮,在强者的世界里,没有弱者的席位。度与劫,丹田为度,丹灵为劫,斗气炼度,灵气渡劫。生与死,情与恨,泪与笑,一杯酒。异灵,狂魔,凡人,天神天陨,血誓,遗迹,有缘人丹药,鬼精,神魄,魔血,焠体炼魂爱,狠,情,仇,断人肠侠,义,恩,蝉,笑人生。
  • 倾城胖妃

    倾城胖妃

    ★穿越大事记★天降紫雷,穿成相府胖女一枚;本就声名狼藉的她更恶名昭彰!天!有没有被她更悲惨的穿越!容貌倾城绝世,身子奇胖无比,破坏力——宇宙级!一不小心就砸烂了琴,一不小心就摔碎了玉,一不小心就踩坏了珠,从此闯祸惹事不断。**********************************☆砸烂皇子的床一日,庞然大物从空而落,某个华丽的床烂了!她不过起身拍拍土,却不小心踩到一个人。“水惊语,你居然砸烂了它!”☆吵醒冰棺美男华丽的暗室里,放着一口冰棺,躺着绝美的人。“大美人,本小姐心情正好,为你唱一首歌如何?”等她唱了N次之后,某男忍无可忍,掐住她的脖子怒道,“胖猪,闭嘴!”☆勾搭谪仙王爷一日,有琴声绕耳,十分动听。林中有一个白衣男子,对着清风低吟浅唱。“佛说前世千百次回眸,才换得今生擦肩而过,你前世一定偷偷看了我千万遍,本小姐就勉为其难嫁给你!”男子嘴角带着一抹浅笑,“谁让娘子如此‘丰腴’,为夫想不注意都难…”“但我感谢上苍,让我遇到了你…”*********************************本文楠竹多多,女猪腹黑无良,男女主身心干净,以宠为主,欢乐搞笑哦~※推荐好友滴文※《枭宠神算辣妻》《农女的锦绣商图》
  • 平蛮录

    平蛮录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 伏藏(下·修订版)

    伏藏(下·修订版)

    杨志军的长篇小说《伏藏》书写了三百多年前的西藏神王仓央嘉措的秘密,诡秘的七人使团、扑朔迷离的地下预言,历史与现实交错,藏地与世界相交,仓央嘉措留下的绝密伏藏,三百年后命定的发掘者和叛誓者,新信仰联盟的阴谋,人类的灵魂之谜,当下世界的精神迷茫,现实的玄机和精神的冒险。《伏藏》是作家三十年生命体验的藏地精神之书,也是出自心灵、探寻人类灵魂的寻梦人之书。在路上,带一本杨志军,想象藏地的壮丽和神秘,倾听藏地的呼唤,感悟心灵的悸动和人类精神的浩瀚。