登陆注册
5406800000245

第245章 FRANCIS BACON(45)

"I ate very sparingly of them on Sunday, and was very slightly indisposed in the evening.But on Christmas-day I almost dined on them, and was so ill that I was in great danger." This is the comparentia instantiarum secundum magis et minus."It cannot have been the brandy which I took with them.For I have drunk brandy daily for years without being the worse for it." This is the rejectio naturarum.Our invalid then proceeds to what is termed by Bacon the Vindemiatio, and pronounces that minced pies do not agree with him.

We repeat that we dispute neither the ingenuity nor the accuracy of the theory contained in the second book of the Novum Organum;but we think that Bacon greatly overrated its utility.We conceive that the inductive process, like many other processes, is not likely to be better performed merely because men know how they perform it.William Tell would not have been one whit more likely to cleave the apple if he had known that his arrow would describe a parabola under the influence of the attraction of the earth.Captain Barclay would not have been more likely to walk a thousand miles in a thousand hours, if he had known the place and name of every muscle in his legs.Monsieur Jourdain probably did not pronounce D and F more correctly after he had been apprised that D is pronounced by touching the teeth with the end of the tongue, and F by putting the upper teeth on the lower lip.We cannot perceive that the study of grammar makes the smallest difference in the speech of people who have always lived in good society.Not one Londoner in ten thousand can lay down the rules for the proper use of will and shall.Yet not one Londoner in a million ever misplaces his will and shall.Dr.Robertson could, undoubtedly, have written a luminous dissertation on the use of those words.Yet, even in his latest work, he sometimes misplaced them ludicrously.No man uses figures of speech with more propriety because he knows that one figure is called a metonymy and another a synecdoche.A drayman in a passion calls out, "You are a pretty fellow.", without suspecting that he is uttering irony, and that irony is one of the four primary tropes.The old systems of rhetoric were never regarded by the most experienced and discerning judges as of any use for the purpose of forming an orator."Ego hanc vim intelligo," said Cicero, "esse in praeceptis omnibus, non ut ea secuti oratores eloquentiae laudem sint adepti, sed quae sua sponte homines eloquentes facerent, ea quosdam observasse, atque id egisse; sic esse non eloquentiam ex artificio, sed artificium ex eloquentia natum." We must own that we entertain the same opinion concerning the study of Logic which Cicero entertained concerning the study of Rhetoric.A man of sense syllogises in celarent and cesare all day long without suspecting it; and, though he may not know what an ignoratio elenchi is, has no difficulty in exposing it whenever he falls in with it; which is likely to be as often as he falls in with a Reverend Master of Arts nourished on mode and figure in the cloisters of Oxford.Considered merely as an intellectual feat, the Organum of Aristotle can scarcely be admired too highly.But the more we compare individual with individual, school with school, nation with nation, generation with generation, the more do we lean to the opinion that the knowledge of the theory of logic has no tendency whatever to make men good reasoners.

What Aristotle did for the syllogistic process Bacon has, in the second book of the Novum Organum, done for the inductive process;that is to say, he has analysed it well.His rules are quite proper, but we do not need them, because they are drawn from our own constant practice.

But, though everybody is constantly performing the process described in the second book of the Novum Organum, some men perform it well and some perform it ill.Some are led by it to truth, and some to error.It led Franklin to discover the nature of lightning.It led thousands, who had less brains than Franklin, to believe in animal magnetism.But this was not because Franklin went through the process described by Bacon, and the dupes of Mesmer through a different process.The comparentiae and rejectiones of which we have given examples will be found in the most unsound inductions.We have heard that an eminent judge of the last generation was in the habit of jocosely propounding after dinner a theory, that the cause of the prevalence of Jacobinism was the practice of bearing three names.He quoted on the one side Charles James Fox, Richard Brinsley Sheridan, John Horne Tooke, John Philpot Curran, Samuel Taylor Coleridge, Theobald Wolfe Tone.These were instantiae convenientes.He then proceeded to cite instances absentiae in proximo, William Pitt, John Scott, William Windham, Samuel Horsley, Henry Dundas, Edmund Burke.He might have gone on to instances secundum magis et minus.The practice of giving children three names has been for some time a growing practice, and Jacobinism has also been growing.The practice of giving children three names is more common in America than in England.In England we still have a King and a House of Lords; but the Americans are Republicans.The rejectiones are obvious.Burke and Theobald Wolfe Tone are both Irishmen: therefore the being an Irishman is not the cause of Jacobinism.Horsley and Horne Tooke are both clergymen; therefore the being a clergyman is not the cause of Jacobinism.Fox and Windham were both educated at Oxford; therefore the being educated at Oxford is not the cause of Jacobinism.Pitt and Horne Tooke were both educated at Cambridge; therefore the being educated at Cambridge is not the cause of Jacobinism.In this way, our inductive philosopher arrives at what Bacon calls the Vintage, and pronounces that the having three names is the cause of Jacobinism.

同类推荐
  • 朝野新谭

    朝野新谭

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 黄庭内外景经

    黄庭内外景经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 正一指教斋仪

    正一指教斋仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 详刑公案

    详刑公案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 史通

    史通

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 正宗过瘾川菜

    正宗过瘾川菜

    《美食天下(第2辑):正宗过瘾川菜》学做最地道的川味家常菜。一菜一格,百菜百味。绝妙配料麻辣鲜香,色香味形巴蜀特色。大厨亲传经典巴蜀美味秘诀,让您在家也能做出正宗川味。
  • 首席公爵请放手

    首席公爵请放手

    为了逃避相亲结婚的话题,她决定来一次出国旅行,却在回国的前一晚,被人卖进黑市。他是黑白两道的神秘大人物,在众多物品中唯独看中了她,一夜之后,她成了众人艳羡的对象。就在她慢慢对他打开心扉的时候,他却厌弃了她。 再次相见,她早已嫁为人妻,身为人母,脸上的笑容一改她曾经面对他时的冰冷。一场大火,烧毁了她的家,她带着孩子苍惶出逃……
  • KIM

    KIM

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 赠予一生相思

    赠予一生相思

    被照顾四年,成为兼职拳击手,转身一张高考准考证,将我送回无以遁逃的现实生活,为报复不惜两败俱伤
  • 逆世神尊

    逆世神尊

    华夏王牌特工意外穿越到了修真大陆,凭借着强大的秘籍和坚韧的心性一路高歌,最后踏上巅峰……
  • 幸福只需一张床(闪小说亲情篇)

    幸福只需一张床(闪小说亲情篇)

    本套书精选3000余篇闪小说,所有篇目均在国内公开报刊发表过。每篇都有独到的思想性,画面感强,适合改编手机短信小说。这些闪小说除了通过故事的演绎让读者了解这些闪小说的可感和领悟其中的深刻含义外,特别对广大初高中生读者的心灵是一次很好的洗涤。
  • 背脊门

    背脊门

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 快穿主神大人太沙雕

    快穿主神大人太沙雕

    【1v1主打感情流】神仙叶笇的人格分裂了为了找回人格和保护仙界和平,叶笇的凡人人格出动了等等,不是说主打剧情吗?反派一个个抱着我啃,还嚷嚷要和我谈恋爱是什么个操作?#星际篇#星际天才指挥家,帽子一戴,谁也不爱,但你为什么老跟着我!#校园篇#这位学生你好好说话,不要满口网上的土味情话!#童话篇#不是,这位美人鱼,你不是应该去救男主吗!而且你下面怎么多出来一个东西!!1.每个反派都是白莲花流,不喜欢看就别点了2.文笔不太成熟,会练,可以提意见,但别喷3.女主不傻,细品4.男主病娇,脑子不太正常那种5.纯属虚构,不要当真,现实遇到病娇,打妖妖灵6.本文没完结,作者好奇点了完结而已,目前每日一更,假期有能力会加更
  • 我的美丽小月历

    我的美丽小月历

    一本书说透女性生理秘密的健康月历,不让你错过每一天的美丽良机!12大排毒攻略,40个美颜秘技,30个不衰老小窍门,按图索骥,自备自查。应对生理期偏头疼、失眠、痘痘、牙痛、便秘、水肿、经期综合征。妙解护肤、丰胸、避孕、补肾、卵巢保养的每日法则!本书是秦文敏大夫综合以往丰富的临床经验与切身体会,提供给如今时尚女性的养生宝典。它以月历的形式,从每一天的小细节开始,详细介绍了一个月经周期中每一天的注意事项和保养方法,应对生理期偏头疼、失眠、痘痘、皮肤敏感、牙痛、压力、便秘、水肿、妇科疾病、经前困乏、经前期综合征,护肤、丰胸、减肥、祛湿排毒、卵巢保养、补充磁性激素、避孕、补肾、疏通肠道、精力充沛神采奕奕、让你经期“Hold住”法则等。现代都市女性时刻面临各种压力,当这些压力海啸般漫过身体时,留下了不仅有疲惫的心灵,还有备受摧残身体。因此,我们必须学会让自己的身体深刻保持健康。
  • 做最得力的中层:带好队伍用好人

    做最得力的中层:带好队伍用好人

    把责任落实到位,做最好的中层,对上,中层是被管理者,需要掌握与上级有效沟通的技巧和方法。对下,中层是管理者,既需要树立自己的权威把工作做出色,在领导中绽放你的光彩