登陆注册
5419400000148

第148章

We can now see that the major, in the above cosmological syllogism, takes the conditioned in the transcendental signification which it has in the pure category, while the minor speaks of it in the empirical signification which it has in the category as applied to phenomena.There is, therefore, a dialectical fallacy in the syllogism- a sophisma figurae dictionis.But this fallacy is not a consciously devised one, but a perfectly natural illusion of the common reason of man.For, when a thing is given as conditioned, we presuppose in the major its conditions and their series, unperceived, as it were, and unseen; because this is nothing more than the logical requirement of complete and satisfactory premisses for a given conclusion.In this case, time is altogether left out in the connection of the conditioned with the condition; they are supposed to be given in themselves, and contemporaneously.It is, moreover, just as natural to regard phenomena (in the minor) as things in themselves and as objects presented to the pure understanding, as in the major, in which complete abstraction was made of all conditions of intuition.But it is under these conditions alone that objects are given.Now we overlooked a remarkable distinction between the conceptions.The synthesis of the conditioned with its condition, and the complete series of the latter (in the major) are not limited by time, and do not contain the conception of succession.On the contrary, the empirical synthesis and the series of conditions in the phenomenal world- subsumed in the minor- are necessarily successive and given in time alone.It follows that I cannot presuppose in the minor, as I did in the major, the absolute totality of the synthesis and of the series therein represented; for in the major all the members of the series are given as things in themselves- without any limitations or conditions of time, while in the minor they are possible only in and through a successive regress, which cannot exist, except it be actually carried into execution in the world of phenomena.

After this proof of the viciousness of the argument commonly employed in maintaining cosmological assertions, both parties may now be justly dismissed, as advancing claims without grounds or title.

But the process has not been ended by convincing them that one or both were in the wrong and had maintained an assertion which was without valid grounds of proof.Nothing seems to be clearer than that, if one maintains: "The world has a beginning," and another: "The world has no beginning," one of the two must be right.But it is likewise clear that, if the evidence on both sides is equal, it is impossible to discover on what side the truth lies; and the controversy continues, although the parties have been recommended to peace before the tribunal of reason.There remains, then, no other means of settling the question than to convince the parties, who refute each other with such conclusiveness and ability, that they are disputing about nothing, and that a transcendental illusion has been mocking them with visions of reality where there is none.The mode of adjusting a dispute which cannot be decided upon its own merits, we shall now proceed to lay before our readers.

Zeno of Elea, a subtle dialectician, was severely reprimanded by Plato as a sophist, who, merely from the base motive of exhibiting his skill in discussion, maintained and subverted the same proposition by arguments as powerful and convincing on the one side as on the other.He maintained, for example, that God (who was probably nothing more, in his view, than the world) is neither finite nor infinite, neither in motion nor in rest, neither similar nor dissimilar to any other thing.It seemed to those philosophers who criticized his mode of discussion that his purpose was to deny completely both of two self-contradictory propositions- which is absurd.But I cannot believe that there is any justice in this accusation.The first of these propositions I shall presently consider in a more detailed manner.With regard to the others, if by the word of God he understood merely the Universe, his meaning must have been- that it cannot be permanently present in one place- that is, at rest- nor be capable of changing its place- that is, of moving-because all places are in the universe, and the universe itself is, therefore, in no place.Again, if the universe contains in itself everything that exists, it cannot be similar or dissimilar to any other thing, because there is, in fact, no other thing with which it can be compared.If two opposite judgements presuppose a contingent impossible, or arbitrary condition, both- in spite of their opposition (which is, however, not properly or really a contradiction)- fall away; because the condition, which ensured the validity of both, has itself disappeared.

If we say: "Everybody has either a good or a bad smell," we have omitted a third possible judgement- it has no smell at all; and thus both conflicting statements may be false.If we say: "It is either good-smelling or not good-smelling (vel suaveolens vel non-suaveolens)," both judgements are contradictorily opposed; and the contradictory opposite of the former judgement- some bodies are not good-smelling- embraces also those bodies which have no smell at all.In the preceding pair of opposed judgements (per disparata), the contingent condition of the conception of body (smell) attached to both conflicting statements, instead of having been omitted in the latter, which is consequently not the contradictory opposite of the former.

同类推荐
  • 佛说十二游经

    佛说十二游经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 近词丛话

    近词丛话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 齐东野语

    齐东野语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 胜鬘经记

    胜鬘经记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编交谊典僚属部

    明伦汇编交谊典僚属部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • The Midwich Cuckoos

    The Midwich Cuckoos

    John Wyndham's 1957 book The Midwich Cuckoos is better known by the more sensational title of its two film adaptations, Village of the Damned. The story begins with Richard and Janet Gayford who have spent the night of September 26 in London, returning to their home in Midwich the following day. Then, in ways that are difficult to pin down, the village seems changed--not quite the same place that it was before. The nightmare that descends on Midwich has dire implications for the rest of the world; whatever dwells there is sowing the seeds for a master race of ruthless and inhumane creatures who are bent on nothing less than absolute and total domination.
  • 大秦游戏攻略

    大秦游戏攻略

    亲爱的玩家,欢迎来到《大秦》您可以根据自身资产状况自由选择想要加入的阵营。千古一帝,名臣良将,至圣先师,蛮族之王,十凶九瑞【系统禁选】可选阵营:一级势力:【要求一万积分】百家弟子大秦兵卒二级势力:【要求一百积分】六国叛逆北地蛮兵域外国度三级势力:【要求一积分】域外凶兽海上人族四级势力:【无积分要求】随机流民注意:一积分兑换十万软妹币。······秦舞阳瞟了一眼账户余额,叹了口气,躺在床板上点了一支烟。氪金还是氪命,这是一个问题。【作者小扑街,考据党,合理党轻点儿喷,手动感谢。】
  • 恶夫恰妻

    恶夫恰妻

    第一部恶夫恰妻(已完结)指腹为婚?亏老妈想得出来现在都什么年代了还奉行这个对方是黑道额你不是把你女儿往火坑里推吗抗议无效?老妈你也太专制了吧就算我老被人炒鱿鱼也用不着用这招来激励我上进吧不是玩笑,立马登记而且对像还是那个没品男上次要不是他把我丢在马路上我会被人炒鱿鱼不行,我要逃婚这两个没良心的竟然惧于老妈的淫威把我拐骗到婚礼现场这笔帐我先记着你看看这一大票女的全是来找我理论的可见这个男人有多花心老妈,为了女儿的幸福咱们毁婚吧不行,要我好自为之我不要啦推荐好友懒忽忽文文:穿越旅行团http://m.wkkk.net/MMWeb/m.wkkk.net来到陌生的世界,开始新的探索旅程,她是史上最倒霉的反穿者。什么?组织团队穿回我的故乡......总结:时代的流行,反穿、穿越人士刷的一大票。-------------------------吼一声:有点雷推荐好友茶茶文文:叫你勾引我
  • 鬼妃夜行:相爷,小心撩

    鬼妃夜行:相爷,小心撩

    “今日,我要跟你恩断义绝!”她割袍断义,痛斩三千青丝。“你若断得了,算我输!”他高居上位,低眉俯瞰,众生若蝼蚁,她若浮萍。她说,诸葛夜行,你从来都没有爱过我。你爱的,只是跟我一样的另外一张脸。可是,阿樱啊,我若不爱,为何要为你打下这锦绣河山,血染了大地,为你,我与众生为敌,不惜……叛国、弑帝、征战天下。这万丈河山纵然再好,若没了你,该多无趣……
  • 太古拳神

    太古拳神

    武者世界,强者为尊,弱者任人宰割,唯他耀阳拳神独霸天下,只喜欢四海为家,最后在渡劫神帝时却被自己的徒弟所暗杀。意外重生在一偏僻的皇极大陆......
  • 双鲤迢迢一纸书

    双鲤迢迢一纸书

    那年,她十四岁,他九岁,她成了他的小夫子。他百般刁难、千般恶语,恨不得小夫子知难而退。偏偏,越是相处,越是心惊,不知不觉喜欢上不该喜欢的你……十六岁那年,他冲破世俗的伦理,痛痛快快地将小夫子吃干抹净。“夫子,这世上惟你知我,可为何你却如此无情?”女师男徒,超脱世俗,演绎一场惊心动魄的旷世绝恋……
  • 妖星传

    妖星传

    林云要封印之术,已经渐行渐远,走向那个冰天雪地世界,心也是随着脚步越来越凉。原本同源两片大陆之间.......
  • 卑鄙的圣人:曹操8

    卑鄙的圣人:曹操8

    历史上的大奸大忠都差不多,只有曹操大不同!曹操的计谋,奸诈程度往往将对手整得头昏脑涨、找不着北,卑鄙程度也屡屡突破道德底线,但他却是一个心怀天下、体恤众生的圣人;而且他还是一个柔情万丈、天才横溢的诗人;最后他还是一个敏感、自卑、内心孤独的普通男人。
  • 染白的英雄生涯

    染白的英雄生涯

    本书别名【某英雄科的替身使者】 我的名字叫染白,不知一天我的脑中竟然多出个替身百科全书,替身百科全书可以让我拥有JOJO中的全部替身,更没想到的是我可以像完美生物一样自己创建替身,发达了,我这样想到。从此「三寸金莲」可以让我像蚁人一样随意变小,「黄金体验」可以让我像@@@一样创建生命,绯红之王可以让我随意消除时间,杀手皇后可以让我随意炸死人……
  • 我不懂放弃

    我不懂放弃

    娱乐圈绯闻很正常,但是李旻祎的粉丝一直坚信:我家偶像是绝对不会有绯闻的,他怕大嫂不要他。李旻祎自十六岁就一直在惦记一件事:该怎么把隔壁的季向阳变成我媳妇儿啊,为了达成这个目标,他开始了长达十年的大灰狼吃兔计划