登陆注册
5419400000149

第149章

If, accordingly, we say: "The world is either infinite in extension, or it is not infinite (non est infinitus)"; and if the former proposition is false, its contradictory opposite- the world is not infinite- must be true.And thus I should deny the existence of an infinite, without, however affirming the existence of a finite world.But if we construct our proposition thus: "The world is either infinite or finite (non-infinite)," both statements may be false.For, in this case, we consider the world as per se determined in regard to quantity, and while, in the one judgement, we deny its infinite and consequently, perhaps, its independent existence; in the other, we append to the world, regarded as a thing in itself, a certain determination- that of finitude; and the latter may be false as well as the former, if the world is not given as a thing in itself, and thus neither as finite nor as infinite in quantity.This kind of opposition I may be allowed to term dialectical; that of contradictories may be called analytical opposition.Thus then, of two dialectically opposed judgements both may be false, from the fact, that the one is not a mere contradictory of the other, but actually enounces more than is requisite for a full and complete contradiction.

When we regard the two propositions- "The world is infinite in quantity," and, "The world is finite in quantity," as contradictory opposites, we are assuming that the world- the complete series of phenomena- is a thing in itself.For it remains as a permanent quantity, whether I deny the infinite or the finite regress in the series of its phenomena.But if we dismiss this assumption- this transcendental illusion- and deny that it is a thing in itself, the contradictory opposition is metamorphosed into a merely dialectical one; and the world, as not existing in itself- independently of the regressive series of my representations- exists in like manner neither as a whole which is infinite nor as a whole which is finite in itself.

The universe exists for me only in the empirical regress of the series of phenomena and not per se.If, then, it is always conditioned, it is never completely or as a whole; and it is, therefore, not an unconditioned whole and does not exist as such, either with an infinite, or with a finite quantity.

What we have here said of the first cosmological idea- that of the absolute totality of quantity in phenomena- applies also to the others.The series of conditions is discoverable only in the regressive synthesis itself, and not in the phenomenon considered as a thing in itself- given prior to all regress.Hence I am compelled to say: "The aggregate of parts in a given phenomenon is in itself neither finite nor infinite; and these parts are given only in the regressive synthesis of decomposition- a synthesis which is never given in absolute completeness, either as finite, or as infinite." The same is the case with the series of subordinated causes, or of the conditioned up to the unconditioned and necessary existence, which can never be regarded as in itself, ind in its totality, either as finite or as infinite; because, as a series of subordinate representations, it subsists only in the dynamical regress and cannot be regarded as existing previously to this regress, or as a self-subsistent series of things.

Thus the antinomy of pure reason in its cosmological ideas disappears.For the above demonstration has established the fact that it is merely the product of a dialectical and illusory opposition, which arises from the application of the idea of absolute totality- admissible only as a condition of things in themselves- to phenomena, which exist only in our representations, and- when constituting a series- in a successive regress.This antinomy of reason may, however, be really profitable to our speculative interests, not in the way of contributing any dogmatical addition, but as presenting to us another material support in our critical investigations.For it furnishes us with an indirect proof of the transcendental ideality of phenomena, if our minds were not completely satisfied with the direct proof set forth in the Trancendental Aesthetic.The proof would proceed in the following dilemma.If the world is a whole existing in itself, it must be either finite or infinite.But it is neither finite nor infinite- as has been shown, on the one side, by the thesis, on the other, by the antithesis.Therefore the world- the content of all phenomena- is not a whole existing in itself.It follows that phenomena are nothing, apart from our representations.And this is what we mean by transcendental ideality.

This remark is of some importance.It enables us to see that the proofs of the fourfold antinomy are not mere sophistries- are not fallacious, but grounded on the nature of reason, and valid- under the supposition that phenomena are things in themselves.The opposition of the judgements which follow makes it evident that a fallacy lay in the initial supposition, and thus helps us to discover the true constitution of objects of sense.This transcendental dialectic does not favour scepticism, although it presents us with a triumphant demonstration of the advantages of the sceptical method, the great utility of which is apparent in the antinomy, where the arguments of reason were allowed to confront each other in undiminished force.

And although the result of these conflicts of reason is not what we expected- although we have obtained no positive dogmatical addition to metaphysical science- we have still reaped a great advantage in the correction of our judgements on these subjects of thought.

SECTION VIII.Regulative Principle of Pure Reason in relation to the Cosmological Ideas.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 候补情人

    候补情人

    绚丽的舞台,耀眼的镁光灯,一个纤细优美的身影在瞬间夺去了所有人的眼球,随即变伴随着泻流出的音乐翩翩起舞,她的动作就像一只居住在森林里的精灵一般,充满灵动。席下没有半点声响,就怕有一点声音,那只翩翩飞舞的精灵就会飞走。观赏的人只能安静的欣赏这充满幻想的舞蹈,谁也无法破坏这种氛围,因为它让人如同置身在舞者的生命里,随着她的每一个动作去思考,去联想。舞者的舞蹈有着自己的灵魂,充满了生机和活力,令人……
  • 快穿女主之男神难逃

    快穿女主之男神难逃

    总有女主不要光环,女配借机上位。系统:叮!路人女主逆袭系列任务正式开始。再三出现的梦境,似曾相识的男人,被封印的记忆,重重谜团,还有一个比自己还有心机的男主——顾泠一次次感受到被超世界线支配的恐惧。系统:宿主想太多,我也很绝望。[本文甜宠1V1么么么]【隔壁新文《蜜宠100婚:吻住,总裁大人》正式开坑辣,欢迎串门!!希望小仙女们能够继续支持我呀(面条泪)】
  • 萌妃逆天:师父你要hold住

    萌妃逆天:师父你要hold住

    初见时,她是一只被小正太施了魔法的兔子,而他是帅的人神共愤的九尾狐王爷。无法修炼灵力的废物,被姐姐欺压,被亲爹追杀。一道磁性的嗓音拯救于她:“本尊收你为徒,今天起你就是本尊的人了。”朝夕相处,古灵精怪的她渐渐的掠夺了他清心寡欲的心。没想到他清冷的外表下,有着遗落万年的深情。(情节虚构,请勿模仿)
  • 带着无敌系统闯异界

    带着无敌系统闯异界

    天才?鬼才?大陆第一奇才?在无敌系统面前,一切天才都是渣渣!
  • 皇朝有女忒彪悍

    皇朝有女忒彪悍

    天煜皇朝,有一州十分特别,名唤:鹿州。此州阴盛阳衰极为严重,男人几乎绝种,所以女人们为了生存变得十分强悍。为了繁衍生息,她们只有偷偷捉周边的男人回去强行配种,被天下人嘲笑和不耻。而这群女人中的魁首,便是获封“骠骑大将军”头衔的——鹿缇莹。她武功高强,大义凛然,是一个在女人眼中帅气,在男人眼中独具魅力的奇女子!也正因为此,各种桃花朵朵开。上到皇帝,下到普通百姓,都为她的魅力所倾倒……她的身后几乎每天都有人在喊:“将军,求嫁!”“将军,求娶!”--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 古瓶山牧道者究心录

    古瓶山牧道者究心录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中国历代庙堂文化故事

    中国历代庙堂文化故事

    了解寺庙的历史,我们可从中领会到佛界的神秘传说;了解寺庙的文化内涵,我们可领略历代文人墨客的别样情怀。还有那关于寺庙的美丽传说,所有的爱恨情仇,最终在佛的宽容中得到升华。
  • 风之剑圣传

    风之剑圣传

    这是一个神奇的异世界,在这里魔力是所有人的追求,背负着世界命运的少年也不例外。当战争的怒吼降临这片大地时,当绝望亲临这片净土时,当万族等待被奴役或灭亡时,传说中的剑圣将会驱散阴霾,让秩序重归大地。
  • 上清黄庭五脏六府真人玉轴经

    上清黄庭五脏六府真人玉轴经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 雪坛(猫头鹰丛书)

    雪坛(猫头鹰丛书)

    民国的人物故事都很平淡,也因其平淡,显出小说氛围的哀痛和神秘,这种匹夫匹妇的卑微,并不是某些阴柔派的矫揉造作可比。