登陆注册
5419400000170

第170章

This argument continues, however, to possess a weight and an authority, which, in spite of its objective insufficiency, it has never been divested of.For, granting that certain responsibilities lie upon us, which, as based on the ideas of reason, deserve to be respected and submitted to, although they are incapable of a real or practical application to our nature, or, in other words, would be responsibilities without motives, except upon the supposition of a Supreme Being to give effect and influence to the practical laws: in such a case we should be bound to obey our conceptions, which, although objectively insufficient, do, according to the standard of reason, preponderate over and are superior to any claims that may be advanced from any other quarter.The equilibrium of doubt would in this case be destroyed by a practical addition; indeed, Reason would be compelled to condemn herself, if she refused to comply with the demands of the judgement, no superior to which we know- however defective her understanding of the grounds of these demands might be.

This argument, although in fact transcendental, inasmuch as it rests upon the intrinsic insufficiency of the contingent, is so simple and natural, that the commonest understanding can appreciate its value.We see things around us change, arise, and pass away; they, or their condition, must therefore have a cause.The same demand must again be made of the cause itself- as a datum of experience.Now it is natural that we should place the highest causality just where we place supreme causality, in that being, which contains the conditions of all possible effects, and the conception of which is so simple as that of an all-embracing reality.This highest cause, then, we regard as absolutely necessary, because we find it absolutely necessary to rise to it, and do not discover any reason for proceeding beyond it.

Thus, among all nations, through the darkest polytheism glimmer some faint sparks of monotheism, to which these idolaters have been led, not from reflection and profound thought, but by the study and natural progress of the common understanding.

There are only three modes of proving the existence of a Deity, on the grounds of speculative reason.

All the paths conducting to this end begin either from determinate experience and the peculiar constitution of the world of sense, and rise, according to the laws of causality, from it to the highest cause existing apart from the world- or from a purely indeterminate experience, that is, some empirical existence- or abstraction is made of all experience, and the existence of a supreme cause is concluded from a priori conceptions alone.The first is the physicotheological argument, the second the cosmological, the third the ontological.More there are not, and more there cannot be.

I shall show it is as unsuccessful on the one path- the empirical-as on the other- the transcendental- and that it stretches its wings in vain, to soar beyond the world of sense by the mere might of speculative thought.As regards the order in which we must discuss those arguments, it will be exactly the reverse of that in which reason, in the progress of its development, attains to them- the order in which they are placed above.For it will be made manifest to the reader that, although experience presents the occasion and the starting-point, it is the transcendental idea of reason which guides it in its pilgrimage and is the goal of all its struggles.I shall therefore begin with an examination of the transcendental argument, and afterwards inquire what additional strength has accrued to this mode of proof from the addition of the empirical element.

SECTION IV.Of the Impossibility of an Ontological Proof of the Existence of God.

It is evident from what has been said that the conception of an absolutely necessary being is a mere idea, the objective reality of which is far from being established by the mere fact that it is a need of reason.On the contrary, this idea serves merely to indicate a certain unattainable perfection, and rather limits the operations than, by the presentation of new objects, extends the sphere of the understanding.But a strange anomaly meets us at the very threshold;for the inference from a given existence in general to an absolutely necessary existence seems to be correct and unavoidable, while the conditions of the understanding refuse to aid us in forming any conception of such a being.

Philosophers have always talked of an absolutely necessary being, and have nevertheless declined to take the trouble of conceiving whether- and how- a being of this nature is even cogitable, not to mention that its existence is actually demonstrable.A verbal definition of the conception is certainly easy enough: it is something the non-existence of which is impossible.But does this definition throw any light upon the conditions which render it impossible to cogitate the non-existence of a thing- conditions which we wish to ascertain, that we may discover whether we think anything in the conception of such a being or not? For the mere fact that I throw away, by means of the word unconditioned, all the conditions which the understanding habitually requires in order to regard anything as necessary, is very far from making clear whether by means of the conception of the unconditionally necessary I think of something, or really of nothing at all.

Nay, more, this chance-conception, now become so current, many have endeavoured to explain by examples which seemed to render any inquiries regarding its intelligibility quite needless.Every geometrical proposition- a triangle has three angles- it was said, is absolutely necessary; and thus people talked of an object which lay out of the sphere of our understanding as if it were perfectly plain what the conception of such a being meant.

同类推荐
  • 于公案

    于公案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 寄杨侍御

    寄杨侍御

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 天马山房遗稿

    天马山房遗稿

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 仰节堂集

    仰节堂集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Children of the Night

    The Children of the Night

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 一本书畅游世界顶级景点

    一本书畅游世界顶级景点

    在亚洲篇里,北京天安门、日本京都、韩国济州岛、度假天堂马尔代夫、世界第一庙宇吴哥窟、印度泰姬陵等等,领略东方的神秘;在欧洲篇里,大英博物馆、法国埃菲尔铁塔、巴黎圣母院、艺术家的殿堂卢浮宫、古老的艺术之城巴塞罗那,享受西方的繁华;在北美篇里,自由女神像、电影之城好莱坞、玛雅古迹、夏威夷以及郁金香之城渥太华等,相约北美的风情;在南美篇里,科隆大剧院、葡萄酒王国门多萨、云中之城马丘比丘……追寻冒险的畅快;在非洲篇里,太阳城、好望角、金字塔、肯尼亚树顶旅馆……体味原始美的淳朴;在大洋洲篇里,新西兰皇后镇、墨尔本、悉尼歌剧院、汤加宫……爱上精致的生态美。
  • 狐王的冒牌杀手妃

    狐王的冒牌杀手妃

    她是杀手,一朝穿越,却成为了某个妖精男的老婆!!这也太诡异了吧!不,不,不,她是不会让这个男狐妖得逞的。相府的傻子小姐?什么?她现在的身份!可笑,想她堂堂杀手,怎么可能又痴又傻。且看她如何玩转天下!
  • 权倾天下:夫君,要乖!

    权倾天下:夫君,要乖!

    她,是现代特工杀手,即将退出杀手组织,隐姓埋名,眼看着幸福生活就要来了,睡个觉,竟然睡到了婚房,看着红绸,杀手大人表示非常无语,非常心累。成亲便成亲吧,这个夫君俊朗若仙,却药不离身,以为是个善良的,谁知道心比墨水还黑,黑心黑肺。黑心黑肺就算了吧,他还会下毒,下毒就算了吧,偏偏这个毒,她还解不开。她表示疑问,要这个夫君干嘛。可是遇到她,是他心中仅有的温暖。他会宠她,但她只能是他的,他可以让她天下徜徉,但是她必须在他的怀抱…总之,这总体不虐,甜甜的~
  • 九星天辰诀

    九星天辰诀

    深埋地心的地底琼楼,沧海桑田演化的死冥湖,诡异神秘的幽冥宫,喂饲冥魂的禁域之地,帝国争霸,世家、宗门林立,人类、妖兽、玄兽,海妖、天魔、魑魅,无尽荒泽大地之上,蜗牛心中的玄幻传奇。
  • 卓有成效的管理者(总经理打理公司的200条成功经验)

    卓有成效的管理者(总经理打理公司的200条成功经验)

    困惑是一个优秀总经理的标志之一。思考困惑时,你已经表现出成为卓越管理者的潜质。德鲁克说:“任何知识会随着时间的变化而成为错误的知识。”如果你不想使自己陷入“错误知识”的陷阱。持有管理困惑是最好的方法之一。“世上的人本不认识路,很多人跟随着带头人一起走,也就走出了路。”这就是“跟随”的力量。跟随的实质是领悟。我们不需要看到这些优秀的企业及企业家。我们只需要领悟到这些企业家管理的实质和精髓。
  • 原善

    原善

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金鳞沉浮

    金鳞沉浮

    五大家族的尔虞我诈,骄傲的白家太子走出大山,来到了都市,开始了无敌的人生。“我要创造一个第六大家族。‘’白硕说道。金鳞岂是池中物,一遇风雨便化龙。恭迎太子白硕回归……
  • 魔皇的夫人会猎龙

    魔皇的夫人会猎龙

    【新文已发,骁爷的小祖宗又野了~多多支持~】她,是二十五世纪异能特工会顶级特工,自带异能,天生妖瞳!她的陨落则是另一番的崛起!“魔皇,您夫人被家族逼婚!”“杀。”“魔皇,您夫人正带着一批人马攻来魔域!”“把结界都撤了,别误伤到她。”“魔皇,您夫人想爬墙!”“……”魔皇睨了眼时笙,“看来本皇昨晚不够努力。”时笙脚下一软,乖乖坐好,揉着小蛮腰朝魔皇投去一抹幽怨的眼神!训龙猎龙调教龙,捕个魔皇当老公~
  • 孔雀海

    孔雀海

    那枚羽毛很轻,颜色是纯白,在手心里没有任何重量。沙木看着这枚羽毛,微微闭上眼睛,像是回忆起了某些不为人知的情绪。在县里仅有的邮局营业大厅里,清早的戈壁还有夜晚残余的清冷空气,沙木穿着一件旧夹克,他的表情在昏沉的大厅里显得黯淡。工作人员也许尚未睡醒,伸了个懒腰敲了敲玻璃窗,提醒这个高大阴郁的少年别再走神了。艾力达也适时地推了推沙木的肩膀,这个有着修长睫毛和热烈笑容的维族少年,用浓郁的地方口音说,嗯,沙木,你不说要寄东西吗?
  • 风暴和风暴的儿子

    风暴和风暴的儿子

    诗集精选诗人、导演王强诗歌作品近百首,涉及诗人熟悉的人和事、暴风骤雨般的社会变革、某一刻的日常生活以及激越的内心。在这些诗中,诗人常常是一个置身事外的观察者,这使得他的诗如同沉稳的镜头,客观、节制、准确,超越了自我辩解和安慰,进入更广阔真实的世界;而在向外注目观察的同时,它们更向内探寻、奔突,从日常中发展出戏剧性,从平凡中攫取意味深长的部分。诗人对巨大的魔力抱有热望,向往遥远、神秘、恐惧,乃至充满危险和被禁止之地,因此,不管多么微小和平常的事物都写得惊心动魄,让我们被他重新发现的世界所吸引,被他语言和情感的风暴击中,愿意跟着他,沉浸在那具有悲剧色彩的每一个细节的漩涡之中。