登陆注册
5419400000176

第176章

Many physical powers, which evidence their existence by their effects, are perfectly inscrutable in their nature; they elude all our powers of observation.The transcendental object which forms the basis of phenomena, and, in connection with it, the reason why our sensibility possesses this rather than that particular kind of conditions, are and must ever remain hidden from our mental vision;the fact is there, the reason of the fact we cannot see.But an ideal of pure reason cannot be termed mysterious or inscrutable, because the only credential of its reality is the need of it felt by reason, for the purpose of giving completeness to the world of synthetical unity.An ideal is not even given as a cogitable object, and therefore cannot be inscrutable; on the contrary, it must, as a mere idea, be based on the constitution of reason itself, and on this account must be capable of explanation and solution.For the very essence of reason consists in its ability to give an account, of all our conceptions, opinions, and assertions- upon objective, or, when they happen to be illusory and fallacious, upon subjective grounds.

Detection and Explanation of the Dialectical Illusion in all Transcendental Arguments for the Existence of a Necessary Being.

Both of the above arguments are transcendental; in other words, they do not proceed upon empirical principles.For, although the cosmological argument professed to lay a basis of experience for its edifice of reasoning, it did not ground its procedure upon the peculiar constitution of experience, but upon pure principles of reason- in relation to an existence given by empirical consciousness; utterly abandoning its guidance, however, for the purpose of supporting its assertions entirely upon pure conceptions.

Now what is the cause, in these transcendental arguments, of the dialectical, but natural, illusion, which connects the conceptions of necessity and supreme reality, and hypostatizes that which cannot be anything but an idea? What is the cause of this unavoidable step on the part of reason, of admitting that some one among all existing things must be necessary, while it falls back from the assertion of the existence of such a being as from an abyss? And how does reason proceed to explain this anomaly to itself, and from the wavering condition of a timid and reluctant approbation- always again withdrawn- arrive at a calm and settled insight into its cause?

It is something very remarkable that, on the supposition that something exists, I cannot avoid the inference that something exists necessarily.Upon this perfectly natural- but not on that account reliable- inference does the cosmological argument rest.But, let me form any conception whatever of a thing, I find that I cannot cogitate the existence of the thing as absolutely necessary, and that nothing prevents me- be the thing or being what it may- from cogitating its non-existence.I may thus be obliged to admit that all existing things have a necessary basis, while I cannot cogitate any single or individual thing as necessary.In other words, I can never complete the regress through the conditions of existence, without admitting the existence of a necessary being; but, on the other hand, I cannot make a commencement from this being.

If I must cogitate something as existing necessarily as the basis of existing things, and yet am not permitted to cogitate any individual thing as in itself necessary, the inevitable inference is that necessity and contingency are not properties of things themselves-otherwise an internal contradiction would result; that consequently neither of these principles are objective, but merely subjective principles of reason- the one requiring us to seek for a necessary ground for everything that exists, that is, to be satisfied with no other explanation than that which is complete a priori, the other forbidding us ever to hope for the attainment of this completeness, that is, to regard no member of the empirical world as unconditioned.In this mode of viewing them, both principles, in their purely heuristic and regulative character, and as concerning merely the formal interest of reason, are quite consistent with each other.

The one says: "You must philosophize upon nature," as if there existed a necessary primal basis of all existing things, solely for the purpose of introducing systematic unity into your knowledge, by pursuing an idea of this character- a foundation which is arbitrarily admitted to be ultimate; while the other warns you to consider no individual determination, concerning the existence of things, as such an ultimate foundation, that is, as absolutely necessary, but to keep the way always open for further progress in the deduction, and to treat every determination as determined by some other.But if all that we perceive must be regarded as conditionally necessary, it is impossible that anything which is empirically given should be absolutely necessary.

It follows from this that you must accept the absolutely necessary as out of and beyond the world, inasmuch as it is useful only as a principle of the highest possible unity in experience, and you cannot discover any such necessary existence in the would, the second rule requiring you to regard all empirical causes of unity as themselves deduced.

同类推荐
  • 伤寒明理论

    伤寒明理论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三命通会

    三命通会

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 十二门论疏

    十二门论疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 广大宝楼阁善住秘密陀罗尼经

    广大宝楼阁善住秘密陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 长乐六里志

    长乐六里志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 网游之重拾山河

    网游之重拾山河

    这儿是我最熟悉的土地,当我回来那天……男儿生当带吴钩,收取关山五十州。当然,电竞圈美女那么多,也是可以……,你们先比赛着,我去那边看看。
  • 只有青山不改

    只有青山不改

    本书是一部长篇历史小说。明清时期是我国封建制度渐趋衰落和统一的多民族国家巩固时期,在这个时期,社会风起云涌。本书以明清交替时期的重大历史事件为主线,通过对历史人物金声桓、王得仁、李成栋、马士英、朱大典等人的刻画描写,深刻地反映人性善恶的两面性和复杂性。
  • 全球追爱小萌妻

    全球追爱小萌妻

    一双能够控制心神的眼睛,却唯独控制不了她。乔西律怎么也没有想到,她会成为最特别的那一个。他宠她到天上,又毁她到地狱。终与他划清界限,却遭到疯狂堵截,企图让她重新回来。数次拒绝后,全球各大媒体被一条带着她照片的新闻占据:一女子强求要给乔西律生猴子,乔总勉为其难的答应。
  • 乱世鬼才:郭嘉

    乱世鬼才:郭嘉

    东汉末年谋士郭嘉,自幼父母双亡,少时与爷爷一起成长,得一同乡资助读书,成绩斐然。在帮助同乡解决家中闹鬼的过程中,结识一哑巴女子名为澜月,并收留她在身边。成年后虽隐居山林,但广结英豪,期待一展宏图之志。后投靠袁绍,呆了数十日,看清袁绍不是明主,愤而离开。之后过了六年隐居生活,期间娶了澜月为妻。建安元年,好友荀彧把郭嘉介绍给了曹操。郭嘉不拘礼节,有话直说的个性受到曹操的赞赏,而曹操做事务实,不拘一格的性格也深受郭嘉信服。随后,郭嘉帮助曹操先后征打败张绣、吕布,之后更是在官渡大败袁绍。在这个过程中,两人渐渐由君臣变成知己。最终,郭嘉帮助曹操一统北方,却在征乌桓回军途中身染重疾去世,曹操痛心不已。
  • 血枪击水

    血枪击水

    神枪现世天下荡,魍魉魑魅杀伐狂。少年百折雪止殇,仇消乱清万古王。
  • 古老的密码下(破解人类文明与科学之谜)

    古老的密码下(破解人类文明与科学之谜)

    揭示人类文明之谜,需要科学严肃的态度,需要建立在丰富的知识与缜密的思维的基础上。如果只是对科学一知半解就断然下结论,那将是幼稚可笑的。我们希望更多的人、尤其是广大的青少年读者,以严谨、求实的科学态度,对待种种神秘现象。只有这样,才能更接近真理,查清真伪,破解宇宙间未知现象的真实本质。
  • 中国历代通俗演义:后汉演义(下)

    中国历代通俗演义:后汉演义(下)

    为了写作的方便,作者把三国时期的历史并入到后汉的历史中叙述。本书讲述从“第五十一回 受一钱廉吏迁官 劾群阉直臣伏阙”到“第一百回 失蜀土汉宗绝祀 篡魏祚晋室开基”的历史。桓帝以后,外戚、宦官更迭擅权。变端百出,初为乱党交讧时代,继为方镇纷争时代,终为三国角逐时代:曹操、袁绍、袁术、齐备、孙权等群雄争霸……
  • 元始说度酆都经

    元始说度酆都经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 不可不知的中外历史(奇妙的大千世界)

    不可不知的中外历史(奇妙的大千世界)

    《奇妙的大千世界:不可不知的中外历史》编写时力求详尽,资料确凿,还历史真实、鲜活之感,这是一本值得深读的好历史书。《奇妙的大千世界:不可不知的中外历史》共分远古、上古、中世纪、近代、现代五部分,时间跨度从原始社会到第二次世界大战结束。受篇幅限制,二战以后的内容《奇妙的大千世界:不可不知的中外历史》没有选取。本书内容丰富,涉及面广,有人物,有事件,有东方历史,也有西方历史,可以说是一本历史百科全书,对普及历史知识极有裨益。
  • 专属校草养成计划

    专属校草养成计划

    刚入学校的许念,开学的前一天就入院了,而且还是被一个全校公认的帅哥用篮球砸了脑袋。这开学的第一天就这么丧,满心期待的心情瞬间就被浇灭了……