登陆注册
5419400000212

第212章

The strife of dialectic is a necessity of reason, and we cannot but wish that it had been conducted long ere this with that perfect freedom which ought to be its essential condition.In this case, we should have had at an earlier period a matured and profound criticism, which must have put an end to all dialectical disputes, by exposing the illusions and prejudices in which they originated.

There is in human nature an unworthy propensity- a propensity which, like everything that springs from nature, must in its final purpose be conducive to the good of humanity- to conceal our real sentiments, and to give expression only to certain received opinions, which are regarded as at once safe and promotive of the common good.It is true, this tendency, not only to conceal our real sentiments, but to profess those which may gain us favour in the eyes of society, has not only civilized, but, in a certain measure, moralized us; as no one can break through the outward covering of respectability, honour, and morality, and thus the seemingly-good examples which we which we see around us form an excellent school for moral improvement, so long as our belief in their genuineness remains unshaken.But this disposition to represent ourselves as better than we are, and to utter opinions which are not our own, can be nothing more than a kind of provisionary arrangement of nature to lead us from the rudeness of an uncivilized state, and to teach us how to assume at least the appearance and manner of the good we see.But when true principles have been developed, and have obtained a sure foundation in our habit of thought, this conventionalism must be attacked with earnest vigour, otherwise it corrupts the heart, and checks the growth of good dispositions with the mischievous weed of air appearances.

I am sorry to remark the same tendency to misrepresentation and hypocrisy in the sphere of speculative discussion, where there is less temptation to restrain the free expression of thought.For what can be more prejudicial to the interests of intelligence than to falsify our real sentiments, to conceal the doubts which we feel in regard to our statements, or to maintain the validity of grounds of proof which we well know to be insufficient? So long as mere personal vanity is the source of these unworthy artifices- and this is generally the case in speculative discussions, which are mostly destitute of practical interest, and are incapable of complete demonstration- the vanity of the opposite party exaggerates as much on the other side;and thus the result is the same, although it is not brought about so soon as if the dispute had been conducted in a sincere and upright spirit.But where the mass entertains the notion that the aim of certain subtle speculators is nothing less than to shake the very foundations of public welfare and morality- it seems not only prudent, but even praise worthy, to maintain the good cause by illusory arguments, rather than to give to our supposed opponents the advantage of lowering our declarations to the moderate tone of a merely practical conviction, and of compelling us to confess our inability to attain to apodeictic certainty in speculative subjects.But we ought to reflect that there is nothing, in the world more fatal to the maintenance of a good cause than deceit, misrepresentation, and falsehood.That the strictest laws of honesty should be observed in the discussion of a purely speculative subject is the least requirement that can be made.If we could reckon with security even upon so little, the conflict of speculative reason regarding the important questions of God, immortality, and freedom, would have been either decided long ago, or would very soon be brought to a conclusion.But, in general, the uprightness of the defence stands in an inverse ratio to the goodness of the cause; and perhaps more honesty and fairness are shown by those who deny than by those who uphold these doctrines.

I shall persuade myself, then, that I have readers who do not wish to see a righteous cause defended by unfair arguments.Such will now recognize the fact that, according to the principles of this Critique, if we consider not what is, but what ought to be the case, there can be really no polemic of pure reason.For how can two persons dispute about a thing, the reality of which neither can present in actual or even in possible experience? Each adopts the plan of meditating on his idea for the purpose of drawing from the idea, if he can, what is more than the idea, that is, the reality of the object which it indicates.How shall they settle the dispute, since neither is able to make his assertions directly comprehensible and certain, but must restrict himself to attacking and confuting those of his opponent? All statements enounced by pure reason transcend the conditions of possible experience, beyond the sphere of which we can discover no criterion of truth, while they are at the same time framed in accordance with the laws of the understanding, which are applicable only to experience; and thus it is the fate of all such speculative discussions that while the one party attacks the weaker side of his opponent, he infallibly lays open his own weaknesses.

The critique of pure reason may be regarded as the highest tribunal for all speculative disputes; for it is not involved in these disputes, which have an immediate relation to certain objects and not to the laws of the mind, but is instituted for the purpose of determining the rights and limits of reason.

同类推荐
  • 台湾郑氏纪事

    台湾郑氏纪事

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • A Dark Night's Work

    A Dark Night's Work

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 性恶

    性恶

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 漳州府志选录

    漳州府志选录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 十住毗婆沙论卷第

    十住毗婆沙论卷第

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 斩红妆

    斩红妆

    前世,顾笙满腔深情,一生戎马为他争得功与名,最后却落得满门惨死的下场……重活一世,她携血海深仇而来,誓要搅乱这京城的棋盘,逆了这命定的乾坤!觉得我顾家功高震主?那便如了你的愿,覆了这腐朽王朝!怕我民心所向?那便让你看看,什么才是民心所向!她本以为复仇之路注定孤苦,却意外得他一路相伴……他的身份成谜,她亦同样满身秘密。她本不愿靠近,命运却一次次的将她推到他的身边。“南瑾黎,你为何一次又一次的帮我?”“付出,自然是为了求得回报。”“如何相报?”“不如,以身相许可好?”遇见他,是她今生最大的幸运。
  • 超越生命的选择:思想者随笔(萨特卷)

    超越生命的选择:思想者随笔(萨特卷)

    本书是萨特哲学及生活的通俗汇编,全书内容是从萨特大量的哲学著作、戏剧、散文、随笔、传记的精选摘录而成的,并将存在主义哲学的精髓贯注其中,重点突出萨特的人道主义情怀及高昂的人生态度:对抗任何可能压制我们生命本身的外部力量,实现我们自由的选择并承担。本书在保留原作思想深刻的同时,力求行文浅显易懂,与读者的现实人生紧密联系。
  • 环

    车子驶出白城地界时突然变了天,晴朗的天色被乌云扑灭,前一秒还在天空翱翔的秃鹫刺入一片灰黑中不见了踪影。轿车大约是受了坏天气的影响,竟也跟着发脾气,排气管往外吐出最后两口浊气,车身往前一冲,彻底停下。李震砸了下方向盘,用力转动钥匙,引擎哽咽着,完全死了火,怎么也打不起来。“他妈的。”李震骂了句粗话,抓起打火机给自己点了根烟,这么干坐着幽幽抽了半根烟,他才下车打开引擎盖研究死火的原因,可惜他对修车这回事一点研究都没有,看了半天都看不出个所以然来,还弄得自己满手油污。
  • 阴符经玄解正义

    阴符经玄解正义

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 我,npc,打钱

    我,npc,打钱

    我表面是个npc,其实我是真人玩家因为重生成了游戏里的npc家里欠电费停电,我被困游戏里出不来现在急需198元交电费我这个npc角色里有一堆极品装备技能道具任务只要你打钱给我交上电费待我出来,定让你一刀满级,屠龙神器随便拿
  • 天道巫神

    天道巫神

    数千年前注定的劫难,一个无法改变的命运,人类终将面对。发掘传说背后的真相,在巫力与术法的世界,顺天还是逆转?-----------------------------现实与神话交融,巫术与探险结合,精心创作,足量存稿,确保完本。每日早9点、晚9点定时更新。书友群:725466103新书《矿海》,敬请关注。
  • 总裁的幸运妻

    总裁的幸运妻

    飞蛾扑火是本能,也是宿命。只为那片刻的心动,他第一次主动向女人抛出诱惑的的鱼饵。两个月后,她被查出怀孕五周,孩子留还是流?在进手术室的那一刻,他如天神般降临。“不如我们奉子成婚?”“你不喜欢孩子。”“你喜欢就行了。”“……”她带上孩子签订协议成了花太太,一年半后,低调离婚。他违背协议力争孩子的抚养权,那日她败诉后,哭泣买醉,他食髓知味的化身为狼!“别哭,女儿归我养,我再给你孩子一个就是!”
  • 366个爱情故事

    366个爱情故事

    每个人每天就要遇见几百个人,多少人你可以记住,一年三百六十五天,每天都喜欢着你,你什么时候喜欢我啊?
  • 农门天师:元气少女来种田

    农门天师:元气少女来种田

    【新书《农门痞妃:耕田,种包子》开始了!】一次任务失败,元气少女穿越成农家长姐季青燕,爹娘双故,无奈带着小弟妹种田、卖干货谋生,靠山吃山、靠水吃水,慢慢攒下积蓄买田地。又有邻家小哥哥来帮忙,一起合伙开作坊、跑生意,闲来帮小哥哥斗斗后娘渣爹、极品亲戚。她有天师技能、随身宝袋,还怕谁来?“娘子,新房建好,咱把事儿办了吧。”小哥哥变夫君,两家不如一家亲。======================燕七的完结种田经商文《农门金凤:冷面夫君童养媳》,欢迎来看哦~
  • 会穿越的国王

    会穿越的国王

    成为了平行地球最不发达国家的国王之后,如何依靠穿越系统崛起?武侠电影世界里学功夫、科幻电影世界里学技术、神话电影世界里……人工智能哪家强?是《复联》中的奥创,还是《终结者》中的天网?或者是变形金刚?无限宝石和神仙法器相比,哪个更厉害?电影中得到的东西,又会如何在现实世界利用?本书最大毒点……主角叫李大牛!……新书《超凡世界的神级偶像》已经上架,主角名字很正常,望各位老板继续支持。