登陆注册
5419400000211

第211章

Everything in nature is good for some purpose.Even poisons are serviceable; they destroy the evil effects of other poisons generated in our system, and must always find a place in every complete pharmacopoeia.The objections raised against the fallacies and sophistries of speculative reason, are objections given by the nature of this reason itself, and must therefore have a destination and purpose which can only be for the good of humanity.For what purpose has Providence raised many objects, in which we have the deepest interest, so far above us, that we vainly try to cognize them with certainty, and our powers of mental vision are rather excited than satisfied by the glimpses we may chance to seize? It is very doubtful whether it is for our benefit to advance bold affirmations regarding subjects involved in such obscurity; perhaps it would even be detrimental to our best interests.But it is undoubtedly always beneficial to leave the investigating, as well as the critical reason, in perfect freedom, and permit it to take charge of its own interests, which are advanced as much by its limitation, as by its extension of its views, and which always suffer by the interference of foreign powers forcing it, against its natural tendencies, to bend to certain preconceived designs.

Allow your opponent to say what he thinks reasonable, and combat him only with the weapons of reason.Have no anxiety for the practical interests of humanity- these are never imperilled in a purely speculative dispute.Such a dispute serves merely to disclose the antinomy of reason, which, as it has its source in the nature of reason, ought to be thoroughly investigated.Reason is benefited by the examination of a subject on both sides, and its judgements are corrected by being limited.It is not the matter that may give occasion to dispute, but the manner.For it is perfectly permissible to employ, in the presence of reason, the language of a firmly rooted faith, even after we have been obliged to renounce all pretensions to knowledge.

If we were to ask the dispassionate David Hume- a philosopher endowed, in a degree that few are, with a well-balanced judgement:

What motive induced you to spend so much labour and thought in undermining the consoling and beneficial persuasion that reason is capable of assuring us of the existence, and presenting us with a determinate conception of a Supreme Being?- his answer would be:

Nothing but the desire of teaching reason to know its own powers better, and, at the same time, a dislike of the procedure by which that faculty was compelled to support foregone conclusions, and prevented from confessing the internal weaknesses which it cannot but feel when it enters upon a rigid self-examination.If, on the other hand, we were to ask Priestley- a philosopher who had no taste for transcendental speculation, but was entirely devoted to the principles of empiricism- what his motives were for overturning those two main pillars of religion- the doctrines of the freedom of the will and the immortality of the soul (in his view the hope of a future life is but the expectation of the miracle of resurrection)-this philosopher, himself a zealous and pious teacher of religion, could give no other answer than this: I acted in the interest of reason, which always suffers, when certain objects are explained and judged by a reference to other supposed laws than those of material nature- the only laws which we know in a determinate manner.It would be unfair to decry the latter philosopher, who endeavoured to harmonize his paradoxical opinions with the interests of religion, and to undervalue an honest and reflecting man, because he finds himself at a loss the moment he has left the field of natural science.The same grace must be accorded to Hume, a man not less well-disposed, and quite as blameless in his moral character, and who pushed his abstract speculations to an extreme length, because, as he rightly believed, the object of them lies entirely beyond the bounds of natural science, and within the sphere of pure ideas.

What is to be done to provide against the danger which seems in the present case to menace the best interests of humanity? The course to be pursued in reference to this subject is a perfectly plain and natural one.Let each thinker pursue his own path; if he shows talent, if be gives evidence of profound thought, in one word, if he shows that he possesses the power of reasoning- reason is always the gainer.If you have recourse to other means, if you attempt to coerce reason, if you raise the cry of treason to humanity, if you excite the feelings of the crowd, which can neither understand nor sympathize with such subtle speculations- you will only make yourselves ridiculous.For the question does not concern the advantage or disadvantage which we are expected to reap from such inquiries; the question is merely how far reason can advance in the field of speculation, apart from all kinds of interest, and whether we may depend upon the exertions of speculative reason, or must renounce all reliance on it.Instead of joining the combatants, it is your part to be a tranquil spectator of the struggle- a laborious struggle for the parties engaged, but attended, in its progress as well as in its result, with the most advantageous consequences for the interests of thought and knowledge.It is absurd to expect to be enlightened by Reason, and at the same time to prescribe to her what side of the question she must adopt.Moreover, reason is sufficiently held in check by its own power, the limits imposed on it by its own nature are sufficient; it is unnecessary for you to place over it additional guards, as if its power were dangerous to the constitution of the intellectual state.In the dialectic of reason there is no victory gained which need in the least disturb your tranquility.

同类推荐
  • 胜天王般若波罗蜜经

    胜天王般若波罗蜜经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 布萨文等

    布萨文等

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 九歌

    九歌

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 续萨婆多毗尼毗婆沙

    续萨婆多毗尼毗婆沙

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 郭公案

    郭公案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 大唐权鉴:李氏王朝家国天下

    大唐权鉴:李氏王朝家国天下

    大唐王朝是让我们为之自豪的一座历史巅峰,大唐盛世的辉煌始终令我们向往。这个气势磅礴,前无古人,后无来者的帝国给后人留下了无数遐想与疑问。本书从家族角度出发,通过多种史料还原历史细节,以通俗的笔法对大唐王朝李氏家族进行重新解读。
  • 与爱情狭路相逢

    与爱情狭路相逢

    沈晏君不是很明白,她为什么总能遇到那个男人,对方像是故意为之,又像真的是不经意,不明白他到底有什么目的。严淮琛也不是很明白,那个女人为什么总是对他一副提防的模样,却又胆子很大,各种利用他,越是这样他就越是好奇。一个是性格冷静要强的女强人,一个是金融圈的大佬人物,原本毫无交集的人生,在命运的安排下,在爱情这条狭路上相逢,一较高下,谁输谁赢?
  • 佛说坚固女经

    佛说坚固女经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 积极心态引领成功(培养学生心灵成长的经典故事)

    积极心态引领成功(培养学生心灵成长的经典故事)

    在这套丛书里,我们针对青少年的心理特点,专门选择了一些特殊的故事,分别对他们在这一时期将会遭遇的情感问题、生活问题、学习问题、交友问题以及各种心理健康问题,从心理学的角度进行剖析和讲解,并提出了解决问题的方法和措施,以供同学们参考借鉴。
  • 归纳类比法训练(青少年提高逻辑思维能力训练集)

    归纳类比法训练(青少年提高逻辑思维能力训练集)

    当今时代是一个知识爆炸的时代,也是一个头脑竞争的时代;在竞争日益激烈的环境下,一个人想要很好地生存,不仅需要付出勤奋,而且还必须具有智慧。随着人才竞争的日趋激烈和高智能化,越来越多的人认识到只拥有知识是远远不够的。因为知识本身并不能告诉我们如何去运用知识,如何去解决问题,如何去创新,而这一切都要靠人的智慧,也就是大脑思维来解决。认真观察周围的人我们也会发现,那些在社会上有所成就的人无不是具有卓越思维能力的人。
  • 重阳盏

    重阳盏

    梨花千树雪带伤,一人白首孤月旁。阅尽凡间花模样,不如仙子略忧伤。《异帝王》一生戎马驰疆场,满身疾伤为谁,策马奔腾凯旋日,登高览望,万户烛光,风萧萧兮易水寒,君已成,汝在何方,当年城州郊外,为汝一诺痴狂,驰疆场,建勋功,帝业已成,汝在何方,本该佳丽三千!却做异帝王!
  • 致命女佣:腹黑冷少接招吧

    致命女佣:腹黑冷少接招吧

    这是个腹黑女与腹黑男相爱相杀相斗的故事。高崇阳,我这辈子跟你没完没了,下辈子也跟你势不两立!!白小蝶站在悬崖边上愤愤地喊。前世,她怀了花心大少高崇阳的孩子,却惨遭狗血抛弃!重生,她将一雪前耻,报复花心大少,也让他尝尝肝肠寸裂的痛苦!为了达到目的,她装清纯,装歹毒,装高贵,装魅惑,斗亲戚,斗前女友,斗男朋友,斗小三,好不容易达到目的,命运的洪流再次将她推上风口浪尖!红尘破,命已绝,痴女笑,在命运的纠葛中她该何去何从?
  • PRINCE OTTO

    PRINCE OTTO

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Hunting Sketches

    Hunting Sketches

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 耀武大帝

    耀武大帝

    七界大陆万族林立,皇天域七国称霸,大楚王朝九州动荡,江州十三氏各领风骚。曾经的万族之首,如今的没落吴家。少年吴耀,出生吴氏一族,奈何家族败落,屈辱一生。上天怜悯,重生五年之前。今世誓要攀那武道巅峰,斩奸除佞,重振吴氏之威,还我荣耀万丈,正我耀武大帝之名!