登陆注册
5429800000037

第37章 THE CROSS AND THE CRESCENT(4)

Can we help inquiring in what the strength of Islamism lay? I, at least, cannot. I cannot help feeling that I am bound to examine in what relation the creed of Omar and Amrou stands to the Alexandrian speculations of five hundred years, and how it had power to sweep those speculations utterly from the Eastern mind. It is a difficult problem;to me, as a Christian priest, a very awful problem. What more awful historic problem, than to see the lower creed destroying the higher? to see God, as it were, undoing his own work, and repenting Him that He had made man? Awful indeed: but I can honestly say, that it is one from the investigation of which I have learnt--I cannot yet tell how much:

and of this I am sure, that without that old Alexandrian philosophy, Ishould not have been able to do justice to Islam; without Islam I should not have been able to find in that Alexandrian philosophy, an ever-living and practical element.

I must, however, first entreat you to dismiss from your minds the vulgar notion that Mohammed was in anywise a bad man, or a conscious deceiver, pretending to work miracles, or to do things which he did not do. He sinned in one instance: but, as far as I can see, only in that one--Imean against what he must have known to be right. I allude to his relaxing in his own case those wise restrictions on polygamy which he had proclaimed. And yet, even in this case, the desire for a child may have been the true cause of his weakness. He did not see the whole truth, of course: but he was an infinitely better man than the men around: perhaps, all in all, one of the best men of his day. Many here may have read Mr. Carlyle's vindication of Mohammed in his Lectures on Hero Worship; to those who have not, I shall only say, that I entreat them to do so; and that I assure them, that though I differ in many things utterly from Mr. Carlyle's inferences and deductions in that lecture, yet that I am convinced, from my own acquaintance with the original facts and documents, that the picture there drawn of Mohammed is a true and a just description of a much-calumniated man.

Now, what was the strength of Islam? The common answer is, fanaticism and enthusiasm. To such answers I can only rejoin: Such terms must be defined before they are used, and we must be told what fanaticism and enthusiasm are. Till then I have no more e priori respect for a long word ending in -ism or -asm than I have for one ending in -ation or -ality. But while fanaticism and enthusiasm are being defined--a work more difficult than is commonly fancied--we will go on to consider another answer. We are told that the strength of Islam lay in the hope of their sensuous Paradise and fear of their sensuous Gehenna. If so, this is the first and last time in the world's history that the strength of any large body of people--perhaps of any single man--lay in such a hope. History gives us innumerable proofs that such merely selfish motives are the parents of slavish impotence, of pedantry and conceit, of pious frauds, often of the most devilish cruelty: but, as far as my reading extends, of nothing better. Moreover, the Christian Greeks had much the same hopes on those points as the Mussulmans; and similar causes should produce similar effects: but those hopes gave them no strength. Besides, according to the Mussulmans' own account, this was not their great inspiring idea; and it is absurd to consider the wild battle-cries of a few imaginative youths, about black-eyed and green-kerchiefed Houris calling to them from the skies, as representing the average feelings of a generation of sober and self-restraining men, who showed themselves actuated by far higher motives.

Another answer, and one very popular now, is that the Mussulmans were strong, because they believed what they said; and the Greeks weak, because they did not believe what they said. From this notion I shall appeal to another doctrine of the very same men who put it forth, and ask them, Can any man be strong by believing a lie? Have you not told us, nobly enough, that every lie is by its nature rotten, doomed to death, certain to prove its own impotence, and be shattered to atoms the moment you try to use it, to bring it into rude actual contact with fact, and Nature, and the eternal laws? Faith to be strong must be faith in something which is not one's self; faith in something eternal, something objective, something true, which would exist just as much though we and all the world disbelieved it. The strength of belief comes from that which is believed in; if you separate it from that, it becomes a mere self-opinion, a sensation of positiveness; and what sort of strength that will give, history will tell us in the tragedies of the Jews who opposed Titus, of the rabble who followed Walter the Penniless to the Crusades, of the Munster Anabaptists, and many another sad page of human folly. It may give the fury of idiots; not the deliberate might of valiant men. Let us pass this by, then; believing that faith can only give strength where it is faith in something true and right:

and go on to another answer almost as popular as the last.

同类推荐
  • 黄帝内经灵枢

    黄帝内经灵枢

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • PARADISE LOST

    PARADISE LOST

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 新编雷峰塔奇传

    新编雷峰塔奇传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说申日经

    佛说申日经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 阿毗达磨俱舍释论

    阿毗达磨俱舍释论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 民族学如何进步

    民族学如何进步

    2016年中国民族学学会高层论坛由中国民族学学会、宁夏大学、宁夏社会科学界联合会联合主办,由宁夏大学政法学院、阿拉伯学院承办。《民族学如何进步》汇集了2016年中国民族学学会高层论坛论文,围绕中国民族学理论与话语建构、民族学学科建设、民族学发展历程等主题展开论述,为中国特色的民族学人类学学派的建立建言献策。作者均为民族学、人类学界的著名专家,如杨圣敏、郝时远、王铭铭等。
  • 大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    大明玄教立成斋醮仪范

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 修西辑要

    修西辑要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 网游之高手寂寞

    网游之高手寂寞

    一段网游的传奇,几段爱情的故事!叶丰,一个失恋的孤儿,神奇的遭遇让他获得了难以想象的实力。为报师仇,灭杀强敌。难耐单人之力无法与一个国家相抗,正好一款游戏的问世让他看到了希望。白衣飘逸,坐下神骑冰雪神物,于敌国乱军之中横行无忌,创造一个神话!
  • 父母应该为孩子做的50件事

    父母应该为孩子做的50件事

    有愈来愈多的教育家都说:“父母不应该为孩子做太多的事情了,因为溺爱,会害了孩子。”可是我们为什么还要列举出“父母一定要为孩子做的50件事情呢”?答案很简单,就是因为不想溺爱孩子,所以有些事情才不得不做。我们不为孩子包办任何事情,但是我们要教给孩子自己处理事情的能力;我们不想主宰孩子的人生,但是要让孩子学会自己判断、自己选择;我们要给孩子智慧的头脑、美丽的心灵和健全的人格,难道这些事情父母不需要去做吗?
  • 抗命2

    抗命2

    随着八路军武工队到来,打鬼子、斗伪军、剿土匪……战斗了一场又一场,冀南大武村的村民们不再只是旁观,他们得过且过、为了保存宗族血脉而摇摆不定的态度渐渐有了变化。每个尚存一丝血性的大武村年轻人,都争先恐后地要加入武工队,不为别的,就为给这片土地留一口气:凡是侵我国土、辱我百姓的,都必须付出血的代价!在战友逐渐增多的情况下,武工队开始稳扎稳打,再加上莫天留等人偷学日语、巧设离间,种种奇袭战术更是让鬼子叫苦不迭。只是好景不长,一场封山大雪给了鬼子喘息之机,鬼子看破了天留的计谋,集结重兵,要与武工队决一死战!一时间,武工队为了掩护乡亲们撤退再次陷入绝地!
  • 辉煌60年

    辉煌60年

    2011年是新中国航空工业创建60周年。为弘扬“航空报国、强军富民”的集团宗旨和“敬业诚信、创新超越”的集团理念, 中国航空工业集团公司离退休人员管理局、中国航空报社、中航出版传媒有限责任公司联合举办了“辉煌60年”征文活动, 组织离退休老同志以著书立说的形式, 发掘航空工业的光荣历史。活动得到老同志积极响应, 收到来自集团总部及所属成员单位老同志撰写的征文320余篇。经过专家评审, 评选出一等奖、二等奖、三等奖、优秀奖共计100篇。
  • 宝贝生病妈妈治

    宝贝生病妈妈治

    宝贝身体不舒服了,我们第一时间想到的肯定是送医院治疗。其实,一些孩子常见的疾病,只要不是急症,有时妈妈完全可以在家里给孩子做治疗,效果不错,孩子也不受罪。都有哪些治疗方法可以在家中进行呢?有很多西药、中草药和其他天然制剂都可以不需要医生处方就在家庭治疗中使用,你知道怎么用吗?妈咪们快快仔细看过来吧。
  • 领导与口才知识(全集)

    领导与口才知识(全集)

    国口才训练大师戴尔·卡耐基说:“假如你的口才好,可以使人家喜欢你,可以结交好的朋友,可以开辟前程,使你获得满意。有许多人,因为他善于辞令,因此而擢升了职位,有许多人因此而获得荣誉,获得了厚利。你不要以为这是小节,你的一生,有一大半的影响,由于说话艺术。” 鉴于此,本书涵盖了领导口才的所有内容,分为下面几个部分:领导口才的魅力、领导口才与心理,领导口才与行为细节、领导口才与自我训练,领导口才与人际关系、领导口才与激励,还有领导在各种场合的说话艺术以及说话技巧。
  • 四库全书精编4

    四库全书精编4

    《四库全书》可以称为中华传统文化最丰富最完备的集成之作。中国文、史、哲、理、工、医,几乎所有的学科都能够从中找到它的源头和血脉,几乎所有关于中国的新兴学科都能从这里找到它生存发展的泥土和营养。