登陆注册
5434100000084

第84章

Then commenced a movement which, as Mr John Austin pointed out,exactly reproduced itself in English law. Proprietors, domini,began to prefer the simpler forms or speedier course of theInterdict to the lagging and intricate formalities of the RealAction, and for the purpose of availing themselves of thepossessory remedy fell back upon the possession which wassupposed to be involved in their proprietorship. The libertyconceded to persons who were not true Possessors, but Owners, tovindicate their rights by possessory remedies, though it may havebeen at first a boon, had ultimately the effect of seriouslydeteriorating both English and Roman jurisprudence. The Roman lawowes to it those subtleties on the subject of Possession whichhave done so much to discredit it, while English law, after theactions which it appropriated to the recovery of real propertyhad fallen into the most hopeless confusion, got rid at last ofthe whole tangled mass by a heroic remedy. No one can doubt thatthe virtual abolition of the English real actions which tookplace nearly thirty years since was a public benefit, but stillpersons sensitive to the harmonies of jurisprudence will lamentthat, instead of cleansing, improving, and simplifying the trueproprietary actions, we sacrificed them all to the possessoryaction of ejectment, thus basing our whole system of landrecovery upon a legal fiction.

Legal tribunals have also powerfully assisted to shape andmodify conceptions of proprietary right by means of thedistinction between Law and Equity, which always makes its firstappearance as a distinction between jurisdictions. Equitableproperty in England is simply property held under thejurisdiction of the Court of Chancery. At Rome, the Praetor'sEdict introduced its novel principles in the guise of a promisethat under certain circumstances a particular action or aparticular plea would be granted; and, accordingly, the propertyin bonis, or Equitable Property, of Roman law was propertyexclusively protected by remedies which had their source in theEdict. The mechanism by which equitable rights were saved frombeing overridden by the claims of the legal owner was somewhatdifferent in the two systems. With us their independence issecured by the Injunction of the Court of Chancery. Since howeverLaw and Equity, while not as yet consolidated, were administeredunder the Roman system by the same Court, nothing like theInjunction was required, and the Magistrate took the simplercourse of refusing to grant to the Civil Law Owner those actionsand pleas by which alone he could obtain the property thatbelonged in equity to another. But the practical operation ofboth systems was nearly the same. Both, by means of a distinctionin procedure, were able to preserve new forms of property in asort of provisional existence, until the time should come whenthey were recognised by the whole law. In this way, the RomanPraetor gave an immediate right of property to the person who hadacquired a Res Mancipi by mere delivery, without waiting for theripening of Usucapion. Similarly he in time recognised anownership in the Mortgagee who had at first been a mere "bailee"or depositary, and in the Emphyteuta, or tenant of land which wassubject to a fixed perpetual rent. Following a parallel line ofprogress, the English Court of Chancery created a specialproprietorship for the Mortgagor, for the Cestui que Trust, forthe Married Woman who had the advantage of a particular kind ofsettlement, and for the Purchaser who had not yet acquired acomplete legal ownership. All these are examples in which formsof proprietory right, distinctly new, were recognised andpreserved. But indirectly Property has been affected in athousand ways by equity both in England and at Rome. Intowhatever corner of jurisprudence its authors pushed the powerfulinstrument in their command, they were sure to meet, and touch,and more or less materially modify the law of property: When inthe preceding pages I have spoken of certain ancient legaldistinctions and expedients as having powerfully affected thehistory of ownership, I must be understood to mean that thegreatest part of their influence has arisen from the hints andsuggestions of improvement infused by them into the mentalatmosphere which was breathed by the fabricators of equitablesystems.

But to describe the influence of Equity on Ownership would beto write its history down to our own days. I have alluded to itprincipally because several esteemed contemporary writers havethought that in the Roman severance of Equitable from Legalproperty we have the clue to that difference in the conception ofOwnership, which apparently distinguishes the law of the middleages from the law of the Roman Empire. The leading characteristicof the feudal conception is its recognition of a doubleproprietorship, the superior ownership of the lord of the fiefco-existing with the inferior property or estate of the tenant.

同类推荐
  • 加句灵验佛顶尊胜陀罗尼记

    加句灵验佛顶尊胜陀罗尼记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 南海志

    南海志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • NOSTROMO

    NOSTROMO

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 兰盆献供仪

    兰盆献供仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上开明天地本真经

    太上开明天地本真经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 田宠医娇

    田宠医娇

    一朝穿越,叶红袖成了赤门村的一名小村姑,左手银针能救人,右手银针能虐渣,发家致富不在话下,弄得上门来提亲的人差点要为了她打架。这下,某腹黑汉子坐不住了,我早就相中的小媳妇怎么能让别人拐了,于是计计连环,撩得叶红袖心驰荡漾,心甘情愿为他生娃娃。(一对一,爽文,甜宠文,欢迎入坑)
  • 混沌九诀

    混沌九诀

    一部神诀,糅合宇宙中九种极致的属性能量,修成即可成神!
  • 畸零女人

    畸零女人

    在维多利亚时期的英国,女性比男性多出一百多万。这些“剩女”无法进入婚姻,为了自己的社会角色与道德处境努力抗争。此书以不同社会阶层的女性生活为代表,真实地描绘了维多利亚晚期的情景,反映了早期的女权运动。
  • 蜀山灵蛇

    蜀山灵蛇

    我家在醉仙崖,老妈是条美人蟒,邻居是独角神貅和芝仙芝马?这情况怎么感觉有点不对劲?
  • 苕溪渔隐词话

    苕溪渔隐词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太虚禁区

    太虚禁区

    其名韩信,手持葬剑,闯西荒、战神庭、斗星海。断万界生机。其名韩信,独掌荒枪,擒府君、杀殿王、封太虚。绝星海辉芒。化身为翼八百载,作古枪剑葬溪湖。
  • 前海剧说(中国艺术研究院学术文库)

    前海剧说(中国艺术研究院学术文库)

    《中国艺术研究学术文库》是系统总结我国艺术学理论前沿发展的大型出版项目,共200卷。文库的研究内容包括戏曲、音乐、美术、舞蹈、话剧、影视、摄影、建筑艺术、红学、艺术设计、非物质文化遗产和文学等,几乎涵盖了文化艺术的所有门类,学者们或以新的观念与方法,对各门类艺术史论作了新的揭示与概括,或着眼现实,从不同的角度表达了对当前文化艺术发展趋向的敏锐观察与深刻洞见;将学术性与资料性很好地结合,既有利于学术研究,也有利于文化传承和发展,极具学术意义和文化意义。**批首推47卷。
  • 抗不住的诱惑

    抗不住的诱惑

    陈吕俩家,世居在一个小山村里,两家的俊儿俏女皆长大成人。吕家老大吕世国进城后,却走上了不归路。王少秋与杨小白突然结婚,打乱了聂良如与吕世国的行动计划,他们只好抓紧做出逃准备。可他们很快就被发现了……纠缠不息的两户山村人家最终扯出了一场惊天大案。亲情、友情、爱情,梦想、追求、执着,权利、金钱、阴谋、诱惑、欲望……
  • 漫威之徽

    漫威之徽

    一枚小小的徽章,却让姜磊拥有改变世界的能力。是神的玩笑,还是另有隐情?
  • 搭讪宝典:快速赢得信任的黄金话术

    搭讪宝典:快速赢得信任的黄金话术

    搭讪,是指想跟人接近,或者为了应付尴尬局面而主动去跟陌生人讲话,其目的就是为了结识对方。简单地讲,搭讪技巧就是跟陌生人交流的话术。《搭讪宝典:快速赢得信任黄金话术》内容丰富全面,搭讪的各种情景、案例、场合、功用、本质分析、训练方法、进阶层次、必杀秘技等,全部收入,真正做到让您拥有一本,从此终身受益。