登陆注册
5451400000017

第17章

It results therefore from this analysis, that a complete sense of the merit of an action, or the feeling of perfect moral approbation, is really "a compounded sentiment," made up of two distinct sympathetic emotions, namely, of a direct sympathy with the sentiments of the agent, and an indirect sympathy with the gratitude of those who receive the benefit of his actions.

Take our sense of the good desert of a particular character in historyScipio, Timoleon, or Aristides. In imagination we become those very persons, and, by a direct sympathy with them, enter into their designs, and feel the same generous sentiments that they felt. But we also by an indirect sympathy feel the benefit of their great actions, and enter into the gratitude of those who experienced them. The sympathetic emotions of gratitude and love, which we thus feel when we bring home to our own breast the situation of those originally concerned, account for our whole sense of the merit of such actions, and for our desire of their meeting with a fitting recompence.

In the same way a complete sense of the demerit of an action is a compounded sentiment made up of two distinct emotions; of a direct antipathy to the sentiments of the agent, and an indirect sympathy with the resentment of the sufferer. We feel a direct antipathy to the detestable sentiments which actuated a Borgia or a Nero, while we sympathize indirectly with the resentment of those they afflicted. Our sense of the atrocity of their conduct, and our delight in hearing of its punishmentin short, our whole feeling of ill desert, and of the justice of inflicting evil on the person who is guilty of it, and of making him grieve in his turnarises from the sympathetic indignation which boils up in our breast whenever we thoroughly bring home to ourselves the case of the sufferer.

Nor is it any degradation of our sense of the demerit of actions to ascribe it to our sympathy with the resentment of another. Resentment is in every respect the counterpart of gratitude, and if our sense of merit arises from our sympathy with the one, our sense of demerit may well arise from our sympathy with the other. Resentment, too, as a principle of human nature, is only evil when it appears in excess as revenge; and as it is excessive a hundred times for once that it is moderate, we are apt to consider it altogether detestable, because in its ordinary manifestation it is so.

But it is not disapproved of when properly humbled, and entirely brought down to the level of the sympathetic indignation of the spectator. When we as bystanders entertain an animosity corresponding to that of the sufferer, when his resentment in no respect exceeds our own, when no word nor gesture escapes him that denotes an emotion more violent than we can share, and when he never aims at inflicting a punishment severer than that we should rejoice to see inflicted or would inflict ourselves, it is impossible that we should not entirely approve of his sentiments.

It appears then in Adam Smith's theory, that the element of morality in actions only really arises from reference to their tendency. The sentiment or affection of the heart from which all action results may in relation to its cause or motive be regarded as unsuitable or disproportionate, according as it exceeds or falls short of that mean point with which the general observer can sympathize. It may be thus approved or disapproved as proper or improper, but it is not applauded or condemned as moral or immoral.

An anger which is out of proportion to the cause of its provocation, a state of joy or sorrow out of keeping with their origin, a generosity or benevolence that seem excessive, are blamed not as immoral, but as out of harmony with the feelings of a spectator. So with reference to the bodily passions, it is the office of temperance to confine them within those limits "which grace, which propriety, which delicacy, and modesty require," (not within those which morality require). It is only when regard is paid to the effects which flow from different actions, that a stronger feeling appears, a feeling not merely of propriety or im- propriety, but of their merit or demerit, or in other words, of their moral worth or the contrary.

It is only actions of a beneficent tendency , which proceed from proper motives, that are thus meritorious, for such actions alone seem to deserve a reward, from the gratitude they command from a spectator through sympathy. And it is only actions of a hurtful tendency , which proceed from improper motives, that seem really wicked, for they alone seem to deserve a punishment, from the resentment they inspire a spectator with by sympathy.

Adam Smith illustrates his theory that the wrongfulness or demerit of actions depends on our sense of their deserving to be punished by the two virtues of beneficence and justice. The mere want of beneficence, the neglect to do the good expected of one, may give rise to feelings of dislike and dis- approbation, but as it does no real positive evil, it provokes no feeling of sympathetic resentment. Take a case of the blackest ingratitude, where a man fails to recompense his benefactor, when the latter stands in great need of his assistance. Every impartial spectator rejects all fellow-feeling with the selfishness of his motives, and he is the proper object of the highest disapprobation. Still since he does no positive hurt, but only neglects to do the good he might, he is the object of hatred, not of resentment, two passions which differ in this respect, that whilst the former is called forth by impropriety of sentiment and behaviour, the latter is only provoked by actions which tend to do real and positive hurt to some particular persons. Ingratitude therefore cannot be punished.

It is improper, and meets with the disapprobation of the spectator, but it is not wrong or immoral, in. the sense in which it would be, if it went a step further, and raised a feeling of resentment by actual hurtfulness of tendency against somebody.

同类推荐
  • 北江诗话

    北江诗话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 上清帝七书

    上清帝七书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 新竹县制度考

    新竹县制度考

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 无量寿佛赞注

    无量寿佛赞注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 内经博议

    内经博议

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 腹黑机长天才妻

    腹黑机长天才妻

    一次意外发病,使带着记忆的周晓语带回到自己小时候。既然老天也看不过她这个残次品存在于世,让她的人生重来一次,那如果再不好好过,岂不辜负了老天的一片好意。于是从读书开始,她就没有尝过第二名的滋味,并开创了跳级的先河。于是她成了第一个学校倒贴生活费上学的学生。于是她从小开始就计划着赚钱和规划自己的人生。可是她显然忘了,“计划远不如变划快”,一时的兴起,让她惹到了一个腹黑闷骚的少年。把她原先设定平淡幸福的生活打乱了……同学无缘无故的挑畔引来腹黑少年的恶意报复,接着她和他的绯闻就满天飞。总得来说,这就是一个男主极其腹黑又极为护短并从小就算计着女主的故事……花絮一:那天,下课时,张家新揉着眼睛对周晓语说:“晓语,我眼睛痛,帮我看看是不是有东西进眼睛里了?”周晓语觉得他语气真诚,就傻傻地帮他看了,对视的良久的结果就是绯闻满天飞。花絮二:那天,张家新从兜里拿出香葱和辣椒,只见他左手拿香葱,右手拿辣椒对周晓语说:“MM,以后就跟着哥哥我吃香喝辣吧!”周晓语喷笑中……花絮三:那天,周晓语从同学聚会上回来后就对张家新说:“我一个同学嫁了个瑞典人,听说还是海盗后裔,唯京海盗哦!”张家新看了眼自我陶醉的妻子,突然爆出一句,“再了不起他也是个开船的,要知道天可比海要宽广多了,我可是开飞机的,所以我比较了不起!”
  • 一个女人的双性恋

    一个女人的双性恋

    虽然同为女人,当我听完林丛的故事后,仍然无法控制那种来自内心深处的震撼。我得承认,这个世界是由**组成的大舞台,而在这个舞台上,不同的人为着不同的**在做着不同的表演,而这些表演的背后,又有多少的故事是愿为人知的呢?
  • 一叶倾城,天才太子妃

    一叶倾城,天才太子妃

    ◇◇她5个月时,他5岁,她是蓝家长女,他是黑市奴隶,她亲指他为她的贴身护卫。☆☆她是蓝青城,隶属情报组织,左手能探知人的过去,穿越重生,竟然变成了甫出生的婴儿,是耀世王朝四大家族之一蓝家的长女。推选太子妃的宴上,蓝青城凭5个月稚龄,在自诩神童太子的画上写下了一个‘烂’字,令她成为史上最小的太子妃。他是夜曦,是世人惧怕的黑暗一族少主。黑暗一族遭血洗,他流落至耀世王朝,阴差阳错被蓝青城所救,而蓝家,正是血洗黑暗一族的主谋之一。白天,他是蓝青城的体贴侍卫,对她百般呵护、千般宠爱。夜晚,他是暗夜下的冷酷修罗,图谋她珍视的一切!她说:“东宫守卫森严,在那里会很安全,待我成亲之日,就放你自由!”☆☆她十八岁的生辰之日,就是她与太子的大婚之时。然,大婚的前一天,蓝家突然遭遇灭门之祸。十八年的忠诚侍卫,摇身一变成为黑暗一族的少主。他居高临下的捏住她的下巴,邪气的嗓音吐在她脸上:“想救你的亲人,做我的女人,我可以考虑考虑!”水晶新浪微博名:雪色水晶-HX,欢迎来互粉调戏……↓↓↓↓下面有“加入书架”的字样,点击收藏本书,以后可以直接在红袖藏书架看到最新更新提示。
  • 竹马老公青梅妻

    竹马老公青梅妻

    为了打消首席大人这门不当户不对的纠缠,薛颖莹一路四处逃窜,却仍跑不出他的五指山,最后还被他给拐进了民政局,稀里糊涂地领了证。等她回过神来,立马发起农民起义的离婚大作战。然而,却被他的一句“要想离婚,先拿孩子来交换”。她都不稀罕他这人,凭啥给他生孩子啊!
  • 一线真金:电话行销话术

    一线真金:电话行销话术

    本书分为十五章,以电话行销的实际操作步骤为切入点,由浅入深地讲解了电话行销的具体操作方法、操作技巧以及提升行销能力的训练,并辅助有大量的经典行销案例。
  • 罗马史(诺贝尔文学奖文集)

    罗马史(诺贝尔文学奖文集)

    诺贝尔文学奖,以其人类理想主义的伟大精神,为世界文学提供了永恒的标准。其中所包含的诗、小说、散文、戏剧、哲学、史学等不同体裁。不同风格的杰作,流光溢彩,各具特色,全面展现了20世纪世界文学的总体各局。吉卜林、梅特林克、泰戈尔、法朗士、消伯纳、叶芝、纪德……一个个激动人心的名字;《尼尔斯骑鹅旅行记》、《青鸟》、《吉檀迦利》、《福尔赛世家》、《六个寻找作者的剧中人》、《伪币制造者》、《巴比特》……一部部辉煌灿烂的名著,洋洋大观,百川归海,全部汇聚于这套诺贝尔文学奖获奖者文集之中。
  • 影子先生在隔壁

    影子先生在隔壁

    初次来到华夏,佐忆就被一位怪阿姨给劫走了,家里还住着一位大冰块,一言不合就甩脸色,行行行,你是老大你说了算,后来大冰块一改前非,整天怼天怼地宠媳妇,一言不合就耍赖皮。#“厉程……”谁能告诉他,这货在干什么呢?“一一,怎么了?”“你在干什么?”“暖床呀,怎么,没看见吗?”“……”“一一~”“……”厉大少爷一脸郁闷,被媳妇嫌弃了,怎么破?“一一,你是不是不爱我了,你是不是有外遇了,嘤嘤嘤~”“……”说好的高冷呢?!这傻比谁呀!佐忆将自己埋入被中,躺尸。#欢迎入坑
  • 最强兼职教师

    最强兼职教师

    本来在五台山菩提寺生活得好好的,没事就下山打点猎解解馋,没想到二师兄一封求救信传来,师傅没动,反把林逍踢下了山……
  • 陆漫其修远兮

    陆漫其修远兮

    她是一个看起来佛系得与世无争但其实是个什么都想做到最好的处女座网络小说作家,偶然在网上认识了国民男神的他。“吴小姐,要不要考虑爆红的滋味。”“顾先生,我不是为了你的人气才和你在一起的。”她常常感叹自己是哪里来的幸运得到他的情深似海,但是又因为是个处女座,所以对生活有很多挑剔,然后就请各位一起来观看这两个人如何在相爱相杀中前行吧——
  • 卡耐基读书笔记

    卡耐基读书笔记

    卡耐基并非象牙塔中的知识分子,他真正活出了自己的理念,并以写作来表达自己的理念——他的著作所引起的热烈回响,对我们这些爱他,且深信“信、勇、爱”乃人类精神泉源的人来说,已是足够的明证。卡耐基源于常理的哲学影响和教育实践,从事实来看,已施惠于千百万人。本书收集并整理了卡耐基曾引用与珍爱的人类智慧的经典话语、词句和段落,结合卡耐基著作中的主题思想,我们从中可以看到他的读书和人生的历程,是与人类历史上那些传承千古、亘古不变的智慧的对话与交流过程,同时体会其著作来自人类精神的源泉与价值。