登陆注册
5451400000051

第51章

Plato, Aristotle, and the Stoics, only regarded, in their account of virtue, that part of it which consists in propriety of conduct. According to Plato, the soul was composed of three different facultiesreason, passion, and appetite; and that higher form of justice which constitutes perfect virtue was nothing more than that state of mind in which every faculty confined itself to its proper sphere, without encroaching upon that of any other, and performed its office with precisely that degree of strength which belonged to it. In other words, this justice, the last and greatest of the cardinal virtues, and that which comprehended all the others, meant that exact and perfect propriety of conduct, the nature of which has been already discussed. Nearly the same account of virtue was given by Aristotle, who defined it as the habit of moderation in accordance with right reason;by which he meant a right affection of mind towards particular objects, as in being neither too much nor too little affected by objects of fear.

And the Stoics so far coincided with Plato and Aristotle as to place perfect virtue, or rectitude of conduct, in a proper choice or rejection of different objects and circumstances according as they were by nature rendered more or less the objects of our desire or aversion. In this propriety of the mind towards external things consisted the life according to nature, or in other words, the virtuous conduct of life.

No less incomplete than systems which placed virtue in propriety alone were those systems which placed it in prudence, or in a prudential regard for mere personal welfare. Such were the systems of the Cyrenaics and Epicureans in ancient times, and of writers like Hobbes and Mandeville in modern times.

According to Epicurus, the goodness or badness of anything was ultimately referable to its tendency to produce bodily pleasure or pain. Thus power and riches were desirable as good things, from their tendency to procure pleasure, whilst the evil of the contrary conditions lay in their close connexion with pain. Honour and reputation were of value, because the esteem of others was of so much importance to procure us pleasure and to defend us from pain. And in the same way the several virtues were not desirable simply for themselves, but only by reason of their intimate connexion with our greatest well-being, ease of body and tranquillity of mind. Thus temperance was nothing but prudence with regard to pleasure, the sacrifice of a present enjoyment to obtain a greater one or to avoid a greater pain. Courage was nothing but prudence with regard to danger or labour, not good in itself, but only as repellent of some greater evil. And justice too was nothing but prudence with regard to our neighbours, a means calculated to procure their esteem, and to avoid the fear that would flow from their resentment.

Adam Smith's first reply to this theory is, that whatever may be the tendency of the several virtues or vices, the sentiments which they excite in others are the objects of a much more passionate desire or aversion than all their other con- sequences; that to be-amiable and the proper object of esteem is of more value to us than all the ease and security which love or esteem can procure us: and that to be odious, or the proper object of contempt, or indignation is more dreadful than all we can suffer in our body from hatred, contempt, or indignation; and that therefore our desire of the one character and our aversion to the other cannot arise from regard to the effects which either of them is likely to produce on the body.

Secondly, there is one aspect of nature from which the Epicurean system derives its plausibility. "By the wise contrivance of the Author of nature, virtue is upon all ordinary occasions, even with regard to this life, real wisdom, and the surest and readiest means of obtaining both safety and advantage." The success or failure of our undertakings must very much depend on the good or bad opinion entertained of us, and on the general disposition of others to assist or oppose us. Hence the tendency of virtue to promote our interest and of vice to obstruct it, undoubtedly stamps an additional beauty and propriety upon the one, and a fresh deformity and im propriety upon the other. And thus temperance, magnanimity, justice and beneficence, come to be approved of, not only under their proper characters, but under the additional character of the most real prudence and the highest wisdom;whilst the contrary vices come to be disapproved of; not only under their proper characters, but under the additional character of the most short-sighted folly and weakness. So that the conduciveness of virtue to happiness is only secondary, and so to speak accidental to its character; it is not its first recommendation to our pursuit of it.

But if the theories which resolved virtue into propriety or prudence were thus one-sided, the remaining theorythat best represented by Hutchesonwas no less so, which made virtue to consist solely in benevolence, or in a disinterested regard to the good of others or the public generally. So far indeed did Hutcheson carry this theory, that he even rejected as a selfish motive to virtuous action the pleasure of self-approbation, "the comfortable applause of our own consciences," holding that it diminished the merit of any benevolent action. The principle of self-love could never be virtuous in any degree, and it was merely innocent, not good, when it led a man to act from a reasonable regard to his own happiness.

Several reasons seem, indeed, at first sight, to justify the identification of virtue with benevolence. It is the most agreeable of all the affections.

It is recommended to us by a double sympathy, and we feel it to be the proper object of gratitude and reward. Even its weakness or its excess is not very disagreeable to us, as is the excess of every other passion.

同类推荐
  • 云安公主下降奉诏作

    云安公主下降奉诏作

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 母亲

    母亲

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 浩然斋词话

    浩然斋词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 琳法师别传

    琳法师别传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说如来兴显经卷第一

    佛说如来兴显经卷第一

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 世界儿童故事经典:奥秘故事

    世界儿童故事经典:奥秘故事

    有一种东西叫做钻石,如天上的星星,风雨的岁月和空间,凝固成人类精神的永恒,它跨越了国界、语言、年龄。“注音版影响孩子一生的名著”系列图书,每一本都是你生命中不可不读的经典。
  • 我是媳妇儿的白月光

    我是媳妇儿的白月光

    锦城傅二少大婚,娶的却是克死10个丈夫的女人蔺暖酒,一夜之间傅二少成为了所有人的笑柄。为了报自己的名声之仇,傅靳衍炮制了一堆的报复计划。第N次被逼无奈的蔺暖酒怒了:“傅宝宝,你知道我那十个老公怎么死的吗?”傅二少凤眸微眯:“知道,跟我一样,被你压榨的。”蔺暖酒:“……”婚后,傅靳衍发现,自己结婚不久的妻子给了他太多的惊喜。比如,她在五年前给他生了一对可爱的龙凤胎,男的奶包子叫傅二代,女的叫傅婆。傅二少一脸懵逼,什么鬼?exm?!(逗逼又骚气十足的大队长+富婆本质的美妆博主)新书:《总裁老公,顶级宠!》
  • 佛说妙吉祥瑜伽大教金刚陪啰嚩轮观想成就仪轨经

    佛说妙吉祥瑜伽大教金刚陪啰嚩轮观想成就仪轨经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 儿童注意力障碍100问

    儿童注意力障碍100问

    本书从注意力缺损多动障碍产生的原因、如何诊断、不同年龄阶段儿童注意力缺损多动障碍的表现、如何进行行为矫正和认知矫正等角度介绍了有关儿童注意力缺损多动障碍的相关知识。本书旨在帮助教师和家长认识、了解与矫正儿童注意力不集中的行为。从而帮助具有这类问题的儿童获得适合他们的教育,帮助这类儿童的家长做合格的家长。
  • BLIX

    BLIX

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 盛世神话

    盛世神话

    一朝穿越,很狗血的穿成了一个废物,可是还好还好,毕竟是爹很疼,娘也很爱,可是,可是为毛?为毛她却是从一个豆蔻年华的少女,穿成了一个“英俊少年。”想死的心都有啊!可是,能不能不要那么丢人,能不能不要教坏小孩子,这样“苍天啊!我要我36D的胸啊!我不要长小JJ啊!”不要脸的话语,在心里想想就好了,为毛,为毛你要如此大声的说出来。她、便是许一凡,那个一朝穿越错成“男”的女孩子,姆妈说是许她一世平凡,所以为她取名许一凡。她有点腐,有点小聪明,明明就是有些懒,可是却想成为一个强者,许一凡,你有没有搞错,自己是个废物懂不懂?废物啊废物,知不知道什么意思,就是废物的意思啊!对,没错,就是这样一个有点懒,却是废物的“男孩子”,身上背负了一个血腥的使命,神话烙印,半个玉玦,这里面到底有什么秘密。啥!她是私生子,那…那他是谁的私生子?姆妈却是告诉他不知道?不知道,那她怎么找她的老爹,那个不负责任的男人,死到哪里去了?
  • 修仙诗画

    修仙诗画

    仙子修行化,飞舞飘渺画。春岚景繁花,诗趣琴语话!
  • 寻找爱情的邹小姐

    寻找爱情的邹小姐

    时光是一条永远无法逾越的河,所有的爱恨嗔痴,所有的悲欢离合,都被悄无声息地侵蚀殆尽,终至消散无痕。十年前,她与他经历了最铭心的爱,最刻骨的恨。她曾那样用力爱过他,他也曾那样执着于她,她以为他们的爱牢不可破。然而,当命运无情地举起镰刀,当罂粟花绽放邪恶微笑,他不过是漠然地转身离去。那一刻,她才知道,一切不过是一场蓄意已久的阴谋。她从天堂跌入地狱。爱也好,恨也好,她说,如果她真的忘记了,她不愿再记起。十年后,前尘往事如烟消散,她真的没有再忆起。她以为自己另有所爱,他身边来去如云,他们不过是咫尺天涯的陌生人。然而,当往昔的回忆如潮水般涌来,当真相的卷帘慢慢掀开……他们是否还能寻回失落了十年的爱?
  • 复仇旅

    复仇旅

    父母接连遭到金鹏堡杀手暗杀,姐姐也不知所踪。于是,愤怒的少年踏上了复仇之旅。
  • 我混烘焙圈的

    我混烘焙圈的

    松软的戚风蛋糕、酥脆的牛角面包、可口的慕斯蛋糕、蓬松的手撕面包、网红的脏脏包。甜的、咸的,酥香的,口感饱满的。种种精致诱人的面包蛋糕似乎都能从这一家小小的烘焙坊找到。这是一个关于烘焙的故事。阅读指南:1、1V1,轻松爽文路线,文风温馨;2、警示:本文涉及面包、蛋糕、奶茶等甜度爆表的食物,这是一本看着让人发胖的故事。 3、书友群:442060939