登陆注册
5451600000006

第6章

I think that the judges themselves have failed adequately to recognize their duty of weighing considerations of social advantage.The duty is inevitable, and the result of the often proclaimed judicial aversion to deal with such considerations is simply to leave the very ground and foundation of judgments inarticulate, and often unconscious, as I have said.When socialism first began to be talked about, the comfortable classes of the community were a good deal frightened.I suspect that this fear has influenced judicial action both here and in England, yet it is certain that it is not a conscious factor in the decisions to which I refer.I think that something similar has led people who no longer hope to control the legislatures to look to the courts as expounders of the constitutions, and that in some courts new principles have been discovered outside the bodies of those instruments, which may be generalized into acceptance of the economic doctrines which prevailed about fifty years ago, and a wholesale prohibition of what a tribunal of lawyers does not think about right.I cannot but believe that if the training of lawyers led them habitually to consider more definitely and explicitly the social advantage on which the rule they lay down must be justified, they sometimes would hesitate where now they are confident, and see that really they were taking sides upon debatable and often burning questions.

So much for the fallacy of logical form.Now let us consider the present condition of the law as a subject for study, and the ideal toward which it tends.We still are far from the point of view which Idesire to see reached.No one has reached it or can reach it as yet.

We are only at the beginning of a philosophical reaction, and of a reconsideration of the worth of doctrines which for the most part still are taken for granted without any deliberate, conscious, and systematic questioning of their grounds.The development of our law has gone on for nearly a thousand years, like the development of a plant, each generation taking the inevitable next step, mind, like matter, simply obeying a law of spontaneous growth.It is perfectly natural and right that it should have been so.Imitation is a necessity of human nature, as has been illustrated by a remarkable French writer, M.Tard, in an admirable book, Les Lois de l'Imitation.Most of the things we do, we do for no better reason than that our fathers have done them or that our neighbors do them, and the same is true of a larger part than we suspect of what we think.The reason is a good one, because our short life gives us no time for a better, but it is not the best.It does not follow, because we all are compelled to take on faith at second hand most of the rules on which we base our action and our thought, that each of us may not try to set some corner of his world in the order of reason, or that all of us collectively should not aspire to carry reason as far as it will go throughout the whole domain.In regard to the law, it is true, no doubt, that an evolutionist will hesitate to affirm universal validity for his social ideals, or for the principles which he thinks should be embodied in legislation.He is content if he can prove them best for here and now.He may be ready to admit that he knows nothing about an absolute best in the cosmos, and even that he knows next to nothing about a permanent best for men.Still it is true that a body of law is more rational and more civilized when every rule it contains is referred articulately and definitely to an end which it subserves, and when the grounds for desiring that end are stated or are ready to be stated in words.

At present, in very many cases, if we want to know why a rule of law has taken its particular shape, and more or less if we want to know why it exists at all, we go to tradition.We follow it into the Year Books, and perhaps beyond them to the customs of the Salian Franks, and somewhere in the past, in the German forests, in the needs of Norman kings, in the assumptions of a dominant class, in the absence of generalized ideas, we find out the practical motive for what now best is justified by the mere fact of its acceptance and that men are accustomed to it.The rational study of law is still to a large extent the study of history.History must be a part of the study, because without it we cannot know the precise scope of rules which it is our business to know.

It is a part of the rational study, because it is the first step toward an enlightened scepticism, that is, towards a deliberate reconsideration of the worth of those rules.When you get the dragon out of his cave on to the plain and in the daylight, you can count his teeth and claws, and see just what is his strength.But to get him out is only the first step.The next is either to kill him, or to tame him and make him a useful animal.For the rational study of the law the blackletter man may be the man of the present, but the man of the future is the man of statistics and the master of economics.It is revolting to have no better reason for a rule of law than that so it was laid down in the time of Henry IV.It is still more revolting if the grounds upon which it was laid down have vanished long since, and the rule simply persists from blind imitation of the past.I am thinking of the technical rule as to trespass ab initio, as it is called, which I attempted to explain in a recent Massachusetts case.

同类推荐
  • 铜鼓书堂词话

    铜鼓书堂词话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 寺沙门玄奘上表记

    寺沙门玄奘上表记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 重订西方公据

    重订西方公据

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 浪淘沙二首

    浪淘沙二首

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • TOPICS

    TOPICS

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 好妈妈育儿经(怀孕、分娩、育儿百科)

    好妈妈育儿经(怀孕、分娩、育儿百科)

    本书提供给读者的是从孩子的孕育到健康身心成长的全面可靠的科学育儿建议:0-3岁婴幼儿的基本护理方法;各生长期体格、情感、语言、运动和认知发育的标准;各种常见疾病、意外伤害及其他健康问题的识别和护理;亲子间感情交流的重要性及其方法;从早期智力开发开始,全面呵护孩子的成长,培养出健康的聪明宝宝。
  • 法华传记

    法华传记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 情殇之豪门爱恋

    情殇之豪门爱恋

    如同一具行尸走肉,浑浑噩噩的头脑还未完全清醒。昨天是她毕业的日子,她却被亲哥哥金文宇贩卖到了夜总会,成了妓女。莫名被夺去初夜,可她却不知道那个男人是谁!姓什么,叫什么,多高,多胖,只知道他有一张俊俏到自愧不如的脸。全身酸痛,毫无力气,金不瑶一个瘫软蹲坐在石阶上,脑海在不断回放昨夜那无休止的缠绵。欢爱,是让人兴奋的,可却是让金不瑶感到惧怕的。她不知道那一个晚上被要了多少次,只知道每一次长……
  • 犬来仪

    犬来仪

    以一条狗怀孕即将产下小狗开头,展开以海平为主人公高考后的暑期生活,面对病重的父亲和上大学作艰难选择,父亲病逝,海平今后的生活又该如何面对?
  • 夜半鬼叫门

    夜半鬼叫门

    惨淡的月光洒进古旧残破的钟魁庙中,让庙中的两个人的脸显的有些狰狞。其中一个长相极为凶恶的大胡子质问对方:“李大人你立志扫尽欺神骗鬼之辈,的确是想为民做一件好事,不过你真的不信这世间有鬼存在吗?”
  • Christ in Flanders

    Christ in Flanders

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 老婆请负责

    老婆请负责

    重生前,她是楚公子同居了四年的临时情人,唯一的妹妹横刀夺爱,红玫瑰转眼成蚊子血,她愤然坐上飞往洛杉矶的班机,不料却发生了空难。重生后,她拿了李家小姐的身份,成了杜家大少规规矩矩的少年妻子,偏偏明月光却是那男人眼里食之无味的白米饭,忍气吞声只有被欺负的份。可惜,她不是懦弱无能的李家小姐,施施然签下杜家副总杜北扬送来了离婚协议书,新的生活在招手,可是新的问题又来了——莫名其妙的饥渴症开始纠缠她,五脏庙一个劲儿地叫嚣着,吃吃吃!白白的米饭她不爱,香香的肉肉不够味,为什么她想要扑倒吃掉的会是——臭烘烘的男人?她想要吃男人也就罢了,为什么男人们一个个洗干净了就等着被吃?红杏出墙还敢跑来深情忏悔的前同居人?风流薄幸还敢跑来继续纠缠的总裁前夫?通通的倒胃口有没有?还不如做了杜北扬的临时夫妻,吃干抹净不留渣外加不用负责!什么,临时夫妻要转永久关系?这个么。。。再考虑考虑吧。。。本文是综合狗血,甜蜜,外加小虐的现代言情,女主纪微然将冲破一切艰难险阻,战胜所有小三情妇,放弃众多的美味佳肴,最终抱得美食归~
  • 卯上蛊惑妃:邪女戏悍夫

    卯上蛊惑妃:邪女戏悍夫

    她是黑白两道闻风丧胆的夺命修罗,生性妖娆且轻狂,一朝穿越成将军府惨遭灭门的小姐,被逼隐姓埋名,他是龙腾国的寒王,性情刁钻古怪,更是视女人为毒瘤,在他与她角逐的游戏里,一颗春心刚开始萌芽,蓦然发现她身边何时出现了众多追求者?额冒青筋,霸道扑倒她:“女人,你享占了我的身体,胆敢勾搭其他男人试试?”
  • 洞玄灵宝升玄步虚章序疏

    洞玄灵宝升玄步虚章序疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 缘深情不负

    缘深情不负

    “你还是要缠着我不可?”念夕苦恼又微怒,面前的楚沐戈一副胜券在握的模样。“嫁给我是你唯一的选择,你是知道的,我始终都爱你。”无论曾经还是现在。年少,她居心叵测的找上了他,一场懵懂的情感就此开始。再遇,他的执念她的困苦,救赎还是陌路?若我爱你是一种习惯,等你回到我身边将是我一生的期待。