登陆注册
5451600000006

第6章

I think that the judges themselves have failed adequately to recognize their duty of weighing considerations of social advantage.The duty is inevitable, and the result of the often proclaimed judicial aversion to deal with such considerations is simply to leave the very ground and foundation of judgments inarticulate, and often unconscious, as I have said.When socialism first began to be talked about, the comfortable classes of the community were a good deal frightened.I suspect that this fear has influenced judicial action both here and in England, yet it is certain that it is not a conscious factor in the decisions to which I refer.I think that something similar has led people who no longer hope to control the legislatures to look to the courts as expounders of the constitutions, and that in some courts new principles have been discovered outside the bodies of those instruments, which may be generalized into acceptance of the economic doctrines which prevailed about fifty years ago, and a wholesale prohibition of what a tribunal of lawyers does not think about right.I cannot but believe that if the training of lawyers led them habitually to consider more definitely and explicitly the social advantage on which the rule they lay down must be justified, they sometimes would hesitate where now they are confident, and see that really they were taking sides upon debatable and often burning questions.

So much for the fallacy of logical form.Now let us consider the present condition of the law as a subject for study, and the ideal toward which it tends.We still are far from the point of view which Idesire to see reached.No one has reached it or can reach it as yet.

We are only at the beginning of a philosophical reaction, and of a reconsideration of the worth of doctrines which for the most part still are taken for granted without any deliberate, conscious, and systematic questioning of their grounds.The development of our law has gone on for nearly a thousand years, like the development of a plant, each generation taking the inevitable next step, mind, like matter, simply obeying a law of spontaneous growth.It is perfectly natural and right that it should have been so.Imitation is a necessity of human nature, as has been illustrated by a remarkable French writer, M.Tard, in an admirable book, Les Lois de l'Imitation.Most of the things we do, we do for no better reason than that our fathers have done them or that our neighbors do them, and the same is true of a larger part than we suspect of what we think.The reason is a good one, because our short life gives us no time for a better, but it is not the best.It does not follow, because we all are compelled to take on faith at second hand most of the rules on which we base our action and our thought, that each of us may not try to set some corner of his world in the order of reason, or that all of us collectively should not aspire to carry reason as far as it will go throughout the whole domain.In regard to the law, it is true, no doubt, that an evolutionist will hesitate to affirm universal validity for his social ideals, or for the principles which he thinks should be embodied in legislation.He is content if he can prove them best for here and now.He may be ready to admit that he knows nothing about an absolute best in the cosmos, and even that he knows next to nothing about a permanent best for men.Still it is true that a body of law is more rational and more civilized when every rule it contains is referred articulately and definitely to an end which it subserves, and when the grounds for desiring that end are stated or are ready to be stated in words.

At present, in very many cases, if we want to know why a rule of law has taken its particular shape, and more or less if we want to know why it exists at all, we go to tradition.We follow it into the Year Books, and perhaps beyond them to the customs of the Salian Franks, and somewhere in the past, in the German forests, in the needs of Norman kings, in the assumptions of a dominant class, in the absence of generalized ideas, we find out the practical motive for what now best is justified by the mere fact of its acceptance and that men are accustomed to it.The rational study of law is still to a large extent the study of history.History must be a part of the study, because without it we cannot know the precise scope of rules which it is our business to know.

It is a part of the rational study, because it is the first step toward an enlightened scepticism, that is, towards a deliberate reconsideration of the worth of those rules.When you get the dragon out of his cave on to the plain and in the daylight, you can count his teeth and claws, and see just what is his strength.But to get him out is only the first step.The next is either to kill him, or to tame him and make him a useful animal.For the rational study of the law the blackletter man may be the man of the present, but the man of the future is the man of statistics and the master of economics.It is revolting to have no better reason for a rule of law than that so it was laid down in the time of Henry IV.It is still more revolting if the grounds upon which it was laid down have vanished long since, and the rule simply persists from blind imitation of the past.I am thinking of the technical rule as to trespass ab initio, as it is called, which I attempted to explain in a recent Massachusetts case.

同类推荐
  • 七女观经

    七女观经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 述报法兵侵台纪事残辑

    述报法兵侵台纪事残辑

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 白救度佛母赞

    白救度佛母赞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洞神三皇七十二君斋方忏仪

    洞神三皇七十二君斋方忏仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 交州记

    交州记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 画品

    画品

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 超强全能农民

    超强全能农民

    叶正琮运气差到极点,父亲断腿,大学辍学,回家务农,被雷劈中……终究否极泰来,他得到惊天奇遇……既然务农,那就是最强的农民,种出的东西,都是极品……玄学道术,那都不叫事,风水玄学,拘鬼成仆,小菜一碟……识人相术,道尽天机,逆天改命,也不过如此,他也会……不治绝症,也难不倒他,只要看得顺眼,一出手保证百病全消,健康的不要不要的……他就是超强全能农民叶正琮……
  • 荼蘼花正开

    荼蘼花正开

    无姓荼蘼空知途,烈凤岂是树上乌!至致末路方涅槃,燃血煅骨画蓝图!容装铠甲万人颂,九天一路觅真龙!羽化玲珑俏佳人,此生无悔守梧桐!终得锦绣佳良缘,以你之名,冠我之姓!
  • 伤寒杂病论

    伤寒杂病论

    《伤寒杂病论》是一部论述传染病与内科杂病为主要内容的典籍,东汉张仲景约撰成于公元2世纪末3世纪初,被誉为“中医临床医学之祖”。
  • 田园风华

    田园风华

    不要在内容简介中泄露你的QQ,以免被他人冒用她是中医世家的传人,却叛逆的想做厨师,谁知梦想即将实现的时候诡异穿越。来到陌生的世界,却又一个单身女子成了有夫有子的神秘少妇。冲着懂事儿子的温情关心,江晓菀决定从此替宁儿照顾这个漂亮的儿子。遇见你何其有幸,当第一眼见到那个成为她丈夫的人的时候,她明白了什么叫做见君倾城,世无其二。
  • 无上狂龙

    无上狂龙

    圣龙出,神魔定。前因后果,几番跌宕,终获正果。广袤的亚兰蒂大陆上,一个小山村中,他,降生了,安静,祥和的生活却在他十岁时走到了尽头,父母的双亡,炼就了他坚韧不拔,永不服输的性格。上天为何如此对待他?自己的身世,他究竟是什么人?他是怎样成长起来的?他又为何来到这世上?
  • 单挑

    单挑

    "作品五度入围直木奖,在日本人气比肩村上春树、东野圭吾“未来三部曲”,多线条烧脑短篇连作,每个情节都别有用心,你敢不敢一个人去拯救世界?"
  • 我重生至未来

    我重生至未来

    简介:这是一代传奇陨落,穿越到万载岁月后的故事。背景:未来仙侠。 …… 真简介:这是有关于,卖瓜的,养殖的,坑爹的,与被坑的故事。 真背景:我叶玄打钱!!! ……
  • 我能看见本章说

    我能看见本章说

    我能看见人身上的本章说,我还是个心理咨询师,这是个完美的组合。但是我好像错了。少掉的章节加群735504149,有粉丝值就行。
  • 蒋勋说红楼梦修订本(套装共3册)

    蒋勋说红楼梦修订本(套装共3册)

    这是蒋勋在长达半个世纪的时间里,数十次阅读《红楼梦》后的心血之作。无关红学,不涉及考证,作者从青春与美的角度出发,带领读者逐字逐句细读小说本身,梳理《红楼梦》中的人物与情感,探寻书中表达的繁华的幻灭、逝去的哀伤,讲述青春的孤独、寂寞与彷徨。这是一个生命对其余生命的叩问与聆听。跟蒋勋读《红楼梦》,仿佛是在阅读自己的一生。蒋勋说:我是把《红楼梦》当“佛经”来读的,因为处处都是慈悲,也处处都是觉悟。