登陆注册
5451600000005

第5章

This mode of thinking is entirely natural.The training of lawyers is a training in logic.The processes of analogy, discrimination, and deduction are those in which they are most at home.The language of judicial decision is mainly the language of logic.And the logical method and form flatter that longing for certainty and for repose which is in every human mind.But certainty generally is illusion, and repose is not the destiny of man.Behind the logical form lies a judgment as to the relative worth and importance of competing legislative grounds, often an inarticulate and unconscious judgment, it is true, and yet the very root and nerve of the whole proceeding.You can give any conclusion a logical form.You always can imply a condition in a contract.But why do you imply it? It is because of some belief as to the practice of the community or of a class, or because of some opinion as to policy, or, in short, because of some attitude of yours upon a matter not capable of exact quantitative measurement, and therefore not capable of founding exact logical conclusions.Such matters really are battle grounds where the means do not exist for the determinations that shall be good for all time, and where the decision can do no more than embody the preference of a given body in a given time and place.We do not realize how large a part of our law is open to reconsideration upon a slight change in the habit of the public mind.No concrete proposition is self evident, no matter how ready we may be to accept it, not even Mr.Herbert Spencer's "Every man has a right to do what he wills, provided he interferes not with a like right on the part of his neighbors."Why is a false and injurious statement privileged, if it is made honestly in giving information about a servant? It is because it has been thought more important that information should be given freely, than that a man should be protected from what under other circumstances would be an actionable wrong.Why is a man at liberty to set up a business which he knows will ruin his neighborhood? It is because the public good is supposed to be best subserved by free competition.

Obviously such judgments of relative importance may vary in different times and places.Why does a judge instruct a jury that an employer is not liable to an employee for an injury received in the course of his employment unless he is negligent, and why do the jury generally find for the plaintiff if the case is allowed to go to them? It is because the traditional policy of our law is to confine liability to cases where a prudent man might have foreseen the injury, or at least the danger, while the inclination of a very large part of the community is to make certain classes of persons insure the safety of those with whom they deal.Since the last words were written, I have seen the requirement of such insurance put forth as part of the programme of one of the best known labor organizations.There is a concealed, half conscious battle on the question of legislative policy, and if any one thinks that it can be settled deductively, or once for all, I only can say that I think he is theoretically wrong, and that I am certain that his conclusion will not be accepted in practice semper ubique et ab omnibus.

Indeed, I think that even now our theory upon this matter is open to reconsideration, although I am not prepared to say how I should decide if a reconsideration were proposed.Our law of torts comes from the old days of isolated, ungeneralized wrongs, assaults, slanders, and the like, where the damages might be taken to lie where they fell by legal judgment.But the torts with which our courts are kept busy today are mainly the incidents of certain well known businesses.They are injuries to person or property by railroads, factories, and the like.

The liability for them is estimated, and sooner or later goes into the price paid by the public.The public really pays the damages, and the question of liability, if pressed far enough, is really a question how far it is desirable that the public should insure the safety of one whose work it uses.It might be said that in such cases the chance of a jury finding for the defendant is merely a chance, once in a while rather arbitrarily interrupting the regular course of recovery, most likely in the case of an unusually conscientious plaintiff, and therefore better done away with.On the other hand, the economic value even of a life to the community can be estimated, and no recovery, it may be said, ought to go beyond that amount.It is conceivable that some day in certain cases we may find ourselves imitating, on a higher plane, the tariff for life and limb which we see in the Leges Barbarorum.

同类推荐
  • Grandfather'  s Chair

    Grandfather' s Chair

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说缘生初胜分法本经

    佛说缘生初胜分法本经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 丽情集

    丽情集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 竹素山房诗集

    竹素山房诗集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 虚空藏菩萨经

    虚空藏菩萨经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 腹黑相公真妖娆

    腹黑相公真妖娆

    孤儿有何可怕,穿越了照样活的风生水起!墨文轩紧紧抱紧了面前的这个少女:“暮雪,不要离开我!你是我一直要找的那个人!”墨文轩泫然欲泣,如雨后白莲般柔嫩,惹人爱怜心疼!....
  • 秋日的苍凉

    秋日的苍凉

    在一个下着小雨的黄昏里,她打着伞走到了他们俩初次约会的那片树下。这已是两人认识的第二年秋末了。细雨迷蒙里,他这个人,他们之间的情感,好像是很久远的事,被裹进了雨雾的深处。一些开花的树,在风中兀自微摇,他们之间,真的成了陈年旧事。重返旧地,又能捡拾回什么?时光风干得他们猝不及防。细密的草地和繁茂的树叶,挡不住风,已将旧景吹散。是啊去那些旧地,又能捡拾回些什么?小草接住了什么,树叶听见了什么吗?什么都被风吹走了,只剩下了小草们的呼吸和存在。时刻、感觉、世事、穿过的只有两个人的心,在他们坐过的地方有一朵盛开的小花,这朵小花的盛开汲取了世事的香气了么?她将那朵小花采下来,拿回家去。
  • 岚郡主

    岚郡主

    【四国鼎立,强者为尊,没有怜悯,只剩征服。移魂前的她是男人的噩梦,重生后的她是天下的梦想。】她,权尊势重的苏王幼女,人尽皆知的草包废物。痴情善妒嚣张跋扈,有爹没娘臭名远扬,被宗室皇子携带小三当街悔婚,遭人围观死于非命!然,移魂重生的她再度睁眼,眉目如画,眉眼冷硬。三分轻狂,七分深藏。为防苏王护女造反,君主钦封“岚郡主”,赏赐荒城一座,人兽祸乱,孰料荒城因她崛起,一举覆灭千军万马,声震大陆,引无数英雄折腰……回返王城,杀机重重。他人机关算尽,难抵锋芒睿智。玄神之赛,四国俊才齐聚,漫天斗气,宗法瑰丽。一介废物,一场对决,一鸣惊人,一举打响遍场的愚者耳目。苏琚岚:“别人帮你,那是情分,不帮你,那是本分。容不容得下是你的气度,能不能让你容下是我的本事!”本文是废柴大翻身,友情金贵,千金难买。呵呵,万千男儿皆绝色,情路坎坷,但心定如一。
  • 指战星际

    指战星际

    今天你可能是叱咤风云的帝国元首,明天你就可能是阶下囚。金钱和荣耀,要用鲜血和子弹铸造。一款跨时代的网游《星际争霸Online》登录战网,终于能够在科普卢星区一展身手,你是想成为高贵的星灵还是无畏的人类?是率领弟兄用钢铁和子弹坚守阵地,还是驾驶自己的战机在杀出重围?是正面交锋重挫敌军,还是隐匿于人群之中取敌将首级?同一款游戏,书写不同人的故事。
  • 修二代的美好生活

    修二代的美好生活

    听说修二代的日子快活无比,不缺灵石不缺丹,不愁法宝不愁吃。 可是……这是真的么?
  • 网游之帝恨传说

    网游之帝恨传说

    新书《我的老婆是鬼尊》已经发布,—— 一把代表负面情绪的禁忌之剑,一段逆天封神之路,他是一名试验品,代号十三,拥有着超越人类的能力;他被外界称作死神撒旦……三年前,为了逃离组织,他和爱人坠落深渊,十死无生,可他却出现在了华夏帝都,失去了她,少年萎靡不振,直到三年后出现了一款超现实网游《幻世》,那里,竟然存在着她的消息!!!可是进入游戏以后,一切颠覆了少年的认知,错位的游戏世界,重叠的位面空间,一个巨大的阴谋正在围绕着他而展开。(欢迎加入醉轩盟,群号码68414274)
  • 兔子报恩十世不晚

    兔子报恩十世不晚

    猪八戒在广寒宫点了一把火,他想借此和嫦娥私奔。嫦娥的玉兔,差点就被这场火烧个魂飞魄散。玉兔被修仙凡人云卿所救,云卿却因此被烧死。玉兔一心报恩,在得知云卿要历经十世轮回的时候,下凡追随只为能还了救命之恩。一连追随九世的玉兔,均没有用武之地。直到第十世,她总算有了些用处。然而,她却得知自己之前九世都寻错了恩公。这一世,眼前的云卿不知道是不是她要找的人……最后一切真相大白时,玉兔欠的可不仅仅是他这一条命。若要还清她欠的,怕只能是以身相许了。简而言之就是一只一根筋的兔子精,死皮赖脸追着禁欲系仙气十足的男神,以报恩的名义捕获芳心的故事。女主面热心冷,男主面冷心热。
  • 玉耶经

    玉耶经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金匮方歌括

    金匮方歌括

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 最强全民系统

    最强全民系统

    “我叫叶枫,因为嘴贱吐槽,所以穿越了!”“哇,居然还送给我一个系统?”“哇,怎么这里每个人都有系统啊!”