登陆注册
5451600000009

第9章

In the teaching of this school and at Cambridge it is in no danger of being undervalued.Mr.Bigelow here and Mr.Ames and Mr.Thayer there have made important contributions which will not be forgotten, and in England the recent history of early English law by Sir Frederick Pollock and Mr.Maitland has lent the subject an almost deceptive charm.We must beware of the pitfall of antiquarianism, and must remember that for our purposes our only interest in the past is for the light it throws upon the present.I look forward to a time when the part played by history in the explanation of dogma shall be very small, and instead of ingenious research we shall spend our energy on a study of the ends sought to be attained and the reasons for desiring them.As a step toward that ideal it seems to me that every lawyer ought to seek an understanding of economics.The present divorce between the schools of political economy and law seems to me an evidence of how much progress in philosophical study still remains to be made.In the present state of political economy, indeed, we come again upon history on a larger scale, but there we are called on to consider and weigh the ends of legislation, the means of attaining them, and the cost.We learn that for everything we have we give up something else, and we are taught to set the advantage we gain against the other advantage we lose, and to know what we are doing when we elect.

There is another study which sometimes is undervalued by the practical minded, for which I wish to say a good word, although I think a good deal of pretty poor stuff goes under that name.I mean the study of what is called jurisprudence.Jurisprudence, as I look at it, is simply law in its most generalized part.Every effort to reduce a case to a rule is an effort of jurisprudence, although the name as used in English is confined to the broadest rules and most fundamental conceptions.One mark of a great lawyer is that he sees the application of the broadest rules.There is a story of a Vermont justice of the peace before whom a suit was brought by one farmer against another for breaking a churn.

The justice took time to consider, and then said that he has looked through the statutes and could find nothing about churns, and gave judgment for the defendant.The same state of mind is shown in all our common digests and textbooks.Applications of rudimentary rules of contract or tort are tucked away under the head of Railroads or Telegraphs or go to swell treatises on historical subdivisions, such as Shipping or Equity, or are gathered under an arbitrary title which is thought likely to appeal to the practical mind, such as Mercantile Law.

If a man goes into law it pays to be a master of it, and to be a master of it means to look straight through all the dramatic incidents and to discern the true basis for prophecy.Therefore, it is well to have an accurate notion of what you mean by law, by a right, by a duty, by malice, intent, and negligence, by ownership, by possession, and so forth.I have in my mind cases in which the highest courts seem to me to have floundered because they had no clear ideas on some of these themes.I have illustrated their importance already.If a further illustration is wished, it may be found by reading the Appendix to Sir James Stephen's Criminal Law on the subject of possession, and then turning to Pollock and Wright's enlightened book.Sir James Stephen is not the only writer whose attempts to analyze legal ideas have been confused by striving for a useless quintessence of all systems, instead of an accurate anatomy of one.The trouble with Austin was that he did not know enough English law.But still it is a practical advantage to master Austin, and his predecessors, Hobbes and Bentham, and his worthy successors, Holland and Pollock.Sir Frederick Pollock's recent little book is touched with the felicity which marks all his works, and is wholly free from the perverting influence of Roman models.

The advice of the elders to young men is very apt to be as unreal as a list of the hundred best books.At least in my day I had my share of such counsels, and high among the unrealities I place the recommendation to study the Roman law.I assume that such advice means more than collecting a few Latin maxims with which to ornament the discourse--the purpose for which Lord Coke recommended Bracton.If that is all that is wanted, the title De Regulis Juris Antiqui can be read in an hour.Iassume that, if it is well to study the Roman Law, it is well to study it as a working system.That means mastering a set of technicalities more difficult and less understood than our own, and studying another course of history by which even more than our own the Roman law must explained.If any one doubts me, let him read Keller's Der Romische Civil Process und die Actionen, a treatise on the praetor's edict, Muirhead's most interesting Historical Introduction to the Private Law of Rome, and, to give him the best chance, Sohn's admirable Institutes.

No.The way to gain a liberal view of your subject is not to read something else, but to get to the bottom of the subject itself.The means of doing that are, in the first place, to follow the existing body of dogma into its highest generalizations by the help of jurisprudence;next, to discover from history how it has come to be what it is; and finally, so far as you can, to consider the ends which the several rules seek to accomplish, the reasons why those ends are desired, what is given up to gain them, and whether they are worth the price.

同类推荐
  • 胡文敬集

    胡文敬集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金刚般若论会释

    金刚般若论会释

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 五美缘全传

    五美缘全传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大清三杰

    大清三杰

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大宋僧史略

    大宋僧史略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 特种兵在古代

    特种兵在古代

    一个从没有失败过的特种兵,阴差阳错地来到了古代。过人的技术,冷漠的性格,让他在新的时代成为无可替代的万人迷...
  • 情定望海城

    情定望海城

    本书的故事创作主要是以现代都市——望海城为背景,以女主人公赵天雪的感情之路为线索进行描写,是一篇感人至深的现代言情小说。--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 将心独宠,下堂妻的春天

    将心独宠,下堂妻的春天

    前世她用尽心思跳出继母的算计出嫁,却遭夫君厌恶,侧夫人欺侮陷害,最终因红杏出墙的丑闻轰动京师,被夫家扫地出门含恨自尽!再次睁眸,另换异魂,恶奴叫嚣,渣男挑衅,继母阴狠,更有阴谋诡计一波接一波?秦牧歌双手环胸冷冷一笑:“渣渣们,放马过来呀!”什么,渣男想复合?对不起,本小姐暂时没有这个闲情逸致!片段一:轩辕澈冷眼居高临下看着秦牧歌,薄唇轻启道:“你以为在本将军面前你算是美的么?”秦牧歌淡淡一笑:“从前,有个家伙说我不美,后来,他疯了;不久前又有个家伙我说不美,现在,他死了……”某人俊脸立刻僵硬起来。女强、男强,温馨的大宠小虐,宫斗、宅斗男女斗,男主深情,不能接受一点点小虐的亲要小心!有波折才会更珍惜所有!最好的时光便是,我正打开心窗,而你恰好从窗前走过!推荐初晴旧文《狂女休夫,狼性邪王的毒妃》
  • 古井冤魂

    古井冤魂

    本书是作者历年来创作的短篇故事合集,共26篇,包括:《丛林里也生长爱情》、《古井冤魂》、《惊心的红色信封》、《通向火星的列车》、《为诚信买个保险》、《心灵绑架案》、《兄弟》等, 其中《兄弟》讲述了兄弟二人为了筹措父亲的医药费,弟弟不惜举报哥哥犯罪,获得奖金救活父亲的故事,读来让人不由得辛酸和感动。
  • 心态好,一切都会好

    心态好,一切都会好

    我们社会现在的主要矛盾是为了解决日益增长的物质文化需求与落后的社会生产力之间的矛盾。为了解决这个矛盾很多人勤奋努力地工作,人心变得淡漠,亲情也因此疏远,还引发了许多社会问题。但是实际上,一个人吃的就是三餐,穿的衣服也就是一,睡觉也只是一个床……要是能够这样看的话,人其实不管多忙都能够活得自在、富足的。由此来看,要活得,最主要的是你的心态够好。
  • 我身体里住着一条龙

    我身体里住着一条龙

    龙,华夏民族的象征,所有国人都以龙的传人自居,但是当它真正住进你的身体的时候,你会发现世界是如此的光怪陆离……
  • 你的狗狗在咬我

    你的狗狗在咬我

    一条可爱的小狗——笨笨让朱璟和露露在一个球场相识,一句简单的问候——“你的狗狗在咬我”让两个年轻人相遇。生活的热情让他们在生活中开始了对爱的追寻。日子如流水般进行着,男女主人公在一次次的见面中萌发情感,由好感到喜欢,到心照不宣的默契。在合肥这个小而温馨的城市,一幕幕感动的爱情片断在街头演绎.....一句简单的话语,让两个年轻人相遇,并开始了对爱的追寻,经历了一段非同寻常的情感历程。第一次牵手、第一次亲吻、第一次.....,美好的爱情似乎就....,然而这段感情却是.....
  • 羿破苍穹

    羿破苍穹

    陈羿受情挫折,奇遇射日神弓,返本归元于盘古遗骨,熔炼己身,且得依附遗骨之上的九大金乌本源和造化玉牒残片助力,熔炼神体,推演万物,助他走上无上巅峰。
  • 《案例。》系列(第1辑)

    《案例。》系列(第1辑)

    围绕着德鲁克与通用汽车的这段案例公案,直到20世纪80年代仍然余音袅袅。在《公司的概念》1983年版本的跋记中,德鲁克仍然语带讥讽地写道:通用汽车公司的主管们不能接受我对管理学的基本观点,他们自诩为这门学科的急先锋,所以,他们完全不能接受《公司的概念》所贯穿的观念:管理首先是一种实践,虽然它与医学一样,把很多科学研究的方法当作工具使用。一家伟大公司与一位伟大管理学家之间的这段案例风波已成前尘旧事,而对于所有的公司研究者而言,它所留给我们的却是争论焦点以外的另外一些启迪:我们应该以一种怎样的姿态去研究企业?在相互尊重与学术独立之间,是否存在着某种平衡?
  • 春殇

    春殇

    白天做了个梦赵友厚梦见娜娜的整个情景有些乱,片段也不是很清晰——赵友厚在一家水饺店吃了两碗水饺,刚出来路过王麻子小吃店,忽然听到有人喊他。转脸一看,就看见娜娜端着两个空盘子站在王麻子小吃店门口。赵友厚惊喜地朝娜娜笑笑,娜娜放下手中的盘子走了过来……忽然,地点不是饮食街上王麻子小吃店门口了,变成矿工大街上一根电线杆子旁边。他靠在电线杆上,两只眼怯溜溜地看着娜娜胸脯一颤一颤地向他走来,心里禁不住“怦怦”乱跳,张了张嘴,却不知说什么好。娜娜走到他跟前,说:“小赵你好!”