登陆注册
5451600000008

第8章

Everywhere the basis of principle is tradition, to such an extent that we even are in danger of making the role of history more important than it is.The other day Professor Ames wrote a learned article to show, among other things, that the common law did not recognize the defence of fraud in actions upon specialties, and the moral might seem to be that the personal character of that defence is due to its equitable origin.

But if, as I said, all contracts are formal, the difference is not merely historical, but theoretic, between defects of form which prevent a contract from being made, and mistaken motives which manifestly could not be considered in any system that we should call rational except against one who was privy to those motives.It is not confined to specialties, but is of universal application.I ought to add that I do not suppose that Mr.Ames would disagree with what I suggest.

However, if we consider the law of contract, we find it full of history.

The distinctions between debt, covenant, and assumpsit are merely historical.The classification of certain obligations to pay money, imposed by the law irrespective of any bargain as quasi contracts, is merely historical.The doctrine of consideration is merely historical.

The effect given to a seal is to be explained by history alone.

Consideration is a mere form.Is it a useful form? If so, why should it not be required in all contracts? A seal is a mere form, and is vanishing in the scroll and in enactments that a consideration must be given, seal or no seal.Why should any merely historical distinction be allowed to affect the rights and obligations of business men?

Since I wrote this discourse I have come on a very good example of the way in which tradition not only overrides rational policy, but overrides it after first having been misunderstood and having been given a new and broader scope than it had when it had a meaning.It is the settled law of England that a material alteration of a written contract by a party avoids it as against him.The doctrine is contrary to the general tendency of the law.We do not tell a jury that if a man ever has lied in one particular he is to be presumed to lie in all.Even if a man has tried to defraud, it seems no sufficient reason for preventing him from proving the truth.Objections of like nature in general go to the weight, not to the admissibility, of evidence.Moreover, this rule is irrespective of fraud, and is not confined to evidence.It is not merely that you cannot use the writing, but that the contract is at an end.What does this mean? The existence of a written contract depends on the fact that the offerer and offeree have interchanged their written expressions, not on the continued existence of those expressions.But in the case of a bond, the primitive notion was different.The contract was inseparable from the parchment.If a stranger destroyed it, or tore off the seal, or altered it, the obligee count not recover, however free from fault, because the defendant's contract, that is, the actual tangible bond which he had sealed, could not be produced in the form in which it bound him.About a hundred years ago Lord Kenyon undertook to use his reason on the tradition, as he sometimes did to the detriment of the law, and, not understanding it, said he could see no reason why what was true of a bond should not be true of other contracts.His decision happened to be right, as it concerned a promissory note, where again the common law regarded the contract as inseparable from the paper on which it was written, but the reasoning was general, and soon was extended to other written contracts, and various absurd and unreal grounds of policy were invented to account for the enlarged rule.

I trust that no one will understand me to be speaking with disrespect of the law, because I criticise it so freely.I venerate the law, and especially our system of law, as one of the vastest products of the human mind.No one knows better than I do the countless number of great intellects that have spent themselves in making some addition or improvement, the greatest of which is trifling when compared with the mighty whole.It has the final title to respect that it exists, that it is not a Hegelian dream, but a part of the lives of men.But one may criticise even what one reveres.Law is the business to which my life is devoted, and I should show less than devotion if I did not do what in me lies to improve it, and, when I perceive what seems to me the ideal of its future, if I hesitated to point it out and to press toward it with all my heart.

Perhaps I have said enough to show the part which the study of history necessarily plays in the intelligent study of the law as it is today.

同类推荐
  • 闻见近录

    闻见近录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Critique of Political Economy

    Critique of Political Economy

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Irish Fairy Tales

    Irish Fairy Tales

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 云阜山申仙翁传

    云阜山申仙翁传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 土司灯仪

    土司灯仪

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 那年桃花朵朵开

    那年桃花朵朵开

    一曲笙歌,一树繁华,一场华丽丽的坑爹穿越,幸运星护身的她内心深处的黑暗是否会觉醒,他们的出现究竟哪一个才会是陪她笑看天下的人,一夜之间,桃花全部争相绽放,竟是一片的血红,那个她爱的人,冷漠,冰凉,他手握玄剑,血泊之中躺着的却是她最爱的娘,她应该怎样面对……---------我好喜欢你,可我也后悔遇见你。
  • 八零女医神

    八零女医神

    新书《槿秀》同步更新中!!还望各位宝贝支持!!!轮回往生不由天,一念留魂赛神仙。九鼎神域一代医神,穿越重生到地球八零年代。既入我门,就得按我的规矩来,想以势压人?对不起,请另请高明.....
  • 武道进化

    武道进化

    这个世界基因觉醒发展到不可思议的地步,所有人的目标就是不断觉醒!觉醒能够提升实力,增加寿命,觉醒基因就是这个世界的主旋律!前世的病秧子,意外开启基因觉醒之路!
  • 天使曾经来过

    天使曾经来过

    传说,任何人都能遇上自己的守护天使,天使会不知不觉落在你的背后,送你一枚硬币,其中一面叫“幸福”。硬币总有正反两面,它们不能同时展现,正当你正沉醉在幸福当中,天使就会把硬币反转,而另一面,叫“寂寞”。垦丁的海边阳光明媚,空白度假屋的咖啡室内飘散着咖啡香气。老板雪芬打算孤独地守护着一个秘密,却遇上了从事广告创作的浩文,经常看穿她的心理;而因梦想独自走到美国工作的小芳,在超市认识了捡过期食品的阿杜。一个带着信件的小女孩,竟揭开了一段段错综复杂的关系……当你被寂寞包围,才会后知后觉到,天使,曾经来过。
  • 99次深爱傅少约吗

    99次深爱傅少约吗

    抱歉,因为个人原因,至使,文章不能继续更下去,抱歉。
  • 修仙之谁与争吃

    修仙之谁与争吃

    诡秘莫测的苍穹下。也有无数人想把小宝捧在手心,视若珍宝。可小宝只想着吃。
  • THE PEOPLE OF THE ABYSS

    THE PEOPLE OF THE ABYSS

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 中华民俗知识全知道(超值金版)

    中华民俗知识全知道(超值金版)

    “百里不同风,千里不同俗”。《中华民俗知识全知道(超值金版)》从中华民族的姓名生肖、饮食文化、服饰文化、传统建筑、传统节日、婚庆礼仪、信仰禁忌以及民间艺术等诸多层面,以生动的语言、精美的图片、丰富的人文内涵,为我们展开了一幅精彩生动的民俗画卷。
  • 既不能反抗那就闭眼享受

    既不能反抗那就闭眼享受

    从头到尾我只是一颗棋子……我以为努力过他会懂我以为只要我付出的够多他就能多看我一眼谁曾想不论我多努力永远也比不上她。
  • 佛说虚空藏菩萨陀罗尼

    佛说虚空藏菩萨陀罗尼

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。