登陆注册
5451600000008

第8章

Everywhere the basis of principle is tradition, to such an extent that we even are in danger of making the role of history more important than it is.The other day Professor Ames wrote a learned article to show, among other things, that the common law did not recognize the defence of fraud in actions upon specialties, and the moral might seem to be that the personal character of that defence is due to its equitable origin.

But if, as I said, all contracts are formal, the difference is not merely historical, but theoretic, between defects of form which prevent a contract from being made, and mistaken motives which manifestly could not be considered in any system that we should call rational except against one who was privy to those motives.It is not confined to specialties, but is of universal application.I ought to add that I do not suppose that Mr.Ames would disagree with what I suggest.

However, if we consider the law of contract, we find it full of history.

The distinctions between debt, covenant, and assumpsit are merely historical.The classification of certain obligations to pay money, imposed by the law irrespective of any bargain as quasi contracts, is merely historical.The doctrine of consideration is merely historical.

The effect given to a seal is to be explained by history alone.

Consideration is a mere form.Is it a useful form? If so, why should it not be required in all contracts? A seal is a mere form, and is vanishing in the scroll and in enactments that a consideration must be given, seal or no seal.Why should any merely historical distinction be allowed to affect the rights and obligations of business men?

Since I wrote this discourse I have come on a very good example of the way in which tradition not only overrides rational policy, but overrides it after first having been misunderstood and having been given a new and broader scope than it had when it had a meaning.It is the settled law of England that a material alteration of a written contract by a party avoids it as against him.The doctrine is contrary to the general tendency of the law.We do not tell a jury that if a man ever has lied in one particular he is to be presumed to lie in all.Even if a man has tried to defraud, it seems no sufficient reason for preventing him from proving the truth.Objections of like nature in general go to the weight, not to the admissibility, of evidence.Moreover, this rule is irrespective of fraud, and is not confined to evidence.It is not merely that you cannot use the writing, but that the contract is at an end.What does this mean? The existence of a written contract depends on the fact that the offerer and offeree have interchanged their written expressions, not on the continued existence of those expressions.But in the case of a bond, the primitive notion was different.The contract was inseparable from the parchment.If a stranger destroyed it, or tore off the seal, or altered it, the obligee count not recover, however free from fault, because the defendant's contract, that is, the actual tangible bond which he had sealed, could not be produced in the form in which it bound him.About a hundred years ago Lord Kenyon undertook to use his reason on the tradition, as he sometimes did to the detriment of the law, and, not understanding it, said he could see no reason why what was true of a bond should not be true of other contracts.His decision happened to be right, as it concerned a promissory note, where again the common law regarded the contract as inseparable from the paper on which it was written, but the reasoning was general, and soon was extended to other written contracts, and various absurd and unreal grounds of policy were invented to account for the enlarged rule.

I trust that no one will understand me to be speaking with disrespect of the law, because I criticise it so freely.I venerate the law, and especially our system of law, as one of the vastest products of the human mind.No one knows better than I do the countless number of great intellects that have spent themselves in making some addition or improvement, the greatest of which is trifling when compared with the mighty whole.It has the final title to respect that it exists, that it is not a Hegelian dream, but a part of the lives of men.But one may criticise even what one reveres.Law is the business to which my life is devoted, and I should show less than devotion if I did not do what in me lies to improve it, and, when I perceive what seems to me the ideal of its future, if I hesitated to point it out and to press toward it with all my heart.

Perhaps I have said enough to show the part which the study of history necessarily plays in the intelligent study of the law as it is today.

同类推荐
  • 累害篇

    累害篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太乙元真保命长生经

    太乙元真保命长生经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 会仙女志

    会仙女志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 全生指迷方

    全生指迷方

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 友古词

    友古词

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 天戏

    天戏

    天黎大陆口口相传:天不生荒,万古如长夜。世世代代守护大黎三百年的荒姓人一夜之间惨遭灭门,幸存稚童荒君渔韶华白首仅剩十年生命立志报仇!结交生死兄弟,相遇红颜知己!在爱恨交织的天黎大陆,荒君渔手持荒戟横扫大黎所有宗派,征战西土脚踏四大凶地!欲错苍天!
  • 唯魔独尊

    唯魔独尊

    她,经过两次的穿越,经历了常人所不曾经历的事情。第一世的她,是一个无依无靠的孤儿,意外中丧生,却魂穿到了雷欧大陆,一个魔法国度。第二世的她,拥有了对她而言弥足珍贵的亲情,接触到了她最爱的魔法,她成了雷欧大陆的天才。当她来到了斗气大陆,一个充斥着斗气,却没有魔法的世界,她会给这世界带来怎样的震撼?在异世,偶然得到了神器七彩玲珑镯,遇到了来自雷欧大陆的强者冰老,在冰老的教导下,女主的努力下,走向了强者巅峰之路。唯有自己,才不会背叛自己;唯有自己实力强大,才不会有人敢对自己不敬。她,虽然不会炼制斗气大陆的丹药,但是她会制作魔法药剂。她的魔法药剂,在拍卖会上卖出天价,无数的世家,强者想要与她拉近关系。她,修习了冰老千年来研究出来的功法,成为了全才,斗气魔法双修,魔法属性由水冰双系转变为了全系……让我们看看,女主是怎样一步步的走上巅峰之路。--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------推荐某珞的新文《极品天骄》本文女主暴强!领养区:女主【水攸涵】由【冰灵沫沫】领养温文尔雅的【尹青冉】由【猫儿玲珑】领养邪魅妖孽的【南宫肆】由【安静守护你】领养潇洒俊逸的【南宫逸】由【菁熙梓ciyi】领养潇洒狠绝的【蓝泽明】由【新愛阑】领养冷酷霸气的【夜啸天】由【囧囧冷子】领养可爱强悍的【小宝】由【奻雪】领养◆◆◆◆推荐《幻城联盟》玄幻好文◆◆◆◆【仙傲】妖孽柒柒【兽仙】颜小票【傲世天狂】墨堇琳【狂血狼颜】曲殇【莲开九霄】剑泣血【唯魔独尊】慕璎珞【邪冰傲天】墨邪尘【妖娆女巫】紫箫泠君【异世女血皇】漫殇【魂战九霄】君别离推荐好友的文怜小瑜的《无敌大小姐》君无凡的《穿越之朕是女人》茗天猫的《瞳变》木慕可乔的《修神天下》刑冷墨的《异火焚天》漫漫的《蜜爱傻妃》
  • 曲礼下

    曲礼下

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 王朝崛起

    王朝崛起

    天生大腚显神威,奇幻变身福祸偎。朝阳初现放光芒,夕阳西下收余辉。少年,成功=努力+坚持+天赋+机遇!少年,成功=十次流血+百次失败+千次挫折+万次洒汗篮球之路,拼搏至上,天赋其二,机遇在三!冠军之路,团队至上,防守其二,进攻在三!
  • 少奶奶不可能那么可爱

    少奶奶不可能那么可爱

    【先婚后爱】‘结婚’对于卫乘风来说就是一件无所谓的事,‘妻子’对他来说也是一个可有可无的摆设,可是结了婚之后才明白什么叫‘怼妻一时爽,追妻火葬场’。嫁入豪门,不安好心的继母,嫉妒成性的妹妹,从今以后都要看她的脸色。丈夫心中的白月光?没关系,她有的是办法让她变成他眼里的蚊子血。至于这个高大帅气但又直男癌晚期的丈夫嘛……苏篱就一句话:能过就过,不能过就拜拜!
  • 废妾惹桃花

    废妾惹桃花

    现代豪门千金冷书蝶因车祸魂飞异时空,附身南夏国卫王府侍妾姜云蕊身上。前姜云蕊清冷高傲,被人陷害偷窃卫王徐侧妃翡翠手镯而遭三十鞭毒打而死。当姜云蕊的身体里装着冷书蝶的灵魂后,因为她的与众不同,而吸引了众多“桃花”他,卫王夏候锦煜,有花心王爷之称,知道她是被人陷害,竟冷眼看着妻妾之间争斗,不管她的死活,只因他最爱的女子已经为他而死,他以为他今生不再动心,然碰到了被鞭打后苏醒过来的她,不一样的她,令他的心弦慢慢的被拨动了。他,夏候锦霖,一代君主,英明睿智,偶遇不一样的她,一点点的迷失了自己,然执着于儿女情长,如何计谋天下?他,东方邪,南夏国第一世家家主,在算计她的同时,却算漏了自己的心!他,慕容雪飒,出身高贵,她再多的冰冷言辞拒绝,也打消不了他誓必娶她为妻的念头!他,南宫昭延,温和有礼乃谦谦君子,甘心为她抛却第二世家家主身份,却只为了她无意中的一句戏言!他,齐之傲,乃他国之君,夺得了天下,却失去了让他魂牵梦萦的绝色红颜!他,顾斓秋,纵横四海,乃他国冷血战神,某天救了她之后,渐生情愫,何意百炼钢,化为绕指柔!他…她,不信感情,却被一缕又一缕的悠悠情愫所纠缠,繁华过后,是谁陪看夕阳彩虹,闲听雨打芭蕉?男主腹黑,女主聪明,宝贝可爱,加油收藏阅读哦,谢谢支持!
  • 若璃情

    若璃情

    出生在玛瑙谷里的若璃担任谷主一职,再后来认识一个叫张宇的男人,两个人互生情愫,在一起甜甜蜜蜜,在有一次事情中,,张宇迫于无奈,独自不迟而别就离开玛瑙谷……一年后,他再次出现在她面前,她却假装不识他,他痛苦万分,想发设法要帮她回忆起自己,之后发生一切种种之事,让他们更加觉得对方都离不开对方……
  • 四川文学(2016年第2期)

    四川文学(2016年第2期)

    《四川文学》: 文学刊物。以发表短篇小说为主,同时容纳其它文学体裁、品类,注重思想性与文学性的统一,刊物融现实性、艺术性、可读性于一体,聚读者、作者、编者为一家,所发作品受到省内外广大读者和全国各家文学选刊的青睐。
  • 盛世独宠之Boss你想干嘛

    盛世独宠之Boss你想干嘛

    当不小心和暗恋多年的男神同床共枕后,钟以情有了很多不好的打算。但没想到的是,后来……“躲什么,我又不会吃了你。”于深将她抱住。
  • The Augsburg Confession

    The Augsburg Confession

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。