登陆注册
5589700000103

第103章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(25)

If we take the 'self-preference principle'absolutely,the question becomes how a multitude of individuals,each separately pursuing his own happiness,can so arrange matters that their joint action may secure the happiness of all.Clearly a man,however selfish,has an interest generally in putting down theft and murder.He is already provided with a number of interests to which security,at least,and therefore a regular administration of justice,is essential.His shop could not be carried on without the police;and he may agree to pay the expenses,even if others reap the benefit in greater proportion.A theory of legislation,therefore,which supposes ready formed all the instincts which make a decent commercial society possible can do without much reference to sympathy or altruism.Bentham's man is not the colourless unit of a priori writing,nor the noble savage of Rousseau,but the respectable citizen with a policeman round the corner.Such a man may well hold that honesty is the best policy;he has enough sympathy to be kind to his old mother,and help a friend in distress;but the need of romantic and elevated conduct rarely occurs to him;and the heroic,if he meets it,appears to him as an exception,not far removed from the silly.He does not reflect --especially if he cares nothing for history --how even the society in which he is a contented unit has been built up,and how much loyalty and heroism has been needed for the work;nor even,to do him justice,what unsuspected capacities may lurk in his own commonplace character.The really characteristic point is,however,that Bentham does not clearly face the problem.He is content to take for granted as an ultimate fact that the self-interest principle in the long run coincides with the greatest 'happiness'principle,and leaves the problem to his successors.There we shall meet it again.

Finally,Bentham's view of religion requires a word.The short reply,however,would be sufficient,that he did not believe in any theology,and was in the main indifferent to the whole question till it encountered him in political matters.His first interest apparently was roused by the educational questions which I have noticed,and the proposal to teach the catechism Bentham,remembering the early bullying at Oxford,examines the catechism;and argues in his usual style that to enforce it is to compel children to tell lies.

But this leads him to assail the church generally;and he regards the church simply as a part of the huge corrupt machinery which elsewhere had created Judge and Co.He states many facts about non-residence and bloated bishoprics which had a very serious importance;and he then asks how the work might be done more cheaply.As a clergyman's only duty is to read weekly services and preach sermons,he suggests (whether seriously may be doubted)that this might be done as well by teaching a parish boy to read properly,and provide him with the prayer-book and the homilies.(123)A great deal of expense would be saved.This,again,seems to have led him to attack St.Paul,whom he took to be responsible for dogmatic theology,and therefore for the catechism;and he cross-examines the apostle,and confronts his various accounts of the conversion with a keenness worthy of a professional lawyer.In one of the MSS.at University College the same method is applied to the gospels.

Bentham was clearly not capable of anticipating Renan.From these studies he was led to the far more interesting book,published under the name of Philip Beauchamp.Bentham supplied the argument in part;but to me it seems clear that it owes so much to the editor,Grote,that it may more fitly be discussed hereafter.

The limitations and defects of Bentham's doctrine have been made abundantly evident by later criticism.They were due partly to his personal character,and partly to the intellectual and special atmosphere in which he was brought up.But it is more important to recognise the immense real value of his doctrine.

同类推荐
  • 培远堂手札节要

    培远堂手札节要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Story of the Treasure Seekers

    The Story of the Treasure Seekers

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 郡斋读书志

    郡斋读书志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大般涅槃经疏

    大般涅槃经疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东岳大生宝忏

    东岳大生宝忏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 当代神探汉尚斌

    当代神探汉尚斌

    老局长汉尚斌五十八岁这年被明升暗降,离开他工作了四十年的榆中县公安局,到兰州市公安局当员外——正处级调研员。临走那天,不知道怎么走漏了消息,县城不少人自发前来送行,挤满了公安局大院。几个被他救过命的人和得到他多年照顾的老干警,控制不住感情先哭了起来,立时全院的人哭声一片。
  • 哈利波特之兄弟会

    哈利波特之兄弟会

    这是一位刺客,追寻着信条的指引,行走在魔法世界的故事
  • 老子不怕你

    老子不怕你

    她的名字叫甄无情,而她这个人也绝对对得起她的名字,无情何止无情,还无欲无求,软硬不吃,厄。。。还有那么点粗鲁她大概是这个世界上最难搞的女人了父母携手去天堂报道那年,她刚好满十八岁拒绝了‘好心’亲人的照顾,毅然决然的带着足够她吃喝几辈子的遗产辗转到了外地她是个小富婆,可是她却从不买名牌,从不吃饭店她小气?NONO,她是想,钱还是省着花的好,这样就算不工作,也能活一辈子她无情,所以她无心、,几个贱男人被她迷的神魂颠倒之后,她却拍拍屁股走人她说,‘老子最讨厌占有欲强、爱吃醋的男人’片段:某扬,用力将手里大半截的烟头扔到地上,又上脚狠狠一碾,大吼道“带人去她公司,砸,砸到她老板开除她!”半个小时后,手下来电话说,某女被开除了,某扬乐了,小样的,看你没了工作还敢拒绝爷?一个月之后,某扬推桌子砸椅子,恨不得掏枪毙了眼前这些废物“废物!一群废物!”“老。。老大。。。她其实是个小富婆。”某硕美滋滋的买了美味早餐给‘女友’送来,可是开门的却是一个只穿了个小裤头的男人“呀,对不起,敲错门了。”退回,仔细看了看门牌号,1001,没错啊,“那个,请问一下,这是无情的家吗?”某央揉了揉一头乱发,慵懒的转身去问那个同样一脸惺忪的某女,“喂,你是叫无情吗?”某硕跳进屋子,指着穿着暴露的某女大叫,“你你你。。。你对得起我吗?”某女揉揉额角,不耐烦的道,“闭嘴!”甄无情老子的人生才刚开始,没空跟你们缠绵,想要孩子?出了大门左转再右转(那里是婚介所哦)米硕情情,咱俩好些年没见了,来,上床聊聊天(注:他们俩是青梅竹马)墨央我的命是你救的,那我的人便是你的了,别激动,没人跟你抢宗政扬要抓住一个男人的心,先要抓住他的胃,女人,你成功了一无情女游荡在三个男人之间,他们会有怎样的故事,又会有怎样的结局呢?宝们,想知道就收藏吧※下面是领养名单米硕被fygutj领养墨央被夏天的墨迹领养无情被冰灵沫沫领养宗政扬被鱼缸里的宝宝领养战青被骨哒领养吴玉娇被小亞子领养友情链接《总裁的迷糊妻》雨落清曦
  • 只想当个牧羊人

    只想当个牧羊人

    当统治者是放牧,做神棍也是放牧。只是不管是怎么样的放牧方式,都是在放养一群比狼更加可怖的存在,智慧生命。
  • 符箓少女种田记

    符箓少女种田记

    一朝穿成大户人家不受宠的大小姐,养在乡下别院,种种灵田修修仙,且看美术系小妞变身超级符箓少女,炮灰嫡女大翻身。林幼娘的优势就是大户人家的小姐好活命。画笔在手,符箓我有。前面帅哥你慢走,本姑娘见你骨骼清奇,姑奶奶要收了。神马?你是我哥?那啥……亲哥哥,见到亲妹子先赏个红包玩玩吧,太少你都不好意思拿出手吧。
  • 学霸修真

    学霸修真

    真气复苏一个月后,大二学生陆小奇得到修真APP,开启人生的春天。“两年内,你若没突破后天境,就回来跟我当茅山道士!”——来自陆小奇的父亲。“陆小奇,你在砖窑直播抓妖的特效真棒!火箭送上!”——来自直播间的土豪。(本书大改,可从第三卷开始读,前两卷改为短篇)
  • 双溪杂记

    双溪杂记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 人脉黄金法则

    人脉黄金法则

    有人脉,成功就像坐电梯;没人脉,成功就像爬楼梯。你认识谁,比你是谁更为重要。30天,让你拥有超级黄金人脉,从此改变人生的命运。
  • 迷失西城

    迷失西城

    那年冬天,周荣穿一身保安服回到九台。有人说他像警察,也有人说,不对,像消防队员。周荣说,是保安,也和警察差不多吧。宋祥生也来了周荣家,说过完年也要和他一起进城。一晃儿的工夫,年就过完了,宋祥生扛了个行李卷和周荣去了西城。周荣把宋祥生安排到一家建筑工地。那晚,宋祥生和周荣去工地的路上,看着马路两边闪烁的一盏盏霓虹灯,耳朵里听到的是歌手满文军唱的一首歌,他不知道歌的名字叫什么,只听到了两句歌词:你静静地离去,一步一步孤独的背影。不知为什么,心里竟有些空落落的,传说中的城市在他看来,是离自己很远的那种感觉。
  • 药园

    药园

    满园药香遮不住,金银财宝进家来,家和万事兴。