登陆注册
5589700000103

第103章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(25)

If we take the 'self-preference principle'absolutely,the question becomes how a multitude of individuals,each separately pursuing his own happiness,can so arrange matters that their joint action may secure the happiness of all.Clearly a man,however selfish,has an interest generally in putting down theft and murder.He is already provided with a number of interests to which security,at least,and therefore a regular administration of justice,is essential.His shop could not be carried on without the police;and he may agree to pay the expenses,even if others reap the benefit in greater proportion.A theory of legislation,therefore,which supposes ready formed all the instincts which make a decent commercial society possible can do without much reference to sympathy or altruism.Bentham's man is not the colourless unit of a priori writing,nor the noble savage of Rousseau,but the respectable citizen with a policeman round the corner.Such a man may well hold that honesty is the best policy;he has enough sympathy to be kind to his old mother,and help a friend in distress;but the need of romantic and elevated conduct rarely occurs to him;and the heroic,if he meets it,appears to him as an exception,not far removed from the silly.He does not reflect --especially if he cares nothing for history --how even the society in which he is a contented unit has been built up,and how much loyalty and heroism has been needed for the work;nor even,to do him justice,what unsuspected capacities may lurk in his own commonplace character.The really characteristic point is,however,that Bentham does not clearly face the problem.He is content to take for granted as an ultimate fact that the self-interest principle in the long run coincides with the greatest 'happiness'principle,and leaves the problem to his successors.There we shall meet it again.

Finally,Bentham's view of religion requires a word.The short reply,however,would be sufficient,that he did not believe in any theology,and was in the main indifferent to the whole question till it encountered him in political matters.His first interest apparently was roused by the educational questions which I have noticed,and the proposal to teach the catechism Bentham,remembering the early bullying at Oxford,examines the catechism;and argues in his usual style that to enforce it is to compel children to tell lies.

But this leads him to assail the church generally;and he regards the church simply as a part of the huge corrupt machinery which elsewhere had created Judge and Co.He states many facts about non-residence and bloated bishoprics which had a very serious importance;and he then asks how the work might be done more cheaply.As a clergyman's only duty is to read weekly services and preach sermons,he suggests (whether seriously may be doubted)that this might be done as well by teaching a parish boy to read properly,and provide him with the prayer-book and the homilies.(123)A great deal of expense would be saved.This,again,seems to have led him to attack St.Paul,whom he took to be responsible for dogmatic theology,and therefore for the catechism;and he cross-examines the apostle,and confronts his various accounts of the conversion with a keenness worthy of a professional lawyer.In one of the MSS.at University College the same method is applied to the gospels.

Bentham was clearly not capable of anticipating Renan.From these studies he was led to the far more interesting book,published under the name of Philip Beauchamp.Bentham supplied the argument in part;but to me it seems clear that it owes so much to the editor,Grote,that it may more fitly be discussed hereafter.

The limitations and defects of Bentham's doctrine have been made abundantly evident by later criticism.They were due partly to his personal character,and partly to the intellectual and special atmosphere in which he was brought up.But it is more important to recognise the immense real value of his doctrine.

同类推荐
  • 佛说目连所问经

    佛说目连所问经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 清世宗实录台湾资料选辑

    清世宗实录台湾资料选辑

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Remember the Alamo

    Remember the Alamo

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 易学滥觞

    易学滥觞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • On Dreams

    On Dreams

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 野性的呼唤

    野性的呼唤

    写给世间每一个孤独的灵魂!用锋利的文字,展现了世间每一个生命原始的勇气和力量。《野性的呼唤》用锋利的文字,展现了世间每一个生命原始的勇气和力量。写的是动物,说的是人,明明是文学,却读出了活生生的人世。动物小说的经典之作,自然主义的代表作。20世纪百佳英文小说,88本塑造美国的书之一。本书收录了杰克·伦敦中短篇小说的代表作——《野性的呼唤》《白牙》《热爱生命》和《生火》,故事都主要发生在加拿大西北部的极寒之地,风格壮烈而阳刚,尽显生命原始的坚韧、勇气和力量。
  • 重生之养成小娇妻

    重生之养成小娇妻

    于妹前二十年的人生一帆风顺,后二十年的人生却异常的艰辛。丈夫出轨,一个人将女儿带大,看着女儿结婚有了照顾她的男人,于妹无力躺在床上,醒来后居然回到了两岁的时候。人生重来,这一次她绝不让父母再为了自己卑躬屈膝,要让父母幸福安渡晚年。前世被自己年幼无知害的没了出生机会的弟弟,这一世她会让弟弟平安降生!当拥有小小志向的于妹不在愚昧,她发誓这一次绝不再找一个大男子主义又没担当的丈夫,一定要睁大眼睛找一个疼爱自己的男人!但是找啊找啊……诶诶,原来男神一直在身边!
  • 重生农女之药园空间

    重生农女之药园空间

    前世是军医世家的继承人,一手针灸出神入化。今世是农家小娘子,先是被浪荡子调戏,再被未婚夫退亲,一气之下投了河。当军医女王成为农家小娘子,看她如何在这个异世大干一场。
  • 九世倾城

    九世倾城

    胡菁因罪被囚在时空囚笼里。那个时间段里有一个雄才大略的皇帝,一群豪爽大方的将军,有各色的英俊少年……十六年一个循环,十六年期满,一切刷新重置。她只想在这段历史里小小的煽动一下翅膀,可一切却是无限穿越,无限重生,N次方的穿越,她如何破局?
  • 墨染星盈

    墨染星盈

    异世重生,神秘吊坠,父母的离奇失踪,一切事件的背后,究竟是谁在操控……“放心,有我。”还是那么的暖心,这一世,终是没有负你。
  • 茶归暖风时

    茶归暖风时

    “无论如何我都不可能娶那个你们随随便便给我安排的女孩!”五年后“那个……卿卿结个婚?”“不好意思,我不嫁。”女孩撇了他一眼,当初谁把我耍的团团转来着?嫁给他,不可能!男孩沉思了一下,斟酌的开口,“我嫁也行,卿卿你娶我吧!”茶思卿:????【男女主身心干净,1V1,请安心入坑,小甜饼!】
  • 柳林中的风声(语文新课标课外必读第十二辑)

    柳林中的风声(语文新课标课外必读第十二辑)

    语文新课标指定了中小学生的阅读书目,对阅读的数量、内容、质量以及速度都提出了明确的要求,这对于提高广大学生的阅读写作能力,培养语文素养,促进终身学习等具有深远的意义。
  • 农家弃女

    农家弃女

    她堂堂一铁血女特工竟然穿越了!还穿越成一未婚生子还被家人抛弃的女人!罢罢罢,反正她一直是一个人,无所谓,该怎么过怎么过,现在最重要的是赚钱养家养儿子。什么?婶婶想谋她的儿子卖钱?想都别想。
  • 白夜恋人

    白夜恋人

    男主角杨启程以帮忙看管酒吧为生,有一天,住在自家对门的小女孩杨静母亲自杀去世,杨启程出于一时的恻隐之心,收留了杨静。
  • 你是我藏不住的秘密

    你是我藏不住的秘密

    和一个对的人相爱是什么感觉呢?她,林以沫,没有父亲,没有母亲,只是一个和外婆相依为命的小小孤女。这样的她,只要看到一点点温暖都应该拼命抓住吧,可是面对这个从小保护她的少年的告白时,她坚定的摇了摇头,因为她难以启齿的卑微和一个深藏心底的秘密……她说不可以,可是他,不这么觉得。他帮她赶走了嘲讽她身世的人,他为她教训了给她一身伤痕的初恋,他以亲人的名义给了她最好的保护,然后一直陪伴着她、信任着她、爱慕着她……“沫沫,你知道和一个对的人相爱是什么感觉吗?和对的人并肩,从来不需要成为更好的人,做自己就好了。”原来这就是爱情,她以为要一路小跑才能跟上他,但竟然发现他放慢了脚步等她……