登陆注册
5589700000102

第102章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(24)

The individual is already there.The moral and the legal sanctions are 'external';something imposed by the action of others;corresponding to 'coercion,'whether by physical force or the dread of public opinion;and,in any case,an accretion or addition,not a profound modification of his whole nature.The Utilitarian 'man'therefore inclines to consider other people as merely parts of the necessary machinery.Their feelings are relevant only as influencing their outward conduct.If a man gives me a certain 'lot'of pain or pleasure,it does not matter what may be his motives.The 'motive'for all conduct corresponds in all cases to the pain or pleasure accruing to the agent.It is true that his happiness will be more or less affected by his relations to others.But as conduct is ruled by a calculation of the balance of pains or pleasures dependent upon any course of action,it simplifies matters materially,if each man regards his neighbour's feelings simply as instrumental,not intrinsically interesting.And thus the coincidence between that conduct which maximises my happiness and that conduct which maximises happiness in general,must be regarded as more or less accidental or liable in special cases to disappear.

If I am made happier by action which makes others miserable,the rule of utility will lead to my preference of myself.

Here we have the question whether the Utilitarian system be essentially a selfish system.Bentham,with his vague psychology,does not lay down the doctrine absolutely.After giving this list of self-regarding 'springs of action,'he proceeds to add the pleasures and pains of 'sympathy'and 'antipathy'which,he says,are not self-regarding.Moreover,as we have seen,he has some difficulty in denying that 'benevolence'is a necessarily moral motive:it is only capable of prompting to bad conduct in so far as it is insufficiently enlightened;and it is clear that a moralist who makes the 'greatest happiness of the greatest number'his universal test,has some reason for admitting as an elementary pleasure the desire for the greatest happiness.This comes out curiously in the Constitutional Code.He there lays down the 'self-preference principle'--the principle,namely,that 'every human being'is determined in every action by his judgment of what will produce the greatest happiness to himself,'whatsoever be the effect.in relation to the happiness of other similar beings,any or all of them taken together.'(117)Afterwards,however,he observes that it is 'the constant and arduous task or every moralist'and of every legislator who deserves the name to 'increase the influence of sympathy at the expense of that of self-regard and of sympathy for the greater number at the expense of sympathy for the lesser number.'(118)He tries to reconcile these views by the remark 'that even sympathy has its root in self-regard,'and he argues,as Mr Herbert Spencer has done more fully,that if Adam cared only for Eve and Eve only for Adam --neither caring at all for himself or herself --both would perish in less than a year.Self-regard,that is,is essential,and sympathy supposes its existence.Hence Bentham puts himself through a catechism.(119)What is the 'best'government?That which causes the greatest happiness of the given community.What community?

'Any community,which is as much as to say,every community.'But why do you desire this happiness?Because the establishment of that happiness would contribute to my greatest happiness.And how do you prove that you desire this result?By my labours to obtain it,replies Bentham.This oddly omits the more obvious question,how can you be sure that your happiness will be promoted by the greatest happiness of all?What if the two criteria differ?

I desire the general happiness,he might have replied,because my benevolence is an original or elementary instinct which can override my self-love;or I desire it,he would perhaps have said,because I know as a fact that the happiness of others will incidentally contribute to my own.The first answer would fall in with some of his statements;but the second is,as I think must be admitted,more in harmony with his system.Perhaps,indeed,the most characteristic thing is Bentham's failure to discuss explicitly the question whether human action is or is not necessarily 'selfish.'He tells us in regard to the 'springs of action'that all human action is always 'interested,'but explains that the word properly includes actions in which the motive is not 'self-regarding.'(120)It merely means,in fact,that all conduct has motives.The statement which I have quoted about the 'self-preference'principle may only mean a doctrine which is perfectly compatible with a belief in 'altruism'--the doctrine,namely,that as a fact most people are chiefly interested by their own affairs.The legislator,he tells us,should try to increase sympathy,but the less he takes sympathy for the 'basis of his arrangements'--that is,the less call he makes upon purely unselfish motives --the greater will be his success.(121)This is a shrewd and,I should say,a very sound remark,but it implies --not that all motives are selfish in the last analysis,but --that the legislation should not assume too exalted a level of ordinary morality.The utterances in the very unsatisfactory Deontology are of little value,and seem to imply a moral sentiment corresponding to a petty form of commonplace prudence.(122)Leaving this point,however,the problem necessarily presented itself to Bentham in a form in which selfishness is the predominating force,and any recognition of independent benevolence rather an incumbrance than a help.

同类推荐
  • 阿育王譬喻经

    阿育王譬喻经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上七星神咒经

    太上七星神咒经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 金锁流珠引

    金锁流珠引

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 嘉运

    嘉运

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • THE ILIAD

    THE ILIAD

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 降三世忿怒明王念诵仪轨

    降三世忿怒明王念诵仪轨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 擦去心灵的尘土

    擦去心灵的尘土

    本书教育人们怎么在各种环境中面对各种不同的情况时,应该拥有怎样的正确心态,并且如何调整自己的心态。
  • 总裁的失宠少奶奶(全本)

    总裁的失宠少奶奶(全本)

    所有人都羡慕孤儿院出身的她麻雀变凤凰,找到了一个有财有势且万般宠爱她的男人!可是新婚之夜,他却一反常态……她不敢相信先前那么宠爱自己的男人竟然会这么对待自己,可是当事情的真相涌出水面,她才发现,原来自己的爱,竟是他复仇的工具……=========================娶她,只不过是他复仇的一个步骤。可是随着两人的相处,他心中的仇恨却抵不过她温柔的笑容……心中日益生出的爱,与日渐生长的情谊,逼得他不知如何是好!复仇,早已经变了质;他的冷酷和无情在无形中悄悄的瓦解……
  • 生死状

    生死状

    程喜田从镇长办公室里出来,下了楼,就看见镇委大院里摆了好几张桌子,桌子前围了一群年轻人。这些年轻人有外村的,也有他们村的,手里都拿着一份合同样的东西。有的在看着,有的按在桌子上,在写着什么。程喜田有些不相信自己的眼睛,明明知道这厂子有这么大的危险,却还是往里钻吗?为了几个钱,这些人连命也不要了吗?他三步并做两步,蹿到那些年轻人跟前。他拨拉开人群,从一个年轻人手里抢过一份协议,站在那里,迅速地浏览着上面的字句。他看到,上面印着的是进厂后的待遇、双方的责任义务等,当然,除此之外,上面也不乏“全厂职工要维护厂子的荣誉,不泄漏秘密”等语。他感到喉咙干干的,似乎有啥东西从腔子里在往外冒。他心想,这不是啥用工协议,这是一份卖身契,这是一份生死状嘛!
  • 穷二代富二代2

    穷二代富二代2

    这是一个普通人的奋斗史,有你的影子,也有我的影子;这是一个朴实的故事,生动、亲切,融入了你我的生活。  生动的叙述、实用具体的融合剖析、独到的心理描写,相信会给众多的有志青年点燃一盏心灵明灯。  相集,生活不会辜负有志者。只要努力、只要找到合适的杠杆和支点,你就一定能撬起巨大的财富。
  • 道德故事

    道德故事

    无数事实、经验和理性已经证明:好故事可以影响人的一生。而以我们之见,所谓好故事,在内容上讲述的应是做人与处世的道理,在形式上也应听得进、记得住、讲得出、传得开,而且不会因时代的变迁而失去她的本质特征和艺术光彩。为了让更多的读者走进好故事,阅读好故事,欣赏好故事,珍藏好故事,传播好故事,我们特编选了一套“故事会5元精品系列”以飨之。其选择标准主要有以下三点:一、在《故事会》杂志上发表的作品。二、有过目不忘的艺术感染力。三、有恒久的趣味,对今天的读者仍有启迪作用。愿好故事伴随你的一生!
  • 倾我一生换你浅笑安然

    倾我一生换你浅笑安然

    某日,贺琛和朋友放大话,说:“我贺琛这辈子都不可能再回头找黎郁子,我要再喜欢她我就是狗。”后来,“郁子,你饿了吗?”“郁子,你累不累?”“郁子,你缺司机吗?”满脸殷勤的贺琛就差没摇尾巴了。“听说,谁喜欢我谁是狗?”“汪汪汪~”“汪汪汪~”(当初的贺琛有多傲娇,现在就有多后悔)
  • 如果未来没有你

    如果未来没有你

    王子安是尹相思用整个青春去爱的人尹相思是王子安爱而无能为力的人尹相思是厉莫阳愿意用一生去守护的人尹相思说“如果未来没有你,我的人生也许就失去了方向吧”后来王子安说“如果未来没有你,我可能就会一直到死都从事我现在的职业”直到很多年以后,两人再次相见时,一个温柔如往昔,一个凌厉如当年,看似未变,实则都早已不是当年的尹相思和王子安。也再没有“玲珑骰子安红豆,入骨相思知不知”的诗意了。
  • 同桌冤家:考试真疯狂

    同桌冤家:考试真疯狂

    伍美珍,喜欢小朋友、喜欢开玩笑,被好友昵称为“美美”的人。善于用键盘敲故事、而用钢笔却写不出一个故事的……奇怪的人。在大学课堂讲授一本正经的写作原理的人,在小学校园和孩子们笑谈轻松阅读和快乐写作的人,在杂志中充当“阳光姐姐”为消解小朋友的烦恼出主意的人。每天电子信箱里都会堆满“小情书”,其内容大都是“阳光姐姐,我好喜欢你”这样情真意切表白的……幸福的人。已敲出七十多本书的……超人!
  • 七年之约:沈少别来无恙

    七年之约:沈少别来无恙

    小雨!再给我一点时间,我会回来娶你!”沈言对着柯雨离去的背影大喊。柯雨停下脚步回头泪水模糊了她的双眼:“沈言,七年,七年了,你看我等来了什么?啊?难道还不够吗?七年,我累了~我们好聚好散吧。”她含泪笑着说,她的身影慢慢的模糊了,沈言想去抓住,可却什么也抓不住。“小雨!小雨!”沈言从梦中惊醒,豆大的汗不断的往下淌着……--情节虚构,请勿模仿