登陆注册
5589700000047

第47章 PHILOSOPHY(1)

I.John Horne Tooke

I have so far dwelt upon the social and political environment of the early Utilitarian movement;and have tried also to point out some of the speculative tendencies fostered by the position.If it be asked what philosophical doctrines were explicitly taught,the answer must be a very short one.English philosophy barely existed.Parr was supposed to know something about metaphysics --apparently because he could write good Latin.But the inference was hasty.

Of one book,however,which had a real influence,I must say something,for though it contained little definite philosophy,it showed what kind of philosophy was congenial to the common-sense of the time.The sturdy radical,Horne Tooke,had been led to the study of philology by a characteristic incident.

The legal question had arisen whether the words,'She,knowing that Crooke had been indicted for forgery,'did so and so,contained an averment that Crooke had been indicted.Tooke argued in a letter to Dunning(1)that they did;because they were equivalent to the phrase,'Crooke had been indicted for forgery:she,knowing that,'did so and so.This raises the question.

What is the meaning of 'that'?Tooke took up the study,thinking,as he says,that it would throw light upon some philosophical questions.He learned some Anglo-Saxon and Gothic to test his theory and,of course,confirmed it.(2)The book shows ingenuity,shrewdness,and industry,and Tooke deserves credit for seeing the necessity of applying a really historical method to his problem,though his results were necessarily crude in the prescientific stage of philology.

The book is mainly a long string of etymologies,which readers of different tastes have found intolerably dull or an amusing collection of curiosities.

Tooke held,and surely with reason,that an investigation of language,the great instrument of thought,may help to throw light upon the process of thinking.He professes to be a disciple of Locke in philosophy as in politics.

Locke,he said,(3)made a lucky mistake in calling his book an essay upon human understanding;for he thus attracted many who would have been repelled had he called it what it really was,'a treatise upon words and language.'

According to Tooke,in fact,(4)what we call 'operations of mind'are only 'operations of language.'The mind contemplates nothing but 'impressions,'that is,'sensations or feelings,'which Locke called 'ideas.'Locke mistook composition of terms for composition of ideas.To compound ideas is impossible.

We can only use one term as a sign of many ideas.Locke,again,supposed that affirming and denying were operations of the mind,whereas they are only artifices of language.(5)The mind,then,can only contemplate,separately or together,aggregates of 'ideas,'ultimate atoms,incapable of being parted or dissolved.There are,therefore,only two classes of words,nouns and verbs;all others,prepositions,conjunctions,and so forth,being abbreviations,a kind of mental shorthand to save the trouble of enumerating the separate items.Tooke,in short,is a thorough-going nominalist.The realities,according to him,are sticks,stones,and material objects,or the 'ideas'which 'represent'them.They can be stuck together or taken apart,but all the words which express relations,categories,and the like,are in themselves meaningless.The special objects of his scorn are 'Hermes'Harris,and Monboddo,who had tried to defend Aristotle against Locke.Monboddo had asserted that 'every kind of relation'is a pure 'idea of the intellect'not to be apprehended by sense.(6)If so,according to Tooke,it would be a nonentity.

This doctrine gives a short cut to the abolition of metaphysics.The word 'metaphysics,'says Tooke,(7)is nonsense.All metaphysical controversies are 'founded on the grossest ignorance of words and the nature of speech.'

The greatest part of his second volume is concerned with etymologies intended to prove that an 'abstract idea'is a mere word.Abstract words,he says,(8)are generally 'participles without a substantive and therefore in construction used as substantives.'From a misunderstanding of this has arisen 'metaphysical jargon'and 'false morality.'In illustration he gives a singular list of words,including 'fate,chance,heaven,hell,providence,prudence,innocence,substance,fiend,angel,apostle,spirit,true,false,desert,merit,faith,etc.all of which are mere participles poetically embodied and substantiated by those who use them.'A couple of specific applications,often quoted by later writers,will sufficiently indicate his drift.

Such words,he remarks,(9)as 'right'and 'just'mean simply that which is ordered or commanded.The chapter is headed 'rights of man,'and Tooke's interlocutor naturally observes that this is a singular result for a democrat.

Man,it would seem,has no rights except the rights created by the law.Tooke admits the inference to be correct,but replies that the democrat in disobeying human law may be obeying the law of God,and is obeying the law of God when he obeys the law of nature.The interlocutor does not inquire what Tooke could mean by the 'law of nature.'We can guess what Tooke would have said to Paine in the Wimbledon garden.In fact,however,Tooke is here,as elsewhere,following Hobbes,though,it seems,unconsciously.Another famous etymology is that of 'truth'from 'troweth.'(10)Truth is what each man thinks.There is no such thing,therefore,as 'eternal,immutable,everlasting truth,unless mankind,such as they are at present,be eternal,immutable,everlasting.'

Two persons may contradict each other and yet each may be speaking what is true for him.Truth may be a vice as well as a virtue;for on many occasions it is wrong to speak the truth.

同类推荐
  • 潜夫论笺校正

    潜夫论笺校正

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 狱中上母书

    狱中上母书

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 亨利四世下篇

    亨利四世下篇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上救苦天尊说拔度血湖宝忏

    太上救苦天尊说拔度血湖宝忏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 东瀛识略

    东瀛识略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 识小编

    识小编

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 暖夏夜未央

    暖夏夜未央

    暖朵在与夏未央因误会分开后,经历了各种各样的挫折,好不容易做了平面模特,而后却被骗签了卖身合同,此时,夏未央却再次出现,将她的卖身合同以公司百分之五十的股份买下。从此,暖朵便成为了夏未央的附属品,只是夏未央对暖朵此女中年如一日,还是向儿时一般宠溺……
  • 老高的病

    老高的病

    同学拍拍老高的肩膀,笑道:行了行了,这也是个教训,今后啊,能不管的闲事尽量别管。再说了,行有行规,家有家法,医院不能给患白血病的孩子免费治疗,肯定有他们的难处,你对医疗行业一窍不通,不能轻易说人家不合理。老高抬眼瞪着同学,想说什么,又把话咽了下去。同学说:破财免灾,破财免灾。老高说:你怎么和我老婆说一样的话?哎,这就对了。这说明我和你老婆不是一根筋,这里很正常。同学边说边抬起一只手,指了指自己的脑袋。
  • 相思歇

    相思歇

    前世今生,今生前世。魂落幽冥,断了情思。黄泉九府,忘川千魂,彼岸花开。我历千重劫,我经万道险。抹不去,那一缕情思入骨。归来时,却叹世事多变,相思湮灭!
  • 重生之宠爱万千

    重生之宠爱万千

    重生前的沈宁曾穿越到一个不知名的朝代,由商家寡妇一路坐上了皇后之位,与皇帝鹣鲽情深,最后又被临死的皇帝送回了现代,居然回到了她穿越前的那一刻!重生回来的她遇到转世的皇帝,在自己地盘上变得又乔又作令人发指!转世的皇帝心疼她前世苦难与委屈,将她宠得无法无天人神共愤!
  • 哈佛大学的第一堂理财课

    哈佛大学的第一堂理财课

    《哈佛大学的第一堂理财课 》一书中深入阐释了哈佛大学第一堂经济学课的两个重要概念:“花钱要区分投资行为与消费行为”,“每月先储蓄30%的工资,剩下的再进行消费”。然后引领读者了解当下最热门的理财投资品种:房产、黄金、股票、基金、债券、外汇。最后给出切实的忠告,避免盲目投资。哈尔滨出版社出版的《哈佛大学的第一堂理财课 》是一本实用的理财投资书,有助于读者了解理财投资,掌握实用的理财投资技巧,并引导读者树立正确的理财投资观。
  • 二零计划

    二零计划

    如果,给我一个机会,我会好好把握,然后......
  • 阿尔法星系

    阿尔法星系

    主要是介绍主角通过科技穿越新时代,名为阿尔法岛,遇到女主发展感情,二人开始一段冒险的旅程。
  • 易天卦

    易天卦

    女警唐霜被上司陷害,身陷囹圄,在宣判执行死刑之际,却灵魂出窍穿越时空,在平行世界,不同的生活,人物却离奇一致,唐霜却在另一个世界也再度面临生死挑战,唐霜靠着不断的努力,打怪升级,踏入上层圈,开启人生开挂模式。
  • 军统“密杀令”失窃案

    军统“密杀令”失窃案

    1943年5月1日,上海临安路135弄一幢不引人注目的陈旧小洋房内发生了一起莫名其妙的盗窃案。由于被窃的赃物是一份由国民党军统局首脑戴笠签署并报请蒋介石批准的“特别密杀令”,该案遂成为惊动远在重庆的戴笠和时任汪伪政府要职的大汉奸周佛海日夜关注的特别重大案件……这是一条位于上海闹市区中心地带的著名马路,早在1865年就已修筑,属于法租界范围,最初名叫公馆马路,1907年由法租界工部更名为巨籁达路,1913年又改为恺自尔路。太平洋战争爆发后,日本侵略军全面占领上海,遂改名为临安路。