登陆注册
5589700000048

第48章 PHILOSOPHY(2)

These phrases may possibly be interpreted in a sense less paradoxical than the obvious one.Tooke's philosophy,if so it is to be called,was never fully expounded.He burned his papers before his death,and we do not know what he would have said about 'verbs,'which must have led,one would suppose,to some further treatment of relations,nor upon the subject,which as Stephens tells us,was most fully treated in his continuation,the value of human testimony.

If Tooke was not a philosopher he was a man of remarkably shrewd cynical common-sense,who thought philosophy idle foppery.His book made a great success.Stephens tells us(11)that it brought him £4000or £5000.

Hazlitt in 1810published a grammar professing to incorporate for the first time Horne Tooke's 'discoveries.'The book was admired by Mackintosh,(12)who,of course,did not accept the principles,and had a warm disciple in Charles Richardson (1775-1865),who wrote in its defence against Dugald Stewart and accepted its authority in his elaborate dictionary of the English language.(13)But its chief interest for us is that it was a great authority with James Mill.Mill accepts the etymologies,and there is much in common between the two writers,though Mill had learned his main doctrines elsewhere,especially from Hobbes.What the agreement really shows is how the intellectual idiosyncrasy which is congenial to 'nominalism'in philosophy was also congenial to Tooke's matter of fact radicalism and to the Utilitarian position of Bentham and his followers.

II.DUGALD STEWART

If English philosophy was a blank,there was still a leader of high reputation in Scotland.Dugald Stewart (1753-1828)had a considerable influence upon the Utilitarians.He represented,On the one hand,the doctrines which they thought themselves specially bound to attack,and it may perhaps be held that in some ways he betrayed to them the key of the position.Stewart(14)was son of a professor of mathematics at Edinburgh.He studied at Glasgow (1771-72)where he became Reid's favourite pupil and devoted friend.In 1772he became the assistant,and in 1775the colleague,of his father,and he appears to have had a considerable knowledge of mathematics.In 1785he succeeded Adam Ferguson as professor of moral philosophy and lectured continuously until 1810.He then gave up his active duties to Thomas Brown,devoting himself to the completion and publication of the substance of his lectures.Upon Brown's death in 1820,he resigned a post to which he was no longer equal.

A paralytic stroke in 1822weakened him,though he was still able to write.

He died in 1828.

If Stewart now makes no great mark in histories of philosophy,his personal influence was conspicuous.Cockburn describes him as of delicate appearance,with a massive head,bushy eyebrows,gray intelligent eyes,flexible mouth and expressive countenance.His voice was sweet and his ear exquisite.Cockburn never heard a better reader,and his manners,though rather formal,were graceful and dignified.James Mill,after hearing Pitt and Fox,declared that Stewart was their superior in eloquence.At Edinburgh,then at the height of its intellectual activity,he held his own among the ablest men and attracted the loyalty of the younger.Students came not only from Scotland but from England,the United States,France and Germany.(15)Scott won the professor's approval by an essay on the 'Customs of the Northern Nations.'Jeffrey,Horner,Cockburn and Mackintosh were among his disciples.His lectures upon Political Economy were attended by Sydney Smith,Jeffrey and Brougham,and one of his last hearers was Lord Palmerston.Parr looked up to him as a great philosopher,and contributed to his works an essay upon the etymology of the word 'sublime,'too vast to be printed whole.Stewart was an upholder of Whig principles,when the Scottish government was in the hands of the staunchest Tories.The irreverent young Edinburgh Reviewers treated him with respect,and to some extent applied his theory to politics.Stewart was the philosophical heir of Reid;and,one may say,was a Whig both in philosophy and in politics.

He was a rationalist,but within the limits fixed by respectability;and he dreaded the revolution in politics,and believed in the surpassing merits of the British Constitution as interpreted by the respectable Whigs.

Stewart represents the 'common-sense'doctrine.That name,as he observes,lends itself to an equivocation.Common-sense is generally used as nearly synonymous with 'mother wit,'the average opinion of fairly intelligent men;and he would prefer to speak of the 'fundamental laws of belief.'(16)There can,however,be no doubt that the doctrine derived much of its strength from the apparent confirmation of the 'average opinion'by the 'fundamental laws.'On one side,said Reid,are all the vulgar;on the other all the philosophers.

'In this division,to my great humiliation,I find myself classed with the vulgar.'(17)Reid,in fact,had opposed the theories of Hume and Berkeley because they led to a paradoxical scepticism.If it be,as Reid held,a legitimate inference from Berkeley that a man may as well run his head against a post,there can be no doubt that it is shocking to common sense in every acceptation of the word.The reasons,however,which Reid and Stewart alleged for not performing that feat took a special form,which I am compelled to notice briefly because they set up the mark for the whole intellectual artillery of the Utilitarians.Reid,in fact,invented what J.S.Mill called 'intuitions.'

同类推荐
  • 医原

    医原

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 苌楚斋续笔

    苌楚斋续笔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 女科秘要

    女科秘要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 广志

    广志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上灵宝洪福灭罪像名经

    太上灵宝洪福灭罪像名经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 倾世谪仙

    倾世谪仙

    一花一世界,一树一菩提。世人皆知,人欲成神!却不知,神欲成仙!!!
  • 元故宫遗录

    元故宫遗录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 纨绔特工之腹黑大小姐

    纨绔特工之腹黑大小姐

    “男人,你可要想好了!你再动就别想过好下半辈子了!”然而某男仅动用了几根手指头,看着自己下身前抵着的银针慢慢消散不要脸道:“小烟儿,同样的招数用了第二遍可就不起作用了哦,今晚你跑不掉了!”她,是21世纪人人闻风丧胆的王牌特工,代号“绯”,身法绝妙,精通医毒,怎料遭到朋友的算计,一朝穿越成了下等国镇国候府的废材大小姐;他,是修真界无人不知的特等国摄政王,强大而又冷漠,却唯独对她百般宠溺。且看她如何一袭红衣走天下,一身风华,傲视天下!【本文女强男强,男女主身心干净,宠文无虐,欢迎入坑~】
  • 无限之末日使者

    无限之末日使者

    新人新作,文笔很烂勿吐槽。主要讲的是一个宅男意外进入到无限恐怖的世界,一步步成为最终boss的故事
  • 唐玄宗御制道德真经疏一

    唐玄宗御制道德真经疏一

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 弑神之我主沉浮

    弑神之我主沉浮

    我是凌毅,一当代大学生,却因为一场雷电,来到了异世大陆,家族宗门林立,丛林法则,优胜劣汰,还有神作威作福,凭什么?我欲突破自我,成就大业,弑神异世,维新秩序。
  • 我的世界模组生存记

    我的世界模组生存记

    某人:我有最终之剑!赵木……某人:我有无限矿物!赵木:……某人:我有神一般的效果!赵木不动声色,在聊天界面输入“/kill某人”于是,世界上少了一个叫某人的人。(以上全都是赵木的想象)且看赵木是如何与整个因特网一起毁灭/重塑整个世界
  • 狐狸男孩

    狐狸男孩

    本书的主人公,叫13号,是一只半人半狐狸的混血男孩,他只有一个耳朵,没有尾巴,非常害羞,几乎说不出完整的句子,他被囚禁在孤儿院里生活和工作,被高帽党统治,被院长打骂,被同类排挤,他没有自由,没有梦想,没有朋友,甚至被禁止听到音乐,直到有一天,他突然发现自己听懂了动物间的秘密语言,一切就此改变。
  • 公子点墨:坐上琴心不思归

    公子点墨:坐上琴心不思归

    一道圣旨,将素未谋面的两个人结成夫妻。一个是京城混世小魔女陆淮湘,一个是江安浊世佳公子贺雏清,性格南辕北辙的两人,对待婚也持不同看法。陆淮湘:我不干。贺雏清:要看淡。陆淮湘:我要逃婚。贺雏清:我来迎亲。……历经波折之后,两人终到皇城,彼时,两人早已深陷情缘,但却迎来更大的挑战。陆淮湘:你走吧。贺雏清:我永在。陆淮湘:我不放手。贺雏清:便跟我走。
  • 豪门斗爱:首席情深深

    豪门斗爱:首席情深深

    “沈太太,这是我的所有动产不动产,全部改成了你的名字,银行卡密码全部是你的生日,跟我回家吧!”“值钱的留下,其余的扔垃圾桶!”盛浅予高傲的撩了撩长发,看也不看单膝跪地的男人。男人站起来一把将她揽进怀里。“你干什么……和你不熟!”盛浅予炸毛。“沈太太,我就是最值钱的。”盛浅予无语:“呵呵,您老还真是回望自己脸上贴金。”“妈咪是我的!”突然冲出来萌萌哒的小萝莉,伸出软软的小手掌:“想要我妈咪,我要……我要五十块!”男人爽快的将小萝莉抱起来,把手里的文件袋塞进她怀里,“成交!”盛浅予彻底无语:“……”宝贝,你这么坑你亲妈真的合适吗?