登陆注册
5589700000049

第49章 PHILOSOPHY(3)

To confute intuitionists and get rid of intuitions was one main purpose of all Mill's speculations.What,then,is an 'intuition'?To explain that fully it would be necessary to write once more that history of the philosophical movement from Descartes to Hume,which has been summarised and elucidated by so many writers that it should be as plain as the road from St.Paul's to Temple Bar.I am forced to glance at the position taken by Reid and Stewart because it has a most important bearing upon the whole Utilitarian scheme.

Reid's main service to philosophy was,in his own opinion,(18)that he refuted the 'ideal system'of Descartes and his followers.That system,he says,carried in its womb the monster,scepticism,which came to the birth in 1739,(19)the date of Hume's early Treatise.To confute Hume,therefore,which was Reid's primary object,it was necessary to go back to Descartes,and to show where he deviated from the right track.In other words,we must trace the genealogy of 'ideas.'Descartes,as Reid admitted,had rendered immense services to philosophy.He had exploded the scholastic system,which had become a mere mass of logomachies and an incubus upon scientific progress.He had again been the first to 'draw a distinct line between the material and the intellectual world';(20)and Reid apparently assumes that he had drawn it correctly.One characteristic of the Cartesian school is obvious.Descartes,a great mathematician at the period when mathematical investigations were showing their enormous power,invented a mathematical universe.Mathematics presented the true type of scientific reasoning and determined his canons of inquiry.The 'essence'of matter,he said,was space.The objective world,as we have learned to call it,is simply space solidified or incarnate geometry.

Its properties therefore could be given as a system of deductions from first principles,and it forms a coherent and self-subsistent whole.Meanwhile the essence of the soul is thought.Thought and matter are absolutely opposed.

They are contraries,having nothing in common.Reality,however,seems to belong to the world of space.The brain,too,belongs to that world,and motions in the brain must be determined as a part of the material mechanism.

In some way or other 'ideas'correspond to these motions;though to define the way tried all the ingenuity of Descartes'successors.In any case an idea is 'subjective':it is a thought,not a thing.It is a shifting,ephemeral entity not to be fixed or grasped.Yet,somehow or other,it exists,and it 'represents'realities;though the divine power has to be called in to guarantee the accuracy of the representation.The objective world,again,does not reveal itself to us as simply made up of 'primary qualities';we know of it only as somehow endowed with 'secondary'or sense-given qualities:

as visible,tangible,audible,and so forth.These qualities are plainly 'subjective';they vary from man to man,and from moment to moment:they cannot be measured or fixed;and must be regarded as a product in some inexplicable way of the action of matter upon mind;unreal or,at any rate,not independent entities.

In Locke's philosophy,the 'ideas,'legitimate or illegitimate descendants of the Cartesian theories,play a most prominent part.Locke's admirable common-sense made him the leader who embodied a growing tendency.The empirical sciences were growing;and Locke,a student of medicine,could note the fallacies which arise from neglecting observation and experiment,and attempting to penetrate to the absolute essences and entities.Newton's great success was due to neglecting impossible problems about the nature of force in itself 'action at a distance'and so forth --and attention to the sphere of visible phenomena.The excessive pretensions of the framers of metaphysical systems had led to hopeless puzzles and merely verbal solutions.Locke,therefore,insisted upon the necessity of ascertaining the necessary limits of human knowledge.All our knowledge of material facts is obviously dependent in some way upon our sensations --however Meeting or unreal they may be.Therefore,the material sciences must depend upon sense-given data or upon observation and experiment.Hume gives the ultimate purpose,already implied in Locke's essay,when he describes his first treatise (on the title page)as an 'attempt to introduce the experimental mode of reasoning into moral subjects.'Now,as Reid thinks,the effect of this was to construct our whole knowledge out of the representative ideas.The empirical factor is so emphasised that we lose all grasp of the real world.Locke,indeed,though he insists upon the derivation of our whole knowledge from 'ideas,'leaves reality to the 'primary qualities'without clearly expounding their relation to the secondary.But Berkeley,alarmed by the tendency of the Cartesian doctrines to materialism and mechanical necessity,reduces the 'primary'to the level of the 'secondary,'and proceeds to abolish the whole world of matter.We are thus left with nothing but 'ideas,'and the ideas are naturally 'subjective'and therefore in some sense unreal.Finally Hume gets rid of the soul as well as the outside world;and then,by his theory of 'causation,'shows that the ideas themselves are independent atoms,cohering but not rationally connected,and capable of being arbitrarily joined or separated in any way whatever.Thus the ideas have ousted the facts.We cannot get beyond ideas,and yet ideas are still purely subjective.The 'real'is separated from the phenomenal,and truth divorced from fact.The sense-given world is the whole world,and yet is a world of mere accidental conjunctions and separation.That is Hume's scepticism,and yet according to Reid is the legitimate development of Descartes''ideal system.'Reid,I take it,was right in seeing that there was a great dilemma.

同类推荐
  • 会仙女志

    会仙女志

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 一枕奇

    一枕奇

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 富克锦舆地略

    富克锦舆地略

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 示儿长语

    示儿长语

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 洞玄灵宝左玄论

    洞玄灵宝左玄论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 大乘楞伽经唯识论

    大乘楞伽经唯识论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 威武将军种田妻

    威武将军种田妻

    杀手穿成差点被家人卖掉的小农女,爹爹不爱,亲戚冷漠看热闹,可恶!看她如何教训烂老爹,恢复自由,发家致富,过上……等等,这后面紧追不舍的男人你谁啊,她发家致富的道路上不需要同伴,太拥挤了。哪知某人说:“娘子,不拥挤,人多力量大嘛!”某女:“那你能做什么呀?”某男:“我能帮你生猴子。”
  • 血性

    血性

    太阳还没有露面,白军就发起了第一波进攻。白军炮兵用榴弹炮和山炮还有迫击炮向红军阵地狂轰乱炸,这个美好的清晨被炸得支离破碎。在炮火的掩护下,白军朝我们阵地发起冲锋。我把盒子枪插在了腰间的皮带上,端起了一支三八步枪,对着冲上来的白军瞄准。白军离我们越来越近,我看着差不多了,就开出了第一枪,高喊了一声:“弟兄们,给我打!”我那一枪洞穿了一个白军小军官的额头,算他运气不好,碰上了我这个神枪手。战士们喊叫着朝冲过来的白军发射出愤怒的子弹。白军士兵一排排地倒下,阵地前丢下了一具具尸体。
  • 激荡百年:大国农业

    激荡百年:大国农业

    在中国漫长的五千年历史中,没有哪一段历史能像1912年至2012年这样精彩,就在这短短的一百年中,中国经历了从军阀混战、割据分裂到内忧外患、强敌入侵再到建国统一、繁荣富强的坎坷历程。就在这激荡的百年时光里,中国农业在波动与革新中不断发展,逐渐进入平稳上升时期。在此后的发展中,作为国家的基础产业,中国农业已经开始走向世界。
  • 修剑城

    修剑城

    人们说:一将成,万骨枯!人们说:残阳剑天下第一!人们说:“热浪”杀人从没失手。人们说:修剑城,是一个人的传说人们说:杨将军是修仙的人,早就封神了。只有他,杨见龙,杨将军,才知道,到底人们说的准不准。
  • 上清高上金元羽章玉清隐书经

    上清高上金元羽章玉清隐书经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 武侠三千年

    武侠三千年

    三千年江湖风雨何时休,一代新人换旧人。这里有民国的血雨腥风枪林弹雨和民族浴火重生的家国情怀;这里有万国来朝,天佑大明的权利纷争,武林争雄和剑气纵横;这里有东华门外唱名方为好男儿的逍遥仙。这里有以天下为棋局风云变幻的道统之争,英雄与豪杰并起的盛世大唐。这里有玄门兴起,魔帝出世,修仙问道的文人雅士求长生的故事。这里还有“秦王扫六合,虎视何雄哉!”的霸气绝伦和“海外寻仙药,反手断长生”的决绝气魄。更有远古时代神话传说,人神杂居的神仙大劫和洞天福地大破灭的上古元凶。
  • 农门,王爷种田忙

    农门,王爷种田忙

    她是被遗弃在乡下的嫡女,她是意外穿越而来的城市凹凸曼。为了生存,她选择了自强奋斗。种田,种水果,财源自然是滚滚来。没想到一不小心玩大了的后果是:引来皇上的注意了;财产多得招来亲爹觊觎了;妹妹为此嫉恨了。上官盈却眉眼弯弯,笑得像只狐狸,谈笑之间化解一切。可更要命还在后面。皇帝的儿子竟然为了她开始明争暗斗!还是三个!上官盈就不知道该偷笑,还是欲哭无泪了。三个性格迥异的男人,到底谁才是她的命中良人!注:简介无能内容精彩,此文穿越种田,结合宫斗家斗,无大虐,走清新路线,欢迎大家踊跃入坑。
  • 东方舞蹈审美论

    东方舞蹈审美论

    “东方”这个词总是勾连着独特的美学意象和文化气质,“东方舞蹈”则是这种美学意象最为生动、可感的呈现。本书作者从“东方美学”的宏观视角对中国、日本、印度的传统舞蹈艺术进行了形态描述与学理分析相融合的研究,从身体观念、审美特征、美学气质与艺术精神四个层面论述了“东方舞蹈”的独特艺术魅力。
  • 新弟子规

    新弟子规

    《新弟子规》编著者高占祥。本书是作者最新撰写的彰显时代精神的著作。在秉承传统的《弟子规》形式的基础上,为传统文化注入新的时代内容,讲解了新时代的弟子为人处世、成才立业之道。韵文共计116句,1392字。全书分“朗诵篇”“注释篇”两部分。