登陆注册
5589700000049

第49章 PHILOSOPHY(3)

To confute intuitionists and get rid of intuitions was one main purpose of all Mill's speculations.What,then,is an 'intuition'?To explain that fully it would be necessary to write once more that history of the philosophical movement from Descartes to Hume,which has been summarised and elucidated by so many writers that it should be as plain as the road from St.Paul's to Temple Bar.I am forced to glance at the position taken by Reid and Stewart because it has a most important bearing upon the whole Utilitarian scheme.

Reid's main service to philosophy was,in his own opinion,(18)that he refuted the 'ideal system'of Descartes and his followers.That system,he says,carried in its womb the monster,scepticism,which came to the birth in 1739,(19)the date of Hume's early Treatise.To confute Hume,therefore,which was Reid's primary object,it was necessary to go back to Descartes,and to show where he deviated from the right track.In other words,we must trace the genealogy of 'ideas.'Descartes,as Reid admitted,had rendered immense services to philosophy.He had exploded the scholastic system,which had become a mere mass of logomachies and an incubus upon scientific progress.He had again been the first to 'draw a distinct line between the material and the intellectual world';(20)and Reid apparently assumes that he had drawn it correctly.One characteristic of the Cartesian school is obvious.Descartes,a great mathematician at the period when mathematical investigations were showing their enormous power,invented a mathematical universe.Mathematics presented the true type of scientific reasoning and determined his canons of inquiry.The 'essence'of matter,he said,was space.The objective world,as we have learned to call it,is simply space solidified or incarnate geometry.

Its properties therefore could be given as a system of deductions from first principles,and it forms a coherent and self-subsistent whole.Meanwhile the essence of the soul is thought.Thought and matter are absolutely opposed.

They are contraries,having nothing in common.Reality,however,seems to belong to the world of space.The brain,too,belongs to that world,and motions in the brain must be determined as a part of the material mechanism.

In some way or other 'ideas'correspond to these motions;though to define the way tried all the ingenuity of Descartes'successors.In any case an idea is 'subjective':it is a thought,not a thing.It is a shifting,ephemeral entity not to be fixed or grasped.Yet,somehow or other,it exists,and it 'represents'realities;though the divine power has to be called in to guarantee the accuracy of the representation.The objective world,again,does not reveal itself to us as simply made up of 'primary qualities';we know of it only as somehow endowed with 'secondary'or sense-given qualities:

as visible,tangible,audible,and so forth.These qualities are plainly 'subjective';they vary from man to man,and from moment to moment:they cannot be measured or fixed;and must be regarded as a product in some inexplicable way of the action of matter upon mind;unreal or,at any rate,not independent entities.

In Locke's philosophy,the 'ideas,'legitimate or illegitimate descendants of the Cartesian theories,play a most prominent part.Locke's admirable common-sense made him the leader who embodied a growing tendency.The empirical sciences were growing;and Locke,a student of medicine,could note the fallacies which arise from neglecting observation and experiment,and attempting to penetrate to the absolute essences and entities.Newton's great success was due to neglecting impossible problems about the nature of force in itself 'action at a distance'and so forth --and attention to the sphere of visible phenomena.The excessive pretensions of the framers of metaphysical systems had led to hopeless puzzles and merely verbal solutions.Locke,therefore,insisted upon the necessity of ascertaining the necessary limits of human knowledge.All our knowledge of material facts is obviously dependent in some way upon our sensations --however Meeting or unreal they may be.Therefore,the material sciences must depend upon sense-given data or upon observation and experiment.Hume gives the ultimate purpose,already implied in Locke's essay,when he describes his first treatise (on the title page)as an 'attempt to introduce the experimental mode of reasoning into moral subjects.'Now,as Reid thinks,the effect of this was to construct our whole knowledge out of the representative ideas.The empirical factor is so emphasised that we lose all grasp of the real world.Locke,indeed,though he insists upon the derivation of our whole knowledge from 'ideas,'leaves reality to the 'primary qualities'without clearly expounding their relation to the secondary.But Berkeley,alarmed by the tendency of the Cartesian doctrines to materialism and mechanical necessity,reduces the 'primary'to the level of the 'secondary,'and proceeds to abolish the whole world of matter.We are thus left with nothing but 'ideas,'and the ideas are naturally 'subjective'and therefore in some sense unreal.Finally Hume gets rid of the soul as well as the outside world;and then,by his theory of 'causation,'shows that the ideas themselves are independent atoms,cohering but not rationally connected,and capable of being arbitrarily joined or separated in any way whatever.Thus the ideas have ousted the facts.We cannot get beyond ideas,and yet ideas are still purely subjective.The 'real'is separated from the phenomenal,and truth divorced from fact.The sense-given world is the whole world,and yet is a world of mere accidental conjunctions and separation.That is Hume's scepticism,and yet according to Reid is the legitimate development of Descartes''ideal system.'Reid,I take it,was right in seeing that there was a great dilemma.

同类推荐
  • 续词余丛话

    续词余丛话

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 六十种曲四喜记

    六十种曲四喜记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘百法明门论疏

    大乘百法明门论疏

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞玄灵宝大纲钞

    太上洞玄灵宝大纲钞

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 就正录

    就正录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 漠非墨

    漠非墨

    查案查到世界末日,因为你,时间不断崩溃,改变,世界一点点消逝又重现,我所知道的历史似乎变了又变,那个有你的世界究竟是怎样的?墨,等我,我很快就回来,回到你记得我的时间里。
  • 皇室公主赖上腹黑恶魔

    皇室公主赖上腹黑恶魔

    她是皇室的公主,善变是她的性格,美貌身手和智慧集于一身的她,谁也想不到她会扮丑并且隐瞒自己的身份去诺樱学院上学,在人山人海中,她扛上了四位帅到没天理的帅锅,好吧,她承认她很衰,但是志气却是有的,她向众人宣布“我一定会让你们拜倒在我的石榴裙下!”从此,诺樱学院的颜色不再只有黑与白。
  • 一往而覃深

    一往而覃深

    这是一场跨越时光的苦恋,但好在结局美好。一场觥筹交错的婚前party上,他和她再次相遇,他调笑的话语将她的心理防线打垮,殊不知她冰冷的话语,也让他的心颤抖。七年前,他是林城一中理科的风云人物,却孑然一身,清冷孤傲,只因为心中那一抹青春的伤痛,让他难以释怀,他的心结成了一层冰,连带着对她也是冷眼相对。她是文科4班鬼马精灵的小才女,原本开朗乐观,不为情所困,行走都带着风,却在遇到他以后逐渐变得清冷…苏覃芊此生深爱之人,不过他覃霂而已。
  • 原始兽世种田记

    原始兽世种田记

    网文作者肖团团穿越到了兽人世界,今后的生活里为了生存,更好的生存而挣扎!她带着他寻找食物:玉米,大豆,红薯,水稻,土豆,白菜,萝卜,莴笋,麦子!也为了保护自己,打造陷阱,制作武器。她带他的族人在天灾与人祸间苦苦挣扎,从一开始的不被信任,到后来被他们全力保护。这中间,成长的不仅仅是肖团团。最后,团团为金岩生下他们的孩子。一起生活下去。
  • 一亩三分田

    一亩三分田

    这孩子天庭,长得奇伟,女生男相,应是女中豪杰,有木兰气概,但是夫人,你家姑娘多灾多难,这串佛珠就送与你家姑娘吧。大学男友:我178CM,而你就170CM,你太魁梧了,太虎背熊腰,男人都希望自己的女人小巧依人一些,可我抱着你,就像抱着一个棒槌。梅兰自己:我不是棒槌,也不虎背熊腰,别人都知道我肩膀窄,我才一百一十多斤,我只是不妖娆;我有空间法器,有一亩三分田,爱情没有了,事业从土地里开始。
  • 牧歌

    牧歌

    郑君已处在弥留之际了,我冲进病房,握着郑君的手说:“郑君,我们的科研成果获得了国家科技进步一等奖。”郑君笑了笑,说:“凡清,祝贺你,几十年的努力终于看到了成果,你也可以告慰你的恩师你的岳父邵教授了。”我说:“成果是我们大家的。你付出的心血,我心里最清楚。”郑君把目光扫到齐怀正身上,说:“齐场长,你是我心中的英雄。”齐怀正上前握住郑君的手,说:“郑君,我们三个一路走来,最让我对不住的一个人,就是你呀。我告诉你,你不能走!我们三个退休了也要在一起,不能散伙,这是咱仨定的规矩!”
  • 2012年中国青春文学精选

    2012年中国青春文学精选

    精选2012年中国最具代表性的青春文学作品。 书中的这些文章反映了2012年度我国青春文学这个文体领域最主要的创作流派、题材热点、艺术形式上的微妙变化 ,同时,在风格、手法、形式、语言等方面充分多样化,注重作品的创新价值,注重满足广大读者的阅读期待,雅俗共赏。
  • 武志红心灵成长系列(全4册)

    武志红心灵成长系列(全4册)

    极具人气的资深心理学家、百万册心理学畅销书作家武志红的经典作品合集。《愿你拥有被爱照亮的生命》:自我成长和真爱,总是互为镜像。当你越是成为自己,爱就越容易出现;爱累积越多,你越容易成为自己。武志红说,这本书可以当做我的 本书来读,其中的《心灵成长的六个定律》讲的是最基本的理论。《每一种孤独都有陪伴》:爱是我们深层的渴望,但为何越爱越孤独?对这个永恒的人的困境,作者深具洞察力,洞悉孤独感背后的深层心理机制,帮助我们对自我、对情感模式有更多的觉察,打破自恋的幻觉,看到关系的真相。《为何家会伤人》:读者称本书为“极具思想性的家庭关系指导书”“内心成长的一本好书,和谐家庭的圣经”。
  • 影后青梅矜持点

    影后青梅矜持点

    真正在乎你的人,想读的不是你的某条心情,而是……你的整个人生。——姜乔四岁的姜乔……
  • 佛说如意宝总持王经

    佛说如意宝总持王经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。