登陆注册
5589700000049

第49章 PHILOSOPHY(3)

To confute intuitionists and get rid of intuitions was one main purpose of all Mill's speculations.What,then,is an 'intuition'?To explain that fully it would be necessary to write once more that history of the philosophical movement from Descartes to Hume,which has been summarised and elucidated by so many writers that it should be as plain as the road from St.Paul's to Temple Bar.I am forced to glance at the position taken by Reid and Stewart because it has a most important bearing upon the whole Utilitarian scheme.

Reid's main service to philosophy was,in his own opinion,(18)that he refuted the 'ideal system'of Descartes and his followers.That system,he says,carried in its womb the monster,scepticism,which came to the birth in 1739,(19)the date of Hume's early Treatise.To confute Hume,therefore,which was Reid's primary object,it was necessary to go back to Descartes,and to show where he deviated from the right track.In other words,we must trace the genealogy of 'ideas.'Descartes,as Reid admitted,had rendered immense services to philosophy.He had exploded the scholastic system,which had become a mere mass of logomachies and an incubus upon scientific progress.He had again been the first to 'draw a distinct line between the material and the intellectual world';(20)and Reid apparently assumes that he had drawn it correctly.One characteristic of the Cartesian school is obvious.Descartes,a great mathematician at the period when mathematical investigations were showing their enormous power,invented a mathematical universe.Mathematics presented the true type of scientific reasoning and determined his canons of inquiry.The 'essence'of matter,he said,was space.The objective world,as we have learned to call it,is simply space solidified or incarnate geometry.

Its properties therefore could be given as a system of deductions from first principles,and it forms a coherent and self-subsistent whole.Meanwhile the essence of the soul is thought.Thought and matter are absolutely opposed.

They are contraries,having nothing in common.Reality,however,seems to belong to the world of space.The brain,too,belongs to that world,and motions in the brain must be determined as a part of the material mechanism.

In some way or other 'ideas'correspond to these motions;though to define the way tried all the ingenuity of Descartes'successors.In any case an idea is 'subjective':it is a thought,not a thing.It is a shifting,ephemeral entity not to be fixed or grasped.Yet,somehow or other,it exists,and it 'represents'realities;though the divine power has to be called in to guarantee the accuracy of the representation.The objective world,again,does not reveal itself to us as simply made up of 'primary qualities';we know of it only as somehow endowed with 'secondary'or sense-given qualities:

as visible,tangible,audible,and so forth.These qualities are plainly 'subjective';they vary from man to man,and from moment to moment:they cannot be measured or fixed;and must be regarded as a product in some inexplicable way of the action of matter upon mind;unreal or,at any rate,not independent entities.

In Locke's philosophy,the 'ideas,'legitimate or illegitimate descendants of the Cartesian theories,play a most prominent part.Locke's admirable common-sense made him the leader who embodied a growing tendency.The empirical sciences were growing;and Locke,a student of medicine,could note the fallacies which arise from neglecting observation and experiment,and attempting to penetrate to the absolute essences and entities.Newton's great success was due to neglecting impossible problems about the nature of force in itself 'action at a distance'and so forth --and attention to the sphere of visible phenomena.The excessive pretensions of the framers of metaphysical systems had led to hopeless puzzles and merely verbal solutions.Locke,therefore,insisted upon the necessity of ascertaining the necessary limits of human knowledge.All our knowledge of material facts is obviously dependent in some way upon our sensations --however Meeting or unreal they may be.Therefore,the material sciences must depend upon sense-given data or upon observation and experiment.Hume gives the ultimate purpose,already implied in Locke's essay,when he describes his first treatise (on the title page)as an 'attempt to introduce the experimental mode of reasoning into moral subjects.'Now,as Reid thinks,the effect of this was to construct our whole knowledge out of the representative ideas.The empirical factor is so emphasised that we lose all grasp of the real world.Locke,indeed,though he insists upon the derivation of our whole knowledge from 'ideas,'leaves reality to the 'primary qualities'without clearly expounding their relation to the secondary.But Berkeley,alarmed by the tendency of the Cartesian doctrines to materialism and mechanical necessity,reduces the 'primary'to the level of the 'secondary,'and proceeds to abolish the whole world of matter.We are thus left with nothing but 'ideas,'and the ideas are naturally 'subjective'and therefore in some sense unreal.Finally Hume gets rid of the soul as well as the outside world;and then,by his theory of 'causation,'shows that the ideas themselves are independent atoms,cohering but not rationally connected,and capable of being arbitrarily joined or separated in any way whatever.Thus the ideas have ousted the facts.We cannot get beyond ideas,and yet ideas are still purely subjective.The 'real'is separated from the phenomenal,and truth divorced from fact.The sense-given world is the whole world,and yet is a world of mere accidental conjunctions and separation.That is Hume's scepticism,and yet according to Reid is the legitimate development of Descartes''ideal system.'Reid,I take it,was right in seeing that there was a great dilemma.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 九功舞之钧天舞

    九功舞之钧天舞

    如果她的身份不凡一点就好了。她开始这么想,因为,她越来越在乎他。他是那么清逸而有才华,身居高位是自然的事。可她只是一个小小的丫环。可以仰慕,他给他温暖,甚至于同他相爱,却永远无法相配。可是当知道了自己的真实身份,她却宁愿自己只是也仍是那个平凡的丫环。那样,至少还可以在心底偷偷地爱他……
  • 顾大总裁别太撩

    顾大总裁别太撩

    六年前,她爬上他的床……六年后,她被他压在身下说:”怎么,上了我的床还想跑?“原以为被她扑倒,是他这辈子最大的耻辱,却又为何在听到她想走的时候却又不甘愿放手。原以为是他的自尊作祟,却不知道,他早已深陷而不自知。
  • 应聘世界500强

    应聘世界500强

    "精彩评论:好的开端是成功的一半,许多卓越的企业家均是从一份好的工作起步的。如果当年我不进入GE,我也不可能有今日的成就。 ——通用前总裁/杰克·韦尔奇 。我不理解今天的年轻人为什么总是乐意跳槽?我从进入投资业以来,一直坚守我的工作,不管是繁荣还是萧条时期。如果你不喜欢的工作就不要去,否则就要全心全意。 ——投资大师/沃伦·巴菲特。找工作跟找爱侣一样,事前要仔细观察,事后在尽心尽力,并且要一辈子相伴,永不放弃。 ——微软总裁/比尔·盖茨 "
  • 考生营养食谱

    考生营养食谱

    本书针对青少年考生在考试这一特殊时期的生理和心理特点,系统地介绍了考生营养食谱的制作方法和营养搭配知识,科学地解决了应考期间考生吃什么、吃多少、怎么吃等营养进食的问题。
  • 快穿之第七维空间

    快穿之第七维空间

    第七维空间,传说中“上帝”所在的空间,可以逆转时空,穿梭未来。是的,这是真的。顾横波第一次这么清晰地认知,因为她此刻就身处这片神秘的空间之中,还莫名其妙地成为了一个什么空间使者,而她的任务就是开启时空大门,逆转他人的人生。第一个世界:《女主她有变美系统》正在进行中……第二个世界:《豪门娇妻带球跑》已完成第三个世界:《这个校草有点儿撩》已完成第四个世界:《完美女神养成手札》已完成第五个世界:《六零之我是恶毒小姑》正在进行中第六个世界:《古代农家生活日常》第七个世界:《民国歌姬逆袭记》……更多世界等待解锁中……
  • 弟弟旺秀(中篇小说)

    弟弟旺秀(中篇小说)

    完玛央金,女,藏族,1962年出生,现供职于甘肃省甘南藏族自治州文联,《格桑花》主编。系中国少数民族文学学会会员,甘肃作协会员。1982年起发表诗歌、散文作品,入选《她们的抒情诗》《中国当代女诗人诗选》《西部的抒情》《藏族当代诗人诗选》《甘肃的诗》《21世纪年度散文选》等,著有诗集《日影·星星》《完玛央金诗选》,散文集《触摸紫色的草穗》,多次获省级以上奖励。六十女有两个多月没见弟弟旺秀了。刚下早班回家,打开门锁,村里乡亲贡保踏脚后跟跟了进来。贡保带来弟弟旺秀回家了的消息。贡保还说旺秀病了,现在炕上躺着。
  • 异界建立商业帝国

    异界建立商业帝国

    俩个为了一根辣条,互相嘲讽了10几年。在名为黑白系统的未来生命体协助下同时上天。不差分毫。来到异界,双系统?身体接触才能查看?......从未见过如此之坑的系统。看双主人公怎么在异界创立一个商业帝国,文笔不好随意看看。
  • 史莱克七怪的成神之路续集

    史莱克七怪的成神之路续集

    双神出,天地哭;千重劫,万事难;人间乱,反叛患;神界归,神王归;幽冥动,祸根现;天机泄,源泉枯.....
  • 三峰半水元禅师语录

    三峰半水元禅师语录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大乘入道次第

    大乘入道次第

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。