登陆注册
5589700000079

第79章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(1)

I.FIRST PRINCIPLES

Bentham's position is in one respect unique.There have been many greater thinkers;but there has been hardly any one whose abstract theory has become in the same degree the platform of an active political party.To accept the philosophy was to be also pledged to practical applications of Utilitarianism.

What,then,was the revelation made to the Benthamites,and to what did it owe its influence?The central doctrine is expressed in Bentham's famous formula:the test of right and wrong is the 'greatest happiness of the greatest number.'There was nothing new in this assertion.It only expresses the fact that Bentham accepted one of the two alternatives which have commended themselves to conflicting schools ever since ethical speculation was erected into a separate department of thought.Moreover,the side which Bentham took was,we may say,the winning side.The ordinary morality of the time was Utilitarian in substance.Hutcheson had invented the sacred phrase:and Hume had based his moral system upon 'utility.'(1)Bentham had learned much from Helvétius the French freethinker,and had been anticipated by Paley the English divine.

The writings in which Bentham deals explicitly with the general principles of Ethics would hardly entitle him to a higher position than that of a disciple of Hume without Hume's subtlety;or of Paley without Paley's singular gift of exposition.Why,then,did Bentham's message come upon his disciples with the force and freshness of a new revelation?Our answer must be in general terms that Bentham founded not a doctrine but a method:and that the doctrine which came to him simply as a general principle was in his hands a potent instrument applied with most fruitful results to questions of immediate practical interest.

Beyond the general principle of utility,therefore,we have to consider the organon,constructed by him to give effect to a general principle too vague to be applied in detail.The fullest account of this is contained in the Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation.This work unfortunately is a fragment,but it gives his doctrine vigorously and decisively,without losing itself in the minute details which become wearisome in his later writings.

Bentham intended it as an introduction to a penal code;and his investigation sent him back to more general problems.He found it necessary to settle the relations of the penal code to the whole body of law;and to settle these he had to consider the principles which underlie legislation in general.

He had thus,he says,to 'create a new science,'and then to elaborate one department of the science.The 'introduction'would contain prolegomena not only for the penal code but for the other departments of inquiry which he intended to exhaust.(2)He had to lay down primary truths which should be to this science what the axioms are to mathematical sciences.(3)These truths therefore belong to the sphere of conduct in general,and include his ethical theory.

'Nature has placed mankind'(that is his opening phrase)'under the governance of two sovereign masters,pain and pleasure.It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do,as well as to determine what we shall do.'there is the unassailable basis.It had been laid down as unequivocally by Locke,(4)and had been embodied in the brilliant couplets of Pope's Essay on Man.(5)At the head of the curious table of universal knowledge,given in the Chrestomathia,we have Eudaemonics as an all-comprehensive name of which every art is a branch.(6)Eudaemonics,as an art,corresponds to the science 'ontology.'

It covers the whole sphere of human thought.It means knowledge in general as related to conduct.Its first principle,again,requires no more proof than the primary axioms of arithmetic or geometry.Once understood,it is by the same act of the mind seen to be true.Some people,indeed,do not see it.Bentham rather ignores than answers some of their arguments.But his mode of treating opponents indicates his own position.'Happiness,'it is often said,is too vague a word to be the keystone of an ethical system;it varies from man to man:or it is 'subjective,'and therefore gives no absolute or independent ground for morality.A morality of 'eudaemonism'must be an 'empirical'morality,and we can never extort from it that 'categorical imperative,'without which we have instead of a true morality a simple system of 'expediency.'From Bentham's point of view the criticism must be retorted.

同类推荐
  • The Task and Other Poems

    The Task and Other Poems

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 雁门集

    雁门集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 相宗八要

    相宗八要

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 三法度论

    三法度论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • The Market-Place

    The Market-Place

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 星辰里的分钟人

    星辰里的分钟人

    一名初来乍到的联邦执法者,栖身于一个暗流涌动的太空文明,卷入一场蓄谋已久的星际战争,揭开一位疯狂学者的秘辛往事...
  • 萌兔代送中

    萌兔代送中

    对死党尽心极力的她,死党首托:代送情书。天!有木有这么坑她的?(遭到拒绝后,为了不让死党伤心难过)好人难做,死党难哄,她决定采取第二次行动:代告白。因这次行动引发了各种小甜蜜...最终自己能否收获幸福?使死党重获快乐?
  • 证类本草

    证类本草

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 绝地求生之夕阳战神

    绝地求生之夕阳战神

    墙头诗:身背黑锅与捷克手握菠萝匍匐行火力全开震山河夕阳落幕攻后庭……落魄大学僧宁天毕业后在这个竞争力强大的都市找到了第一份工作:扫厕所!却因为听到前女友不堪的消息开始了暴走。一觉醒了,我被包养了?我成了包身奴?却由此人生改写!算命瞎子说:汝命犯桃花,近忌出行与大举动,熬过此关,一飞冲天!城市赛,宁天握了握拳头:“死瞎子忽悠我!叫我不出行,劳资偏去!还要轰动一把!”……
  • 孔子叫我们宽容点

    孔子叫我们宽容点

    本书主要以孔子及其《论语》为基本出发点,融会古今,多方位地阐释了孔子的思想学说与当代现实生活的紧密联系,既不乏理论上的严谨性,又通俗易懂,是一部可读性极强的好书。当然,由于历史和现实的差异性,所以我们今天重新读孔子时,也应该与时俱进,以全新的视角和观念,走进孔子的世界,才能从孔子的思想体系中,提取出对我们具有现实指导意义的智慧。
  • 决胜谈判桌

    决胜谈判桌

    用智慧制约对手,以魄力与其交锋,然后在决定胜负的棋盘上,巧妙的放置一枚双赢的活子。决胜谈判桌,第一次谈判,就让你轻松上手。编者基于对谈判的认识与看法,编著了《决胜谈判桌》一书。全书分为九章,其内容涉及到谈判方方面面,重点从九个角度分析与讲解了谈判人员所必备的硬招、妙招、鲜招、快招、高招、狠招、绝招、新招与稳招,相信读者在阅读后能大有收获,深受启迪。
  • Literary Boston As I Knew It

    Literary Boston As I Knew It

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 异世牧天

    异世牧天

    天启大陆,每个人一出生就被赐予“圣源”,拥有形态各异的力量。这是“天”的恩赐,大陆子民深信不疑。。。。
  • 请判一只狼无罪(动物传奇·关爱卷)

    请判一只狼无罪(动物传奇·关爱卷)

    动物与人类一样经历“生老病死”、“婚丧嫁娶”,动物们也性格各异。它们的存在使大自然充满生机和活力,也使人类的生活更加丰富和充实。“动物传奇”丛书以短小的篇幅、精练的语言,描绘出大自然是善良的,同时也是冷酷的,人类只有顺应大自然,而不是战胜大自然,才会与大自然和谐地融为一体。这是一套关于人与自然的心灵健康之书。关爱卷为其中一本,讲述的是人类与动物互相帮助互相“取暖”的故事。
  • 大乘止观法门宗圆记

    大乘止观法门宗圆记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。