登陆注册
5589700000080

第80章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(2)

He regards 'happiness'as precisely the least equivocal of words;and 'happiness'itself as therefore affording the one safe clue to all the intricate problems of human conduct.The authors of the Federalist,for example,had said that justice was the 'end of government.''Why not happiness?'asks Bentham.'What happiness is every man knows,because what pleasure is,every man knows,and what pain is,every man knows.But what justice is --this is what on every occasion is the subject-matter of dispute.'(7)that phrase gives his view in a nutshell.Justice is the means,not the end.That is just which produces a maximum of happiness.Omit all reference to Happiness,and Justice becomes a meaningless word prescribing equality,but not telling us equality of what.Happiness,on the other hand,has a substantial and independent meaning from which the meaning of justice can be deduced.It has therefore a logical priority:and to attempt to ignore this is the way to all the labyrinths of hopeless confusion by which legislation has been made a chaos.Bentham's position is indicated by his early conflict with Blackstone,not a very powerful representative of the opposite principle.Blackstone,in fact,had tried to base his defence of that eminently empirical product,the British Constitution,upon some show of a philosophical groundwork.He had used the vague conception of a 'social contract,'frequently invoked for the same purpose at the revolution of 1688,and to eke out his arguments applied the ancient commonplaces about monarchy,aristocracy,and democracy.He thus tried to invest the constitution with the sanctity derived from this mysterious 'contract,'while appealing also to tradition or the incarnate 'wisdom of our ancestors,'as shown by their judicious mixture of the three forms.Bentham had an easy task,though he performed it with remarkable vigour,in exposing the weakness of this heterogeneous aggregate.Look closely,and this fictitious contract can impose no new obligation:for the obligation itself rests upon Utility.Why not appeal to Utility at once?I am bound to obey,not because my great-grandfather may be regarded as having made a bargain,which he did not really make,with the great-grandfather of George III;but simply because rebellion does more harm than good.The forms of government are abstractions,not names of realities,and their 'mixture'is a pure figment.King,Lords,and Commons are not really incarnations of power,wisdom,and goodness.Their combination forms a system the merits of which must in the last resort be judged by its working.'It is the principle of utility,accurately apprehended and steadily applied,that affords the only clew to guide a man through these streights.'(8)So much in fact Bentham might learn from Hume;and to defend upon any other ground the congeries of traditional arrangements which passed for the British Constitution was obviously absurd.lt was in this warfare against the shifting and ambiguous doctrines of Blackstone that Bentham first showed the superiority of his own method:for,as between the two,Bentham's position is at least the most coherent and intelligible.

Blackstone,however,represents little more than a bit of rhetoric embodying fragments of inconsistent theories.The Morals and Legislation opens by briefly and contemptuously setting aside more philosophical opponents of Utilitarianism.

The 'ascetic'principle,for example,is the formal contradiction of the principle of Utility,for it professedly declares pleasure to be evil.Could it be consistently carried out it would turn earth into hell.But in fact it is at bottom an illegitimate corollary from the very principle which it ostensibly denies.It professes to condemn pleasure in general;it really means that certain pleasures can only be bought at an excessive cost of pain.

Other theories are contrivances for avoiding the appeal 'to any external standard';and in substance,therefore,they make the opinion of the individual theorist an ultimate and sufficient reason.Adam Smith by his doctrine of 'sympathy'makes the sentiment of approval itself the ultimate standard.

My feeling echoes yours,and reciprocally;each cannot derive authority from the other.Another man (Hutcheson)invents a thing made on purpose to tell him what is right and what is wrong and calls it a 'moral sense.'Beattie substitutes 'common'for 'moral'sense,and his doctrine is attractive because every man supposes himself to possess common-sense.Others,like Price,appeal to the Understanding,or,like Clarke,to the 'Fitness of things,'or they invent such phrases as 'Law of Nature,'or 'Right Reason'or 'Natural Justice,'or what you please.Each really means that whatever he says is infallibly true and self-evident.Wollaston discovers that the only wrong thing is telling a lie;or that when you kill your father,it is a way of saying that he is not your father,and the same method is applicable to any conduct which he happens to dislike.The 'fairest and openest of them all'is the man who says,'I am of the number of the Elect';God tells the Elect what is right:therefore if you want to know what is right,you have only to come to me.(9)Bentham is writing here in his pithiest style.His criticism is of course of the rough and ready order;but I think that in a fashion he manages to hit the nail pretty well on the head.

His main point,at any rate,is clear.He argues briefly that the alternative systems are illusory because they refer to no 'external standard.'His opponents,not he,really make morality arbitrary.This,whatever the ultimate truth,is in fact the essential core of all the Utilitarian doctrine descended from or related to Benthamism.Benthamism aims at converting morality into a science.

同类推荐
  • 四明它山水利备览

    四明它山水利备览

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宦游偶记

    宦游偶记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 大广方总持宝光明经卷第一

    大广方总持宝光明经卷第一

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说善恭敬经

    佛说善恭敬经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 奉和袭美酬前进士崔

    奉和袭美酬前进士崔

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 阴持入经注

    阴持入经注

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 毒压六宫之鬼医邪王妃

    毒压六宫之鬼医邪王妃

    楚翘,21世纪苗疆医术一脉传人。武艺超群,玲珑狡猾!穿越异世掉在冷宫,好心搭救‘大美人’,谁知美人变男人,还以怨报德,要对她酷刑逼供?——够无耻。楚绯夜,云溪千岁王,权倾朝野,阴毒龌龊,惑国媚政的第一大奸佞!这丫头胆儿忒肥,扒他衣裳,占他便宜,还敢用蛊毒银针这等玩意儿埋汰他?——够胆大。她只不过误会他性别,岂知惹上妖孽一般的千岁爷,毒女难敌变态,怎办?宁欺君子莫惹小人,以假乱真,变身侄女,笑容可掬,叩头磕拜:“九叔叔,饶命。”千岁挑眉:“丫头,饭可以混吃,叔不能乱认。”*楚翘穿越异世,寻找银铃玉佩返回现代,却阴差阳错假扮国公府小姐,换取自由条件是为当朝千岁王爷完成三项任务。可当她如他愿做上皇帝妃子,成为一代妖妃,邪肆的千岁却将她霸占。*扶摇大陆,诡秘皇朝,她怀着一颗赤子之心游刃宫闱,血刹朝堂。欺她压她辱她之人她必定如数奉还,绝不容情。一场场精心算计里,一次次腥风血雨中。幸有他始终相伴,溺她宠她疼她爱她,祸福与共,死生不离。◆【片段之无耻千岁爷】:“哦?”青铜灯树下,灯光如橘,楚绯夜正倚在凤雀小榻上,恹恹地挑选着丹蔻的颜色,底下两个婢女跪于榻下,双手捧高银盘,银盘内装的是各色鲜艳丹蔻。“小树子,你这是在骂本王是祸水?”木小树咕咚跪地上,甩了自己个耳光:“瞧奴才嘴笨,千岁爷穿上这身衣裳,必定惊艳四海,云溪又添一道极致风景!”“所以,你这是在骂本王是个东西?”木小树啪啪又甩了自己俩耳刮子:“哟,奴才嘴拙,爷天生丽质难自弃,即便不穿这衣裳,也是云溪最美第一人!”“那么,你这是在骂本王不男不女?”木小树哭丧着脸:“奴……奴……奴……”果然,主子心情不好时,十之八九会变得不可理喻。“爷,咱别玩了好么,奴才给您学狗叫了。”“狗?你有他们叫得好么?”修长玉指一抬,指着面前一干人。所有奴才神情一懔,不管男女齐齐抬头张嘴:“汪汪……汪汪汪!汪汪!”木小树泪流满面,鸭梨山大,只得叫出升级版的狗吠:“嗷嗷!**************【注:本文男强女强,1V1宠文,男女身心干净!】
  • 留不住斜阳

    留不住斜阳

    独自一人坐在编辑部里,默默感受这有雪季节和从不被人看好的落日,任指间的烟雾袅袅升起,在房间的上方扩展成无边的寂寞。?街对面就是邮局,就是那个卖书的地方,就是那卖《围棋天地》的地方,每次都是她甜甜的声音从电话中传来,“您的书到了,过来取吧”,而每次看到她都让人怦然心动,美丽自然天成,清纯不落俗色,而我总是没话找话,问她卖了多少书啦,几点下班啦等日常用语,结果可想而知,每次都是以我仓慌逃走而告终。
  • 爱似覆水,情难收

    爱似覆水,情难收

    李子琪死的那一天,他才知道,他爱这个女人早已深入骨髓。假如不曾爱过你,心是不是就不会那么痛……
  • 干了这碗恒河水穿越印度

    干了这碗恒河水穿越印度

    一朝穿越,大梦初醒……为什么空气里都是一股咖喱味儿?为什么周围的女人全都干瘪瘦弱,麻木不仁?为什么我这具十岁的身体明天就要入洞房?夏枫无语问苍天!苍天变无语:乖,古印度欢迎你,这里绝不会是你的地狱!--情节虚构,请勿模仿
  • 校园用电安全管理与教育

    校园用电安全管理与教育

    从历年发生的触电死亡事故来看,不懂用电知识,发生的触电死亡事故占二分之一。因此当前安全用电的宣传工作是非常重要的。我们认为安全用电应从学生抓起,因为各家各户都有学生,可以依靠学生宣传安全用电常识。
  • 简·奥斯汀信件集

    简·奥斯汀信件集

    奥斯汀在小说里探讨爱情与婚姻,那么生活中的她呢?她的信是我们现在唯一可以直接了解她的方式了。听她娓娓道来那些家长里短的闲言碎语、俏皮的玩笑,还有细腻的小心思。在通讯并不发达的年代,写信是便捷又神秘的沟通方式,就像我们今天用电话、短信、微信那样平常。奥斯汀的信有时候不是同一天写的,今天写一点,明天写一点,然后再一起寄出,有点像日记。信虽不及小说有章有法,却让我们看到一个更加真实的奥斯汀。
  • 一入仙门,悟终生

    一入仙门,悟终生

    因电竞,他与她重逢因他,她爱上了电竞再见时,他已是电竞圈中最顶尖的那一个而她只是普普通通的大学生她爱他,很爱很爱,却深知自己配不上他,于是她选择默默地仰望着他。殊不知他之所以选择站到顶峰,只是因为想让她一下子就能看到他,想让她随时都能找到他......
  • 汉末英雄记

    汉末英雄记

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 聊斋志异精装分类全评本

    聊斋志异精装分类全评本

    清初作家蒲松龄所著《聊斋志异》,是中国古典文学的奇葩。问世300多年来,该书流传甚广,饮誉中外,妇孺皆知,但真正通读全书并读懂原文的人并不多。文言文、不分类、缺评语,是令现代人难以走进这部名著的3只拦路虎。为打掉3只拦路虎,让《聊斋》重返民间,王咏赋(网名“红庙老王”)耗时8年,编著了这部《聊斋志异精装分类全评本》。