登陆注册
5589700000080

第80章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(2)

He regards 'happiness'as precisely the least equivocal of words;and 'happiness'itself as therefore affording the one safe clue to all the intricate problems of human conduct.The authors of the Federalist,for example,had said that justice was the 'end of government.''Why not happiness?'asks Bentham.'What happiness is every man knows,because what pleasure is,every man knows,and what pain is,every man knows.But what justice is --this is what on every occasion is the subject-matter of dispute.'(7)that phrase gives his view in a nutshell.Justice is the means,not the end.That is just which produces a maximum of happiness.Omit all reference to Happiness,and Justice becomes a meaningless word prescribing equality,but not telling us equality of what.Happiness,on the other hand,has a substantial and independent meaning from which the meaning of justice can be deduced.It has therefore a logical priority:and to attempt to ignore this is the way to all the labyrinths of hopeless confusion by which legislation has been made a chaos.Bentham's position is indicated by his early conflict with Blackstone,not a very powerful representative of the opposite principle.Blackstone,in fact,had tried to base his defence of that eminently empirical product,the British Constitution,upon some show of a philosophical groundwork.He had used the vague conception of a 'social contract,'frequently invoked for the same purpose at the revolution of 1688,and to eke out his arguments applied the ancient commonplaces about monarchy,aristocracy,and democracy.He thus tried to invest the constitution with the sanctity derived from this mysterious 'contract,'while appealing also to tradition or the incarnate 'wisdom of our ancestors,'as shown by their judicious mixture of the three forms.Bentham had an easy task,though he performed it with remarkable vigour,in exposing the weakness of this heterogeneous aggregate.Look closely,and this fictitious contract can impose no new obligation:for the obligation itself rests upon Utility.Why not appeal to Utility at once?I am bound to obey,not because my great-grandfather may be regarded as having made a bargain,which he did not really make,with the great-grandfather of George III;but simply because rebellion does more harm than good.The forms of government are abstractions,not names of realities,and their 'mixture'is a pure figment.King,Lords,and Commons are not really incarnations of power,wisdom,and goodness.Their combination forms a system the merits of which must in the last resort be judged by its working.'It is the principle of utility,accurately apprehended and steadily applied,that affords the only clew to guide a man through these streights.'(8)So much in fact Bentham might learn from Hume;and to defend upon any other ground the congeries of traditional arrangements which passed for the British Constitution was obviously absurd.lt was in this warfare against the shifting and ambiguous doctrines of Blackstone that Bentham first showed the superiority of his own method:for,as between the two,Bentham's position is at least the most coherent and intelligible.

Blackstone,however,represents little more than a bit of rhetoric embodying fragments of inconsistent theories.The Morals and Legislation opens by briefly and contemptuously setting aside more philosophical opponents of Utilitarianism.

The 'ascetic'principle,for example,is the formal contradiction of the principle of Utility,for it professedly declares pleasure to be evil.Could it be consistently carried out it would turn earth into hell.But in fact it is at bottom an illegitimate corollary from the very principle which it ostensibly denies.It professes to condemn pleasure in general;it really means that certain pleasures can only be bought at an excessive cost of pain.

Other theories are contrivances for avoiding the appeal 'to any external standard';and in substance,therefore,they make the opinion of the individual theorist an ultimate and sufficient reason.Adam Smith by his doctrine of 'sympathy'makes the sentiment of approval itself the ultimate standard.

My feeling echoes yours,and reciprocally;each cannot derive authority from the other.Another man (Hutcheson)invents a thing made on purpose to tell him what is right and what is wrong and calls it a 'moral sense.'Beattie substitutes 'common'for 'moral'sense,and his doctrine is attractive because every man supposes himself to possess common-sense.Others,like Price,appeal to the Understanding,or,like Clarke,to the 'Fitness of things,'or they invent such phrases as 'Law of Nature,'or 'Right Reason'or 'Natural Justice,'or what you please.Each really means that whatever he says is infallibly true and self-evident.Wollaston discovers that the only wrong thing is telling a lie;or that when you kill your father,it is a way of saying that he is not your father,and the same method is applicable to any conduct which he happens to dislike.The 'fairest and openest of them all'is the man who says,'I am of the number of the Elect';God tells the Elect what is right:therefore if you want to know what is right,you have only to come to me.(9)Bentham is writing here in his pithiest style.His criticism is of course of the rough and ready order;but I think that in a fashion he manages to hit the nail pretty well on the head.

His main point,at any rate,is clear.He argues briefly that the alternative systems are illusory because they refer to no 'external standard.'His opponents,not he,really make morality arbitrary.This,whatever the ultimate truth,is in fact the essential core of all the Utilitarian doctrine descended from or related to Benthamism.Benthamism aims at converting morality into a science.

同类推荐
  • 寒山帚谈

    寒山帚谈

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 刘鹗诗存

    刘鹗诗存

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说花积楼阁陀罗尼经

    佛说花积楼阁陀罗尼经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 佛说大乘百福庄严相经

    佛说大乘百福庄严相经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 西昆酬唱集

    西昆酬唱集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 都市之活了几十亿年

    都市之活了几十亿年

    “我曾一人独活在史前地球,我经历过侏罗纪,曾亲眼看着小行星灭绝了一个时代。”“我曾穿梭诸天万界,世人尊我为太上至尊!”“我之大道,随心所欲,为所欲为!”陈正与至高无上一战,让纪元重启,回到了地球某个时间节点!他虽然被削弱了修为,可肉身与元神不死不灭,带着过去几十亿年的经历,轻松纵横都市,游戏人间!
  • 余光暖暖都是你

    余光暖暖都是你

    【电竞大神X女团主唱】某次,暗恋江时的七月小心翼翼问他:“江时,我可不可以……喜欢你?”江时沉默片刻,面瘫脸回答:“我考虑考虑。”后来,在乌漆墨黑的电影院里,七月鼓起勇气牵了江时的手,开心的冒泡泡:我终于摸到江时的手啦!!江时傲娇开口:“你怎么可以对我耍流氓?喂,负责。”“怎、怎么负责?”“在一起,一辈子。”【日更√】【女追男√】【傲娇江同学X小可爱南同学√】
  • 人物不打折扣

    人物不打折扣

    《人物不打折扣》收录了老舍先生描写人物的多篇经典散文和长篇小说《骆驼祥子》。这些作品用有声有色、生动活泼的语言,刻画了当时一些人物的形象,在他所描绘的范围之内,将一年四季的自然景色、不同时代的社会气氛、风俗习惯,及各种人物的喜怒哀乐、微妙心态都结合在一起。让人在历史和现实之中品味生活人生百态。
  • 畜德錄

    畜德錄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 培养小学生情操的100个感人故事

    培养小学生情操的100个感人故事

    中国民间有句俗语,叫:“三岁看大,七岁看老”。这从侧面反映出了小时候的性格养成会影响到一个人的一生。中国民间有句俗语,叫:“三岁看大,七岁看老”。这从侧面反映出了小时候的性格养成会影响到一个人的一生。如果说人生是一次壮丽的海上航程,那么小学时代则是这段船程的起锚阶段,面对着不可捉摸而又神秘的未来,他们充满了既兴奋又紧张的心情。我们每个人都要经历这人生的起锚阶段,无论前面是布满暗礁的危险之地,还是风平浪静的辽阔海面,人生的第一步是我们踏上未来航程的最重要阶段,只有平安地度过这一时期,才能进入浩瀚的大洋去远航。
  • 正灵创变

    正灵创变

    天地之间,有十大正灵属性。上古十大强者用十属性创造了强大的职业—正灵者,流传至今,但在天地中,介于十大属性之外的新属性,正缓缓出世。
  • 不许人间见白头

    不许人间见白头

    她是风华绝代的倾世太子妃,倾尽全家之力,辅他一步步登上至尊之位。他荣登大宝之日,她等来的却不是封后的圣旨,而是满门抄斩的厄运……
  • 萌宝快递请签收

    萌宝快递请签收

    【已完结】她是走投无路的落魄千金,他是高高在上的商业大亨。黑暗之中,他无情的说,你不过是我的工具。结果,她的身影却夜夜入梦。五年后,天降萌娃。被一个熊孩子拐走,一觉醒来,小包子变成了放大版的霸道总裁。某男无耻,“安子琪,你必须对我负责。”某女淡定,“不好意思,你已经过了保修期,概不负责。”小包子,“老爸,成功捕获老妈一只,包邮哦!”宠文无虐,男女主身心干净!
  • 诗格

    诗格

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 破解人脉密码:打造黄金人脉的自助读本

    破解人脉密码:打造黄金人脉的自助读本

    本书不仅会告诉读者人脉能为他们带来什么,还会将关于人脉的密码一一破解。如何建立人脉,如何扩展人脉,如何让人脉发挥最大的效用,如何走过人脉的雷区,如何掌握经营人脉的技巧……这种种问题,读者都可以在书中找到答案,从而轻松地经营自己的人脉网络,享受人脉所带来的福利,进而收获成功的人生。