登陆注册
5589700000080

第80章 BENTHAM'S DOCTRINE(2)

He regards 'happiness'as precisely the least equivocal of words;and 'happiness'itself as therefore affording the one safe clue to all the intricate problems of human conduct.The authors of the Federalist,for example,had said that justice was the 'end of government.''Why not happiness?'asks Bentham.'What happiness is every man knows,because what pleasure is,every man knows,and what pain is,every man knows.But what justice is --this is what on every occasion is the subject-matter of dispute.'(7)that phrase gives his view in a nutshell.Justice is the means,not the end.That is just which produces a maximum of happiness.Omit all reference to Happiness,and Justice becomes a meaningless word prescribing equality,but not telling us equality of what.Happiness,on the other hand,has a substantial and independent meaning from which the meaning of justice can be deduced.It has therefore a logical priority:and to attempt to ignore this is the way to all the labyrinths of hopeless confusion by which legislation has been made a chaos.Bentham's position is indicated by his early conflict with Blackstone,not a very powerful representative of the opposite principle.Blackstone,in fact,had tried to base his defence of that eminently empirical product,the British Constitution,upon some show of a philosophical groundwork.He had used the vague conception of a 'social contract,'frequently invoked for the same purpose at the revolution of 1688,and to eke out his arguments applied the ancient commonplaces about monarchy,aristocracy,and democracy.He thus tried to invest the constitution with the sanctity derived from this mysterious 'contract,'while appealing also to tradition or the incarnate 'wisdom of our ancestors,'as shown by their judicious mixture of the three forms.Bentham had an easy task,though he performed it with remarkable vigour,in exposing the weakness of this heterogeneous aggregate.Look closely,and this fictitious contract can impose no new obligation:for the obligation itself rests upon Utility.Why not appeal to Utility at once?I am bound to obey,not because my great-grandfather may be regarded as having made a bargain,which he did not really make,with the great-grandfather of George III;but simply because rebellion does more harm than good.The forms of government are abstractions,not names of realities,and their 'mixture'is a pure figment.King,Lords,and Commons are not really incarnations of power,wisdom,and goodness.Their combination forms a system the merits of which must in the last resort be judged by its working.'It is the principle of utility,accurately apprehended and steadily applied,that affords the only clew to guide a man through these streights.'(8)So much in fact Bentham might learn from Hume;and to defend upon any other ground the congeries of traditional arrangements which passed for the British Constitution was obviously absurd.lt was in this warfare against the shifting and ambiguous doctrines of Blackstone that Bentham first showed the superiority of his own method:for,as between the two,Bentham's position is at least the most coherent and intelligible.

Blackstone,however,represents little more than a bit of rhetoric embodying fragments of inconsistent theories.The Morals and Legislation opens by briefly and contemptuously setting aside more philosophical opponents of Utilitarianism.

The 'ascetic'principle,for example,is the formal contradiction of the principle of Utility,for it professedly declares pleasure to be evil.Could it be consistently carried out it would turn earth into hell.But in fact it is at bottom an illegitimate corollary from the very principle which it ostensibly denies.It professes to condemn pleasure in general;it really means that certain pleasures can only be bought at an excessive cost of pain.

Other theories are contrivances for avoiding the appeal 'to any external standard';and in substance,therefore,they make the opinion of the individual theorist an ultimate and sufficient reason.Adam Smith by his doctrine of 'sympathy'makes the sentiment of approval itself the ultimate standard.

My feeling echoes yours,and reciprocally;each cannot derive authority from the other.Another man (Hutcheson)invents a thing made on purpose to tell him what is right and what is wrong and calls it a 'moral sense.'Beattie substitutes 'common'for 'moral'sense,and his doctrine is attractive because every man supposes himself to possess common-sense.Others,like Price,appeal to the Understanding,or,like Clarke,to the 'Fitness of things,'or they invent such phrases as 'Law of Nature,'or 'Right Reason'or 'Natural Justice,'or what you please.Each really means that whatever he says is infallibly true and self-evident.Wollaston discovers that the only wrong thing is telling a lie;or that when you kill your father,it is a way of saying that he is not your father,and the same method is applicable to any conduct which he happens to dislike.The 'fairest and openest of them all'is the man who says,'I am of the number of the Elect';God tells the Elect what is right:therefore if you want to know what is right,you have only to come to me.(9)Bentham is writing here in his pithiest style.His criticism is of course of the rough and ready order;but I think that in a fashion he manages to hit the nail pretty well on the head.

His main point,at any rate,is clear.He argues briefly that the alternative systems are illusory because they refer to no 'external standard.'His opponents,not he,really make morality arbitrary.This,whatever the ultimate truth,is in fact the essential core of all the Utilitarian doctrine descended from or related to Benthamism.Benthamism aims at converting morality into a science.

同类推荐
  • 士容论

    士容论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 紫微斗数

    紫微斗数

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 救伤秘旨

    救伤秘旨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • OF THE EPIDEMICS

    OF THE EPIDEMICS

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞真贤门经

    太上洞真贤门经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 钱钟书家族:嵚崎磊落的人生

    钱钟书家族:嵚崎磊落的人生

    钱基博、钱锺书、杨绛、钱媛……回首过去的一个世纪,饱览群书、博古通今者大有人在;精多国语言、学贯中西者不乏其人;专于治学又擅创作者,也不只一人……但钱锺书是独特的,他从儿时起便“锺”情于书;沦陷孤岛的战乱岁月,他将平日里积攒的种种不屑不满化为“忧世伤生”的诗话集《谈艺录》与长篇小说《围城》;历经十年浩劫、走过一个花甲后,他那些“写在人生边上”(散文集)的批注,对世相种种的感悟,渐渐汇成历史、现实、人生的大江大海,积淀为浩瀚深沉的扛鼎之作《管锥编》。最终汇成了中国近代史上一个颇具传奇色彩的家族。
  • 地球有话说

    地球有话说

    本书主要讲述了一个时代的诞生,那就是宇航时代。该书一步一步告诉小读者们,人类是怎样开发宇宙的、又是怎样进入宇宙的?读者关心的很多重要问题在这里都有一个充分的讲述。书中既有科学原理的生动讲解,又综合运用图片、图标等具象形式加以表现,从而使读者直观、迅速、深刻地理解了作者所要传达的知识和理念。
  • 我在最好的时光等你

    我在最好的时光等你

    闵寒因为父母忙于生意并且把很少的关心都放在弟弟闵瑞身上而导致心理上有些失衡,对父母和弟弟都很疏远,和邻居林海笑一家很亲近。直到韩国转学生姜智英的到来,林海笑的关注点转移,闵寒不能接受林海笑放在自己身上的关心全部给了另外一个女生,开始有些偏执,成绩下滑。闵瑞看在眼里,便去离间姜智英和林海笑,加上一直被妈妈拿来比较的学神孟小琥邀请她组队参加青少年电子竞技大赛,期间不断开导和感染她,闵寒终于努力找回了活泼开朗、积极进取、热爱生活的自己。
  • 总裁的命定女佣

    总裁的命定女佣

    ***“咣”的一声,她把手上端的黑咖啡泼到了他那价值不菲的西装裤上。“对不起,我不是故意的。”她惶恐地道歉,却看到一双魅惑的眼眸,禁不住慌张地低下了头。他藏匿于眼底的戏谑在看到她如出污泥般的清颜时却陡然一震,被逼相亲的晦暗一扫而光。***“贱货,你和你妈妈一样,都是狐狸精,为什么要来搞砸我的相亲宴,你知道这对我来说多么重要吗?还是靠你那个傻样能救我们蓝家吗?你以为他会看上你吗?”一个女人怒极的咆哮声在蓝家的客厅里响起,随着啪的一声脆响,蓝天素白的小脸上印上了一个大红印,她没有哭,只是漠然转身进入自己的小房间。被辱骂的日子,早已是一种习惯。***“纪总,这是我们蓝氏企业的合作开发案,只要你愿意娶我的女儿,我们就可以共同赢利了。”明明是自己有求于人却还要摆出一副高姿态的蓝振林,在纪正哲玩味的笑容下心里直打鼓。“噢,是吗?我们合作可以,但是我还有个条件,我正好缺个女佣,让你的二女儿到我家当女佣,怎么样?”......亲们,这是飘的最新文噢,还盼着你们给我多多支持啊!!我会努力的,别看简介不怎么样,但内容还是很精彩的噢!!!推荐好友黛墨儿的文《花心恶少恋娇妻》自己的新文《亿万前妻》
  • 阿达拉·勒内·纳契人

    阿达拉·勒内·纳契人

    法国的破落贵族子弟勒内离家出国,只身流落于北美洲,来到路易西安那的纳契部落的一个村子里,被德高望重的瞎眼老酋长夏克塔斯收为义子。夏克塔斯把自己年轻时与阿达拉相爱的曲折故事,讲述给勒内听。
  • 邪神专宠:魔神大小姐

    邪神专宠:魔神大小姐

    她是陆府众所周知的傻女,万事不知。和亲路上被亲人抛之毫无生还可能的黑沙漠,一朝蛇血改命。尘封的记忆,不同的陆府,天赋异禀的她强势登上天地舞台。无情地帝皇,恶毒的二娘,待她重新归来,必定斩于剑下。
  • 电视里的哀嚎

    电视里的哀嚎

    露西躺在床上,凝视着剑桥旅馆客房的天花板,盘算着是否到城里找个人来让自己娱乐一下。她刚刚从芝加哥拜访一位客户回来,身负使命到这里参加一个技术座谈会,但最后疲劳占了上风。露西下了床,打开电视机,电视上正在播报晚间新闻。男播音员正在报道发生在M5公路上的一起撞车事故,一段模模糊糊的视频出现在屏幕上:警车上闪光的蓝灯、呈V字形的拖挂、被路障挤得皱皱巴巴的小轿车。这时发生了一件令人毛骨悚然的怪事,她从晚间新闻里听到一个尖声尖气的男人哀嚎的声音,这个男人无疑正处于极大的痛苦中。
  • The Tin Woodman of Oz

    The Tin Woodman of Oz

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 崩坏救赎

    崩坏救赎

    在这无底之渊般的崩坏中,或许,没有救赎,只有绝望…(崩坏3rd世界观,再加上个人原创)
  • 张恨水经典作品系列:夜深沉

    张恨水经典作品系列:夜深沉

    《夜深沉》是一部令人感喟的女性情感史。一位美丽、极富艺术才情的街头歌女,被捧红为京剧名角后情感迷失,难拒纨绔子弟之诱惑,堕入火坑,被军阀、富商所摧残,欲逃不能……一位执著不渝的爱慕者旷日苦恋,奈何贫富之差,阴差阳错,一直在痛苦中徘徊,最终无奈地娶老板的姘妇为妻。夜深沉,情也深沉。