登陆注册
5590800000025

第25章 Political Theory(3)

Mill proceeds to argue at some length that a favourite scheme of some moderate reformers,for the representation of classes,could only lead to 'a motley aristocracy,'and then answers two objections.The first is that his scheme would lead to the abolition of the monarchy and the House of Lords.The reply is simple and significant.It would only lead to that result if a monarchy or a House of Lords were favourable to bad government.He does not inquire whether they are so in fact.The second objection is that the people do not understand their own interest,and to this his answer is more remarkable.If the doctrine be true,he says,we are in a 'deplorable'position:we have to choose between evils which will be designedly produced by those who have both the power to oppress and an interest in oppression;and the evils which will be accidentally produced by men who would act well if they recognised their own interests.19Now the first evil is in any case the worst,for it supposes an 'invariable'evil;while in the other case,men may at least act well by accident.A governing class,that is with interests separate from those of the government,must be bad.If the interests be identical,the government may be bad.It will be bad if ignorant,but ignorance is curable.Here he appeals for once to a historical case.The priesthood at the Reformation argued on behalf of their own power from the danger that the people would make a bad use of the Bible.The Bible should therefore be kept for the sacred caste.They had,Mill thinks,a stronger case in appearance than the Tories,and yet the effect of allowing the people to judge for themselves in religious matters has been productive of good effects 'to a degree which has totally altered the condition of human nature.'20Why should not the people be trusted to judge for themselves in politics?

This implies a doctrine which had great influence with the Utilitarians.

In the remarkable essay upon 'Education,'which is contained in the volume of reprints,Mill discusses the doctrine of Helvétius that all the differences between men are due to education.Without pronouncing positively upon the differences between individuals,Mill observes that,at any rate,the enormous difference between classes of men is wholly due to education.21He takes education,it must be observed,in the widest possible sense,as meaning what would now be called the whole action of the 'environment'upon the individual.This includes,as he shows at length,domestic education,all the vast influence exercised upon a child in his family,'technical education,'by which he means the ordinary school teaching,'social education,'that is the influences which we imbibe from the current opinions of our neighbours,and finally,'political education,'which he calls the 'keystone of the arch.'The means,he argues,by which the 'grand objects of desire may be attained,depend almost wholly upon the political machine.'22If that 'machine'be so constituted as to make the grand objects of desire the 'natural prizes of just and virtuous conduct'of high services to mankind and of the generous and amiable sentiments from which great endeavours in the service of mankind naturally proceed,it is natural to see diffused among mankind a generous ardour in the acquisition of those admirable qualities which prepare a man for admirable action,great intelligence,perfect self-command,and over-ruling benevolence.'The contrary will be the case where the political machine prompts to the flattery of a small ruling body.

This characteristic passage betrays an enthusiasm which really burned under Mill's stern outside.He confines himself habitually to the forms of severe logic,and scorns anything like an appeal to sentiment.The trammels of his scientific manner impede his utterance a little,even when he is speaking with unwonted fervour.

Yet the prosaic Utilitarian who has been laying down as a universal law that the strong will always plunder the weak,and that all rulers will reduce their subjects to abject slavery,is absolutely convinced,it seems,of the possibility of somehow transmuting selfishness into public spirit,justice,generosity,and devotion to truth.Equally characteristic is the faith in the 'political machine.'Mill speaks as if somebody had 'discovered'the representative system as Watt (more or less)discovered the steam engine;that to 'discover'the system is the same thing as to set it to work;and that,once at work,it will be omnipotent.He is not less certain that a good constitution will make men virtuous,than was Bentham that he could grind rogues honest by the Panopticon.The indefinite modifiability of character was the ground upon which the Utilitarians based their hopes of progress;and it was connected in their minds with the doctrine of which his essay upon education is a continuous application.The theory of 'association of ideas'appeared to him to be of the utmost importance in education and in politics,because it implied almost unlimited possibilities of moulding human kings to fit them for a new order.In politics this implied,as J.S.Mill says,23'unbounded confidence'in the influence of 'reason.'

Teach the people and let them vote freely,and everything would follow.

同类推荐
  • a rogue' s  life

    a rogue' s life

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上洞玄灵宝灭度五炼生尸妙经

    太上洞玄灵宝灭度五炼生尸妙经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 唯识论(一名破色心论)

    唯识论(一名破色心论)

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Bulfinch's Mythology

    Bulfinch's Mythology

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 道德经顺朱

    道德经顺朱

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 宋阵

    宋阵

    穿越到了积弱已久的宋朝也就罢了,还偏偏到了靖康之耻被金人掳走的宋俘队伍里,肉体上的折磨动摇不了身为杀手的意志,却又为了皇帝老儿交给的任务,达到自己救世的目的,不得不和第一奸臣秦桧扯上关系。探测同化预警隐匿辅助攻击防御……携阵法系统之大成,踏入历史的潮流,随风起而云涌,踏天下之不平。这是一段历史不会记载的岁月,也是一场烽烟四起的沙场拼杀,这里有情义,有兄弟,有烈酒,有美人,更有那不朽的铿锵悲歌。交流群号《237519282》推荐收藏打赏,谢谢大家支持。
  • 相声“三字经”

    相声“三字经”

    《相声三字经》是一本介绍相声历史和演变的书籍,它用一种说唱文学的语言与形式去演绎另一种说唱文学的历史。相声艺术博大精深,以“三字经”的形式讲述相声的发展史更是别树一帜。书中不仅详细地介绍了相声的表演技巧、语言习惯,还有相声界的大师、前辈等名人,还请来徐德亮为“三字经”的内容作注释,使内容更加贴近生活,便于阅读。
  • 经济学会撒谎

    经济学会撒谎

    本书是一本趣味性经济学读物。通过一些有趣的话题,帮助大家更好地认识经济学,学习经济学,用好经济学。其核心思想仍与经典、传统的经济学思路一贯,但看事物的角度则力求新奇,改变大家对经济学的传统认识,解决一些学习经济学,运用经济学时的观念误区,使经济学能够更好地为我所用。
  • 代课总裁狠霸气

    代课总裁狠霸气

    缘浅情深?那只是她年少时的一场梦罢了,梦醒了,情也就淡了;此生也就如此,无缘,至少可以回忆。她是这么认为的。真爱难寻?那只是他人生的一个插曲罢了,走过了,心也就宽了;此生必不会如此,缘分,需要自己争取。他是这么认为的。这些年,为了心中所爱,她失了自我。回过头,真爱已等在身后。这些年,为了心中执念,他封闭自我。抬起头,真爱已站在眼前。等待并不可怕,可怕的是你不愿意等。从来爱情与时间无关,它只是一种两人间的情愫。
  • 左道末世行

    左道末世行

    中二少年赵皓,多年收集各种秘籍,打坐站桩,因为他坚信修仙长生,结果仙没修成末日来了。全球性的火山爆发,大面积冰川融化各种天灾接踵而至。当人类陷入恐慌时,植物开始快速生长,特殊的雾气笼罩地球,大面积电子仪器失灵,昆虫动物每天以肉眼可见的速度变大,地底人,岩石人,鲛人,鱼人,红野人这时候人类才发现什么才是真正的末日。
  • 抓狂妖妃:狼二殿下缠上身

    抓狂妖妃:狼二殿下缠上身

    第一次见面,他莫名其妙的英雄救美。却是狠狠的一脚把她踹开怒吼道,“死小鬼你挡道了,给老子滚开!”第二次见面,“女人,看在你救了我的份上。我不嫌弃你是个低贱愚蠢的人类,和我交配吧。”在他恢复了一半的妖力以后便居高临下的用一副恩赐的模样对她说。千千满头黑线的喊道,“替我谢谢你祖宗十八代,滚——”在遇见情敌以后,某狼抓住某龙的衣服领子恶狠狠的说道,“你这个浑身臭鱼腥味的死半妖给我听好了,千千是我的。受了我血狼族二殿下的一吻,身上便沾染了我们狼族的气味和印记,生生世世就只能是我狼血痕的女人。你敢碰,我就敢屠龙。”千千,“……”
  • 麦收

    麦收

    全村群众大会一宣布结束,会场上马上就乱哄哄的。这是上世纪70年代,在全民参加劳动的热潮中,我们这些初中生,今年也全部放假回村参加夏收。我被分到一队的第二小组,组长是刘福禄。刘福禄是队长兼组长,所以一散会,我就赶紧去找刘福禄。刘福禄50多岁,个子不高,在熙熙攘攘的人群里找到他,是一件很不容易的事。好在他嗓门奇大,还未见人,就听见他喊叫:“第二组的人,到枣树底下集合;第二组的人,到枣树底下集合。”几个人已经等在树下。刘福禄端然坐在一块大石头上,手里捧着一份《人民日报》,不时把白眼珠一翻,看看来人。
  • 腹黑郎恶毒妻

    腹黑郎恶毒妻

    未语沫在争夺权力的路上一直不得手段,甚至和自己的兄弟姐妹自相残杀……重生的未语沫装神弄鬼的吓坏了未府上上下下,不料却无意间撞破了未家大少爷未宗伟,和苏家大小姐苏荷的好事。腹黑郎君,恶毒妻子……
  • 帝国政界往事:公元1127年大宋实录(全新修订典藏版)

    帝国政界往事:公元1127年大宋实录(全新修订典藏版)

    写历史的人很多,这样写历史的人很少!2004年夏天,一部名为《帝国政界往事:公元1127年大宋实录》的历史作品突然问世,因其从人性角度和史料细节中,发现历史的鲜活与真实面目,一时洛阳纸贵,海内风行。作者李亚平也成为各大媒体争相报道的热门作家,被誉为“黄仁宇之后最会讲历史的人文学者”。
  • 祸国册

    祸国册

    生得娴静,名为安宁。人生目标是祸国殃民自小的偶像是妖妃妲己。奈何生于现代,只能祸害祸害学校里的小情侣。有人说她是绿茶婊?嗤,安宁笑了。那些个没颜值没身材没气质连自己喜欢的人都守不住的,也就只会把所有错误都归在她身上。纵然安宁一直也没和任何一个在一起,可她还是犯了众怒。安宁抛了个挑衅的媚眼你奈我何?几杯浓硫酸!即使被毁了容要了命,安宁依旧傲然笑着:“即使我没了容貌,即使我死了,你们喜欢的人也不会回到你们身边!”一朝红颜薄命断,再睁眼……什么?!秀女选秀要表演才艺?!对不起我只会钢琴芭蕾舞……哎诶诶诶……别别别公公有话好好说我我哎哎哎别赶我出去呐才艺可以学的嘛哎哎……QAQ